North American Working Group on Violence Against Indigenous Women and Girls Framing Paper, 2016 September 2

1 Office on Violence Against Women
North American Working Group on Violence 
Against Indigenous Women and Girls 
Framing Paper 
September 2015
September 2016
BACKGROUND 
On June 29, 2016, President Obama traveled to Ottawa for the North American Leaders Summit 
(NALS) to meet with the President of Mexico and the Canadian Prime Minister to discuss a 
variety of topics impacting our shared borders. Among the many commitments announced at the 
NALS was a tri-lateral commitment to address the high levels of violence against indigenous 
women and girls that exists across North America. This commitment appears in the White House 
Fact Sheet on Key Deliverables for the 2016 North American Leaders’ Summit under the 
“security and defense” pillar. All three countries agreed that the high levels of violence endured 
by indigenous women and girls across the region warrants increased attention and coordination, 
resulting in the formation of the new North American Working Group on Violence Against 
Indigenous Women and Girls (the Working Group), which will meet for the first time in October 
in Washington, D.C. 
Across Canada, the United States, and Mexico, indigenous women and girls face alarmingly high 
levels of violence and often lack access to justice, health care, and social services.  A new report 
from the United States Department of Justice (DOJ), National Institute of Justice (NIJ), which 
was released in May 2016, found that more than 84% of Alaska Native and American Indian 
women had experienced some form of violence in their lifetimes. According to the researchers, 
of those women, 66% experienced psychological violence, 56% experienced sexual violence, 
55% experienced physical violence from an intimate partner, and 49% experienced stalking. 
Despite the grave need for support and protection from this violence, 38% of Alaska Native and 
American Indian female victims were unable to access legal, medical, and other services. The 
report also found that, among the women who reported experiencing violence in their lifetimes, 
97% of victims experienced violence by a perpetrator who was not American Indian or Alaska 
Native. 
These disturbing statistics underscore the importance of the Special Domestic Violence Criminal 
Jurisdiction (SDVCJ) provisions in the 2013 Reauthorization of the Violence Against Women 
Act (VAWA), which recognized tribes' inherent power to exercise special criminal jurisdiction 
over non-Indian offenders who commit domestic violence, dating violence, or violate certain 
protection orders. As the data in the NIJ study show, interracial violence is unacceptably 
common in Indian Country and this provision is needed to hold non-tribal offenders accountable 
for their crimes.  
Regional coordination on the challenges presented by the incidence of this violence across 
borders comes at a pivotal time. According to reports by the Royal Canadian Mounted Police, 
indigenous women and girls face greater risks of violence and homicide.  In recognition of this 
situation, the Trudeau government, in partnership with First Nations advocates, has officially 
launched a National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls. Likewise, 
in Mexico, lethal violence against indigenous women and girls is a serious problem. Across Latin 
America, including in Mexico, it is estimated that indigenous women and girls are 
 
 
 
North American Working Group on Violence  
Against Indigenous Women and Girls  
Framing Paper 
 
 
 
 
 
2 
 
September 2015 
disproportionately the victims of feminicidios (gender-motivated killings) according to a report 
prepared by the United Nations Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues.  
 
Given the widespread impact of this violence, the governments of Mexico, Canada, and the 
United States have resolved to work together as part of the Working Group, with the goals of: 
 
 Exchanging knowledge of comprehensive policies, programs and best practices to 
prevent and respond to violence against indigenous women and girls through increased 
access to justice and health services, with a human rights and multicultural approach; 
 Enhancing cooperation to address violent crimes against indigenous women and girls, 
including human trafficking, residing on or off their tribal, First Nations, and indigenous 
lands and across our borders; 
 Improving the response of our justice, health, education, and child welfare systems to 
violence against indigenous women and girls; and 
 Strengthening the capacity of our health systems to provide culturally-responsive victim 
services. 
The 2015 Tribal Consultation Report, recently published by the U.S Department of Justice’s 
Office on Violence Against Women (OVW), demonstrates that there are a number of challenges 
posed by the U.S.-Mexico and U.S.-Canada borders. In preparation for the first Working Group 
meeting in October, the Department has developed this framing paper and is seeking input from 
tribal leaders through two upcoming listening sessions. These listening sessions will supplement 
the information received on an annual basis through OVW’s Tribal Consultation.  
 
The schedule for the listening sessions is below: 
 
1) Conference Call with Tribal Leaders, 3:00 p.m. Eastern Time, September 16, 2016 
2) In-person with Tribal Leaders, 9:30 a.m. – 11:30 a.m. Eastern Time, September 28, 2016 
Following the first Working Group meeting in October, the Department will share outcomes of 
the meeting, as well as solicit tribal input regarding subsequent directions for the Working 
Group, at its Eleventh Annual Government-to-Government Tribal Consultation on Violence 
Against Women to be held on December 6, 2016 on the reservation of the Agua Caliente Band of 
Cahuilla Indians in Palm Springs, California.  Information on registering for this annual tribal 
consultation on violence against women issues can be found at http://ovwconsultation.org/. 
 
The Department welcomes comments on the issues presented here, as well as on any other issues 
regarding violence against indigenous women and girls and the work of the Working Group. 
 
 
QUESTIONS: 
North American Working Group on Violence 
Against Indigenous Women and Girls 
Framing Paper 
3 
September 2015
1. (As applicable) What types of challenges in responding to violence against wome n 
and girls in your community are presented by shared borders with Canada/Mexico?
For example, do shared borders make it difficult to prevent or respond t o 
trafficking of indigenous women and girls or hinder the enforcement of protec tion
 
orders?
2. (As applicable) What type of interactions have your tribal law enforcement and
victim services programs had with law enforcement and victim services programs in
Canada/Mexico, with regard to domestic violence, sexual assault, stalking, or human
trafficking?
3. Canada has recently officially launched a National Inquiry into Murdered and
Missing Indigenous Women and Girls. What has been the experience of your tribe
with missing Native women and girls and domestic violence homicides, sexual
assault, or trafficking?
4.
In preparing to exchange information with the governments of Canada and Mexico
regarding  best practices to prevent and respond to violence against indigenous
women and girls, what policies, programs and practices do you believe should be
highlighted or addressed? Additionally, what barriers, challenges and ongoing
needs do you think should be highlighted, as well as recommendations to address
those needs?