Arley Henderson, 1895 May 31

Online content

Fullscreen
fore fifty witnesses in a stockade built in the jail yard at Murphys-
boro, Each maintained to the end that he was not the aetual killer,”
Henderson's last words were: "I hope to meet you all in Heaven," while
Jeffreys only said: "I am innocent of this crime,"

THE ILLINOISAN, Carbondale, 111,, Dece 1) 197he

Letter dated 7=21-1977 from Preson M, Jones, 11$ North Ninth St.,
Murphysboro, I11,, 62966 _

fore fifty witnesses in a stockade built in the jail yard at Murphys-
boro, Each maintained to the end that he was not the aatual killer.
jenderson's last words weret "I hope to meet you all in Heaven," while
Jeffreys only said: "I am innocent of this crime."

THE ILLINOISAN, Carbondale, 111,, Dece 1) 197hs

Letter dated 7-21-1977 from Preson M, bh, 41$ North Ninth Ste,
Murphysboro, Ill, , 62966

fore fifty witnesses in a stockade built in the jail yard at Murphys=
boro, Each maintained to the end that he was not the aatual killer,
Henderson's last words weret "I hope to meet you all in Heaven," while
Jeffreys only said: "I am innocent of this crime,"

THE ILLINOISAN, Carbondale, 111,, Dece 1, 197k.

Tetter dated eM, PR eens 12S North Ninth ste,
Murphysboro, I11., 6

Sear Aan Somertradeoreirt meta

te tnt

Icke ated ela fon Peon ety MS Bort EA Sty

HENDERSON, Arley Douglas ("Dug") and JEFFREY, Frank

Henderson, a 23-year-old white native of Marion, Ill., and Jeffrey,
also white and 28-yearseold, was a native of Carterville, Both were
unemployed laborers living in Carterville when, on Dec. 20, KXZK
189), they followed James Towle, a widower who had been working for

a few days there when Towle left town walking on the right of way

of the Short Line Railroad, Towle was going to visit a sister in
Makanda and they caught up with him shortly after he had crossed
the Jackson County line, One of them shot him twice in the head

and they robbed the body of some silver coins before dragging it

into some brushes by the right-of-way, The body was discovered

the next day but it was several days later before it was identified.
Jeffreys had left one of his gloves at the scene of the crime, their
footprints matched those found there and they were positively iden~
tified as the two men who had attempted to rob another traveler near-
by and as having been seen near the site of Towle's murder, Both ad-
mitted participation in the robbery-murder but each claimed that the

bher d actually killed T owle and that he had been forced to par-
feats at gunpoint. -¢ At their trial, both were convicted a

sentenced to die and on May 31, 1895, they were privatbly hanged be-

HENDERSON, Arley Douglas ("Dug") and JEFFREY » Frank

Henderson, a 23-year-old white native of Marion, Ill., and Jeffrey,
also white and 28-years-old, was a native of Carterville, Both were
unemployed laborers living in Carterville when, on Dece 20, XKX3K
189, they followed James Towle, a widower who had been working for

a few days there when Towle left town walking on the right of way

of the Short Line Railroad, Towle was going to visit a sister in
Makanda and they caught up with him shortly after he had crossed
the Jackson County line. One of them shot him twice in the head

and they robbed the body of some silver coins before dragging it

into some brushes by the right-of-way. The body was discovered

the next day but it was several days later before it was identified.
Jeffreys had left one of his gloves at the scene of the crime, their
footprints matched those found there and they were positively iden~
tified as the two men who had attempted to rob another traveler near-
by and as having been seen near the site of Towle's murder, Both ad-
mitted participation in the robbery-murder but each claimed that the

piber d potually killed T owle and that he had been forced to par-
icipate at gunpoint. . At their trial, both were convicted and

sentenced to die and on May 31, 1895, they were privatbly hanged be-

HENDERSON, Arley Douglas ("Dug") and JEFFREY, Frank

Henderson, a 23-year-old white native of Marion, I11,, and Jeffrey,

also white and 28-years-old, was a native of Carterville, Both were

unemployed laborers living in Carterville when, on Dec. 20,

189h, they followed James Towle, a widower who had been working for

a few days there when Towle left town walking on the right of way

of the Short Line Railroad, Towle was going to visit a sister in

Makanda and they caught up with him shortly after he had crossed

the Jackson County line, One of them shot him twice in the head

and they robbed the body of some silver coins before cragging it

into some brushes by the right-of. The body was

the next day but it was several days later before it was identified.

Jeffreys had left one of his gloves at the scene of the crime, their

footprints matched those found there and they were positively iden-

tified as the two men who had attempted to rob another traveler near-
Both ad-

mitted participation in the robbery-nurder but each claimed that, the

d, actually, filled 7 oye, and that he had been forced to par-
Phoebe oe Gimpalnts mirateitrialyiieent sere Gouvictsd lana

sentenced to ae and on ree 31, 1895, they were privatbly hanged be-

YBROMoH, ay Dowpha (He!) aed JERE Prank



Metadata

Resource Type:
Document
Description:
Arley Henderson executed on 1895-05-31 in Illinois (IL)
Rights:
Image for license or rights statement.
CC BY-NC-SA 4.0
Date Uploaded:
July 12, 2019

Using these materials

Access:
The archives are open to the public and anyone is welcome to visit and view the collections.
Collection restrictions:
Access to this record group is unrestricted.
Collection terms of access:
The researcher assumes full responsibility for conforming with the laws of copyright. Whenever possible, the M.E. Grenander Department of Special Collections and Archives will provide information about copyright owners and other restrictions, but the legal determination ultimately rests with the researcher. Requests for permission to publish material from this collection should be discussed with the Head of Special Collections and Archives.

Access options

Ask an Archivist

Ask a question or schedule an individualized meeting to discuss archival materials and potential research needs.

Schedule a Visit

Archival materials can be viewed in-person in our reading room. We recommend making an appointment to ensure materials are available when you arrive.