Severe Mental Illness Exemption: An act of compassion
Last year, a professor at the University of Virginia School of Law wrote
about the conviction and sentencing of Russell Brown, a Virginia man who
had been “talking in fantastical and paranoid ways,” eating bark and
obsessing over conspiracy theories, the book of Revelation and the Mayan
calendar in the weeks before he shot and killed a state trooper.
Despite the testimony outlining his erratic behavior, the jury rejected his
insanity defense and found Brown guilty of capital murder. Thankfully he
was not given the death penalty, but received a sentence of life in prison
without parole.
There was similar evidence of bizarre and psychotic behavior in the cases of
Virginians Calvin Eugene Swann and Percy Levar Walton. Unlike Mr.
Brown, both of these men were sentenced to death in the Commonwealth
despite having documented, lifelong severe mental illnesses diagnosed by
medical experts.
While these men may have committed very serious crimes, our law is still
supposed to protect the constitutional rights of both the victims and the
defendants in a case. But where were their protections?
The U.S. Supreme Court has ruled that juveniles and people with
intellectual disabilities should not be executed due to their “diminished
culpability.” The same could - and should - be said of people with severe
mental illnesses, as their impairments may make them undeserving of the
death penalty. However, people with severe mental illnesses still face
capital punishment because their particular condition or symptoms do not
fit the narrowly defined insanity defense definition.
The deck is stacked against these people. Their conditions affect many
aspects of the legal process, impacting their appearance in court, the jury’s
perception of ticks or socially awkward/inappropriate interactions, the
defendant’s presentation of facts, and even their own admission of guilt
(innocent or not). Indeed, studies have shown that defendants with severe
mental illness are more likely to give a false confession.
New legislation introduced in the General Assembly this year could protect
vulnerable defendants that fall through these loopholes. This legislation is
endorsed by most major Virginia mental health groups. Under the proposed
exclusion, a defendant with a severe mental illness could still be
prosecuted, convicted and sentenced to life in prison without parole if found
guilty. But that defendant would not be eligible for the ultimate punishment,
the death penalty.
As a faith leader, I am compelled to advocate for compassionate and fair
laws such as this exemption that has been proposed to exclude people with
severe mental illness from capital punishment.
Under current laws, the death penalty is supposed to be reserved for the
most blameworthy individuals who commit the worst crimes. People with a
severe mental illness are distinctly different from this group. They lack the
capacity to fully understand reality or consequences, control their behavior,
and are most unlikely to be deterred by threats of the death penalty. Lastly,
they do not have the privilege of choosing their condition.
We cannot be a country that condemns the weakest, and sometimes
innocent, among us to death. We cannot be a commonwealth that remains
staid when given the chance to lead.
The book of Peter reminds us to have, “sympathy, brother love, a tender
heart and a humble mind.” The book of Deuteronomy asks us to give as we
are able. The Virginia’s General Assembly is called to act now and with
compassion. This year, let’s continue to encourage them to answer that call.