Virginians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty
Tides Foundation Grant Report
July 31, 2018
$40,000 Death Penalty Mobilization Fund Grant
# 1711-48648
Impact and Assessment
In October and November 2017 VADP convened five regional meetings in northern Virginia,
Richmond, Norfolk, Charlottesville, and Roanoke. We provided education on the Severe Mental
Illness (SMI) exclusion idea and encouraged contacts with legislators to support the concept.
VADP held its 26th anniversary Awards luncheon in October. Eighty supporters heard a keynote
by David Bruck of the Virginia Capital Case Clearinghouse and saw Rob Lee, Director of the
Virginia Capital Representation Resource Center, accept the Citizen Advocate of the Year award.
VADP continued to work for enactment of an SMI exemption with the Virginia Alliance for the
Severe Mental Illness Exclusion (VASMIE). This coalition includes DisAbility Law Center,
Mental Health America of Virginia, National Alliance on Mental IIIness (NAMI) Virginia, NAMI
Central Virginia, National Association of Social Workers — Virginia Chapter, Virginia Counselors
Association, Virginia Organization of Consumers Asserting Leadership, and, ACLU of Virginia.
In January 2018 VADP sent an e-mail to over 3,000 supporters with information about the SMI
exemption. VADP staff attended education events sponsored by the ACLU of Virginia, NAMI
Central Virginia, the NAACP, and Virginia Interfaith Center to talk about the SMI exemption.
VADP placed op-eds supporting the SMI exemption in the Bristol Herald Courier, the
Harrisonburg Daily News-Record, and the Lynchburg News and Advance.
This was the third year of our coalition’s campaign to pass SMI exclusion legislation. Eighteen
conservative and Libertarian leaders — including former Attorneys General Ken Cuccinelli and
Mark Earley and former Congressman Tom Bliley — endorsed this reform legislation. Twelve
murder victim family members in Virginia also supported the proposed statute.
Despite this support, we ran into implacable opposition from the new chair of the Virginia House
of Delegates Courts of Justice Committee. He refused to allow the bill to be heard in committee.
In the Senate, we made a strong presentation on behalf of the SMI exemption to the Courts of
Justice Committee. But it was referred to the Crime Commission for study by the Senate Majority
Leader, a positive sign. In the prior year the bill was defeated on a party-line vote in committee.
Five regional meetings in northern Virginia, Richmond, Norfolk, Charlottesville, and Roanoke were
held in the spring of 2018 that debriefed General Assembly’s consideration of the SMI exemption.
During the grant year VADP Field Director Dale Brumfield gave death penalty presentations that
highlighted the SMI exemption at seven venues — including the Three Chopt Rotary in Zion
Crossroads & Chatham Rotary (March), Gemeinschaft House in Harrisonburg, Smith Mountain
Lake Rotary, a DP forum at the Barter Theatre in Abingdon (April), and the Valley Justice
Coalition in Harrisonburg (May).
In addition, he has developed significant relationships with conservatives in the state. As a result of
his participation at the national CPAC conference, he got an invitation to speak at the Monticello
Republican Women’s Club in Springfield. His talk was so well received that he was invited to
have a VADP display table at the Virginia Federation of Republican Women’s Conference (May).
This resulted in invitations from five more local Republican women’s clubs to speak about the DP.
1
His work has resulted in supportive relationships with an elected Republican prosecutor in
Lynchburg as well as a Retired state Circuit Court Judge who once sentenced someone to death.
Both are willing to help with behind-the-scenes communication and lobbying with legislators.
Challenges
The strident opposition of the new chair of the House Courts of Justice Committee, Del. Rob Bell,
effectively ends any opportunity to move the SMI exemption in that legislative chamber.
While Governor Ralph Northam, elected in November 2017, has said that he would sign an
abolition bill, he has pledged to carry out executions. The three remaining men on Virginia’s
death row are all near the end of their appeals process. It is likely that all three will receive
execution dates by the end of the 2019 calendar year.
Evaluation and Lessons Learned: Severe Mental Illness Exemption
There was a dramatic change in the House of Delegates as a result of the November 2017 elections.
Democrats went from a small minority (34 of 100) to near parity (49 seats).
This shift in power, however, hardened Republican opposition to death penalty reform measures
like the SMI exemption because of the new Courts of Justice Committee chair, Del. Rob Bell. He
made it clear that as long as he is committee chair, the SMI exemption bill will go nowhere.
As a result, the SMI coalition will focus our efforts on the Senate where two Republican Senators
have signaled a willingness to consider sponsorship of our bill in 2019.
After the 2018 General Assembly, the Virginia SMI coalition met and identified key legislative
districts for grassroots education on the SMI exemption:
Sen. Ben Chafin (Abingdon) Sen. Mark Peake (Lynchburg)
Sen. Bill Stanley (Moneta) Sen. Glen Sturtevant (Richmond)
Coalition partners will work together to carry out grassroots education work in these areas.
Funding and Finances
VADP ended its 2016 year with a net income of $23,661.03 and $87,569.19 in assets.
For the first six months of 2017 VADP expenses have exceeded income by $40,152.78. Our board
adopted a budget anticipating a negative $25,088.25 balance for the 2018 year.
The larger negative balance has been caused by an unanticipated $10,000 reduction in our grant
from the Sisters of Bon Secours and increased costs due to the hiring of a Field Organizer in May
2017. By the end of the year this negative balance will decrease substantially.
VADP has held “friend-raising” events during the first half of 2018 in Arlington, Washington (DC),
and Charlottesville. We anticipate holding additional “friend-raisers” in Charlottesville (October
Ist) and northern Virginia (date TBD) later in the year.
Because of its fundraising efforts, VADP received $5,000 first-time contributions from two new
donors. A partner in a major Washington, DC law firm contributed $500 at a “friend-raiser.”
Contributions from Virginia’s faith community to VADP so far this year has already exceeded the
total that we received from this source in 2017.
Finally, the VADP Treasurer challenged each of our 13 board members to develop a plan to raise
$1,000 in new funding by the ne of the 2018 year and to share it at our September board meeting.
I know that at least five of these board members have started working on their fundraising plans.
2
Virginians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty
Tides Foundation Grant Report
July 31, 2018
$40,000 Death Penalty Mobilization Fund Grant
# 1711-48648
Financial Report for the Grant Year
January 1, 2018 to December 31, 2018
Tides Grant Expenditures
Budget (as of 6-30-2018)
Personnel Expenses:
Executive Director $ 52,000.00 $ 20,000.00
Field Organizer 35,000.00 15,000.00
FICA & MEDC 6,655.00
Personnel Subtotal $ 93,655.00 $ 35,000.00
Direct Expenses:
Travel $ 14,500.00 5,000.00
Postage and Shipping 500.00
Printing and Copying 500.00
Materials and Books 300.00
Database and Website 2,500.00
Direct Expenses Subtotal $ 18,300.00 $ 5,000.00
Indirect Expenses:
Telephone and Fax $ 900.00
Development/Fundraising 6,000.00
Professional Fees 3,650.00
Indirect Expenses Subtotal $ 10,550.00 0
Total Expenses $ 122,505.00 $ 40,000.00