11/2/2016 The Coarseness of Our Times | National Catholic Reporter
NCR S
The Coarseness of Our Times
by Michael Sean Winters | May. 2, 2014
It is difficult to imagine how American politics could become any more coarse. Yet, the evidence seems overwhelming: Just as sportsmen and women must
always strive to jump higher or run faster, the tendency in our politics to push the envelope, no matter how regressive the contents of the envelope, seems
inexorable.
Lam not one of those perennial nostalgia mongers, who imagine there was once a golden age of American politics in which thoughtful men and women
debated issues of public import with seriousness and determination without ever getting their hands dirty in the rough and tumble of electoral politics:
‘The 1800 presidential contest between incumbent President John Adams and Thomas Jefferson remains one of the nastiest campaigns in U.S. history, the
things said about Abraham Lincoln were no gentler than the things said about President Obama, and, more recently, conservative cranks floated dozens of
conspiracy theories about the Clintons and liberal cranks returned the favor during the Bush presidency.
Still, just as war used to be something that soldiers did on a battlefield, until the advent of “strategic bombing” when whole cities were targeted
indiscriminately, in today’s politics the nastiness is not confined to accusations hurled against the protagonists, but is spilling out into the equivalent of
strategic bombing.
‘The Latest instance comes from the Republican Senate primary in South Dakota. Dr. Annette Bosworth, trailing in the polls, needed to fire up the base and
‘what better way than to speak their language. And so, she took to Facebook with the kind of offensive comment that is par for the course on certain Fox
‘News programs and conservative talk radio. Under the heading “Taday’s Lesson in Irony" Bosworth wrote:
The food stamp program is administered by the U.S. Department of Agriculture, They proudly report that they distribute free meals and food stamps to over 46
rillion people on an annual basis.
‘Meanwhile, the National Park Service, run by the U.S. Department of the Interior, asks us ‘please do not feed the animals.’ Their
Lisuror stated reason for this policy being that .. the animals will grow dependent on the handouts, and then they will never learn to take
care of themselves. This concludes today’s lesson. Any questions?
SPIRIT OF
‘The real “lesson in irony” here is, of course, that Bosworth does not seem to grasp how offensive her comparison of food stamp
recipients with wild animals is, The lack of human sympathy with those who struggle to feed their families is shocking. And,
‘unsurprisingly, there seems tobe no awareness that many millions of people who get food stamps are working families whose
incomes are insuficent to pay for groceries. Her Facebook posting is the political equivalent of Wal-Mart's holiday food drive for
its employees, a window into the grea issue of our time ~ income inequality ~ dressed up to look like something else. At least
and commentary are Wal-Mart’ intention was to help people. Dr. Bosworth's intention was to demean.
possible because of
support from people a different example of coarseness comes from Georgia where the legislature passed a “guns everywhere” bill that seems about as
like you. Givetoday. yecessary asa rerun of that horrible show about the Kardashians. Kudos to Archbishop Wilton Gregory and other faith leaders
for publicly resisting the effort to get more guns into Peach State churches, Bt, why was this bill passed, other than thatthe NRA.
wanted to make a point? Coarseness comes in may shapes and sizes, not just vile, demeaning comments about the poor. There isa coarseness in the
enactment ofa policy that is unnecessary and dangerous, simply because the extremists inthe NRA want it.
NCR's award:
‘winning reporting
‘And, what to make of the Rev. R. Albert Mohler, President of the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary, not only defending the death penalty but
chastising those of us who oppose the death penalty for being the real culprits in what he perceives isa loss of moral sensibility in our culture. Mohler,
writing at CNN, states:
There is also the larger cultural context. We must recognize that our cultural loss of confidence in human dignity and the secularizing of human identity has
‘made murder a less heinous crime in the minds of many Americans.
Most would not admit this lower moral evaluation of murder, but our legal system is evidence that this s certainty true.
We also face a frontal assault upon the death penalty that is driven by legal activists and others determined to bring legal execution to an end in America.
Controversy over an execution this week in Oklahoma will bring even more attention to this cause, but most Americans will be completely unaware that this
tragedy was caused by the inability of prison authorities to gain access to drugs for lethal injection that would have prevented those complications.
Opponents of the death penalty have, by their legal and political action, accomplished what might seem at first to be impossible ~ they now demand action to
correct a situation that they largely created.
Their intention is to make the death penalty so horrifying in the public mind that support for executions would disappear. They have attacked every form of
execution as “cruel and unusual punishment,” even though the Constitution itself authorizes the death penalty.
eis a testament to moral insanity that they have successfully diverted attention from a murderer's heinous crimes and instead put the death penalty on trial
“Moral insanity"? Yes, our judicial system looks at the heinous crimes perpetrated and metes out an appropriate penalty. But, the opposition many of us
have to the death penalty is precisely the fact that we are the moral agents who perform the execution. The botched execution of Clayton Lockett in
(Oklahoma was carried out on behalf of the people of Oklahoma, Timothy McVeigh was executed in all our names. I did not know Mr, McVeigh and I would
have declined to be complicit in his bombing of the federal building in Oklahoma City because I have not lost my “confidence in human dignity” and have
not secularized my understanding of human identity. And itis for this exact same reason that | would have declined to be complicit in his execution. Rev.
‘Mohler likes to quote the Bible, but perhaps he should focus a little more on the central drama of the Gospels, the execution of Jesus Christ. Either way, why
ishhe hurling epithets at opponents of capital punishment when it was not us who botched the execution? Because that is how the game is played now.
‘At the end of the day, Ido not know what I find more troubling, the coarse demeaning of the poor, the craven pandering to the NRA, or the deeply
‘troubling attack on death penalty opponents coming from a seminary president who could do with a few courses in Moral Theology 101. Offensive is bad,
soiis stupid, and so is myopic. For all of our technological advances, itis not easy to make the case that humankind’s capacity for understanding, real
understanding, about the things that matter and not just the matter of things, is on the uptick. A gloomy start to a beautiful day, but there itis,
https:/|www.ncronline.org/blogs/distinctly-catholic/coarseness-our-times
11/2/2016 The Coarseness of Our Times | National Catholic Reporter
show
AL ALERTS
svi ne epti eil ngchng yt etna ayn ttn haa
es
Pvc bv GY Sefesubscxbe
INTHIS
OCTOBER 2!-NOVEMBER 3, 2016
Refomation's aniversary brings commemeraton, considerations
Picks further diversity Collegeof Cardinals
Etosa: re-issue obsession impenis ceciity
Special Section [Print Ory: SAINTS
SUBSCRIBE!
LATEST POSTS >
Hillary Clinton want tobe president, not your mother
yeni Mimo Gaseo
Links for 1/01/16
ty Mitel Som Wakes sinc Cato
[Article 9, Catholics, and ominous rend in apanese polis
byDvidDeCome NCRTodey
Morning Briefing
‘ey Sephani Yale NOR To
Ecumenism our time: fruit the Counc
IyMiael Som Wks Ona Cato
Homeless mather lets the cruel knife drop
by Inde Angin Soul See
Francis the comie strip
tyPat Marin The rand
For Ursuline ster, everyday is World Food Day
‘ny Sharon Aterroie Fe Cato
‘The Reformation’ polities and ous
Links for 10/31/16
IyMiiuelSom Winks Obtecy
More posts»
National Cathli + publications: NCRonline.org | CelebrationPublications.org | GlobalSistersReportorg
jpyright © The National Catholic Reporter Publishing Con 11S E. Armour Rv. iy, MO 64111
https:/|www.ncronline.org/blogs/distinctly-catholic/coarseness-our-times
In Copyright - Educational Use Permitted