Onondaga Nation of Indians v. Minnie Schenandoah et al, Court Transcript, 1928

Online content

Fullscreen
219

A. The individual Indian might have an Indian
name himself, but when he accepts the Chieftain-
ship --~

(Interrupting) He must accept-~-

A. (Continuing) --- he must accept the name of the
ohief,

The name that goes with the chieftainship?

A. Yes, sir,

- Now, during the time that George Thomas was

Head Chief of the $ix Nations, did I understand you
to say that there was not any regular clerk at

that time?

A, There was not.

And the condolence or council after it was called
together appointed an acting clerk for this meeting?

A, For that meeting; yes, sir.

. And at at least two of those meetings you acted as

clerk?
A. Well, I would not say that there was two meetings

that George Thomas was presiding officer over,

Q. But during the time that he was presiding officer?

A, No, it was not. It was after he was deposed.

I see. And the first regular clerk that you know of
was Walter Kennedy?

A, He was put in, well, it wasn't a regular clerk;
it was just a question of being elected to that
office,

I see.

A. No special set time, or term of office.

. Now, I am not quite clear as to what your answer

was in reference to the Six Nations being governed
by the same rules. Do youmean by that when they are
assembled in the Six Nations Council, or ina
condolence, that they are then governed by the same
rules, but that they have separate rules governing
their individual reservations?

A. Yes, sir.

Q.T hat is right?

A. There are separate rules governing the individ-
val reservations; they are independent nations,
because our traditions and soforth are different.
And each nation or seservation has its own rules and

regulations in reference to the qualifications of

2

chief? |

A, The whole business on the reservation pertaining

to that nation,

And the Seneca nation, as you understand it, has

a written constitution?
A. Yes, sir,

And they call their chiefs councilors?

A. Yes, according to their constitution.

. Now, what the rule is on the Onondaga reservation

in reference to a person having adopted a whiteman's

religion and being inelligible for office, you don't

know what that is?

A. That is their business,

That is their business and applies to their reserva~

tion alone?
A. Yes, sir.

Now, in deposing the Head Chief of the

Six Nations;

just how is that done; or, what is necessary in

that proceeding?
A. Deposing any Head Chief, it must be

something detrimental to the nations.

he has done

Therefore, it

takes a similar procedure to the deposing of a regu-

lar chief.

Q. Well, he is deposed in a condolence?
A. Yes, sir, #

Q. Well, it is not necessary to have his local council
meet and pass on it first before he is brought up
in a condolence; is it?

MR. BROWN: I object to that as leading and
improper.

THE COURT: It ie leading.

MR. CREGG: Well, is it?

MR. BROWN: He has already stated it was,

MR, ORUGG: No, he hasnot.

MR. BROWN: That is just exactly what he
sald,

MR. OREGG: I will see about that,

BY MR, CREGG:

Q.Tell us whether or not it is necessary in order to
depose a Head Chief of the Six Nations, that he
should be first passed on in the council; is it or
is it not necessary?

A. No, sir.


Q

BY

Q

It is not necessary!

A. No, sir.

So that in order to depose a Head Chief of the Six
Nations, that can be brought up for the first time
in a condolencert

A. In a condolence, yes, sir.

MR. CREGG: That is all.

RECROSS EXAMINATION
MR. BROWN:
Well, now, Mr. Brayley, upon what authority do
you say that’
A. Indian custome.
Well, tell me when and where you have seen that
custom practiced at any time?
A, Practiced right along.
Whent
A. Now.
Well, when?

A. As in the past.

Q. When?

A. After he does something wrong.

Q.And then after he does some act, that gives the
right to the clan mother to depose him‘
A. Yes, sir.

Q. You have already told me that before she could depose
him the council of the nation have got to agree
by a majority vote with the clan mother; that is
what you have already said?

A. I did not.

Q. Well, what did you say?

A. I said when they put him in office,

Q. I understood you very definitely to say that that
also applied when she was putting him down, that
her choice to make a chief had to te approved by
the council and her choice of deposing a chief
had to be approved in the same manner; did you say
that?

A. No, sir, I did not say that in deposing him,

Q. That is, the clan mother, adcording to your idea,

has no power to make a chief, except in concurrence

with the council of her nation; is tht right?

A. On her recommendations they work along together,

. But she alone, without anybody else, oan depose any

chief?

A. In a@ condolence.

In a condolence, and nobody has got anything to say
about itt

A. No, sir,

She is the only one who can say anything about it
ano she can bring it up at a condolence without
anybody knowing she is going to bring it up?

A. That is her right, if she wants to.

Q.For instance, if there happened to be a condolence

Q.

on the Tuscarora reservation at which there were
present only one Onondaga Chief, it would be per-
fectly proper, according to your understanding of

the law, for every other Onondaga Ghief to be deposed
without anybody having anything to say about itt

A. And that all these clan mothers will be there?
Yes, we will assume they will be there?

A, And they have done something wrong?

Q.

BY

Q

Regardless of something wrong. We are just talking
about forms and ceremonies now; we haven't got into
the question of what has been done.

MR. OREGG: I submit he has a right to assume
that in his answer.

THE COURT: Yes, he is entitled to assume that.
MR. BROWN:
Well, we will make this assumption, Mr. Brayley,
that the clan mothers say that they have done some-
thing wrong; that is the only information you have,
anyway; isn't it? ,
A, Surely.
That is, you yourself have no knowledge of any
wrongdoing upon the part of Thomas, have you? You
yourself know of no wrongdoing upon his part?
4. I know of some things.
That is, you have personal knowledge, or is it what
somebody has told you?
4. Together with written documents; yes, I have.
That is you have received some written documents of

his that you do not agree with?

827 228

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And they oan be represented by one representative,
Q. And those were before you when you sat in this

can't they?
condolence?

A. Duplicates; one for one way and one for another.
| A. The Fire Keepers are Onondaga people by their

A. They had been before me before that time.

: rights of being Fire Keepers, but they cannot act
Q. Well, now, let us go back to this question I asked

as Fire Keepers and as the Onondaga Indian Nation
you, that if there was a condolence held at the

at the same time; they are in acting as Fire Keepers
Tuscarora reservation, attended by only one Onondaga

acting for the $ix Nations themselves.
Chief, it would be possible, if your olan mothers

Q. You mean there are certain Onondagas that have a
were there, to depose every other Onondaga Chief ‘

certain particular office with respect to the Fire
without anyoody having anything to say about it?

Keepers?
A. It would not be possible because you could not

A, Certainly.
have a condolence without the Fire Keepers, i

Q. Who are they?
Q. The Fire Keepers would be pepresented, as I told you,

A. The Onondagas.
by only one thief; that is possible; you could have

Q. Who are they?
@ condolence if only one Onondaga Ghief were

A. They must be the chiefs of the Onondaga
present?

Nation.
A. No, sir,

Q. What Chiefs?

2

How many have you got to have?

_A, Chief Sachem, that is, the Principal Chief,
A, You have got to have the Fire Keepers to put the
Q. Well, all right. Let us have him there, let us
ceremony over.

: have the principal chief there; it would then be
Q. The Fire Keepers are the Onondagas?

possible according to your understanding of the

Indian Law to have every other Chief of that nation
deposed without anybody having anything to say
about it or knowing anything about it, except the
condolence mother, who is proposing the deposition?
A, Well, they have had ~ there would not be any
such thing because they have had notice the condo~
lence meeting is going to be held for that purpose,
Well, they don't know all these chiefs are coming
up to be deposed; do they’ When this condolence
was held at which you claim George Thomas was deposed,
was there a notice given that he was to be deposed,
that his name was to be acted on for deposition?

A. No, sir, I didn't have any such notice.

Nobody knew about it until Paula Isaacs got up

and said, "I want to kick George Thomas out", or
something to that effect?

A. I never seen the lady.

. What is that?

Q.

A. I never met that person.

Wasn't Paula Isaacs the one who proposed: ~~~

BY

$

THE COURT (Interrupting): He did not say that
was the one.
MR. BROWN:
Who was the woman who testified ~ oh, it was Phoebe
Lyons
A. Yes, sir.
Was that in the notice that Phoebe Lyons was going
to propose George Thomas! name to be deposed?

A. THat is not our custom.

- Well, these chiefs that came to this condolence, or

who were told to come and did not come, did not know
anything about the fact that that was coming up
at all until they got there, unessl they happened
to be on the insidef
A. That is not our custom.
I am not asking about custom. I am asking about
this particular condolence?

MR. OREGG: I don't see how he can testify as
to what somebody else did.

THE COURT: He can testify to what uroerenee

he has.

MR. OREGG: He is testifying to custom here.

THE WITNESS: That is right.
THE COURT: He can testify as to custom but not
as to anything outside of his knowledge,
BY MR, BROWN:
Q. It would be the custom and practice to give that
information in calling a condolence; would iti

A. No, sir, not in deposing a chief, unless that

Was ——

&

(Interrupting) It 1s not the custoa and practice to

give the names of the chiets that are tobe raised

at a condolence; is iti

A, It is not the regular rule that I know of,

Q. Well, now, here, we have gone over this, Chier
Brayley, if you want to make chiefs at Tuscarora,
if you had gone through your own preliminaries and
then asked for a condolence for the purpose of raig—
ing a certain number of chiefs, notice would go outt
A. Yes, sir,

Q. And then after this notice goes out to the other

nations, another nation having a vacancy can come

condolence.
Q. THat is the fact; that is the way they dot
A. We actually raised a chief at that condolence,
Q. Well, now, you cannot raise any chief until he is
approved by his own tribal or national council; can
yout
A, What kind of chief?
Q. Any kind of chiefi
A. There are two different ways of raising chiefs.
Q. What are they?
A. A chief not having a voice or vote in the council,
Q. Yest
A. A sachem or principal chief has no voice or vote
until he is raised to chieftainship after a
condolence.
Q. Yesi

in without notice to anybody and raise their chief
at the same condolence; is not that got

4A. That is just my experience on attending that

A. A ward chief or.a Ssub-chief, or a chief, as we

call them war-chiefs in our nation, the clan mother

833

comes in and requests a man and if we accept that
man a8 war chief of the tribe, we can place him in
the council and have a voice and a vote, but that

is not ratified until the next condolence ia

called, and then we have to go to the condolence and

have them ratify it.

. Well, whether he is a principal chief or a ward

chief, or bodybuard - it is sometimes called "body-
guard"?

A. Yes, sir.

Every name has to be passed on by their own council
in any event before they can be condoled?

A. Before they can be raised to chieftainship.

+ Yes. Now, Lf will ask you thie: Suppose a candidate

is approved by his council, can the condolence refuse
to condole him?

A. They have that privilege.

. And they can refuse to raise him?

A. Yes, sir.

- And, now, let us go right back to this first question

of deposing: You say it is perfectly proper for a

oa

234

chief to be deposed without any vote of anybody?
A. Yes, sir,

Any chief’

A. Yes, sir.

And he must, of course, be a chief?

A. Yes, sir,

So the situation I have suggested to you, whereby
all the chiefs of any nation, except one, the one
appointed to be present, could be deposed without
thea or anybody else knowing anything about it; that
is possible ynder your interpretation of the

law; is that right?

A. That is all governed by his acts, If you become

‘8 chief you are there for life or deposed,

Yes?

A. T hat means your rule is continuous, until you
have done something that id detrimental ~——
(Interrupting) Now, let us. not ignore this question:
It is possible under your interpretation of the law
to depose every chief but one at any condolence

without notice; just "yes" or "no" about that 7?

A. If all the olan mothers were presenti?

Q. If all the clan mothers were present, and each
individually proposes the deposition of her own
chief, no one has got anything to say about except
her?

A. She presents what she pleases to the officer
that is raising the chiefs.

Q. Yes?

A. And it is always his duty, there is a lull in

the meeting at that time, what we call a rest,

there is a onance then, he asks, he never goes and
pulls @ man right down, he always asks: "Is there any
volce to be hearat"

Q. He asks those that are there present?

A. Yes, sir,

Those that are not present know nothing about iti

2

A. That is their own business for not attending,
Q. They don't as a matter of fact?
A. They know when they get there,
Q. So then the hypothetical situation I put up to you,

that it would be perfectly possible at any condo-

lence, with your proper set up of your mothers there,

these clanmothers, that they could depose every chief
of any nation except the particular chief who happen-
ed to be there, is correct, according to your
understanding of the lawt

A. Hypothetically correct.

MR. BROWN: That is all,

REDIRECT EXAMINATION

BY MR. CREGG:

Q.Well, as + understand it, if there was a condolence

regularly called and that condolence was in session
and the different nations were represented, then a
clan mother might come in and ask that her chief

be deposed?

A. Yes, sir.

- Any clan mother might do tha® at gucha condolence;

is that right?
A. Yes, sir,
Now, just what is the procedure when the clan

mother comes in and says: "I want to depose such a

chief"; tell us what the procedure is then?

A. She presents her wampum to the officer that is

in charge of that part of the ceremony and she makes
her complaint. Sometimes she doesn't do that.

She does it through another party, generally the sub-
chief,

She designates somebody to speak for her?

A. She could designate anybody, but ordinarily it

is the sub-chief.

All right. ‘Tell us what is done then?

A. Ana then he asks, if this is so.

. He asks of the council if there is any reason why

he should not be deposed?

A. Yes, sir.

And then everybody is given an opportunity to speak;
is that right?

A, The House is open to hearing anything; his ears
are open to hear one side or the other, if there is

anyone there to be heard,

. And if he hears opposition, what happens? Suppose

somebody gets up and says: "I am not in favor of

deposing Tom Jones", for instance?

A. Then he hears the evidence and giving them the
fullest opportunity to be heard,

And then the condolence passes on it?

A. Yes, sir.

. And after that the real deposition 1s made by the

condolence there; that is, the condolence can refuse
to depose a man if it wants to?

A, Certainly,

Just the same as the condolence can refuse to raise
a chieft

A. Yes, sir,

. Do you know what it means to lodge a chief?

A. Yes, sir.

And explain what thet means?

A. The principle of the Iroquois is of a tree, with
the different tribes being the different branches.
The lodging of a chief, that expression is best
interpreted by the starting to break this limb off
and deposing him, starting to out him down; he has

done something and they want to warn him; and that

2839

is the first step they can take, lodging him,

Q. And by lodging him, does that mean half way down,
like a tree falling and lodging against another
tree?

A. It has that same effect.

Q. That is the significance of it; is it?
A, That is right,

Q. And the Six Nations are supposed to represent the
trunk of a tree with the different nations out on
the branches?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Now, do you know anything about this condolence
that George Thomas purported to have held on some
reservation in June, 1924; did you get a notice
of thatt
A, In June, 1934, we got a notice from George
Thomas of a meeting to be held on the twenty~seventh
of June, which would be on a Saturday, if I remember
right,

Q. Where?

A. To be held on the Tonawanda Reservation,

&

340

On the Tonawanda Reservation?
A. Yes, sir.
And at that time did you recognize George Thomas
as having any authority to call a condolence?
A. No, sir. ,

. Did you go over there out of curiosity!
A. We did,
And what did you discover when you got there?
A. Well, I didn't lose any time that day. I worked
in the forenoon and after dinner I got some of the
Tuscarora chiefs and we drove over in my car to
see if anything was doing. We did not have any chiefs
to raise, if it was a condolence, and so we were kind
of disinterested and we wanted to see what was going
on, after he has been deposed, to try and carry on
a condolence.

. Yest

A. And so we went over there and there was nobody
there and it seems to me they had been there and the
Tonawandas had not given them the right to use any

hall or pbuilding, or anything there, and they went on,

as we heard, to the Cattaraugus Reservation,

Q.And was that a written notice you got from Thomas?
A. Yes, sir,

@, And that designated the Tonawanda Reservation as
the place?
A, Yes, sir.

Q. Now, how long during the day does the condolence
last, usually?
A, Well, upon different reservations they last
longer. On the Tuscarora reservation during our
condolences over there they do not have so much
of the old Indian customs over there; very few of
them know how to dance an old Indian dance.

Q. Well, do they dance at these condolences?
A. Yes, sir.

Q. And does a condolence usually last all day? -
A. Takes up the best part of a day and some of
the night, generally, when the dance goes on,

Q. And after the business of the condolence is trans-
acted, do they have a feed then?

A. At the end of the ceremony they have the feast,

. And is there any particular nation that is designat~

They have a feast?

A. After they have raised the new chief it is to
rejoice in the new chieftainship being put into
office,

And that feast is usually cooked in a large kettle;
is it?

A. Yes, sir; beef is always used.

. Beef is always used?

A. And cooked in a kettle and bread is used and
after this feast, then we have the pipe.

And then they smoke the pipe of peace after the
feast? :

A. Yes, sir.

ed which has charge of the kettle, or is it the
nation on whose reservation the condolence is
held?

A. Why, we generally have charge, that is, on the
reservation; the nation that is raising the chief
has to provide all the --~

(Interrupting) The nation that is raising the chief


Q.

has to provide the feast?

A. Surely; take care of the delegates.

. Can more than one head chief or principal chief be

raised on the Cayuga Nation, for instance, at one
condolence?

A. Generally the notice I have received has always
been one principal chief, but as many war chiefs
as you want from any other nation. ,

But your understanding, as I get it is, only one
principal chief can be raised at a condolence?

A. Yes, sir; that makes the condolence; we do not
have condolences for war chiefa,

But as many war chiefs as the nations or nation
sess fit, or the condolence sees fit, may be
raised at that condolence?

A.Yes, sir. The other nations have already got the
men ready for office.

I see. But also at a condolence chiefs maybe de-
posed?

4. Yes, sir,

Whether they are head chiefs or what they are?

A. It don't make any difference.

MR, OREGG: That is all.

RECROSS EXAMINATION

BY MR.. BROWN:

Q.

Do you mean, Mr. Brayley, if there were two or more
vacancies in the nation in the office of principal
chief, that they could not raise them at the same
time?

As From my own experience, that is all I could ever
see,

That ic, in these condolences you have been to,
there has been only one principal chief elected

of each nation?

A. Only one principal chief raised.

Well, at any time when you have gone to a condolence,
has there been more than one vacancy, or don't you
know about that?

A. I don't know ‘the business of the other nations,

but our offices are all filled,

Q.

2

Your testimony in that respect, in the respeot Mr.
Oregg has just questioned you, is limited to the
information that you gained in going to three
different condolences; is that right?

A. Yes, and from the custom Has it has always been

handed down to us.

Well, suppose there was a vavancy, two vacancies or
three vacancies in the. Tuscarora Nation, we will
take three, for instance, do you mean you would
have to call three difference condolences before
you get your full roster of chiefs back againt

A. Sachem chiefs’

Yes, you have so many sachem chiefst

A. Yes, sir,

Suppose three of them got in an automobile accident
and got killed; have you any right to raise three
to take their places at any one time?

A. I suppose we would have, but we have never had
that kind of an experience,

Now, a part of the ceremony of the condolence is

the calling of the Indian names, the Indian title of

the Chiefe of the different nations; is it not?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And what name or names are used with respect to
your nation assuming names at that call of this
roll?

A. T have never gone so thoroughly into research
as to be able to say as to that,

Q.That is, you do not understand the language in which
that roll call is made?

A. I do not participate in the ceremony to that
extent.

Q. Well, as a matter of fact, the call of that roll
of names contains but one name from the Tuscarora
nation; doesn't it?

A. I could not say.

Q. Well, now, we will talk for a moment again about
the deposition sy the clan mother; were you at the
condolence at which George Thomas was made a
chief?

A, Made a chief?

Q. Yes,

2

A. No.

» Have you ever been at a condolence at which the

principal chief or the head chief of the Six
Nations was elevated or crownea?

A. No, sir,

Do you know anything about the proceeding which

is gone through under the ritual in the crowning of
a head chief?

A. Only through our custom; that is all I know.
Well, you have never been present at any timet

A. No, six, never present.

And is there any clan to whioh the head chieftainship
belongs thatyou know of 7

A. Not to my knowledge.

Do you know whether any clan mother ever proposed
the name of George Thomas for Head Chief of the

Six Nations yourself?

A. I don't know of any myself.

» And if one clan mother ever proposed such a name,

no other clan mother would have the right to offer

his name to be deposed? You say the clan mother

has control only over her own chiefs; that is the

fact?
A. Yes, sir.

Q. And if one clan mother had proposed George Thomas
for this place, no other clan mother would have
the right to depose him; would she?

A. I don't know about that.
MR. BROWN: That is all,
MR. CREGG: That is all.
Jesse Thomas?
(No response)
Adam Thomas?
(Present)

Take the stand,

OR OR OR OK OK OK

ADAM THOMAS,

called as a witness on behalf of the defendants and

being duly sworn, testified as follows, through the

Interpreter:

BY

DIRECT EXAMINATION
MR. BRBGG:
Adam, how old are yout

A. Fifty years old. !

. Fifty?

A. Yes, sir.

. And of what Indian Nation are you a member?

A. Oneida,
Can't you talk a little louder so I can hear you,
Adam?

A. Yes,

Q.Where do you live?

A, Onondaga Reservation,

- Had you known - well, let me ask you this: To what

nation of Indians does the Wampum Keeper belong?
A. Why, I was appointed; Oneida Indians.

You were appointed Wampum Keeper of the Oneidas;

Q.

talk a little louder so I can hear yout

A. Yes, sir.

. When were you appointed Wampum Keeper?

A, In the neighborhood of about thirty years,
You were then about nineteen or twenty years old?

A. Yes.

» And have you been Wampum Keeper ever since?

A. Yes, sir,
Who fixes a date for a condolence?

A. I do,

. And is that a right of the Wampum Keeper?

A. Supposed to be.

. Has that been the custom in theSix Nations as long

as you can remember?

A. Yes, sir, ,

Who asks you to fix a date?

A. Why, one of the Head Chiefs of the Onondagas,
Of the Onondagas?

A. Yes, sir.

Well, is it the Head Chief of the Onondagas that

asks you to fix a date?

BY

Q.

BY

251

A. Yes, sir,
MR. BROWN: He said it was one of them.
MR. CREGG:
And after you fix a date for a condolence, what do
you do, after the date is fixed? Do you notify
anybody?
A. Oh, yes.
And whom do you notify?

THE COURT: Perhaps we can go along better
through an interpreter. Have you any objection?

MR, BROWN: No.

MR. OREGG: Just act as interpreter, if you
will, Mr. Hill, and see if we can hurry this along,
MR. CREGG:

Who do you notify?

A. Mfter he 1s notified, after he has set the
date, he notifies the Tuscaroras and the Oneidas,
How about the Mohawks?

A. I also notify the Mohawks,

Who notifies the other three nations?

A. The Head Chief of the Onondagas .

252

Do you remember a condolence that was held on
the Onondaga reservation on March eighth, 19247
A. Yes, sir.

Did you fix the date for that condolence?

A. Yes, sir.

. And did you notify your three nations, the Mohawks,

fuscaroras and Oneidas?

A. Yes, sir,

Q.Were you there at that condolence?

&

A. Yes, sir,
Was George Thomas there?

A. Yes, sir.

. He was Head Chief of the Six Nations at that time?

A. Yes, sir.

And what did you do at that condolenset

A. At the condolence I appointed a man to act in
my place, to carry the ceremony on.

You appointed a man to take charge of the ceremony?

A. Yes, sir.

. Is that your right; do you have a right to do that?

A. Yes, sir,


Q.

BY

BY

Q.

Go ahead and tell us what took place at that condo-

lence?

A. That was the time when George Thomas was deposed,
MR. BROWN: I move to strike that out as not

responsive.

MR. OREGG:

Well, before you come to that part of the ceremony,

were there some chiefs raised there, or a chief

raised?

A, Yes. James Lyons and B1li Schanadoah,

. ELL Schanandoah is a bodyguard?

A. Yes, sir.
Do you recollect whether or not there was any
chief raised there from the Tuscarora Reservation?
A. No, sir,
MR. BROWN: What does he say?
THE WITNESS: No, sir,
MR. CREGG: He does not recall.
MR. OREGG:
Now, did there come a time ~ well, I will waive that.

Whom did you appoint to takecbarge of the ceremonies?

BY

co

A. Stephen Obediah was appointed.

. Now, when it came along to the part of the ceremony

where there was a lull, or an intermission, a
pause, or whatever you call it, what took place theni
MR. BROWN: Let us hear what part Jesse Lyons
playedt
THE INTERPRETER: I am trying to explain what
the question is,
MR. BROWN: Will you tell us what he said about
Jesse lLyonst
THE INTERPRETER: He said it was Jesse Lyons
whowas appointed to depose George Thomas,
MR. BROWN: All right. That is what I want
to knoe.
MR. CREGG:
Who appointed him?)

A. Phoebe Lyons.

. All right. Now, go ahead and tell us the ritual?

A, That was all that happened after the deposition
and the raising of these two sub-chiefs,

Well, if you remember, tell us just what took place


2

BY

after Jesse Lyons was appointed to depose him;
what did Jewse say and do?
A, After he had ennounced the deposition of George
Thomas he delivered the wampum to me and I accepted
it, signifying that he was deposed.
Do you sometimes attend the councils of the Onondagas,
the meetings of the Onondaga Chiefs?
A, Sometimes,
Do you remember a meeting of the Onondaga Chiefs in
September of that year, 19247
A. Yes, sir, ,
And was there some action taken by the Onondaga
Ohiefs at that time in reference to naming a Head
Chief of the Six Nations?

MR, BROWN: I object to that unless it appears
who was there and who took this action,

THE COURT: Let him show first who was present,
if he remembers.

MR. CREGG:

.« Do you remember who of the Onondaga Chiefs were

present at that time?

BY

A. I cannot remember,

Do you remember about how many were there?’

A. I cannot say just how many there were there,

. Well, what was said and done there?

MR. BROWN: Well, I object to that as irrele-
vant and immaterial; it does not appear that the
meeting was in anyway properly called or that any-
body with authority was present.

MR. CREGG: We will show it by another witness,

THE COURT: Objection overruled. [I will receive
it subject to motion to strike it out leter if it
is not connected up.

MR. OREGG:
What was said and done there with reference to naming

a new Head Chief of the Six Nations?

A. It was at that time that the discussion was about

George Thomas being deposed.

WR. BROWN: I move to strike that out as not
Tesponsive. Adam, I want you to speak a little
louder, so George Thomas can hear what you Bay.

THE COURT: That may go out.

BY MR, OREGG:
Q. Was there someoody recommended at that time to take
his place?
MR. BROWN: I object to that as leading.
THE COURT: Objection overruled,
MR. BROWN: AN exception,
THE WITNESS: I cannot say.
BY MR. OREGG:
Q. Now, do you remember a condolence that washeld on
the Tuscarora Reservation in October, 12347
A. Yes, sir,
Q. Did you fix the date for that condolencet
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And did you notify your three nations of Indians?
A. Yes, sir,

. Who asked you to fix the date for that condolence?

Oo

A. Andrew Gibson.
Q. And were you present at that condolence?
A. Yes, sir,

Q. Wes there a head chief of the Six Nations raised at
that time?

BY

A. Yes, sir,

. And who was itt

A. Joshua Jones,

. And, now, is there anybody else that has any right

to fix a time for a condolence of the Six Nations,
except yourself as Wampum Keeper?
A. No, sir.
Did you fix any date, or.a day for any condolence
to be held on the Tuscarora or Cattaraugus Reserva-
tion in June of, that year?

MR. BROWN: Let us have his answer. When he
says "yes", say yes.

THE INTERPRETER: He doesn't say "yes",

MR. OREGG: I will repeat that question.

MR. BROWN: He said "Yes, sir", Interpret
what he said. May the Court make that instruction?

THE COURT: If he says "yes", of course, give
it, and then the attorneys can clear it up later, if
necessary,

MR. GREGG:

Q. Did George Thomas --~

BY

2

2

359

MR. BROWN: Just a minute, now. If there is
any question about this question, I ask the stenogra-—
pher to read it and give it to him and get the same
answer,

THE COURT: We have already taken the answer.

MR, CREGG:

. Did George Thomas ever ask you to call a conference?

A. No, sir,

. And was there any conference held in June of that

year, or a condoleme held in June of that year, that
you know off

A. Yes, sir,

Where’

A. Tuscarora,

. Were you there?

A. Yes, sir.

What day was that?

A. Fourth day of June.
Fourth day of June?

A. Yes, sir, fourth day of June.

260

What was done at that conference or condolence?
A, Why, the cause was that the Tuscaroras, they were
to raise a chief.

And did they raise a chief?

A. Yes, sir,

And is that all that took place at that conference
or condolence?

A. Yes, sir.

Q.And is that the condolence you referred to as having

fixed the date for in June, 19247

A. No.

Well, was there any condolence » tell us all of

the condolences that were held during the year 1924
that you know of, that were called by yout

A. It was when James Lyons was raised as a chief, and
H1li Schanandoah,

That was at the Onondaga reservation?

A. Yes, sir.

. Now, what was the next condolence that you fixed

the date fort

A. It was in the fall,


2

)

-

261

. And where was that held?

A, At Tonawanda.

And is that the one where Joshua Jones was made
Head Chief?

A. Yes, sir.

And are those all the conferences or condolences

‘that wereheld during 19247

A. Yes, sir,

You said something about a conference being held
June fourth, on the Tuscarora Reservation; is
thet right?

A. Yes, sir.

And what June was that; when?

A, This last summer.

- Oh, last Junet

A. Yes, sir.

. And were there any chiefs raised at that condolence?

A. I don't know the name,

. Well, from what reservation?

A, Tuscarora,

: Now, is that the conference that you referred to
’

BY

262

or that you meant when you answered that you fixed
the date for a conference or condolence in June?

A. Yes, sir.

. Now, have you told us of all of the condolences --~

A. (Waterpreter starts) -~-
(Interrupting and continuing) --~-Wait a minute until
I finish the question, Have you told us of all of
the condolences for which you fixed the date between
the time George Thomas was deposed and now?
A. Yes, sir.
Just two, one at Tonawanda and another at Tuscarora?
A. Yes, sir,

MR. CREGG: I think I will let you ask him for

a while,

CROSS EXAMINATION

MR. BROWN:

. Adam, what is that paper you have got in your

hands?
A. Piece of paper.
Let me see it,

A. (Same handed over).


263

. Whowrote that out for you? Ask him that?

A. James Lyons,

And this has got these dates on that Mr. Cregg has

been asking you about; hasn't it?

A. Yes, sir.

James Lyons told you that this was what you were to
say on the stand; that you were to tell about these
dates and not any others; didn't he?

A. He was the secretary and he got me the dates.
You don't know anything about these dates, except
what we have got here on this paper?

A. Yes, sir. ,

What did he say?

A. Yes, sir.

Did you ever call any other condolences in your life
except these three that James Lyons wrote down on
the paper for yout

A. No, sir,

» Well, you haven't been very active in this supposed

duty you had to call all these condolences; have yout

A. When I am asked to make a date, why, I do so.

264

Q. And there have been lots of condolences called and
lots of chiefs raised when you didn't have anything
to do with it at all; haven't there’

A. I think so,

Q. Yes. Who is the leader of the movement to try to
have George Thomas declared out of the chieftainship?

MR. OREGG: That is objeoted to as immaterial.

rae COURT: Objection sustained.

MR. BROWN; An exception,

BY MR. BROWN: |

Q. Well, haven't you been active yourself in attempting
to have George Thomas disqualified?

A. No, sir. .

Q. Has Jesse Lyons?

MR. OREGG: That is objected to.

MR. BROWN: It appears Jesse Lyons is the one
that made the pronouncement that hewas and we want
to have the interest of these people appear here.

MR. CREGG:; It wasn't Jesse Lyons at all,

MR. BROWN: Yes, he said it was,

MR. CREGG: He said it was Phoebe Lyons.


BY

. THE COURT: Objection sustained.
MR. BROWN: Anexception,
MR. BROWN:
Well, are Jesse Lyons and Phoebe Lyons related in
any way?

A. I don't think so.

. Is there any relationship between James Lyons and

Jesse Lyons?
A. I can't say what it is.
Of what tribe of Indians are you a member?

A. Oneida,

- Where is the Stockbridge tribe of Indians located?

A. I don't know,

- Bo you know where Stockbridge is?

A. No, sir.

Where were you born?

A. Onondaga reservation.

And you have lived all your life on the Onondaga
reservation?

A. Yes, sir,

» You live on Onondaga land there; do yout

MR. OREGG: That is objected to as immaterial. -
THE COURT: He may answer.
THE WITNESS: He said yes.
BY MR. BROWN:
Q. And by whom were you made chief?
A. The clan mother; I woul wee the clan of the
mother.
Q. Well, your only claim to being chief is your
since, who was an Oneida woman, appointed you chief;
isn't that right?
A. No, sir.
Q.Well, was there ever an Oneida council that passed
on your name as chief?
A. I can't say.
Q. Were you ever raised at any condolence of any kind?
A. Yes, sir,
Q. Where was that held?
A. Onondaga reservation.
@. And who was there?
A. All the chiefs were there.

Q. What chiefs?

267

A. The Ynondaga chiefs.

MR, BROWN: I guess that is all.

REDIRECT EXAMINATION
BY MR, CREGG:
Q. Adam, tell us the first condolence that you ever
attended?
MR. BROWN: I am afraid you will have to give
him the paper.
MR. OREGG: I will take care of that.
BY MR. CREGG:
Q. Well, let me ask you this, and this 6 certainly
not on the paper: When were you made chiefi
A, About thirty years ago.
Q. And where was the Condolence held at which you were
made chief?
A. At Onondaga reservation.
Q. Do you know who called that condolence or fixed the
date for it?

AT cannot say who it was,

268

. Whenafter that was the next condolence that you

attended’

A, I cannot say when,

. Where was it held?

A. At Onondaga reservation,

. Who fixed the date for it?

A, I cannot say as to that. -
When were you made Wampum Keeper?

A. About thirty years ago.

. Do you remember the condolence at which George Thomas

was-made Head Chief of the Six Nations’
A. Yes, sir,
Who fixed the date for that condolence?

A. I did.

. Were you there at the time of the condolence?

A. Yes, sir,

. Was there any other condolence held after that and

during the time that George Thomas was Head Chief?
I will ask that question this way and perhaps he
will understand it better: Between the time George

Thomas was made Head Chief and the time he was deposed,


269

was there any condolence held in there’
A, I can't say.
2. Do you remember any condolence before George Thomas
was made Head Chieft
A, Many a time that I remember.
Q. And who fixed the dates for those condolences?
A. I have,
MR. CREGG: That is all.
MR, BROWN: That is all.

MR. OREGG: I will call Jesse Lyons.

JES SH Lyons,
called as a witness on behalf of the defendants and being
duly sworn, testified as follows:
: DIRECT BXAMINATION
BY MR. OREGG:
a Do you talk English’

MR, BROWN: I guess he talks pretty good Wnglish.

THE COURT: We will take a recess for five minutes.

(Recess taken from 21:50 to 11:55 A. M.
Case resumed thereafter. )

BY MR, CREGG:
Q. Jess, where do you livet

A. Onondaga reservation,
Q. How old are you?

A. Fifty-six.
Q. Are you an Onondaga Indian?

A. Yes, sir.
Q. What ie your position on the reservation?

A. I am now sub-chief,
Q. You wre suopohieft

A. Bodyguard,
Q. Bodyguard’

A. Yes, sir.
Q. How long have you been such sub-chief or bodyguard?

A. Between twenty-two and twenty#four years.
Q. And you are. bodyguard for what head chief, or which

head~chieft?

A, I am bodyguard to Andrew Gibson.

Q. Now, as bodyguard for Andrew Gibson, what are your


Eyes

duties?
A. My duties is to do whatever he says; if he sends
me a8 a runner to other reservations, and if there

is some special call.

Q. That is, it is your duty to do whatever Andrew Gib-
son. directs you to dot
A. Yes, sir,

Q. Do you remember the condolence that was held at
the time George Thomas was made Head Chief?
A. Yes, sir, ;

Q. And where was that hela?
A. It was down on the Onondaga reservation,

Q. And about when was that?
A. On March eighth.

Q.What year?

A. 1924.

ray

. Well, is that the date he was raised?
A. No, sir,
Q. Well, when was he raised to be chief?

A. Well, that was vefore that,

ad

How long before that?

‘

2

)

=

A. Well, I couldn't say exactly; I say about between
seven and ten years before tht.

Somewhere along there’

A. Yes, sir.

Well, where did that condolence take place where

he was raised to be chiefi

A. Onondaga reservation,

Were you there at that condolence’

A. Yes, sir,

Tell us how he was made Head Chief?

A. What do you mean; who has charge of the ceremony,
or what?

Everything you know about it; begin at the beginning
in your own way?

A. In the beginning of it, the chiefs call a special
council,

That is, the chiefs on the Unondaga reservation?

A. The chiefs of the Onondaga tribe.

I see. Now, let me ask you right there: Who was
Head Chief before that?

A, Andrew Gibson,

2

©

273

He was Head Chief of the Onondagas?

A. Yes, et.

Now, who was Head Chief of the Six Nations before
that condolence?

A. Before? ,

Yes.

A. Nobody was; the fellow died at that time.

That is what I am getting at. Who was he that
died?

A. Frank Logan,

Frank Logan was Head Chief and he died sometime
before that?

A. Yes, sir.

I see. Now, does the Head Chief of thé Six Nations
belong to the Onondaga Nation of Indians?

A. Yes, sir.

Now, you say that the Chiefs of the Onondagas

got together; didn't they?

A. Yes, sir,

Q.Were you present at their meeting?

A. Yes, sir.

2

Q.

A And in that meeting do they disouss different

names or different men tobecome Head Chief of the
Six Nationst

A. Yes, sir,

Who was present at that meeting?

A, The majority of the chiefs.

The majority of the chiefs?

A. Yes, sir,

Is there any clan mother present there?

A. No, sir.

Now, whet name did the chiefs decide on at that
meeting?

A. They decided first and who was nominated was a

young fellow by-«the name of Levi Green.

. Yest

A. And they discussed over him and he wasn't
qualified enough to become Six Nations Chief.
Yes?

A. and then another nominee come in was George
Thomas, and they discussed over that and they

decided upon George Thomas to be Six Nations Chief,

2

2

and they wanted to know what clan he belongs,

and finally they found he belongs to fel clan,

and then they discussed over again who is going to
be mother, condolence mother, and then they finally
said Phoebe Lyons at that meeting, the same time.
And they decided right there on the whole thing?

A. Yes, sir,

And after that was there a condolence called?

A, A condolence was called; yes, sir,

And who fixed the date for that condolence’

A. Adam Thomas.

And what part did you have in calling the condolence’

A. Why, after the ceremony --~-

(Interrupting) Before you get to the ceremony;

did you notify any nations to attend?

A. No, sir, I had no business to notify any nations.
I see. But you were present at the condolence?

A, Yes, sir. ,
Now, who was master of ceremonies there at the
condolence?

A. The ceremony was done by Steve Obediah.

Q. I see. Was George Thomas therei

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Now, tell us all that took place there that day;
right from the beginning of this condolence on
that day, tell us what happened?’

A. I beg pardon. I didn't quite understand. You
speaking about the time when he was raised, ain't
yout

Q. Yes, sir, the day he was raised?

A. Yes. Well, on that time, I could not say how

many chiefs we raised, but anyway he was raised;

I could not mention what day of the month, but it
ihappened in Onondaga Reservation,

Q. Yes. Well, all right, get down to the part of the
ceremony where George Thomas was raised to be
Chief, Head Chief of the Six Nations, and tell
us about that part of it?

A. Well, that is all, what I told you,

Q. Well, who named George Thomas in the condolence?

A. I don't understand you, named him in condolence;

do you mean who raised him?

Yes.

A. Well, yes. Raised him by Phoete Lyons.

. Well, now, Jess, tell us just what she said in

there and what was done as near as you can, so

that we will have a picture of what took place;
what did she say when she raised him?

A. I don't know what they said. It was through the
chiefs, and the chiefs they handed it over to me

to raise him.

. And did you take part in raising him?

A. Yes.

. AlL vight. Well, who designated you to take partt

A. The chiefs,

Now, then, what did you dot Tell us what you dia.
there’

A. Well, I went through the regular ceremony.

I was speaker, ana they produced the wampum and I
went across -——~

(Interrupting): That is, they produced the wampum
and gave it to yout

A. Yes, sir.

2

a

. And you carried it over to one side?

A. Yes, sir.
And then back to the other side?

A. Yes, sir.

. And then delivered it to Adam Thomas, the Wampum

Keeper?

A. I wasn't sure it was, but whoever was over there,
But you delivered it to somebody on that side?

A. Yes, sir.

And then he was Head Chief, was he, after that?

A. Yes, sir,

. Now, come along down to March eighth, 1924; tell

us what happened before that in reference to George
Thomas?’

A, Wheat do you mean, in the ceremony on March the
elghthi

No. Before we get to the condolence on March eighth,
what had George Thomas done; had George Thomas

done something, did he do something that was dis-—
pleasing to the Nation’

A. Only thing I know, I ain't going to say anything

else than what I know,

That is all I want you to say?

A, They appointed me one evening to go around to
different reservations to stop conferences being
held by Livingston Crouse and Mrs. Kellogg. I

go down to the Tonawanda reservation and notify the

chiefs, and I went from there to Tuscarora reservation.

I had consent of these chiefs in our reservation,

. That is, the chiefs of your reservation, the

chiefs of the Onondaga reservationt

A. Yes, sir,

That you should do that?

4. And I got consent from George Thomas too.

To go around?

A. Yes, also, and Andrew Gibson, also Joshua Jones,
and Emmett Lyons and some others.

I see,

A. And when I got down there to Tuscarora tenereniiion
I went right straight to Warren Brayley. I got
over there and I found that Brayley was up to his

house. He was a chairman of their tribe. And 1

talked with him and I told him that I was sent from

the chiefs and they authorized me to notify them to
don't have any conference with these two people.

Q. You mean no confidencest

THE COURT: No conference.

BY MR, OREGG:
Q. No conferencet
A, Yes. And then Mr. Brayley, he said, "Who sent
yout Who authorized yout" I showed him my credential,
and he laughed at me. He said that, "Did Mr. Thomas
give you that credential?" I said, "Yes, sir",
He said, "That's funny", and then he went over
and showed me Mr. Thomas give them the consent to,
Mr. Livingston Grouse and Mrs. Kellogg, to go
around and see them,

And hold the conference?

=

A.Yes. And then I asked Mr. Brayley, I said, "Will
you copy this?" and he said, "Yes, sir", and then he
copy it, and then I had a fellow with me, fellow by
the name of Adam Spring, who is a Seneca Tonawanda
Indian,

Q. What is that?

Bl

A. Spring.
Q. Some thing?

A. Spring.
Q. Oh. Spring?

A. Yes.

Q. All right. And then I asked this man Spring, I said,

"You see what I discovered?" and he said, "Yes, sir".

I said, "Will you approve of thati" "Yes, sir", he
said, and then he signed it, and also I asked Mr.
Brayley if he will sign any paper for me, and they
did, both of them; and so I come back, ana after
I return home, and then they came up to my house
one evening, it was no regular meeting, but they
came and so I set right side of the table and they
came and Thomas came up, and I said, "Well", —
asked me a question when [ --~

MR. BROWN (Interrupting): If we are going to
have any deliberations, I would like to have the
names of those present.

BY MR. CREGG:

Q. Tell us who came to your house as near as you can?

i
i
‘i
i

After I return, you mean?

. Yes, after your return?

A. Yes. Andrew Gibson, George Thomas, Wilson
Johnson and Joshua Jones, and John White, John
W. White. That is all I could mention the names

of.

. Did you say George Thomas was there?

A, Yes, sir,

. All right. Now, tell us what took place there;

tell us everything that was said’

A. They didn't have any regular esting, just wanted
to know what I done. I was sent to different reser~
vations, and so I told them. I said, "I discover

this", and I laid it on the table.

. And that was the paper that you got at Tonawanda’

A, No, sir.

. Wheret

A. To Mr. Brayley's,
Tuscarora?

A. Yes, sir.

Q.Yes, sir. All right. Now, when you laid those two

B83

papers on the table, what was said?

A. Wasn't two papers; only one.

One paper?

A, Yes.

ALL right.

A, Well, I laia it on the table and George Thomas
read it and he just put it to one side and didn'+%

said not a word about it.

. Did anybody else say anything?

A. No.

. Well, didn't anybody talk there at all that night?

A. Didn't say nothing about what I discovered,

. Did you show it to the other chiefs?

A, I told them.

. Well, what next happened?

A. Well, that is all I can remember of from my
part.

All vight. Well, what did you say or do after
that? ,

A. What do you meant

. Did anybody say anything or warn Thomas that he --~

Did anybody warn George Thomas, that you know of?

BY

. At a meeting of the Onondaga Council.

A. Well, I wouldn't say they did because I wasn't

with them, but I just heard it, but I wouldn't say
I know all about it.
Just tell us what you know about it?

A, What do you meant

. About his being warned?

A, Well, I was told that.
MR. BROWN: I object to that as incompetent
and hearsay.
THE COURT: He may tell what he knows person-
ally.
MR. BROWN: Yes.
MR. CREGG:
Now, was it brought up at any meeting of the
Onondagas after that?
A, At what kind of meeting? What do you mean?
What meeting?
Where was
George Thomas next discussed by anybody that you
know of in your presence?

A. Some woBds there I can't get hold of.

385

. When was he next talked about?

A. What matter’

. About his actions on the reservation?

A. I don't go to all the meetings. I don't know
what they did at the next meeting.

I see. Well, then, there was this condolence

of March eighth, 1924; wasn't there?

A. Yes, sir,

. Were you there?

A. March eighth, 19247
Yes.

A. Yes, sir, I was there,

. Were there any chiefs raised at that time?

A. Yes, sir.

. Who?

A. James Lyons, #1i Schanandoah, that is, Onondagas,
and there 1s another sub-chief was raised, I
couldn't mention his first name, but Rickard I

think his last name was, from Tuscarora reservation.

. Was George Thomas there’

A. Yes, sir.

2

2886

About how many were there altogetheri
A. A full house.
The Long House was filled?

A. Yes, sir.

. About how many people will the Long House on the

Reservation hold?

A. I couldn't say;-I couldn't say how many.
Can you tell us about how large it ist

A. Well, just about - oh, just about the length
of this,

About as long as this room is?

A. Yes, sir, but not so wide.

As wide as from the bench over to the wall?
A. Well, about from that bench,

From the table, you mean?

A. Yes, sir.

From the table to the wall’

A. Yes, sir, That is only guessing.

. How were the people in the House; were they séated,

or standing?

A. Seated.


287

Q. And was the place pretty well filled, as you say?

A.Yes, sir.

2

What nations were represented there besides the
Onondaga?
A. In that condolence?
Q. Yes.
A, Tonawanda, Senecas, Oneidas, Tonawanda Senecas,
Oneldas, Tuscaroras and Onondagas.
Q. Were the Cayugas theret
A. I don't know; I couldn't say.
Q. Now, will you tell us how many chiefs of the
Onondagas were present at that condolem ef
A. I couldn't say how many, but a majority of
them,
Q. Now, tell us what took place when a lull came in
the condolence?
A, When a lull in the condolence came?
Q. Well, there came a time in the condolence when
there was silence, that everyoody stopped for a
little while; wasn't there?
A. Well, what part do you mean? So many parts of

the condolence going on,

i

BY

Well, just before you considered George Thomas,

was there a pause in the condolence?
MR, BROWN: A restt

MR. CREGG:

» Well, let me ask you this way: After the chiefs were

raised, James Lyons, Schenandoah, and this other
chief, what next took place in the condolence?

A. Well, that is the time they brought the matter
to open, if any person wants to dispose the chiefs,
and then I went ~ when I raised these three chiefs,
I got over to where there was chiefs was sitting
on a long bench, wasn't any chairs there, it is a
bench, they were setting lined up there, and when

I got over there John White, he showed me a wampum,
and I said, "What is that fori" He said, "That is
to depose George Thomas". there is lined up
chiefs on the bench, and when I got over there I
said, "This is legali" They said, "Yes", And
then I looked to mother condolence, Phoebe Lyons,

she set away back, and I said, "This is all right?"

and she done like that (nodding head), must be


Q

meaning "yes", and so I went down to the ceremony
to depose, and I went across amd handed it to Adam
Thomas, and when I was going back halfway to

cross the hall, Harry Isaacs, my friend Harry Isaacs,
he was sitting, I was on right hand side, when I
come to go back across the hall, over to where the
chiefs was setting, and he jumped up, got right up
and he said, "That never will be stand", and he
said he is going to be chief forever,

Was Harry Isaacs a chief?

A. No. And then he Advert produced a wampum to
stop George Thomas putting down, and then when

I got down where the chiefs are they produced
another wampum and they want me to cut him down
entirely, and so I took it again and I explained
few remarks and I went over there and handed it to
Adam Thomas the second time, ana tmt is all there

is to it, Nobody had said nothing at all.

. Did you ask Phoebe Lyons if it was all right?

A. Yes, sir.

. And what did she say’

290

A. Why, well, she told me to do this, and I said,
‘This is all right?" and ehe said, "Yes, sir",
Now, why did you go through that ceremony twice,
with two wampunst

A. Yes.

I say, why did you do that?

A. Because Harry Isaacs jumped up half way and he
stopped George Thomas, pulling bim down, down
legally, but the chiefs, they authorized me to

put him down second time.

This is what I am getting at, right there: If

a chief is to be deposed, and after the first part
of the ceremony, can somebody object then, and
that only puts him part way down, if there is some
objection; is tht right?

A. Yes, sir.

. And thenwhen you go through the seremony the second

time that cuts him all the way down’

A. Yes, sir.

Now, did you attend any conferences or councils

of the Six Nations during the summer of 1924, after

George Thomas was cut down?

291

A, Six Nation conference’

Yes,

A. You mean Six Nation conference?
Yes, conference and not a condolence?
A, Yes, sir.

Where?

A. Down to Tonawanda reservation.

» Do you remewber when that wast

A. No, sir. The Clerk is supposed to know.

Well, to refresh your reoollection, was that on
or about the twenty-first of September, or do you
remember? Let me ask you this: Was that conference
that you atvented at Tonawanda between the time
George Thomas was cut down and the time Joshua
Jones was raised?’ Was it in between those two
dates!

A, I think they had a session there after George
was put out, down at Tonawanda.

And before Joshua Jones was put int

A. I think after he was put in, I think that; I

am not sure.

292

Q. Well, what I was getting at, who presided over the

Six Nations after George Thomas was put out am
before Joshua Jones was put ini

A. In that meeting, you mean, at Tonawandai

. Yes,

A, And what do you mean there?’ You are jumping

over there. I don't know what you mean.

I don't know as I make it clear, but did anybody
pteside, as you know of, at any of the conferences
between the time George Thomas was put out and before
Joshua Jones was out int Do you know?

A. If you will give me a Little explanation, I

can tell what you mean,

- Well, it is not so important. If there isn't any

Head Chief of the Six Nations, who presidest Is
it the Head Chief of the Onondagas?

A. No, not now.

. No, not now, but suppose there wasn't any Head

Chief of the Six Nations, would the Head Chief of
the Onondagas presidet

A. I can't get at all what you mean.

893

. Now, were you present at a condolence, or, first

let me ask you this: After George Thomas was put

out as Head Chief, what was done toward making a

new Head Chief?

A. Well, after George Thomas was put out there was

a vacancy in his position about four or five months
and then I got notice -~~

(Interrupting) Go ahead?

A. I got notice from Andrew Gibson that we going
have a session to consider the matter of that matter,
and that was on September ninth, nineteen ---~
(Interrupting) And was there a meeting of the council
that day’

A. And then is when really they called to have a
session,

Was that the Long House?

A. No, sir.

. Where was it?

A. We got together over to Phoebe Lyons, and we got
together and she brought this matter up that George

Thomas was deposed and she wanted to name a man on

that place, and so she brought the matter to the
council that Joehua Jones was a young man qualified
enough to take on that position, and they decided
to accept him,

@. They decided on Joshua Jones; did they?
A. Yes, sir,

Q. And approved him for the office of Head Chief?

A. Yes, sir.

2

Now, after that, was shere a condolence called?
A. Yes, sir.
Q.And where did that take place?

A, On the Tonawanda reservation.
Q. When, what date?

A. On October fourth.
Q. Of the same year?

A. Same year, 1924.
Q. Now, what was done at that condolence to make
Joshua Jones Head Chief?
A. Well, after we went over there, we went over
there and opened the ceremony and when it come to

raise the chief, they had a vacancy over there for


&

295

sachem on Tonawanda Reservation, and they put me in
for spokesman for the raising chief and so I did,
and after that is done they theycalled my attention
to raising Joshua Jones, and then I did, that is,
Six Nation Chief. Then they give another wampum

to raise another chief, whichewer it was, I

don't know what it is, sub-chief, or I codldn't
say, but anyway I raised a young Wilson Johnson,

As Chief of the Onondagas?

A, Yes, sir,

. To take whose place? Whose place did Wilson Johnson

take?

A, Took the place on where Joshua Jones was before
he took on Six Nations Chief.

Was Joshua Jones a chief before he was made Head
Chief?

A.Yes, sir,

He was Chief of the Onondagas?

A.Yes, sir.

Now, when a Chief is raised to Head Chief, does

that make the office of Chief vacant?

A. Yes, sir; can't hold two chairs,

One man cannot hold two chairs?

A, No, sir.

When he is raised up higher he gives the lower
chair away?

A. Yes, sir,

. Was Phoebe Lyons there that time’

A. Yes, sir,

What did she say or do in reference to the naming
of Joshua Jones as Head Chief?

A. Well, after I done this rasing of new chiefs,
she came up and she said to the Chiefs that was
with us that she was ready and they told me that,
and I go through this ceremony and put Joshua Jones

in place of George Thomas.

. You mean all the cniefs that were there at that timei

A. Yes, sir.
And how many chiefs were present at that time
from the Onondaga Reservation?

A. In that condolence?

Q. Yes,

A. Specially of the Onondagas, or whet do you mean?

. dust tell me who was present from the Onondagas

first and then tell me all the others after?
A, Andrew Gibson was there, and Emmett Lyons, and
Joshue Jones, and Wilson Johnson, and I, and Lucius

Schenandoah,.

Q. And you said Phoebe Lyons was there?

A. Yes, sir.

. And she is the Hel clan mother?
A, Yes, sir.

. And she is the woman who raised George Thomas in
the first placet
A.Yes, sir.

. And also the woman who deposed him in March,
19247

A. Yes, sir,

Q. And then she named Joshua Jones in his place’

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Who is the Head Chief of the Ynondagas?

4. Andrew Gibson,

Q. How long has he been Head Chief?

©

A. I couldn't say. He was chief longer than I was,

. And how long have you been chief?

A. Between twenty-two and twenty-four years.

And Andrew Gibson has been Head Chief ever since?
A. Yes, sir,

Can you name the. Chiefs on the Onondaga Reservation
as they were before this dispute started in 19247
Do you know what I mean?
A, I don't know as I can name them all,

Well, name as many as you can?

A. What do you meant I want a full understanding.
What do you mean, before George Thomas was put

out or after he was put out?

Before he was put out? ,

A. Beforehe was put out?

Yes, ,

A, When he was holding office?

Yes, sir, when he was Head Chief of the Six Nations,
Do you understand?

A. Yes,

Now, first, let me ask you this: While he was Head


2

299

Chief of the Six Nations thete was not any dispute
about the chiefs; was there’

A, There was when‘

. He was Head Chief, and while he was Head Chief,

then there wasn't any dispute’

A. No, sir.

As to who was Chiefs, was there?

A.No, sir.

Now, give me the names of all the chiefs that you
can remember just before George Thomaswas put outs
A, Just before?

Yes.

A. ALL right, sir. I try. I do the best.

George Thomas.

. He was Head Chief of the Six Nations?

A, You got me balled up again. Just keep cool
for a while, please.

All right, Jess. You take your time and go ahead.
A, I want to go through, now. George Thomas,

Andrew Gibson, Emmett Lyons, George Crowe, John

“We. White, old man Wilson Johnson, and young Frank

B

i)

e

BY

Isaacs, and old man George Van Every, and Charlie

Green, and Webster, I think William Webster, I think,

anyway I say Webster.

. Do you think his name is William?

MR. BROWN: Willie’

THE WITNESS: I don't know Willie or William;

I say Webster.

MR. CREGG:

Well, it is William or Willie, either one. Go

ahead, |

A. And then his son George Webster, and then Young

David Green,
Howard Hill,

Howard what?

and then Rubin Jones and myself and

MR, BROWN: Hill,

WR. OREGG:

-» Howard Hill?

A. Yes, sir,
And who else
A. Just give

I think that

do you. remember at that timo?
mea achance. I am just thinking.

is all I can name, as near as I can,

301

Maybe I skip one or two, or two or three. I don't
know as I can name any nore now.

MR, CREGG: If Your Honor please: There is one
matter I want to bring before you and that is, we
have a witness on the reservation who is a very
elderly woman and ill and she cannot attend court,
and I was wondering if at this time an application
would be in order to have her testimony taken and
preserved, and I would like to present the formal
order this afternoon,

MR. BROWN: Who is the witness?

WR, CREGG: Phoebe Lyons,

THE COURT: Very well. We will take that up
later,

The Court will take a recess until two o'clock.

(WHEREUPON at 12:40 P. M,, a recess was taken

until 2:00 P. M,, same date and place. )

AFTERNOON SESSION,

SYRACUSE, NEW YORK, THURSDAY, MARCH 1, 1988, 2:00 P. M.
PRESIDING:
HONORABLE FREDERICK H, BRYANT,
FEDERAL JUDGE.
APPEARANCES:
(Same as before.)5

JESSE Lyons,
resumed the stand as a witness on behalf of the
defendants, testified as follows:
DIRECT EXAMINATION
BY MR. OREGG: (Continued)
Q. Did you name all the chiefs that you remember before
Thomas was cut down’

A. I named them all that I can,

£

Was Newton Green a bodyguard?
A. I don't know whether he was a bodyguard while

he was a chief, bodyguard or whatever it was,

303

Q. How about Oscias Schenandoah?

rz)

&

BY

2

A, I couldn't remember if he was, I know he is
chief, or bodyguard.
How about Albert Kennedy’

A, Yes,

.. And Joshua Jones?

A, Yes, sir.
MR, BROWN: He named Joshua Jones.
MR, OREGG: Did he name Joshua Jones?
MR. BROWN: No, I guess he did not.

MR, CREGG: You may cross~examine.

OROSS EXAMINATION
WR. BROWN:
How long ago did you say it was, Mr. Lyons that
George Johnson, or George Thomas was made Head
Chief?

A. George Johnson?

. George Thomast

A. Well, between six and eight years.

p>)

304

- Well, it was 1917; wasn't it? Isn't that avout

right?

A. I dian't say 1917, because I don't know what year.

- But you do remember the things which happened when

he was made Head Chief of the Six Nations?

A. Yes, sir,

. And he succeeded Logan, did he?

A, Yes, sir,
Logan was Head Chief for how long?
A. I wouldn't say how long, but I know he was Chief

a long time.

. Was he Chief of the Six Nations when you became

Chief, Logant

A. Yes, sir.

And 1t was after his death that you had this meeting
of the Onondaga. Council to determine who should be
chief, wasn't it; after Logan's death?

A, Explain that again?

I say it. was after Logan'a death that you had this
meeting of the Onondaga Council to talk about having
a new Head Chief of the Six Nations; wasn't it;

after Logan died?

2)

305

A, Yes, sir,

. All right. Ana the Chiefs met and talked over

their candidates and decided upon George Thomas,
as I understand you; is that right?

A. That is just for the Onondaga chiefs.

. The Onondaga Chiefs met and decided to have George

Thomas for the principal chief or head chief of
the Six Nations?

A. Yes, sir,

. And then after they made that decision they called

in this woman elder of the clan to propose his
name ¢

A. Yes, sir.

. And that was Phoebe Lyons?

A. Yes, sir,
She didn't have anything to say about it until after
the chiefs had made their decision; did she?

A. No.

. All right. Now, what was the date of thie condolence

in which you say that Thomas was cut down as head

chief?

A. On March eighth.

Of 19247

A, Yes, sir, in Onondaga Reservation,

On that date’

A. Yes, sir.

When did you first know that that was going to be
done at that condolence’ What was the first you
knew about it?

A. You mean to have a condolence on our reservation?
No. When did you know first that cutting down George
Thomas was going to come up at that condolence?

A, The time I got into the Council House,

. You mean while the condolence was going ont

A. Yes, sir,

» You as chief did not know anything about it until

that time?

A. They had geetings three or four times and I
never went.

And you don't know who was there?

A. What do you meant

You didn't know when they had meetings, and you didn't


©

BY

307

know who was at the meetings they had; did yout
A, They had the meetings over in Henry Isaacs!
and they had the meeting over in old man George

Johnson's, I was told and I didn't go.

. You didn't got

A. No.

But you knew that old man George Johnson never

wanted to have George Thomas cut down or

replaced up to this time?

A, To have George deposed?

Yes.

A. He has no right to say.

You know he has not?

A. I know he hasn't right.

You know he has not; don't you?

A. Yes, sir.
MR. CREGG: I don't know how he knows that.
WR, BROWN: Let him say so then,

MR. BROWN:

Now, who first told you at the condolence then

that George Thomas was to be cut down?

A. John White.

. And who elset

A, And the majority of the chiefs there.

. Well, who were they?

A. A lot of them,

Q. Who?
A. Well, there is Johnnie White.
Q. Yest
A. Young Joshua Jones.
Q. Yest
A. And Howard Hill was there and Wilson Johnson,
and old man Van Every, he was there,
Q. Yes, And who else?

A. And Charlie Green was there.

Yes. And who elset

A.That is all I can mention.

Now, take those you tell us were there, which ones
of them told you to nit George Thomas down?

A. John White.

. Yes. George Van Every, Senior, didn't tell you

that, did he, or didn't consent to it?


Q.

2

309

A. George Van Every’ No, sir.

. And Howard Hill didn't consent to it either; did

he?

A. No, sir.

Nor Charles Green didn't consent to it?
A. No, sir.

Well, how do you say that the majority of them
consented to it, when everyone I asked you here
about you say did not; now, who were the ones

that didt

A. Do you want me explain it to yout

. No. I want you to answer my question. Who are

the ones that did tell you to cut him downt John
White was one. Now, who else?

A. John White, Joshua Jones. They did when they
handed me the wampum,

Well, all right. Well, now, let me ask you this:
You have given Mr. Oregg the names of twenty—one
men who were chiefs at the time that George Thomas
was Head Chief, of which George Thomas is one of

the twentysone; that leaves twenty others; now,

BY

how many of these twenty ever told you to cut down

George Thomas as Head Chief?
A. That is not supposed to be for consent for

the whole chiefs,

. Just answer the question.

A, That belongs to the mother condolence,

I did not ask you that.
MR, CREGG: I object to that as immaterial.
THE COURT: He may answer.
MR. CREGG: An exception,

MR. BROWN:

. How many of those twenty chiefs ever told you to

do. that?

A. I just mentioned.

You mentioned two. How many more were there besides
the twof

A. That is all,

That is all. So, including yourself there is

three of the twenty chiefs that have ever told

you to do that; is that right?

A. Yes, sir.


313

A. I don't know.

Q. Well, you made up your mind you had to do it
over again; didn't yout
A. Yes, sir. .

Q. And who else besides Harry Isaacs objeoted to it
right there in the condolence?
A, That is all I know of.
Q. That is all you heard?
A. Yes, sir,

Q. Well, now, you were notified that same night or
the next morning to attend the meeting at the
Long House of the Onondaga Council of Chiefs; were
yout
A. After that date?

Q. The next day; the meeting held on the ninth of
March?

A. No, sir.

Q. You say you were not notified?
A. No, sir.

Q. Did you attend?

A. No, sir.

Q.

BY

Now, there isn't any question but what George

Thomas was chosen to become Head Chief by the
Oouncil of the Onondaga SBiefs; is there?

MR, CREGG: I object to that as a conclusion.
He stated what took place,

THE COURT: Yes.

MR, BROWN: Well, if it appears, all right.

MR. BROWN: -

. Well, now, when you were closing at this condolence

what you were attempting to do, somebody made an
objection; didn't they?

4. Objection to having the condolence?

No. An objection to cutting down George Thomas
or deposing him?

A. Yes, sir, ,

And who made that objection’

A. Harry Isaacs,

And when an objection is made that calls for a
consideration, or a reconsideration of that
action; doesn't iti That is the effect of it,

isn't it?


BY

313

. Did you ever see any transcript of proceedings

that were had at thet meeting the next day?
A, No, sir.
MR. BROWN: I ask to have this marked for iden~
tification.
(Paper -three sheets- marked plaintiff's
exhibit No. 1, for identification. )
MR. BROWN:
I show you an exhibit consisting of three sheets,
marked plaintiff's exhibit Number one for identifi-
cation, and I ask you if you ever saw that?
A. I cannot read,
Can't you read English’
A. No, sir,
Can you read names when you see them?
A. I can't see,
You can't seet
A. No, my eyes is bad.
Can you see the different lines; can you count the
names that are on there, starting right there with

that firet one’

Qo

2

2

2

314

A. One, ~--
(Interrupting) Two, three, four, five, six, seven,
eight, nine, ten, eleven, twelvet

A, Twelve,

. Yes. Well, now, Georbe Van tivery, Senior, he was

one of the chiefs at that time; wasn't heft
A. Yes, sir,

Charles Green was one of them?

A, Yes, sir. ,

Frank Isaacs was one of them?

A. Yes.

. Howard Hill was one of them?

A. Yes, sir,

William Webster was one of themt

A. Yes, sir.

Aloert Kennedy was one of them?

A, Yes, sir,

George Webster was one of them’

A. Yes, sir,

George Van Every, Junior, was one of them?

A. Yes, sir.

&

Q.

Q.

BY

Q.

315

Newton Green was one of them?
A. Yes, sir.

Davis Green was one of them’

A. Yes, sir.

Ruben Jones was one of them?

A. Yes, sir.

And George Crowe was one?

A, Yes, sir.

. And so that this paper, if it does contain the

names of these thirteen men I have read as of
March ninth, contains the signatures of a majority
of the chiefs out there at that time; doesn't it?
MR. CREGG: Just a minute. I object to that
question in that form.
THE COURT: Objection sustained.
MR. BROWN: An exception,
MR. BROWN:
You did not attend this meeting of the Onondaga
Council?
A, On the ninth of tarchi

On the ninth day of March?

A, No, sir,

. All right. Now, you did attend a meeting on the

ninth day of September at the home of Phoebe
Lyonst

A. Yes, sir.

How did you happen to meet at the home of Phoebe
Lyons?

A. How did it happen?

Yes, how did it Happen Is that where you
ordinarily hold meetings of the council?

A. No, str,

How did you happen to hold the meeting there’

A. I got notice from Andrew Gibson.

- To go over to Phoebe Lyons House’

A. Yes, sir,

. Who was there?

4. I was there. Andrew Gibson was there.
Yes. And who else?
A. And John White, Emmett Lyons, Wilson Johnson,

and Ocias Schenandoah, and James Lyons, and I,

. Now, you have told me how many’ You have given me

317

the names of seven; haven't you!
A. Have you seven namest
Yes,

A, Well, seven or eight; whichever it is.

. At that time there were at least twenty chiefs on

the reservation; weren't there?

A. Yes, sir,

. You seven met down there and you seven attempted

to make up your minds who was going to be Head
Chief for all the rest of them; didn't yout

A. Yes, sir.

. Why didn't you have the others meet with yout

A. I don't know.

But there were only seven of you that made up your
minds you were going to have Joshua Jones; is that
right’ :

A. Yes, sir.

And then after that you went to a condolence some-
where; is that right?

A. Yes, sir,

Q. Where did you have the condolence?

Q

A. On the Tonawanda Reservation,

Well, now, in all your knowledge of Indian history
and customs, did you ever know of a Head Chief of
the Six Nations of Indians to be raised anywhere
except upon the Onondaga reservation before this
time? Where was George Thomas raised?

A. George Thomas was raised on the Onondaga reserva-
tion,

Where was Logan raised?

A. I don't know where he was raised.

. Have you ever heard of raising a Head Chief anywhere

except upon the Onondaga Reservation, that is, until
this time you went up there and raised this Joshua
Jones?

A, Not that I know of,

Now, why didn't you hold this condolence right here
on the Onondaga Reservation where all the chiefs

and all the people could know about it?

A. Why?

Q. Yes.


319

4. Want me to explain it to you?

Yes.

A. The reason he wasn't dead, just put him out,

and they can raise on any other reservation. If he
was dead in our reservation, we couldn't raise from
the Tonawanda Reservation.

Well, George Thomas wasn't dead; he was right here?

A. Yes, sir.

. And you didn't want to have a condolence where

he would know about it, or a majority of the chiefs?
A. It is not that.

Well,isn't the reason why you called this condolence
out there that you did not want a majority of the
chiefs at the reservation to know anything about

iti

A, No, sir.

The majority of them didn't know anything about it;
dia they?

A, It is no action of mine to notify them.

Did you notify anybody?

A. Me?

2

320

Yes.

A, No. I ain't got jurisaiotion to notify them,
Was George Thomas notified of this condolence’
A. I don't know.

Was George Orowe notified’

A. I don't know,

Was Frank Isaacs notified?

A. I don't know,

George Van Everey, either old or young George,
were they notified?

A, I don't know.

Charles Green notified/ Was he?

A, I don't know.

Davis Greent

A. I don't know.

. Newton Green’ Any of these ment

A. No, I don't know.

And, as far as you know, there weren't any of them
notified to be at the meeting where and when it was
calledi

A, All I know is I was notified by myself,

3282 y

George Thomas was the Head Chief?
A. Not of my knowledge.
Q. Well, you never attended a meeting at which George
Thomas presided as Head Chief?
A. I don't know if we had any sessions on the Onon-
daga Reservation.
Q. What?
A. I don't know if we had any Six Nation meetings when
George Thomas was Chief. 1
Q. I want to find out if you attended. I am not asking roy
if you had any. Did you go to-any during the time |
that George Thomas was Head Chief?

A. Wo, I didn't go anywheres, because we didn't

have no meetings.

Q. Well, you didn't go to any meetings anywhere; did
you; isthat right?
A. We didn't have no meetings when George Thomas
was Chief of the Six Nations,

Q.Then you never attended any Six Nation council or

condolence while George Thomas was presiding, did

yout Is that right or wrong?

And, now, did you ever attend any meetings of the

Onondaga council - or, of the Six Nations council?
A. I did.

What?

A. Yes, sir.

When was the first time you attended a meeting of
the Six Nations councilt

A, Oh, quite a few times.

. Well, when was the first time?

A. I think it was - the first time the Six Nations
met, you meant
The first time you attended a Six Nations Council?

A. Onondaga Reservation.

Q. When?
A. Well, quite a while ago. I don't remember what
year.
Q. Well, who was the Head Chief at that time?
A, It was Frank Logan.
Q. Yes, and when next did you attend’
A. We had a few sessions in our reservation.
Q. Well, have you ever been to any sessions when


324

. Yes.
A. Yes.
. And who was there?
A. George Thomas.
« Now, you have been to meeting at which he presided?
A, Yee, sir,
. And who was olerk at those times?
4. I don't remember the names,
Q. Now, you know Adam Thomas?
A. Yes, sir,
Q.Is he a chief?
A, Yes, sir,
Q. Of what nation?
A, Oneidas,
What church does he go tof
A. What Judge?
» What church?
A. I don't know if he goes to any church.
» Does he attend the Episcopal Church?
A. I don't know.

There is an Episcopal Church on the Reservation?

A. No.
You never didi’

A. Only when a ~~~

‘(Interrupting) What?

A. Will you explain?

. What is it?

A. Will you explain so I can answer?

. What I want to find out is, since George Thomas

became Head Chief; that was in 19177

A. Yes, sir,

. Have you attended any meetings of the Six Nations

Council?
A. Yes, sir,
I mean besides these rump conventions you have been
havirg ?
MR, OREGG: I object to that as improper.

THE COURT; Objection sustained.

BY MR. BROWN:

Well, besides these meetings lately where you have
gone and Joshua Jones has presidedi

A. A Six Nation meeting, I said, on our Reservation,


A. Yes, sir.
Q. Do you know of a Baptist Thomas?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Was he a chief?
A. Yes, sir,
Q. How many years was he a chief?
A. I don't know.
Q. He was chief when you became chief?
A, Yess sir.
Q. And he lived for sometime after you became chiefi
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What church did he go tof
A. He used to go over to Long House and goes all
over,
Q. Well, wasn't he a member of the Wesleyan church out
there’ ,
A, I don't know if he was.
Q.He was chief up to the time he died; wasn't het
4. No, sir.
Q. When did he cease to be chieft

A. He was deposed.

Q.

BY

326

When?

A, I don't know what year, but he was deposed on
our reservation,

I see. Did you know Wilson Rubin?

A Yes, sir.

Wes he a chief?

A, Yes, sir.

. How long was he a chief?

A. I don't know.
Was he a chief when he died’

A. He was a chief when he died.

. What church did he go tot

MR, OCREGG: Who is thie?
THE COURT; Wilson Ruben,
MR, BROWN:
He went to the Episcopal church; didn't het
A. I used to see him over to the Long House too,
Well, didn't he go to the Episcopal church?

A. I don't know. I didn't follow him,

. So far as you know, one chief, Mr. Lyons, does not

have a right to depose another chief; has he?

327

A. What do youmean’

Q. Does one chief have the right to put another chief
down’
A. To cut him down?

Q. To depose him, or to cut him down; yest
A. You mean one man have to do the cutting or depos-
ing?

Q. No, I don't mean the action itself, but one chief
cannot himself depose another chief; can hei
A, Not the real chief, not the supreme chief.

MR, BROWN: That is all.

REDIRECT EXAMINATION

BY MR, CREGG:

Q. At the time of this condolence on the Tonawanda
Reservation when Joshua Jones was made Head Chief,
was George Thomas a chief of any kind at that time’

MR. BROWN: I object to that as calling for a
conclusion. I assume that is the issue we are
trying out, or one of them at least.

MR. CREGG: Well, you are trying to complain

BY

338

because George Thomas was not notified of thé
condolence,

MR. BROWN: I don't object to the fact appear-
ing, if it is the fact,

MR. OREGG:

. Did you consider that he was a chief at all at

that time?
A, What do you meant On his part, do you mean?

After he was deposed; after or before thist

. After,

Q.

A, After?
Yes, ,
A, No, sir.
So that if he was not a chief he would not be notified
of a condoleme; would het
A. No, sir.
Now, what is the rule on the Onondaga reservation
in reference to Indians adopting the Whlteman's
religion?
A. You mean people that belongs to the church?

That is what you meant


329

. Yes. Are they eligible to hold office if they

adopt the whiteman's religion? Or, what is there to

that?

A. They are not allowed to have any, hold any office.

They are not allowed to hold any office, if they

adopt the whiteman's religion?

A. No, sir; absolutely. aI
That is, they must be members of the Long House?

A. Yes, sir.

+ And is that what you call the Hanson Lake religion?

A. TI don't know what you call it, whether Hanson

Lake or Hiawatha.

. Well, you call it the Long House?

A. Yes, sir.

. And that is the regligion that the Indians have

themselves on the reservation?

A, Yes, sir, ,

Do you recall anything that Adam Thomas - or,
George Thomas did before he was made chief; do you

recall whether or not he adopted the whiteman's

330

religion before he was made chief and then whether
or not he gave it up to become chief? Do you

know about thati

A. I don't know about that.

Now, why was Baptist Thomas deposed!

A. I don't know. He was deposed by his mother of
condolence. I ain't supposed to know. It is the

mother condolence who is supposed to know.

« Well, do you know for what reason he was put out?

Do you know what the reason was, why he was put
out?

A. I think I do.

And what was it?

A. About he don't care anything about the wampum.
He waid it wasn't worth anything, nothing but old
pants, or something like that.

I see, How many Onondaga chiefs were there at this
condolence where George Thomas was deposed?

A. I didn't count the majority of them. They usually
do. When we get a meeting and have something to

eat they usually all go, when they get a chance to

331

get something to eat.

George Thomas was there at that condolence; was het
A. Yes, sir.

And when it was announced that George Thomas was
deposed, did anybody make objection, except Harry
Isaacs!

A. That is all I remember.

. And Harry Isaacs was not a chieft

A. No, sir.

George Van Every and Charlie Green and Howard Hill
were there?

A. Yes, sir.

And they made no objection?

A. No, not that I know of.

. AND did I understand you to say that you went over

to the chiefs and asked them if that was right, or
something to that effect?

A. Well, I had to go over in front of the chiefs,

pecause they called me, and I went over there and

the chiefs lined up over there, and they called me

and I got to go over there next to the chiefs.

2

333

So that the chiefs of the Onondagas that were present
on that aay were lined up on a bench together?

A. Yes, sir, just the same as they are lined uo

there (indicating bench in court room).

And they called you to come over there to them?

A, Yes, sir.

. And when they did that Chief White took out this dark

colored wampum; did he, or what did he dot

A. It is a little kind of a dark blue and

white,

And is that the wampum that is used to depose the
ohieft

A. Yes, sir.

. And when he handed it to you, what did he say?

A. Well, when he handed it to me I say, “What is the
mesning of thisi Is that to Depose George Thomas?"
and the chiefs are lined up in here (indicating) ,
"This is all right?" and they said, "Yes", 1

said, "It is quite true and regular’" and they said,

"Yes", and then the mother condolence was sitting,

or stood quite a ways back, and I done like that

Qo

oa

333

(raising hand) and I said, "Is that right?" and I
don't know she said anything, but she did like
this (nodding head) meaning "yes", Q.
You asked the chiefs sitting around first if it

was all right and they said yes, and then you

held it up to the condolence mother, Phoebe Lyons,

and asked if it was all right and she nodded her a.

headt

A. Yes; it must be meaning "yes"; I don't know, but

that is what she did.

You Know when you nod your head down that means

"yea"y

A. Yes, sir.

You intend us to understand that to mean tyes: BY
don't your ; Q.

A. Yes, sir.

. And Harry Isaacs was never a chief on the reservation?

A. Not within my knowledge.

. When there is objection made by someone to cutting

down a chief, then the ceremony has to be gone

through again in order to make it final and legaj;

is that right?

A. Yes, sir,
Now, before George Thomas was deposed as chief on
the eighth day of March, 1924, did the Onondaga
Ohiefs hold some meetings before he was cut down?
A. Before he was put out, you meant
Yes.

MR. BROWN: I object to that as incompetent.
I think we have this man's testimony to the
effect that he was not at any such meetings, al-
though he understood some were held. I did not
suppose he could give us any further information
as to that.
MR. CREGG::
Do you know that meetings of the Onondagas were call~
edt

MR. BROWN: I object to that as incompetent,

and, of course, he cannot take ---

THE COURT (Interrupting): Well, if he knows
they were called, he may answer,

MR. OREGG: I understood him to say he was


335

notified to come to certain or some meetings.
THE WITNESS: They had a meeting first

over to Harry Isaacs, before the condolence. [I
never went over there. TI notified them to come
and ~-~

BY MR. @REGG:

Q. (Interrupting) Did you notify ---
A, (Continuing) --~ and they went over to George
Van Every's,

Q. There was a meeting mk at what Isaacs; Harry
Isaacs!
A. Yes, sir,

q. And another meeting at George Van fivery's?
A.Yes, sir, old man George Van Every's.

Q. And do you know who called these meetings?
A. I got notified through Andrew Gibson and I
never went,

q. You got notified to come then?
A, Yes, sir. ,

Q. Did he tell you what the meeting was fori

A. Yes, sir.

Q.

BY

What did he say the meeting was for’
A. He said they were going to have a practice over
about the condolence.
MR. BROWN: Have a practice about the oondolencet
THE WITNESS: Yes, sir, certain ceremony go
through.

MR

BROWN: Rehearsing?

THE WITNESS: Yes, rehearsing.

MR. GREGG:
And which meeting was that; at Harry Isaacet
A. Both of them,
Both of them?
A. Yes, sir,
And was any other meeting held before that at that
time?
A, Not that I know of. That is all I know of,
WR. CREGG: That is all.
MR, BROWN: THat is all,

MR. OREGG: I will call Howard Hill,

337

HOWARD HILL,
called as a witness on behalf of the defendants and
being duly sworn, testified as follows:
DIRECT EXAMINATION
BY MR. CREGG:
Q. Howard, where do you live?
A. Out on the reservation,
Q. Onondaga reservation?
A. Yes, sir.
Q.And you are an Onondaga Indian’
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How old are your
A. Forty-two.
Q. Are you a sub-chief on the reservation’
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And when were you made sub-chiefit
A. When I was eleven years old.
Q. ts there any age Limit at which a man may become
a chief on the reservationt
A. No, gir.

Q. That is, whenever they decide he has sufficient

reason and judgment to be a chief, they can make

him one?

A. Yes, sir; and if they cannot find any person

in the clan they can leave it to somebody else,

Q. Thatjs, if there is no male descendant -—-~
A. (Interrupting) Yes.
Q. (Continuing) --~ eligible to take the office, they

oan borrow a man from some other clan?
A. Yes,

Q.fs that right’
A. Yes, sit.

Q. Now, do you remember a condolence that was held on
“arch eighth, 1924, on the Onondaga reservation?
A. Yes, sir,

Q. And were you present at that condolence?

A.Yes, sir, I had to be,

&

What t
A. I had to be.
Q. You had to bef
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You were notified to be there?

A. Yes, sir,


&

2

339

. And you were one of the Onondaga chiefs at

thet time!

A. Yes, sir,

« And did you sit in the Long House with the Onondaga

Chiefst

A. Yes, sir.

And what action was taken at that condolence with
reference to George Thomas’

A. I didn't know it until afterward,

What is that?

A. I didn't know anything about it until afterwards,

. Until afterwards?

A. Yes, sir.

Well, were you there?
A. Yes, sir.

Well, were there some chiefs raised at that condo-

lence?

A. Yes, sir.

Who were they? ek

A, James Lyons.

. And who else?

340

A. Why, I couldn't say who it was; some young fellow
out there.

Was it H1li Schanandoah’
A. Why, I couldn't say whether H1li Schanandoah or
somebody else.
Well, was George Thomas deposed at that condolence!

A. Yes, sir, he was,

. Who has the right to depose a chief?

A. Well, there is what they call the chief's sister;
the clan has a right.
You mean the clan mother?

A. Yes, sir.

. What are these things for which a chief can

be deposedt

A. What did you say?

. For what reason can a chief be deposed?

A. Well, a man abuses his family, --~-
(Interrupting) Or disobeys the orders of the chiefs?

A. Yes, sir.

. Or usurps the powers of his office?

A, In other words, if you don't attend to them,

341

Q.That is, if he does not attend to his office, if
he neglects his officet
A. Yes, sir,

Q. Or if he is unfaithful to the tribe?
A. Yes, sir.

Q. Who is the wampum keeper?
A. Why, a fellow named Adam #homas now, and he is.

Q.And how long has he been Wampum Keeper to your
knowledget
A. Along about twenty years, if not any more than
that.

Q. And who fixes the date for a condolence?
A, Why, Adam Thomas,

Q. The Wampum Keeper?
A. Yes, sir.

Q. And must the Wampum Keeper fix a date for a
condolence before a legal condolence can be heldt
A. Yes, sir.

Q. And after a date for a condolence is fixed, how

are the different nations notified?

A. Why, he has a right to notify the three tribes
,

and the Fire Keepers has three different tribes

to notify.
Q. That is, the Wampum Keeper notifies three?
A. Yes, sir,
Q. And the Fire Keepers the other three?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And must the Wampum Keeper be an Oneida Indian, as
you understand it?’
A, Yes, sir.
Q.And the Head Chief of the Six Nations must be an
Onondagan?
A. Yes, sir; he has to be an Onondagan.

WR, CREGG: T hat is all.

OROSS EXAMINATION
BY MR, BROWN:
Q. Just one moment.
MR. BROWN: Have you got the original moving
papers thoret
MR. CREGG: I am pretty sure we filed the

original moving papers.


343

(Paper produced)

BY MR. BROWN:

Q. Howard, I show yOu @ paper, which is marked Exhibit
ij" and attached to the moving papers herein, dated
January ninth, which is a petition to this Court,
asking Mr. Fenner, the Onondaga Indian Agent, to
turn over to Jesse Jones, the duly constituted
treasurer of this nation the moneys now in his
hands, and I call your attention to the name Howard
Hill on it; did you ever sign that paper?

A. No, sir.

Q. That is not your signature?
A. No, sir.

Q. And you are not here petitioning the court to
turn the money over to Jesse Jonest
A. No, sir.

Q. Do you remember the day when George Thomas was
made Head Chief?

A, Yes, sir.

Q. Did you attend at the council meeting when his

name was decided ont

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And was he picked by the Onondaga Council of

Chiefs to become Heed Chief?
A, Yes, sir.
Q. And he was not proposed by any condolence mother
at all until after his nomination was made; was
het
A. No, sir.
MR. OREGG: Just a moment. I object to this
question as leading. .
| MR, BROWN: No question about it being leading.
! MR.CREGG: This is something I have not inter-
Togated the witness concerning and he is making him
his own witness and I object to it as leading.
MR, BROWN: You have led other witnesses with-
out objection on my part,
THE COURT: Ask him the general question and
if he can understand I will let him answer.
BY MR. BROWN:
Q. Go on and tell ust
A. What?

Q. Just go on and tell us how George Thomas was chosen


a
B
ol

At the Onondaga Council to be Head Chief?

A. Well, at the time theywas going to put up
George Thomas, but before that, after Logan is
dead, and they had a meeting,what they call a

meeting at Martha Brown's house.

. Yes?

A. And they had a fellow out there picked out
before; they had a fellow picked out by the name
of Levi Green, he was going to be Six Nation

Chief.

Q. Yes?

A. And on account he could not read and he could
not, he could not speak English very well, it
takes three or four men to explain things, what

it means, before he sign a paper.

Q. Yest
A. Well, it wasn't satistactory to them on
account of that.

Q.. Yest

A. And the next day they had condolence date,

» Vest

BY

4. I was living down here in the city, on here, on

back down on Marcellus street, 718, I wes working
down here, and I had to go out the next day.
After I got up there by the council house ---

MR, OREGG (Interrupting): What is he talking
about nowt

MR. BROWN: He is telling you how George
Thomas was picked to be Head Chief.

THE WITNESS: After I come down, here is the
fire ana the kettle hung up cooking beef,or
whatever it 1s; I got inside and crowd in there,
shanty full.

MR. BROWN:

Now, you are tellingus about the condolence meeting?
A. Yes, sir, ,
Were you at the meeting where George Thomas was
picked before the condolence’ That is what I am
talking about, the meeting of the Onondaga council?
A. Yes, sir.

That is what I want you to tell-us about.

A. Well, the time before the condolence, we was

347

sitting out there, the last meeting, I forget
who it was that was doing the talking out there,
and John White come in there and he says we all
go out there, and there is a building there,
a little shack there, and whole gang of the chiefs
out here, and so we all walk out there and
went in, and I never knew anything what was going
on, I thought somebody got hurt, and walk in, and
what's his name, Hamett Lyons and Wilson Johnson,
and they are speaking they were going to elect this
boy out here to be Six Nations Chief.
. Well, he was chosen and elected by the Onondaga
Council; wasn't he?
A. Yes, sir.

MR. OREGG: dust a minute. I object to that
as a conclusion,

MR. BROWN: Well, your own witnesses testified
to that,

THE COURT: Objection overruled.

MR, CREGG: An exceptkon,

348

BY MR. BROWN:

Q. Now, you were at this condolence which was held
March eighth at which it was claimed that George
Thomas was deposed; weren't yout
A. Yes, sir.

Q, Now, before that condolence, or before this
cutting down proceeding was had, did you know
about that?

A.No, sir,

Q. Did you ever propose to have George Thomas deposed
yourself
A. No, sir,

Q. You did attend the meeting of the Onondaga council
held the next day after that; didn't yout
A. Yes, sir.

Q. And was there a resolution adopted there with
reference to that!

A. Yes, sir.

Q. I will show you the name of Howard Hill on page

three of this plaintiff's exhibit one; is that

your signature?


A. Yes, sir,

Q. And is that the resolution that was adopted by

the Onondaga. Council the next dayt

A. Yes, sir.

. And were these men whose names appear there there,
and did they sign this resolution?

A. Yes, sir. ,

MR. BROWN: I offer plaintiff's exhibit one,
for identification, in evidence,

WR. OREGG: Just a moment. Let me ask the
witness a gquewtion or two. Did you keep these
minutes? Were you secretary!

THE WITNESS: Tommy Lyons was Secretary.

MR. GREGG: Well, you did not write out these
minutes yourself?

THE WITNESS: No, sir.

MR, OREGG: And you don't know whether they
are correct or not; do your

THE WITNESS: Yes, sir, I signed my name,

MR. BROWN: He signed it.

THE WITNESS: I signed my own name,

MR. BROWN: They all signed it.

BY

BY

Q.

THE COURT; Were they read over to yout

THE WITNESS: Yes, sir.

MR, OREGG: Very well. What does that purport
to bet A meeting of whatt

MR. BROWN: A meeting of the Onondaga Council
held on March ninth,

THE WITNESS; That was on Sunday.

MR. BROWN:
And this meeting was held after the condolence
where you said you deposed Thomas?

WR. OREGG: I object to that unless it appears
tne manner in which it was called and how it was
called.

MR, BROWN:
You were a chief and therefore you were notified
to be there, Mr. Hill?

A. Yes, sir.

. By whom?

A. Charlie Green and George Van Every and what's
his name - two or three other fellows.

Were a majority of the chiefs theret


351

A. Yes, sir.

. And in fact a majority of them signed this

paper; didn't they?

A. Yes, sir.

. Do you know whether or not the others were

notifed to be there that were not there?
A, Yes, sir.

MR, BROWN: I offer this paper in evidence.

THE COURT: Received.

(Paper referred to received in evidence

and marked plaintiff's exhibit No. 1.)

MR. BROWN: WH, the Members of the Onondaga
Council, assembled in the Long House on March
ninth, to pass upon the action of Jesse Lyons in
attempting to depose George #1 Thomas, Ta-~do-da~-ho,
on March eighth, as fraudulent, illegal and of
no effect.

We have from time to time suspected Jesse
Lyons to be wrongfully connected and have proof
of many things in his relations with the OQnondata

nation which we can no longer countenance. We

believe that this action of Jesse Lyons is part

of large propaganda wherein white agents are
putting up funds to antagonize and disrupt the
Onondaga Council and Six Nations, and that the
prentense of upholding the old law is to conceal
the treachery on his part. Jesse Lyons is only sub-
chief. There are elven of these and thirteen
principals. These sub~chiefs are assistants and
they neither initiate or put through anything
without the consent and action of the principal.
This is the law of Houdnosaunee. The officer of
Ta-do-da-ho is an office that belongs to the
council regardless of the clan and that George &.
Thomas remain Head Chief for Life.

Signed George Van Every, Charles Green, Frank
Isaacs, Howard Hill, Harl Webster, Albert Kennedy,
George Webster, George Van Hivery, Junior, Newton
Green, Davis B. Green, Ruben Jones, George Crowe,

(The above was read by Mr. Brown and thé

above transcript has not been checked with

the original by the stenographer. )


353

Q. Never mind what that is. Now, didn't you write that

BY.MR. BROWN:
there (indicating)?
Q. You, as a chief, Mr, Hill, still recognize George
A. No, sir.
Thomas as Principal Chief of the Six Nations; do
Q. Do you know Fenner, the Indian Agent?
“yout
: A, Yes, sir, I do.
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Don't you remember writing that in his presence?
Q. And you recognize Charles Green as the treasurer
A. Not on that paper,
of the Onondaga Nation; do yout
: Q. Where were you when you wrote your name on that
A. Yes, sir,
paper?
MR, BROWN: That is all,
A. Where was yout On January ninth?

Q. On January ninthi Now, where were you when you
REDIRECT EXAMINATION
wrote your name on that paper?’
BY MR, OREGG:
A. On January nich.
. Q Ani George Thomas was deposed at a regular condo-

Q

No, not on January ninth. I don't mean the date. I

lence on March eighth, as you said here a minuted
don't care about that. I say when your name was

agot
° put there, J ask you again if that is not your
A. Yes, sir, they did, |

: name in your hand writing?
Q. Now, Howard, you don't mean to say that you did not
A, I didn't. seen that paper. Maybe this is
sign this paper, and that that is not your signature 4

i January ninth,

on there; do yout Look at 1% carefully, right
: Q. Never mind the date. That is your handwriting; isn't
there? Isn't that your name? ay
A. That is like here on that thing.

1 A. No, sir.

. Have you a pen there?
(Same produced)
Now, write "Howard Hill" for me on heret

Don't print any part, but write it all up here

A. (Witness writes).
Ien't that the same, Howard Hill?
A, Look how that be written. I don't put any "nt

on my name theres

A, No, sir. I never put a shape of  n" on rt,

» Never put a shape of "n" on trl?

Is that your name on there written by you?

That is paper you asked me about last
Saturday in your office.

Don't you remember signing a paper at Jamesville

when Mr. Fenner was presenti
,

A. Jamesville?

Yes, at Jamesville?

A. That paper might have been up to Jamesville.
What is that?

A. That paper might have been up to Jamesville.
Don't you remember signing & paper when you were
at Jamesville in the present of Mr. Fenner?

A, I had him brought up papers and Ohief Lyons,
and I wouldn't sign it,

- You wouldn't sign it?

A. No, sir.

. Did you sign any papers at a time when Mr. Fenner
was there?

A. I got three or four letters and never sent out
for a paper, and they come up there and ask me

af I would Sign one paper; I forget all about it,
what it was about.

. Did you sign a paper when Fenner was there?

A. I signed one paper was up there, and I said, "I
don't recall, and don't be after me sign papers",
You did sign a paper when Fenner was there?

A. Not for that reason.

Q

&

Q.

called as a witness on behalf of the defendants and

Never mind what it was for. Did you sign a paper
when Fenner was theret

A. No, sir,

- You did not?

A.No, sir.
You did not sign any paper when Fenner was there?
A. Only come there once with Emmett Lyons and asked
me it I wanted to get out ~--
(Interrupting) I am not asking you about that.
You did not sign any paper when Fenner was there?
A, Not for this case.
I see.

MR. CREGG: That is all,

wR. BROWN: That is all,

MR. CREGG: I will call Martha Brown.

MARTHA BROWN, !

being duly sworn, testified as follows, through an

interpreter:

DIRGCT EXAMINATION

BY MR. CREGG:
Q. How old are you, irs, Brownt
A. Eighty-six,
Q. Are you an Onondaga Indiant
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And live on the Onondaga Indian reservation?
A. Yes, sir.
Q.Are you a clan mother?
A, Yes.

Q. OF what clan’

A, Beaver olan,

Q, Can you tell us who the chiefs ot the reservation were
before George Thomas was deposed?
A, I can tell only those that I at clan mother of.

Q. Ani who are those?
A, Andrew Gibson and Emmett Lyons.

Q. Were you present at the condolence of March eighth,
1934, when George Thomas was deposed?

A. Yes, sir.

&

. Who was the clan mother that took part in deposing

359

him at that time?

A. I only heard that it was Phoebe Lyons.

. Phoebe Lyons?

A, Yes, sir.

. And then can you descrB®be what took place at the time
he was deposed?
A. I was at the condolence and at the ceremony and
seen the action when he wis deposed,

. Well, just tell what they said and did at that time,
if you cant
A, All I knew was that he was put down and I didn't
know anything about it until I was there at the con-
dolence,

. That day?
A, Yes, sir,

. Were you at the condolence when George Thomas was
made a chief in 19174
A. Yes, sir,

. And who was the clan mother that made him chief at

that time?

A. Phoebe Lyons, because she was the Hel clan and so

BY

BY

+

&

was he.

. Phoebe Lyons was the Hel clan mother’

A. Yes, sir.
And Phoebe made him chief and Phoebe deposed him?
MR. BROWN: I object to that as calling for
a conclusion and leading.
THE COURT: Objection sustained,
MR, OREGG: Of course, we have had it over and
over again, I guess,

MR. CREGG:

. Were you at the condolence when Joshua Jones was

made Head Chief of the Six Nations’
A, No, sir, I was not there,

MR. CREGG: That is all.

OROSS EXAMINATION
MR, BROWN:
How long have you been condolence mother of the
Beaver Clan, Mrs. Brownt
A. About sixty years,

About sixty years?


>

A. Yes, sir.

. Have you been the oldest woman of that olan all

that time’

A. Yes, sir,

And you hold your office by reason of the fact that
you are the oldest woman of the clan; do yout

A, Y#S, sir.

. Now, you yourself don't know anything about the

proceedings which were taken before George Thomas

was made Head Chief; do your

A. No, six.

Nor you don't know anything about the proceedings

that were taken before he was claimed to have been

deposed; do yout

A. No, sir.

. Have you ever been in my office, Mrs. Brown?

A. Yes.

» Do you remember when that wast

A. I think it was last summer.
Who were you there with?

A. Paula Isaacs,

368

Q. Who else?

A, That is all.

Q. Wasn't George Thomas with yout
A. Yes, sir,

Q. And did you recognize him as a chief when you came
into my office to talk with me about some matter
thent
A. 1 supposes that he was deposed them,

Q. Well, didn't you talk to me through him?

A. Paula Isaacs done the talking; I did not,

Q. Well, didn't you, both of you, tell me that he was
the chief and was there representing both of yout
A, We didn't talk about that.

Q. All right.

MR, BROWN: That is all.
MR, CREGG: That is all,

I will call Emmett Lyons,

ROR OK OR OK OR

363

EMMETT LYONS,
called as a witness on behalf of the defendants and
being duly sworn, testified as follows, through an
interpreter:
DIRECT EXAMINATION
BY MR. CREGG:
Q. Emmett, how old are yout
A. Fifty-six,

MR. BROWN: This is another gentleman that
understands the English language and I think the
witness ought to speak up so we can hear what he
says,

THE COURT: Yes, talk a little loud, so the
folks on the back row can hear you,

BY MR. OREGG:
Q. Where do you live’
A, Onondaga gesorvation.
Q. Are you an Onondaga Indian?
A. Yes, sir. : ,
Q. Are you a chief on the reservation’

A. Yes, sir.

. How long have you been chief?

A. Ever since I was eighteen years old,

And can you name the chiefs on the reservation
before George Thomas was cut down?

A. Some of them I can,

But you don't think you can name all of them?
A. No, I don't think I can.

Now, was there any dispute about whowere the

chiefs until after Mra, Kellogg came on the reserva-

tion in 1923?

4A. Nothing before she came,

Were you present at the condolence when George
Thomas was cut down?

A. Yes, I was there,

And that was held on the Onondaga reservation?

A. Yes, sir.

Tell us what took place there in reference to George
Thomas being deposed?

A, I noticed when Jesse Lyons was designated to
take the part as the spokesman for the clan mother,

Ana what was doje then?


Q

365

A. He was deposed,

Were you present at a meeting of the Onondaga
Chiefs in September of that same year, when Joshua
Jones was selected to take his place?

A. Yes, sir.

. And tell us what took place at that meeting?

A. The clan mother of George Thomas came and said
that she has dropped him because he had violated
the rules of the clan,

And what else was said?

A, That was the statement made by her to the council,
And then after that what did the council do towards
selecting somebody else’

A. We cannot help because it was her clan. It was
up to her to say as to who would be his successor.
And what did she say? Who did she say was to be
the successor?

A. She proposed Joshua Jones, young Joshua Jones,
Joshau Jones?

A, Yes, sir,

Did you attend the condolence at Tonawanda when

366

Joshua Jones was made Head Chief?

A. Yes, I was there.

Now, going back a minute to the meeting of the
Onondaga Chiefs when Phoebe Lyons proposed Joshua
Jones; did the council approve of that name?

A. We approved, as long as it was according to the
wishes of the clan.

Now, how many chiefs of the Onondagas attended the
condolence at Tonawanda?

A. I cannot say just how many, but there were quite
a few.

And was that a regular condolence?

A. Yes, sir.

And what took place there in reference to making
Joshua Jones Head Ohieft

4. It was conducted according to the custom by the

use of the wampum,

. Now, were you present at the condolence when George

Thomas was made Head Chief in 19177
A. I was not there; I was working.

Did you attend any of the meetings of the Onondaga


BY

367

council before Joshua Jones was deposed ~ or before
George Thomas was deposed?

A. Before he was deposed?

Yes.

A. I have attended the council, but he doesn't know
which one you mean.

Well, I mean a council meeting shortly before George
Thomas was cut down?

A. Yes, I was there,

. And was George Thomas name discussedat that meeting’

A. Yes, sir,

. Tell us what was said at that time in reference to

George Thomas?

MR, BROWN: Just a minute. I object to that
unless it appears where the meeting was and who
was present. This is another meeting.

MR. OREGG:
Well, where was this meeting held that you are now
talking about?

A. At Mrs. Martha Brown's.

. Houset

A. Yes, sir.

On the Onondaga Reservation?

A, Yes, sir.

And about how long was that before the condolence
at which George Thomas was cut down?

A. Just a few days before. ,

And who wae present at that meeting, if you know?
A. John White, Emmett Lyons, Jesse Lyons, ,
Ocias Schanandoah, Joshua Jones, Andrew Gibson;

that ls all that I can remember.

. You were there, of course, yourself?

A. Yes, sir.

Now, what was said and done there in reference to
George Thomas?

A. The clan mother was there and it was then that

she presented his name, the name of George Thomas,

- Well, presented his name for what?

A. She there reported that he was not doing accord~
ing to the custom of the clan,

And what action did the council take on it?

369

MR. BROWN: I object to it as improper and
incompetent and assuming a fact not proven. It
is the action of these men I suppose we are after,
and I object to the designation as "council", He
styles this the council.
THE COURT: Objection sustained as to the con~

clusion.

BY MR. CREGG:

Q.

2

What action was taken there’
A. In answer to her wishes the chiefs declared that

it was up to her for whatever her wishes are.

. Was there any other meeting that you know of before

that, or that you attended, rather, about that
time, of the Onondaga OOuncil’?
A. That is all I rememper,
What is that?
A, That is all that I can remember.

MR, CREGG: You may cross-examine,

THE COURT: We will take a recess at this time
for five minutes, and, Mir. Orege and Mr. Brown, we

will have a conference at the bench,

(Recess taken at 3:50 P, M. Case resumed

at 3:55 P. M.)

CROSS HXAMINATION
BY MR. BROWN:
Q. You have been a chief for a good many years; have
you, Mr. Lyons?
A. Since I was eighteen years old,
Q. And of what clan?
A. Beaver clan,
Q. And who is the condolence mother of your clan?
A. MArtha Brown.
Q. Are you married?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And what is your wife's namet
A. Phoebe Lyons.
Q. And is she the same Phoeoe Lyons that undertook
to depose George Thomas?
A. Yes, sir. ,

Q. Were you present at the Onondaga council meeting

371

that was held before George Thomas was condoled as
Head Chief?

A. Yes, sir,

2

And how many chiefs were present at that meeting?
A. John White, Jesse Lyons, Ocias Schanandoah,
Andrew Gibson, and Joshue Jones; that is as many
as [ can remember.

Q. Well, now, what meeting are you talking about now?
A, At the time the clan mother of George Thomas
gave out notice as to her intentions.

Q. Well, I am talking about the meeting that was held

before he was raised as chief; do you remember

that meeting?

A. I don't remember it,

Q

I see, Well you knew then before the cotitlolence

at which it was claimed that George Thomas was
deposed, that that proceeding was going to be
taken; didn't yout

A, I didn't know until it was ~ the notice was
given there at the council.

Q. Well, there were six chiefs that met together and

talked this over before the condolence; wasn't

there?

A. There were more than six chiefs that weme there,
out I couldn't remember who whey were,

Well, can you give me any names other than those
you told me and Mr. Gregg were there?

A, No, sir.

How many were there there’

A. Hight or nine.

And at that time there were at least twenty~one
chiefs in the Onondaga council; weren't there?

A. I think there was.

. Now, you were also at a meeting at the home ~ at your

home on the ninth of September; weren't you;
19247

A. I don't remember of being there,

- Well, don't you remember the night that your wife

said to the men who were there that she was going
to have Joshua Jones for Head Chief?
A. I know that it was ot that time that that was

said.

&

373

. And there were only seven chiefs there at that time;

were there’

A. It might be more than seven,

. Well, how many more than seven?

A. I cannot say how many.
Can you tell me who was there?

A, About the same ones that I mentioned before.

. Well, you only mentioned six before; didn't you?

A. That is all that I can remember is the six,

Well, it ie the same crowd that were at the other
neeting that were at this meeting where you decided
on Joshua Jones?

A. Yes, sir.

And there weren't a majority of the chiefs at either

one of these meetings; were there’

- A. That was all that were invited to come,

I see, And that was all that knew about this con-
dolence at Tonawanda as well; asn't it?

A. The whole reservation knew about that.

How did they find out about itt

A. It was through the Oneida chief.

Q. You did not tell anyoody about it yourself; did you;

except this same little crowd?
A. I didn't have anything to do with it,
Q. Well, did you tell anybody about it outside of this
same crowd of six or seven men?
A. I didn't have anything to say.

MR, BROWN: That is all.

REDIRECT EXAMINATION
BY MR, OREGG:
@. Did practically the whole reservation attend that
condolence where George Thomas was deposed?
A. Yes, sir.

MR, CREGG: That is all,

REOROSS EXAMINATION
BY MR. BROWN:
Q. Well at this condolence that was held on the onondaga
reservation, it was held for the purpose of xaueune
James Lyons and #11 Schanandoah to chieftanships;

wasn't itt

375

A. I was late in the meeting and I only saw when
Gli Schanandoah was installed.

Well, there wasn't anybody that knew the deposition
of George Thomas was to come up, except you six

men and your wife; is not that true’

A. There is no one's business, only the clan mother
of George Thomas,

Well, did anybody know it besides your wife and
these six men who met at your house?

MR.OREGG: I don't know or see how he would
know that.

THE WITNESS: I don't know anything about that.

THE COURT: Let me ask him this question:

Under the Indian law, do the chiefs from other
nations who are present have anything to say about
whether a chief of the $ix Nations shall be deposed
or not?

THE WITNESS: At the condolence?

THE COURT: Yes.

THE WITNESS: They have no right to say

anything one way or the other; only the clan

BY

BY

376

mother of the sachem. They have nothing to say
at the condolence.

THE COURT: That is, they have no right to
object?

THE WITNESS; No, they have not.
MR. BROWN:
When did your wife first start to act asa.
condolence mother?
A. Well, it has ‘been sometime; I can't say how

long.

MR. BROWN: That is all.

REDIREC THXAMINATION
MR. OREGG:
She was a condolence mother when George Thomas
was made chief?
A. Yes, sir.
MR. CREGG: That is all,

I will call Minnie Maybee,

37?

A. Yes, sir.

MINNIE MAYBEE,

Q. And that is what they call the Long House?
called as a witness on behalf of the defendants and

A. Yes, sir.
being duly sworn, testified as follows:

How many Onondaga Indians were present there at

2

DIRECT EXAMINATION
that time’
BY MR, OCRWGG:

A. Well, I couldn't tell you. The house was full.
Where do you live?

=

Q. The house was full?
A, Onondaga reservation,

A, There was no seats vacant.
Q. Ate you an Onondaga Indian?

Ay A Q. And was it filled mostly with Onondaga Indians‘
. Yes, sir.

: A. Why, mixed; there is all kinds of tribes on
Q. Do you remember the condolence that was held on

the reservation, Oneidas and others.
the Onondaga reservation when George Thomas . i

5 Q. There were some from all the six reservations
was made Head Chief of the Six Nations?
‘ there?
A. I remember it, yes, sir, but [ was not there.
. A, Yes, sir,
Q.You weren't there at that time?
. Q. Do you remember who called the condolence
A. No, sir.
together in the beginning?
Q. Were you at the condolence on March eighth, 1924,
2 A.No, I could not tell you.
when he was deposed? .
Q. I mean on the date when they all assembled there in
A. Yes, sir.
the Long House?
Q. Where was that held; in the Long House? ;
A. YES,
A. In the council house on the reservation.
Q. Who first spoke?
Q. In the council house on the Onondaga reservation?

©

Q.

379

A. When that meeting first startedat

- Yes, when the meeting first started?

A. Why, I codldn't recall that.

You couldn't recall?

A, Wo, sir.

Well, there were somebody took charge of the
ceremony; didn't they’

A, Yes, sir.

. And who was that?

A. Why, what oo you mean? With reference to being

ohief or what?

- Just tell us what happened?

A, Well, there was the opening of the ceremonies,
and, of course, when they put up chiefs there is
another man, and that was Jesse Lyons.

Describe how condolences are carried on? One

man takes charge of a meeting more or less; doesn't
het

A, There is singing, and a person directs it that
knows how to do it.

Well, just tell us, Minnie, in your own way, just

how they start the condolence?

A. I couldn't tell you.

Oan't you tell us?

A, No,

Well, it is opened with singing?

A. Well, I don't remember. I remember they came in
from the outside, That is the first thing occurred,
when they entered the Long House,

The spectators are all assembled in the Council
Chamber and the chiefs all walk in from the outside?
A. Yes, sir,

And are they dressed in their Indian costumes?

A. No, sir.

- Ordinary clothing?

A. Yes, sir.

And did certain chiefs take seats on one side

of the council chamber and other chiefs on the
other side of the council chambert

A. Yes, sir.

Now, did there come a time in that ceremony when

some action was taken in reference to George Thomas?

381

A. What do you mean?
There was a time during the day there when some-
thing was sald and done about George Thomas?

A, Yes, sir.

. Now, tell us what that was; just describe that?

A. Well, I remember seeing Jesse Lyons go back
and forth in the middle of the House there with the

wampum,

And did he announce that George Thomas was L

deposed there?

A. Yes, sir.

And did he go through that ceremony twice’

A. Well, after Harry Isaacs got up and made a
fuss about it, he got up and did it a second time.
He got up and did it a second time?

A. Yes, sir.

. And did anybody there make any objection except

Harry Isaacs?
A. No, sir,
And then after he went through the second ceremony

nobody made objection?

A. Well, Harry Isaacs done talking, but he didn't

produce a wampum,

. He didn't produce any wampum’

A. No,gir,

Now, was Phoebe Lyons there that dayt
A. Yes, sir.

And did she consent that he be deposed?

A. Yes, sir.

. Do you remember what she said’

A. No, they didn't talk right out loud,
She nodded her consent; did she?
A, Yes, sir, she whispered and when they talked ~-~

WR, BROWN (Interrupting): I assume you are
going to object to my questions as leading on
cross examination,

MR. OREGG: I thought it was up to you. I
have found out when this evidence was favorable to
you you don't object and when it ils not you object
very strenuously,

MR. BROWN: (Laughxs. )

THE COURT: You both have been pretty good


BY

383

about objecting.

MR. OREGG:

Were you present at any of the meetings of the
Onondaga Chiefs; have you attended those meetingst
A. Well, I have;since Mrs. Kellogg came in, I

have been interested.

. You became interested since Mrs. Kellogg camei

A. Yes, sir, Ihave been attending meetings,

Now, let us hear more about that: Up to the tins
Mrs. Kellogg came on to the reservation, had there
been any disputet

A. Not that I know of,

. Not that yOu heard?

A. No, six.

. And prior was there peace ami harmony there?

A. Yes, sir,
And theniirs. Kellogg came on the reservation and
what did she want to do; what did she ask the
chiefs to do?
MR, BROWN: Well, I think I will object to that

as irrelevant and immaterial and does not affect the

BY

question at issue,

THE COURT: Objection sustained.

MR. CREGG: I think it does affect the question
at issue.

THE COURT: Objection sustained.

MR. CREGG: An exception,
MR. CREGG:
Did you attend any of the meetings of the chiefs on
the Onondaga Reservation before George Thomas was
cut down’
A. Yes, sir,
And about how many?
A, Well, twice; maybe once or twice; I couldn't

remember,

. And where were those meetings held’

A. At the council house.

At the council house’

A. Yes, sir.

And was some matter discussed at those meetings?

A. Yes, sir.

. And was George Thomas discussed at those meetings?


385

A.Yes, he was discussed.
And now, just tell us what was said and done at
those meetings of the chiefs at the council house
pefore George Thomas was deposed?

MR, BROWN: I object to it unless the time is
fixed and the persons present are know,

THE COURT: Fix the time.
MR. GREGG:
How long before George Thomas was deposed was
this meeting held?
A. Well, I remember there was a meeting held there
somewheres in February; I couldn't say what day;
I know it was in the winter time.
Well, February before he was deposed?
A. Yes, sir.
And when you cay the council house,you mean the
Long House; the same thing?
A. Yes, sir,
. How many chiefe of the Onondaga Reservation were
there; about?

A. Oh, I couldn't tell; most all, I suppose.

Q. Most all of the chiefs were there, as you recall it?

A. They were all interested, you know.

They were all interested at that time?

A. Yes, sir.

Now, tell us what was said and done at that meeting
with reference to Mre. Kellogg and George Thomas?
A. Well, I don't know. She was trying to make
some kind of contract and she wanted the chiefs to
sign and they tried to Stop George Thomas, but he
went on and signed,

The chiefs tried to stop George from signing and
he went on and signed?

A. Yes, sir, because he was going to get lot of
money or something.

And the chiefs assembled did not want him to sign
it; is that itt

A. No, not a majority of the chiefs.

. And was there any other meeting that you know of of

the council, or at which you were present on the
reservation of the Onondaga Chiefs before George
was deposed’

A, I don't remember; I have been to different ones

387

and I couldn't tell you what time.
Q. You don't just exactly know what timet
A. No, six.

MR, GREGG: You may cross-examine,

OROSS PXAMINATION
BY MR, BROWN:
Q. How old are yout
A. Thirty-four.
Q. You are Joshua Jones sister, as *+ understand’
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Does that account for any of your interest in this
matter?
A. No, six, there is no relation into this.
Q. tt doesn't make any difference to you whether Joshua
Jones ig found to be Head Chief or not?
A, No; all I care is I belong to the right true
party.
Q. Whet is that?
A. All T care is I belong to the right true party.

Q. And you don't know anything more about this matter

than you have talked about and told on the stand;

do yout
A. gure, I understand.

Q. What t
Ae I understand,

Q. I say, do you know any more about it than you have
testified tot
A. Not if you'aak me some questions.

Q. You said there wasn't any controversy about who
the chiefs were until about the time Mrs, Kellogg
came on the reservation; is that true?

A. What did you sayt

Q. I understood you to say that there wasn't any contro-
versy as to who the chiefs were until after urs,
Kelloge came on the reservation?

A, No, there was not,

Q. And did you know at any time of a talk on the part
of some persons to abolish the chieftain form of
government there; has that ever been talked in
your presence?

A, There has been trouble before among the whites --~

- A. No, sir.
Q. (Interrupting) No. Has that ever been talked in ;

Q. Did that have anything to do with the controversy
your presence, abolishing the chieftain form of

+ % th z as to who the chiefs were?
government ou ere

A. No.
A. I couldn't say.

Q. Was a paper circulated by some person in an attempt Q. And that started about the time irs. Kellogg came

out there?
to get signatures to abolish the chieftain form of

A. That is about the time I know,
government?

Q. About that time you heard?
A. I know Thomas! folks has been circulating papers

; ys A. Yes, sir.
and they never came to us with any papers,
|

Q. None came t out i Q. And she didn't have anything to do with that; did
2 to y !
she 't
A. No party. 5 et
MR. CRHGG: She said she didn't know anythin
Q. Who was the person who wanted to abolish the chief- i a y ?
; about it. |

tain form of government?

BY MR, BROWN:
A. No one came to me; only what I have been told.

Q. You don't know about the paper’
Q. Well, what have you ever been told?

oR: 0 t , if 4. I don't know anything about that,
MR, LiGG: Objected to.

4 GH® COURT: She said she didn't know anything
BY MR. BROWN: |

i about such a paper.

2

Do you know anybody who was interested in abolish-
B

<

MQ. BROWN:
ing the chieftain form of government out there?

Q. Was there any time that anybody proposed to abolish
A, No, sir.

the institution of condolence mother, that you know

a

You don't know who they were?

Sol

oft
A. What is that’

Was there any time that anybody proposed to abolish

2

the institution of condolence mothers; do away
with condolence mothers; have you heard anything
about that?

A. No, sir.

@o

. You never had any part in it?
A. No, sir.

Q. What is that?
A, No, I never did.

WR, BROWN: That is all,

MR, OREGG: That is all. I willeall Delia
Jones.
; DELIA JONHS,
called as a witness on behalf of the defendants and
being duly sworn, testified as follows:

DIRECT EXAMINATION

BY MR. CREGG:

Q. Delia, where do you live?

A. Reservation,

Q. And are you an Onondaga Indiant
A. Yes, sir.

Q. How old are yout
A, Thirty.

MR, BROWN: A little louder, if you please,

BY MR, ORHGG:

Q. Were you present at the condolence held, the
condolence of the Six Nationsheld on the Onondaga
Reservation March eight, 19247
A.Yes, sir,

Q. Where was that held?

A, In the council house,

Q. The Long House on the reservation?
A. Yes, sir.

Q. And about how many of the Onondaga Indians were
present on that occasion?

A. Quite a number of then,

Q. Was the council house filled?

A, Yes, sir.

Q. Did the Indians on the Reservation know generally


that there was to be a condolence hed that aay’
A. Well, I couldn't say, but he carried out the
A. Yes, sir.
ceremony.
Q. It was talked about awound the reservation; was itt
Q. What is thatt Did he have a wampum there’
A. Yes, sir.
A. Yes, six.
Q. Before that date? .

oO

And did he carry that from one side to the other
A. Yes, sir, of the council houset
Q. Ant: were there chiefs from the other reservations A.Yes, sir.
present at that aust iz Q. And did he announce that George Thomas was cut
A. Yes, sir. down?
Q. Whowas it took part in deposing George Thomas Ay Yes, sir.
at that time? Q. ANG then did you hear an objection from Harry Isaacs?
A, Jesse Lyons. A. Yes.
Q. Jess Lyons? Q. And then aid he go through the same ceremony again?
A. Yes, sir. A. Yes, sir.
Q. Was he designated by some one to speek? Q. Were you present at any meetings of the chiefs on
A. I imagine eo. the Onondaga reservation before George was cut down?
MA. BROWN: I didn't hear that, A. Yes, I attend some,
THE WITNESS: IT imagine so, Q. How many meetings did you attend?
BY MR, OREGG: A. I couldn't say.
Q. Now, just tell us what took place after Jess Lyons

Q. Where were they heldt

£ the ceremonyt
took charge of the c a A, In the council house,

BY

©

©

In the council house’

A. Yes, sir. .

And about how long before this meeting at which
George was deposed?

A, I don't remember,

+ You don't remember’

A. No, sir.

Wee there anything saia or done there at the meeting
at which you were present in reference to George
Thomas and airs. Kellogg?

A. I couldn't remembder.

. You don't remember?

A, No, sir,

MR. CREGG: You may cross—examine.

CROSS HXAMINATION
WR. BROWN:
You are Joshua Jones' wife; are yout
A. Yes, sir.
How many different condolences have you ever been

to?

396

A. Two.

. What other one besides this one you déscribed?

A. One in Tuscarora,

And that 1s when they purported to make your
hubband chief?

A. No. ,

What i

A. No, I don't think so.

Woat i

AY No, I don't think so,

That was not the onet

A. No,

What one did you attend at Tuscaroral

A. Waen they were raising chiefs up there.
Well, when; what kind of chiefs?

A. Up on Tuscarora,

What chief?

A. Up at tuscarora, a chief.

There were no Onondaga chiefs concerned in it, one
way or the other?

A. No, sir.

397

&

. Have you ever been to any condolence where anybody
was deposed, except this one’
A. Only to Onondaga Reservation.
@. That is the one you have told us aboutt
A. Yes, six.
Q. That is the only one you ever did seet
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Whether it was done in accordance with the custom
or not, you don't know anything about it?
A. No,
MR. BROWN: That is all,
MR, GREGG: That is all,

I will call Joshua Jones,

JOSHUA JONES,
called as a witness on behalf of the defendants and
being duly sworn, testified as follows;
DIRECT EXAMINATION
BY MR, GREGG:

Q. Joshua, how old are yout

o

A. Fortyi

Where do you livet

A. Onondaga reservation,

. Are you an Onondaga Indian?

A. Yes, sir.

And your mother is Phoebe Lyons?

A. Yes, sir,

And were you at one time a chief of the Onondagas?
A, Yes, sir,

Keep your hand down so we can hear you better, When
were you first made a chief of the Onondagas’

A, 1917, I think,

» About 19177

A. Yes, sir.

. And where was that condolence held?

A, At the Gnondaga reservation,

And how are condolences calledf First, le me ask you:
When a vacancy occurs in @ Ghieftainship on the
reservation, what is done then in order to fill

that chair?

A, Yo fi11 that chair, the vacancy there?

Q.

399

When a chief dies on the reservation that leaves

a vacancy; doesn't it?

A. Yes, sir.

Now, what is the first thing necessary to be done
in order to fill that chair with somebody, to put
somebody in that chair’ Does the mother condolence
of the clan have something to do with it?

A. Yes, sir.

. And does she select the person to be placed in the

chair? i

A.Yes, sir.
And it finally goes to the condolence; does iti

A. YES, sir.

. And what does she do after she selected a person

to £111 that chair; does she notify somebody?
A. Notifies the chief of the nation.
The head chief of the nation?

A, Yes, sir.

. And who is the Head Chief of the Onondagas?

A. Mir. Gibson,

Andrew Gibson?

A. Yes, sir.

Q How long has he been Head Chief of the Onondagas?t

BY

=

A, As long as I can remember.

. And that is thirty years or more?

A. Something like that; yes, Bir,

THE COURT: May I ask a question? Refore the
condolence mothe r recommends a man to the chiefs as
chief of her clan, does she have to consult with
the other women in her clan?

THE WITNESS: Yes, sir.

MR. OREGG:
And then she is designated as the spokesmen for
those women’

A. Yes, sir.

. And then she notifies the Head Chief of the Ononda~

gast

A, Yes, sir,

That is, if it is an Onondaga chief to be raised?
A. Yes, sir.

What action is taken next; what does the Onondaga

Chief do, if anything?

401

A, Well, the Head Chief will go to the Wampum
Keeper and notify him,

And asks the Wampum Keeper to fix a date for a con-
dolence; is that right?

Ay Yes, sir.

And now is it necessary for the chiefs of the reser-

vation to take any action on the name before a date
is fixed for the condolence? Do you understand
what I meant

A, Before the date is fixed?

Let me get this clearly before you, if I can: When
the condolence mother notifies the chief that she

has a man ready t@ fill that job, fill that chair,

does she give him the name of the man; does she tell

him who 1t is?

A. Certainly.

Now, does he cell the council together and take any
action on that name, or doesn't het

A. Yes, sir, he does.

Ana then that name ks approved by the council; is it?

A. Yes, sir.

408

Q. And has the council the right to reject that name
if it pees fity
A, Yes, sir, if they think he is not fit.
Q. If the council feel that he is not fit for that
job they can reject himt
A. Yes, sir; and it goes back to the clan mother.
Q. And it goes back to the clan mother to select another
namet
A. Yes, sir,
Q. Now, after the council approves the name, then
somebody goes to the Wampum Keeper and asks him to
fix a date for thefondolence?
A. Yes, sir,
Q. And who is the Wampum Keeper?
A. Adam Thomas, ,
Q. How long has Adam Thomas been Wampum Keeper?
A, Been there ever since I can remember,
Q. Would you say around thirty years?
A. Yes, sir. ,
Q. And does the Wampum Keeper, the position of Wampum

Keeper belong to the Oneida Indianst

2

2

4038

A. Yes, sir,

And whenever a condolence is to be held, must the
Head Chief of the Onondagas be notified of that
condolence

A. Yes, sir,
And musthe go to the Wampum Keeper and asx that he
fix a date for the condolence’

A, Yes, sir.

Is that right?

A.Yes, sir,

Now, can a condolence be called in any other way

of the Onondagas

except through the Head Chief/going to the Wampum
Keeper of the Oneidas’
A, Yes, six.
Well, is that the only way it can be called?
A, No, sir, not that I know of.
WeEL, is there any other wayt My friend here seems
to get a little amusement out of your inability to
understand this question. Let me see if I can make
it clearer: Is there anyother way a condolence can

be called?

2

Qe

A, No, sir, not that I know of.

And then after the Wampum Keeper fixes a day for
the condolence, what is done next; what is the next
stept

A, They notify the other ations.

All right. Who notifies the other nations?

A. Wampum Keeper and the Head Chief of the Nation.
That is, the Wampum Keeper notifies part of them and
the Head Chief of the Onondaga Nation notifies

the other part of them?

A. Yes, sir.

What nations does the Head Chief of the Onond@gas
notify?

A. The Onondaga, Cayugas and Senecas,

And the Wampum Keeper notifies the other three?

A. Yes, sir,

The Oneidas, Mohawks and Tuscaroras!
A. Yes, sir.

Ana then the condolence is held wherever the Wampum
Keeper fixes the place?

A.Yes, sir, wherever the vacancy is


405

He don't have to fix the place there. cooked in itt

A, Yes, sir,

Q. Well, wherever the Yamoum Keeper fixes the place?

A, Yes, sir Q. And who furnishes that; the nation or who?
. Yes, ‘

Q.Does the Wampum Keeper fix the place as well as the 4, The clan mothers.

aate? Q. Of the nation where the chief is to be raised?

A. He fixes the date where the vacancy is; that is, A. Yes, sir,

the place it takes place, the condolence. Q. Te that eid

Q. Now, what is the first thing that is done when the A. Yes, sir,

condolence gets together? Q, Now, were you ~ well, let me ask you there: Who

. announces the na f the
A, There ceremony starts. ea the name of the man to be made chief at

the condoleweet

Q. How does the ceremony start; tell us in your own

way A. Well, the clan mother selects the spokesman,
i. Phot Be: someting 7 cannét, Q. The clan mother of the clan where the chief is to

Hoes it open with a song or prayer? be madet

©

A. A song. A. Yes, sir,

£

Q. Is there any prayer there? She selects somebody to speak for her; is that

A, No, not exactly. right?

Q. What do you mean by the "Kettle Keepers"; is there - A, Yes, sir.

or, first, who are the "Kettle Keepers"? Q. And then he goes through the ceremony of carrying

the wampum fro side t e ¢
A, Kettle Keeperst pus m oné side to the other

A. Yes, sir,
Q. Is there a kettle there where there ig something

&

407

And asking whethere or not there is any objection
to such a man being made chief?

A, Yes, sir.

Is that right?

A. Yes, sir,

And, now, at any of these regular condolences can
a chief be cut down’?

A. Yes, sir, on certain length of time.

I see. Well, what do you mean by that; a certain
length of time transpires or elapsest

A, It 1s up to the Head Chief of the Fire Keepers,
the Onondagasx.

To do what?

A. To open that up; if a certain place is vacant,
that is the time to put them up, and the chief ~--
(Interrupting) But, suppose you want to cut a chief
down?

A. It is the same way.

It is the same way’

A. Yes, sir,

Ana then the clan mother appears{

2

A. Yes, sir,
And what does she do when she wants to cut a chief
down?

A, She has to get somebody to,

She designates somebody to soeak for her?

A. Yes, sir,

And then he is given a wampum; is hei

A.YES, sir.

And does he barry it back and forth from one place
to the other?

A. No, when he gets through speaking, then he
takes it over to the Wampum Keeper and leaves it
over there,

And that cuts the chief down; does it?

A. Yes, sir,

Now, suppose anybody objects at that time? Suppose
somebody objects and says it is not right,that he
should not be cut downt

A. Well, then, if the clan mother has got another
wampum to hand over to the spokesman, she hands it

over and he cuts him down, clear down,


2

409

And then he goes through the same performance again
and he is cut clear down?

A. Yes, sir. ,

And were you presentin 1917 when George Thomas wae
made Head Chief of the Six Nations?

A. Yes, sir,

. And where was that condolewee held?

A, At the Onondaga reservation,

. Were you a chief then?

A No, sir. That is the time I became chief.

Qh. You were made chief on the same day he was made
Head Chief of the Six Nations?

A.Yes, sir,

And was George a chief at that time, before he was
made Head Chief; do you know?

A. That I can't say.

You can't sayt

A. No, sir.

Now, if a chief of the Onondagas is made Head Chief
of the Six Nations, does that leave his office as

chief vacant?

410

A, Yes, sir,

. A man cannot hold two chairs’

A. No, sir.

And, now, does the Head Chief of the Six Nations
belong to the Onondagas?

A. Yes, sir,

Who is the clan mother that proposed George Thomas
for Head Chief in 19174

A. Phoebe Lyons.

. Phoebe Lyons?

A. Yes, sir,
And that is your mother?

A. Yes, sir.

- And was the regular ceremony gone through in making

George Thomas Head Chief of the Six Nationsthat

day?

A. Yes, sir,

And that was the same day that you were made a chief
of the Onondagas; is that right?

A. L917’

. Yes,

Q.

A, Yes, sir.

Ana, now, was there any dispute on the reservation,
so far as you can remember, as to who the chiefs
on the feservation were, until Mrs, Kellogg came
on the reservation?

A. No, sir.

And just before George Thomas was deposed, who
were the regular chiefs on the reservationt

Can you tell usi

A. Well, I will try. That is before he was cut
down?

Before he was cut down,

A. Yes. Well, there was George Thomas, Andrew
Gibson, Emmett Lyons, John White, Jesse Lyons, How-
ard Hill, Charles Green, George Van Every, Davis
Green, Ruben Jones and myself.

William Webster’

A, Yes, sir, and George Webster; and that is 11

I can remember.

And Ocias Schanandoah, a bodyguard?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And Albert Kennedy?

BY

412

A. Yes, sir.

. Eli Schanandoah, was he made chief -~-

MR. BROWN (Interrupting): He was later.
THE WITNESS: No, sir, he was not,

MR. OCREGG:

And any othere you remember? Was Newton Green’

A. Newton Green, yes, sir,

. And George Crowe?

A. Yes, sir,

And Wilson Johnson?

A. Yes, sir.

Frank Isaacs’ Was Frank Isaacs a chief?

A. Yes, sir,

Was Wilson Johnson, Senior and Junior, that is,
both of them?

A. At that time?

Yes.

A. dust the Senior,

I see. You are not sure you have named all’
A. What is that?’

You are not sure you have named all of them?


413

A, I think that is all. TI don't know just how many. ; ,
i Q. And how many meetings did they have
That is all I can remember anyway. ,

; A. Why, I couldn't say,

Now, were you present at the condolence at which

Q. Well, two or three, or what numbert

George Thomas was deposed?
A. Yes, three or more,
A. Yes, sir,
Q. And about how long before this condolence of
And that was held in Werch, 1924; was iti i dazed
i eighth were these meetings held?
A. Yes, sir. |
4, You mean just the Onondagas alonet
Where was it heldt c
. Q. The Onondagas alone; that is right?
A, At the Onondaga reservation.
A. I can't say.
Now, before he was deposed, were there meetings
Q. Now, how many of these Chiefs of the reservation
of the chiefs on the Onondaga reservation’ :
‘ were present at each of these meetings of the Onondaga
A. Yes, sir, there was.
Nation alone?
And where were those meetings held’
A. Well, I am going to try and explain,
A. You mean the Six Nations?
Q. ALL right. Go ahead,
No, no. Before he was deposed at the Six Nations
; A. When we hold a meeting we generally have eight
conference or condolence, did the Onondagas have
; chiefs ena the rest of them, we don't know where
some meetings on the Onondaga Reservation themselvest
they are - sleeping or somewheres,
I mean the Onondaga Council itself.
Q. Well, when a meeting is held, or bo be held xr
A, The Onondaga Council itself? , ° , > anes
all notified to comet
Yes,
A. Yes, sir.
A. Yes, sir,
Q. And who is it has the right to call such a meeting?


BY

Q.

415

A. The Chairman of the Nation.

. Andrew Gibson?

A. Yes, sir.

. And how many does it take to have a quorum?

A. About eight.
Eight?
A. yes, gir.
MR, BROWN: What is that again’

MR. CREGG:

. How many does it take to make @ quorumt

A. Bight.
And, now, how many were present at these meetings
thet were held before George Thomas was deposed?

A, How many chiefs?

Q. Yes, sir.
A, They ought to have eight; that is all.
Q. Hight?
A, That is all I was sure of.
Q, Now, was there anything said at those meetings, or

any of them, in reference to George Thomas and Mrs.

Kelloggit

MR. BROWN: Well, I objec to that, unless it

appeare when the meeting was held and who was
there.

THE COURT: Objection sustained,

wR. ORHGG: Well, he said it was a short time
verone.

THE COURT: Did he say who were present?

BY MR. OREGG:

Q. Can you tell us who the eight were that were

Q

Q.

Q.

present?)

A. Pretty near.

Go ahead and tell us?

A. There is George Thomas, Andrew Gibson, Emmett
Lyons, John White, Charles Green, Wilson Johnson,

George Van very and myself.

I didn't keep track of them, Does that make eight’

A. That makes eight.

Q. All right. Well, now, was there anything said at

that meeting in reference to Mrs. Kelloge and

George Thomas’

A, Not until after Mrs, Kellogg came there,


Qe

2

2

rat
@.

41?

That is what I mean, after Mrs. Kellogg came there.
All vight. Now, go ahead? ,
A. Well, these eight chiefs were all there at that
time , and we held this meeting over to George Van
Every's residence,
George Van Iivery's?
A. Yes, sir.
And was George Van Every at that meeting himelf?
A.Yes, sir, George Van Every.
I see. Senior or Junior?
A, Senior; and John White and Emmett Lyons and
myself, Wilson Jonnson. I don't believe Gibson
was there; I can't say. That is all I can remember,
Well, did you say that there were eight there?
A. Oh, that was before mrs. Kellogg came there.
This ls after she was around.
And were they all notified of this meeting at
George Van Ivery's*
MR. BROWN: I object to it unless he knows,
wR. CREGG: I did not ask him to tell anything

he does not know,

B

ws

BY

Q.

MR. OREGG:

WHo called the meeting at George Van Every'st

‘A, If I remember right, I think George Van Every

was chairman at that time.
Of the meeting?
A. Yes, sir.
Yeat
A. This is about George Thomas' case.
About George Thomas' case’
A. Yes, sir. ,
And was George Thomas there?
A, No, sir.
WR. BROWN: There was only four and he gave the
names,
THE WITNESS; There was one delegate from the
Tonawanda delegation,
MR. CREGGS
He was there?
A. Yes, six.
Who was it?

A, He is dead. He was Chief Scroge.


Q. And how many of the Onondaga chiefs were there?
A. I just mentioned them a few minutes ago.
Q. Well, I didn't count them to see,
MR. BROWN: He named four.
BY MR. OREGG:
Q. Well, name them again so we will find out?
A. George Van Every, Senior, and John White, Wilson
Johnson, Emmett Lyons and myself,
Q. Four besides yourself?
A.Yes, sir; yes, and ne delegate from Tonawanda,
Q. Was George Van very, Senior theret
A, He was there.
Q. And Junior toot
A, No, sir.
Q.Just the one?
A. Yes, sir,
Q. Well,what was the discussion at that time in reference
to George Thomast
A. Well, it was about the action he has done,
Q. Ana what was that; tell usabout it; what was said

there at that time?

PS

-

430

A, Well, George Van fivery himself said before us that
George Thomas was not eligible to take the office
in the first place.

He was not eligible to take the office in the first
placet

AY Yes, sir. That is what he said.

And what reason did he give?

A. The reason that he is always working out.
Working off the reservation?

A. Yes, sir, and he has got no time to hold the
meetings on our reservation; and that is what he
said there at that time.

He did not give your reservation proper attention!
A. No, sir.

And what else was said there at that timet

A, Well, I can't ~ everybody seems to be talking
right along in the seme manner at that time,

Now, do you know whether your mother as spokesman

for the Eel clan notified or warned George Thomas‘

A, He has been notifiea several. times, not only ny

mother but some others,

2

421

And who are the others that notified him?

A. There is Andrew Gibson, Martha Brown, and Thomas
Jones from Tonawanda, and Sky - there is another

one from Canada; I can't recall his name.

Notified him or warned him of what?

A, To live up to our constitution, not to sign any
papers what comes to him, to not infringe our rights.
That is, not to infringe upon your rights?

A.Yes, sir.

And were there other meetings held anywhere else
about that time?

A. Well, that is the only place I remember,

That is the only one you remember at that timet

A. Yes, sir,

Now, were you present at that condolence on March
eighth?

A. Yes, gir.

How many of the Onondaga Indians were there?

A. You have got me. I cannot tell exactly. I cannot
recall,

Was the council hoase pretty well filled?

mf

o

A. Yes, sir, it was.

Was it quite crowded that day?

A. Yes, sir.

What other nations were present theret

A, There was Tonawanda, Tuscarora, and the

Oneidas, and that is all I remember,

Were the Cayugas and the Senecas there?

A. I cannot say as to that.

You cannot say as to that?

A. No, sir.

Now, what took place at the condolence in reference
to George Thomas?

A. At the condolewe his condolence mother was there
to depose him.

Just tell us how that was done’

A. Well, after they out up these two chiefs, or,
three, rather, there was James Lyons as the principal
chief and H1i Schenandoah, bodyguard, and another
from Suncereral, as a chief; those three were put up.

After that, then Gioson opened up, if there is

anybody that wants to cut down a chief, and that was

Q.

483

the time that the clan mother selected Jesse Lyons
to be her spokesman,

And then, let me see if I understand you: After
these chiefs were raised, two on the Onondaga
Reservation and one on the Tuscarorat

A.Yes, sir,

Then Andrew Gibson asked if there was anybody to
be deposed?

A.Yes, sir.

And is Andrew Gibson, or was Andrew Gibson at that
time, by reason of being Head Chief of the Onondagas
in charge of the condolence?

A. Woy, I think I will have to correct that. I
don't believe Andrew Gibson was there,

You don't think he was there?

A, No, sir.

You think it was somebody else?

A. I think somebody else; yes.

Well, is that a regular procedure in a condolence
that there is a time when there is a pauset

A. It is any principal chief; it has got to be N

2

424

an Onondaga Chief to take that part,

To take that part?

A. Yes, sir.

Is that a regular procedure in a condolence?

A. Yes, sir.

I see. Now, after someone announced and asked whether
there was anybody to be deposed or not, what haoppen-
edt

A, That is the time the clan mother selects Jesse
lyons to depose George Thomas, which he did.

Ana then did somebody hand Jesse Lyons a

wampum there’

A, John White.

John White?

A, Yes, sir.

And then did Jesse Lyons go through the regular
procedure of deposing a chief there’

A. Yes, sir.

And did he oarry the wampum from one side to the
other?

A, No,

&

425

How is that done’ How is a chief deposed?
A. Stands right there and speaks, makes a speech,
and when he gets through then he goes over and

hands it to the Wampum Keeper.

Well, first, does he ask if there is any objection,

or is this all regular?

A. Yes, sir.

And your mother, Phoebe Lyons, was there at that
timet

A. Yes, sir,

And did she consent to it?

A. She is the one that handed John White the
wampuin,

Oh, I see. That is, your mother, Phoebe Lyons,

handed John White the wampum there at that timet

A. Yes, sir.
And then John White, in turn, handed it to Jesse
Lyonst

A, Yes, sir.

And, now, after he went through the first ceremony

and handed the wampun to Adam Thomas, did anybody

make objection?

A.Yes, sir.

Q. Who was iti
A. Harry Isaacs.

Q. Ana after Sarry Isaacs ~ or, first, what did Harry
Taaacs Bay, as you recall’
A, Well, he saia that he is, that George ‘Thomas is
to be Head Chief as long as he lives, but he didn't
have any wampum.

Q. But he didn't have any wampum to hand to ---
A. (Interrupting) No, sir.

Q. To Adam Thomas?
A, No, sir,

Q. Or to Jesse Lyons?
A. Adam Thomas.

Q. He didn't have any to hand to Adam Thomas?

A. No, sir.

Q.Now, what happened after thati
A, Thea the clan mother handed John . White another
wampum,

Q. Thatis, Phoebe Lyons, the clan mother, handed John

White another wampum?


427

A. Yes, sir, and then he handed it over to Jewse
Lyons,
Jesse Lyons?
A. Yes, sir.
And then Jesse Lyons went through the same ceremony?
A. Yes, sir,
And after that he was cut diese down?
A, Yes, sir.
. And was there any objection from anybody after thati
A. George Thomas, himself.
What did George sayt
A, Well, he said he is going to hold that office
as long as he lives.
Whether they deposed him or not?
A. Yes, sir,
And was it ann@unced there by those in charge that
he was depocedi
A. Yes, sir; it was all over, done,
MR, BROWN: I object to that. Let us know what
was done,

MR. CREGG: I think he has already said that he

was cut clear down.

wR, CREGG:

. By cut clear down, do you mean deposed and put out?

A. What?
When a chief igs cut clear down, do you mean he is
put outi
A, Yes, sir.
And cannot hold the office of chief any more?
A, No, sir.

MR. CREGG: Now, if Your Honor please, there
is a whole lot more of this witness's testimony.

THE OOURT: You will not be able to finish it
tonight?

MR, CREGG: No, six.

THE COURT: I want to ask two or three questions
if I may.

you said, as I understood, that the Head
Chief of the Six Nations had to be a member of the
Onondaga Tribe?

THE WITNESS: Yes, sir.

THE COURT: And does he have to bea member of

439

any particular clan in the Onondaga tribe?

THE WITNESS; No, sir, not ~ no, sir.
The chiefs select the clan mother.

THE COURT: The Chief selects a clan or condo-
lence mother for the Head Chief, or Chief of the
8ix Nations?

THE WITNESS; Yes, sir, and she has the full
power to depose him,

THE COURT; And after she is selected she
would then have to choose that man from what clan,
you sayt

THE WITNESS: It is this way: When they
choosed Chief George Thomas to be the Head Chief,
and then the next was who would be the clan mother,
and they got Phoebe Lyons as his clan mother. Seet

THE COURT: Well, if George Thomas, or if the
office which George Thomas held became vacant, would
Phoebe Lyons still continue to be clan mother, or
condolence mother?

THE WITWESS: Yes, sir, unless the chiefs made

another clan mother,

THE COURT; Now, when a clan mother chooses
a man to be the Chief of the Six Nations, that
name is then sent where?

THE WITNESS; To the council of the Chiefs.

THE COURT: The Couneil of all the Nations?

THE WITNESS: Of the Nation, of the Onondaga
Nation,

THE COURT: Of the Onondaga Nation?

THE WITNESS: Yes, sir, ,

THE COURT: Or the Six Nations?

THE WITNESS: Onondaga Nation; the same as any
other principal chief is put bn.

THE COURT; Take in your case, for instance;
You claim that you were named by the condolence
mother, Phoebe Lyons, to be Chief of the Six
Nationst

THE WITNESS: She selects me,

THE COURT; I say, you claim you were chosen?

THE WITNESS; Yes, sir, ,

THE COURT: Now, where was your name sent?

Where did Phoebe Lyons report that?

THE WITNESS: The Head Chief of the Onondaga

Nation,

THE COURT: Head Chief of the Onondaga Nation?

THE WITNESS: Yes, sir,

THE COURT: And then what did he have to do’
THE WITNESS! He notifies the other chiefs to
hold a meeting and specifically for that matter.

THE COURT: That is, the Onondaga Chiefs?

{THE WITNESS: Yes, six.

THE COURT: And then, after the Onondaga Chiefs
agree on some man it goes to the council or condo-
lence of the $ix Nations; is that right?

THE WITNESS: And then it goes over to the

Wampum Keeper to set the date.

THE COURT: To set the date for the condolence?

THE WITNESS: Yes, sir,

THE COURT: Well, now, when the condolence is

held, do the other nations, the Oneidas, the Mohawks

right to object to the man who has been selected by

the Onondagas?

431

and the Senecas, and the others, do they have any

THE WITNESS: No, sir. The reason why,
because the other nations don't know, don't know
me.

THE COURT: What?

THE WITNHSS: They don't know whether I am
eligible or not. The Onondagas, they know, they
are right there,

THE COURT; Well, your understanding is that
the Onondagas have the right to select the chief of
the Six Nations?

THE WITNESS: Yes, sir.

THE COURT: Now, when the condolence mother
makes a complaint against the chief and asks to have
him deposed, have any of the other nations a right
to object to that deposition?

THE WITNESS: Well, they have got — you know
they cannot depose him unless he has done some thing
detrimental.

THE COURT: Well, who determines whether he
has done something out of the way or not?

A, The Onondagas, where he is chief,

THE COURT: Yes. But in the condolence, as. you
start to depose a man, did I understand you to say
that if anybody objects you have to start over?

THE WITNESS: The spokesman have to start
over, yes,

THE COURT: Now, supposing someone objected the
second timet

THE WITNESS: The second time he has gone
clearn down. That is the last,

THH COURT: But, then, I want this clear:

As I understand you, none of the other nationshave
any authority to object to a chief that has been
chosen by the Onondagas; that is right?

THE WITNESS: Yes, sir

THE COURT: And none of the other nations have
any authority to object to the Onondagas deposing a
chief?

THE WITNESS: No, sir,

THE COURT: Do the Onondagas, the Onondaga
Chiefs have a right to overrule any complaint that

is made by the condolence mother?

T

ii WITNESS: No, sir.

THE COURT; They have no right to overrule?

THE WITNESS: No, sir.

THE COURT: And then as you understand it, the
condolence mother, on her own complaint, can depose
the Chief of the Six Nations?

THE WITNESS: Give her the full power,

THE COURT: That is all.

(Discussion at the bench between the Court and

Counsel outside the record as to adjournment, )

THE COURT: This matter will be adjourned sub~
ject to call to a date to be set by me later, This
case will now be adjourned to a date to be fixed

by me later. I am sorry, but I have to leave tonight.

(Whereupon, at 5:10 P, M., the matter was
adjourned to a date to be hereafter fixed by

THE COURT, )

435

IND# XxX,

Opening statement-Mr. Cregg, 3

w ul Mx. Brown, 10
WITNESSES: DIRECT. CROSS, REDIRECT. RECROSS.
Andrew Gibson, 19 53 68 70
ivan Fellows, 73 91 100
Walter Kennedy, 104 156 173
J. Warren Brayley, 173 A388 336 B44
Adam Thomas, 849 ab3 367
Jesse Lyons, 269 303 337
Howard Hill, 337 342 353
Marthe Brown, 357 360
Emmett Lyons, 365 370 74. 374.

376

Minnie Maybee, 377 387 :
Delia Jones, 391 395
Joshua Jones, 397.

ORK OR OK OR OR OK

Metadata

Containers:
Box 1 (1-Legal Papers), Folder 16
Resource Type:
Document
Rights:
Date Uploaded:
September 18, 2025

Using these materials

Access:
The archives are open to the public and anyone is welcome to visit and view the collections.
Collection restrictions:
Access to this record group is unrestricted.
Collection terms of access:
The researcher assumes full responsibility for conforming with the laws of copyright. Whenever possible, the M.E. Grenander Department of Special Collections and Archives will provide information about copyright owners and other restrictions, but the legal determination ultimately rests with the researcher. Requests for permission to publish material from this collection should be discussed with the Head of Special Collections and Archives.

Access options

Ask an Archivist

Ask a question or schedule an individualized meeting to discuss archival materials and potential research needs.

Schedule a Visit

Archival materials can be viewed in-person in our reading room. We recommend making an appointment to ensure materials are available when you arrive.