September }9, 1983
SENATE MEETING
ATTEND
---L------------------------
September 19, 1983
.
SENATE ~1EETING
A T T E N D
·--------- ---------~
UNIVERSITY SENATE
STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORK AT ALBANY
1400 Washington Avenue
Albany, New York 12222
UNIVERSITY SENATE MEETING
Monday, September 19, 1983
3:30p.m. - Campus Center Ballroom
A G E N D A
1.
Approval of Minutes of 4/25/83, 5/2/83, and 5/9/83.
2.
President's Report
3.
Chair's Report
4.
Council and Committee Reports
5.
New Business:
5.1 Bill No. 8384-01 - Change in Membership of Student
Affairs Council (Executive Committee)
5.2 Bill No. 8384-02 - Proposed Student Conduct Model (Task
Force on Student Ethics and Cheating)
STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORK AT ALBANY
1400 Washington Avenue
UNIVERSITY SENATE
Albany, New York 12222
UNIVEHSI'rY SENATE
MINUTES
September 19, 1983
ABSENT:
H.P. Krosby, J. Shumaker, H. E,arrell, M. Deasy, A. Loesch, H. Bakhru,
D. Reeb, T. Dandridge, M. Salisch, R. Hardt, o. Nikoloff, N. Armlin,
A. Cali, R. Halsey, N. Shapiro
The meeting was called to order at 3:30 p.m. in the Campus Center Ballroom
by the Chair, Ronald A. Bosco.
The Chair reminded everyone that all future Senate meetings will be held
in the Campus Center Assembly Hall.
He asked that any expected sabbatical or
other leaves be reported to either the Chair or Senate Secretary. The first
Faculty Forum was scheduled for Septerrber 28 for all Faculty Senators.
Prof. Bosco welcomed Alan Iselin, Chair of the University Council.
1. Approval of Minutes
The minutes of 4/25/83, 5/2/83, and 5/9/83 were approved as submitted.
2.
President's Report
President O'Leary welcomed everyone and Alan Iselin, in particular, to the
first Senate meeting of the academic year.
Mr. O'Leary reminded everyone
that the Senate was the main governance body of the University which he
turns to.
'l'he President reported on a number of items worked on over the sunuuer.
He
spoke briefly on the budget and stated that it was holding relatively
firm. A chart indicating the University's budget situation with respect
to positions was distributed.
He reviewed the chart giving an explanation
of the figures.
President O'Leary turned attention to the issue of the bus service. The
University was faced with three alternatives: to cut the service,
reallocate funds, or impose a bus fee.
He reported that there had been
dissent on the issue during the summer as to what should be done. It was
decided to delay the i1nposition of a bus fee until 12/l/83 and create a
task force which could look into alternatives in the interim, and after
deliberation, report to EPC, which would in turn, make a reco1mnendation to
the President.
He stated that this process would be the appropriate use
of the governance structure.
University Senate Minutes
September 19, 1983
Page 2
4.
Chair's Report
Prof. Bosco reported on the following items:
4.1 The Task Force on Student Ethics and Cheating met over the sumner.
The bill on the Proposed Student Conduct ~bdel evolved from the Task
Force.
4.2 UAC was charged to review the current drop/add policy on the campus.
4.3 CAFE was charged to join with the President and the Senate Chair to
establish a uniform and consistent policy regarding_fr~e9Qm of_
expression at the University.
4.4 A committee was established to review the by-laws and to provide him
and the Executive Comnittee with an interpretation of sections that
stipulate the powers of the Executive Cotnmittee, in particular to act
on behalf of the Senate.
The committee is to provide recomnendation
on the implementation of this.
5.
Council Reports
5.1 Executive Co1nmittee- The Chair reported that the Resolution on the
Bus Service was discussed at the Executive Comnittee meeting.
He
explained the course of action that took place and that although he
felt it should be referred to EPC, because of the issue of resource
reallocation, the Executive Committee overruled him and the
resolution was sent to the Senate for discussion.
He felt the
resolution should be referred to EPC and the Task Force.
R. Schaffer, who proposed the resolution, then spoke on the
resolution particularly with regard to the time factor and the issue
of long-range planning.
V.P. Hartigan spoke briefly on the issue.
He stated that the Task Force had met and could cane to a close by
Novermber 1.
C. LaSusa moved that the issue be moved up on the
agenda as an action item under new business. It was seconded. A
hand voted was taken and the motion was defeated.
There was further
discussion and dissent on the issues.
The Chair stated that if the
resolution clearly had been sent to the Senate as an action item it
would have been placed on the agenda as a bill for action.
Council Membership Changes - H. Cannon moved approval of the
changes.
It was seconded, voted on, and approved.
5.2 EPC -F. Frank reported that the Council would be holding its first
meeting on Septanber 23.
5.3 UAC - C. LaSusa reported that UAC had met on September 16.
The
Council approved revision in the composition of the council
membership.
University Senate Minutes
September 19, 1983
Page 3
5.4 GAG - This Council had nothing to report.
5.5 SAC - L. Kerr announced that the council would be holding its first
meeting in two weeks.
5.6 Research - Tbere was no report from this Council.
5.7 UCC- R. Chaves announced that the Council would be meeting in two
weeks.
5.8 CAFE - W. Simmons reported that the council had not yet met.
5.9 CPCA- This Council had no report.
5.10 Library -This Council had no report.
6. Bill :No. 8384-01 - Change in Membership of Student Affairs Council - 1be
bill would change the membership of the Council by adding the Vice
President for Student Affairs. It was voted on and approved.
7.
Bill No. 8384-02 - Proposed Student Conduct Model - Pat Rogers, who
chaired the Task Force, and Prof. Bosco gave some background information
on the origin of the bill. P. Rogers explained the mechanism of the
proposed model.
The Task Force had also submitted, for information in the
packet, a memo with recommenations from the Task Force which was sent to
the President and other members of administration and a policy statement
on cheating and student ethics.
F. Frank moved to amend the bill by stating "that this be implemented in
the Fall of 1983 for a period of two academic years and be reviewed by the
Senate in the Spring of 1985." The motion was seconded, voted on and
approved.
A discussion ensued.
H. Cannon moved the previous question to
close discussion.
It was seconded and carried.
The bill was then voted
on and approved.
'Ihe meeting was adjounred at 5:10p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
~\-~~
Crystal J. Hutchins
Recorder
, I
UNIVERSITY SENATE
STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORK AT ALBANY
1983-1984 Membership
Ronald A. Bosco, Chair
EX OFFICIO SENATORS
Vincent O'Leary, President of State
University of New York at Albany
Lewis Welch, Vice President for
University Affairs
Judith Rama1ey, Vice President for
Academic Affairs
Joseph Nitecki, Director of
University Libraries
John rmrtigan, Vice President for
Finance and Business
H. Peter Krosby, Past Chair
1982-1983 University Senate
-
-
-
Frank Pogue, Vice President for
Student Affairs
Harold L. Cannon, SUNY Senator (1985)
(Alternate: Robert Gibson)
John Shumaker, Acting Vice President for
Research and Educational Development
Anne Roberts, SUNY Senator (1986)
(Alternate: Frank Carrino)
ELECTED SENATORS
Elected: At Large
Robert Gibson (1984)
CUE
Tl1omas MacGregor (1984)
Mathematics
Patricia Rogers (1984)
PEAR
Ivan Steen (1984)
History
Jeffrey Berman (1985)
English
Dorothy Christiansen (1985)
University Library
Gloria DeSole (1985)
Affirmative Action
Richard Farrell (1985)
Graduate Studies
Elected: Humanities and Fine Arts
Ronald Bosco (1984)
English
Ulrich Mache (1984)
German
Augustine Zitelli (1984)
Hispanic & Italian
Jerome Hanley (1985)
Theatre
Sophie Lubensky (1985)
Slavic
Georges Santoni (1985)
French
Kendall Birr (1986)
History
Michele Deasy (1986)
Continuing Studies
Francine Frank (1986)
Linguistics
Wendell Lorang (1986)
Institutional Research
Sylvia Barnard (1986)
Classics
Mojmir Frinta (1986)
Art
George Hastings (1986)
English
-2-
Elected: Science and Mathematics
William Closson (1984)
Chemistry
Nelson Cue (1984)
Physics
Arthur Loesch (1984)
Atmospheric Science
Hassaram Bakhru (1985)
Physics
Eric Block (1985)
Chemistry
Samuel McGee Russell (1985)
Biology
Elected: Social and Behavioral Sciences
Richard Alba (1984)
Sociology
William Simmons (1984)
Psychology
Dean Taylor (1984)
Economics
Elected:
Business
John Levato (1984)
Thomas Dandridge (1985)
Paul Leonard (1986)
Elected: Education
Fred Dembowski (1985)
Educ. Administration
Oliver Nikoloff (1985)
Educ. Psy. & Statistics
Elected:
GSPA
Martin Edelman (1984)
Abdo Baaklini (1985)
Elected: Libraries
Stephen Watkins (1984)
Roger Gifford (1985)
Kay Shaffer (1986)
John Logan (1985)
Sociology
Robert Hoffman (1986)
History
------- (1986)
Elected:
Cont. Studies
Marc Salisch (1984)
Nelson Armlin (1986)
CASDA
Theodore Bayer (1986)
Educ. Psy. & Statistics
Elected: Library Science
Joseph Morehead (1985)
John Dellano (1986)
Geology
James Gilliam (1986)
Biology
William Hammond (1986)
Mathematics
William Lanford (1986)
Physics
Donald Reeb (1986)
Economics
Chris Smith (1986)
Geography
Elected: Criminal Justice
Robert Hardt (1985)
Alfred Cali (1986)
Educational Administration
Elected: Social Welfare
Burton Gummer (1984)
.,.·j'<>•
APPOINTED SENA'IDRS
Neil Brown
Harry Hamil ton
Edward Turner
Student Affairs
Atmospheric Science
Mathematics
Ronald Farrell
sung Bok Kim
Richard Wilkinson
Criminal Justice
History
Anthropology
Richard Halsey
John Pipkin
Library & Information
Geography
Science
ELECTED UNDERGRADUATES
-
-
-
-
Todd Benton
Steve Gawley
Paul Neuhedel
Peter Blau
Douglas Kahan
Sal Perednia
Robert Chaves
Greg Kearns
Robin LeMoiner
Craig Doran
~tl'l'l·
Jeffrey Schnapper
Eric Dorf
Lisa Kerr
Neil Shapiro
Diane Edbil
Richard Lapidus
Tammy Swan
Robert Farley
Cathy LaSusa
Alan Weiner
Mitch Feig
Mike Levine
Kendall Birr, Library Council
UNIVERSITY SENATE
Council Chairs
\ C\ O"t '"' ~"l'- \,\
~~~
Robert Chaves, University Comnunity Council
William Closson, Council on Promotions and Continuing Appts.
Thomas Dandridge, Research Council
Francine Frank, Educational Policy Council
Lisa Kerr, Student Affairs Council
Cathy LaSusa, Undergraduate Academic Council
Williwn Simmons, Council on Academic Freedom and Ethics
Ivan Steen, Graduate Academic Council
7-8687
455-6991
7-8505
7-8506
7-8l~06
7-8087
7-7945
7-8482
7-8687
REPORTS TO THE SE~TE
September 19, 1983
FROM:
The Executive Committee
University Senate
FOR INFORMATION:
The attached Resolution on Bus Service (Richard Schaffer)
FOR ACTION:
The Senate Executive Committee moves approval of the following Council
membership appointments:
Educational PoliGy Council
Teaching Faculty: Donald Reeb, Economics
Undergraduate Academic Council
Teaching Faculty:
Thomas MacGregor, Mathematics
University Community Council
Service Staff: Joseph Fox, Plant
Council on Academic Freedom and Ethics
Non-Teaching Faculty: Nelson Armlin, CASDA
Library Council
Teaching Faculty: Martin Edelman, GSPA
Arnold Foster, Sociology
Mojmir Frinta, Art
Richard Wilkinson, Anthropology
Graduate Students: Susan Safford
FROM:
Patricia Rogers, Chair
Task Force on Cheating and Student Ethics
FOR ACTION:
1.
Proposed Student Conduct ~~del to accommodate cases of
academic dishonesty.
!.:l':ecu::.ve Cot:Qi:te:e: c: :he t:niversit:y Senate
State University of New 'YorlG at Albany
September 7, 1983
~esolution offered by Richard Schaffer
The bus service is an essential par: of t;he operations of the Albany campus and (
-... ~:-.ereas:
i\nereas:
~-;,"lereas:
The bus service was badly affected by the re<::ent cutbacks in the SU~"'t budget,
causing a down grading of an already overburdened servtlce and
The University administration has eleeted t:c; imposa a ''sp~c:tal se:tV:Lce a.harge"
for all students except those who live om. Alumni Quad., Wellington Hotei or
those who are enrolled in an academically credited co't!Ununity service or intern-
ship program. · Those needing to attend the downtown campus for l,lniversity
activities are also exempt.
And
.
. .
~· .. .
This fee -w~ll result in a $10 per semester ot 10·¢ per ride serv±ce charge ,
which includes a cost of $11,000 for a:dministrative 6verl\,ead and
The SUNY Board of Trustees has gone on the r·ecord as being opposed to any fee
charges for the 198.3-84 academic year s.nd'
Once a fee is instituted it is likely to :be increased l:!.nd not likely to be
removed even if the situation warrants its removal and
Once one fee is implemented to replac:e state operatdoms funding others similar
to it are likely to follow and
.
i
Fees are not covered by any type of tulttion. assd.stanc:.e ..
result in hardship for students on if'i:K:ed in:comes such as
Educational Opportunities :Program and'
'l'h,ir· le\71irtg will
thote in the
;,-~e:-eas:
The Student Association, thus the entire student body~ was omitted from the
crucial planning stages of this fee and :
..
:,-nereas:
It has been a University tradition, as well as a SUN":l wide philosophy, to
include students in the governance process and
:...-nereas:
The institution of the fee ~ill. already t.a:x overburdened student support
services such as the library~ registrar
1 s offi.c.e, Student Attivit:Les anci
Residential Life anci
Whereas:
This will affect the quality of life for.the SUNY Albany campus and
i·tnereas:
The University administration, in consultation with Student Association, has
ordered a November l, 1983 impleme.ntati.ot(l, date and 'W:illl convene a special task
force to study alternate.methods of transportation: and funding.
(
5e it herebv resolved that the Executive Committee of the University Senat!e o,£ the State
l.:niversi ty ~f New York at Albany support the appoin.t:ment of a special task force, comprised
c: Universi:y Administration, faculty and studtan.Ur tb study a1ternate methods of
~~~~sportation and funding and
5e it :urther resolved that the bus fee be postponed for the 1983-84 academic year in
::-~er to give the s?ecial task force sufficent: tim~ to study the campus bus system.
(
l""tVV VVU.o,J·•I'I~LVI• r·\~....., '"""-
Albany, New York 12222
State University of New York at Albany
September 13, 1983
MEMORANDUM
TO:
University Senate
FRQ.i:
John Hartigan F fi..t; ..,._
I am writing to provide background information pertaining to the
resolution on the bus service which was presented to the Senate Executive
Committee and forwarded to the Senate.
As you may be aware, a combination of budgetary reductions and early
retirements has led to the loss of 113 positions on this campus in the past 18
months.
This loss is superimposed on approximately 250 positions eliminated
in the five years prior to that. These reductions have affected all areas
student services, library, faculty, physical plant, instructional support, and
administrative support.
We have taken these position reductions each year only after careful study
designed to protect areas of strength in the University, and particularly to
preserve academic, safety, environmental, and programmatic requirements.
As
you know, these decisions have been made in close consultation with the
university-wide Budget Panels, using agreed upon criteria which we have
mutually developed.
The Budget Panel identified the bus service as an area of
concern and suggested a charge to cover a portion of its cost.
It needs to be emphasized that the University bus service was originally
justified as necessary to link the dormitories and academic units uptown and
downtown.
Rides for others have been offered as an optional service.
Nevertheless, I believe that all of us agree that this extra service is a
desirable asset which enhances the attractiveness of this campus and makes it
possible, for example, for many students to live off campus without owning an
automobile.
As the events of 1983 unfolded, (early retirements, turnover, and position
freezes) vacancies developed in the bus service staff as elsewhere on the
campus.
We thoroughly studied the situation, and we found three options
available to us:
University Senate
September 13, 1983
Page 2
a.
Reduce the schedule and have fewer buses on the road. Reduction of
service, however, without a reduction in riders will mean
serious delays, long Unes, and a very unpleasant situation,
particularly in the winter. Another alternative, is stop the extra
service and prohibit persons from riding who are not traveling between
academic units nor living at Alumni Quad or the Wellington. This
seems undesirable for a number of reasons.
b.
Reallocate resources from some other part of the campus.
This might
be an attractive solution if there was slack somewhere on the campus,
but there is not. Past reductions and redeployment of staff have been
· · so widespread across all categories .of employees and services that we
cannot justify removing lines from other critical areas. It has been
suggested that a simple infusion of titemporary service" funds from
elsewhere on the campus would·solve the problem.
I can assure you
that if the Registrar, or the Library, or any other unit loses
temporary service money., they will need full-time replacement lines in
exchange.
c. Find new resources.
The introduction of a modest bus fee for some
categories of riders is an option which has been examined and
supported by Budget Panel recommendations.
It seems the least
(
· objectionable of the many alternatives studied. Albany is the only
(
SUNY campus providing such an extra :;ervice without a fee, a student
tax, or some other form of revenue from students.
The students at
Binghamton and Oneonta, for example,·make substantial contributions to
bus service resources.
SUNY Buffalo provides only a point-to-point
express service among its three campuses.
This Summer we sought and received SUNY approval to introduce a limited
charge.
On August 23, 1983, I indicated in a communication to all students
that beginning this Fall it would be necessary to limit free bus service to
students 1i ving in Allllllli QUadrangle and the;l~ellington Hotel.
Provisions
were also made for students registered for academic credit in approved
internships and community service program assignments.
Persons having
academic business between the two campuses would also ride free. All other
persons would ride at a service charge of $lp.oo a semester for a pass, or 10¢
a ride.
There have been disputes about the consultation process during the
Summer.
It should. be emphasized that the pr9posal results from the
deliberations of Budget Panels composed of faculty, staff, and students.
Moreover, numerous interactions did occur between the administration and
student leaders during the Spring and Summer'.
There was ex:tensi ve
communication, student views on this subject were well articulated and the
final bus fee proposal was influenced by tho,se views.
I believe that a good
faith effort was made to consult students an4 the record of that consultation
is being unfairly distorted. However, charge and counter charge will benefit
no one; we must focus on the substance of th~ issue.
(
,.
University Senate
September 13, 1983
Page 3
To that end, President 0 1Leary has asked me to provide even more time for
review and study and to allow wider participation in this decision. He has
indicated his decision to set up a Task Force consisting of faculty, students,
and staff.
The special Task Force ~ill be asked to review alternatives to the
bus fee and to report to the Resource Advisory Committee of the Educational
Po 1i cy Co unci 1.
Now a word about timing.
The President has asked the Task Force to submit
its recommendations by November 1 in order to allow the month of November for
review by governance and a report to him by the 1st of December.
It is
important to get this settled by December because many decisions are made
during the winter mon~hs. MOst new faculty for Fall 1984 will be recruited in
January and February. Resource decisions for 1984 -s&E- and temporary serv-ice- - -
will be made in February and March.
Graduate student recruitment is also at
its peak in those months, and departments need to know how many assistantships
and fellowships are available to them.
In addition, many students formulate
early housing plans for 1984 and make deposits.
Finally, if circumstances
require that we implement a charge ~ith the opening of the spring semester we
need to inform everyone in timely fashion.
I am prepared to brief the Task Force on the legal, contractual, and
economic dimension of the problem.
I realize that the time is limited, but
the issues are fairly well-focused.
The Task force is organized and will
start its work shortly, I believe the group capable of rendering findings
recommendation by November 1.
The members should be able to consider all
alternatives.
We should not take a~a.y options before they even have a chance
to study them.
If unanticipated problems need further address and the Task
Force or the Educational Policy Council recommend other steps, we can consider
them at the end of November.
i
\.
UNlVERS!~ SENATE
STATE UNIVERSITY OPj N.JliW YORK AT ALBANY
•• J
'
1983-84 Council Membership
·' '
.
CQUNCI:l. ON ~CADEMI:C FREEDOM :AND;Jl'l'KXCS
teaching Faculty:
,,
,/
*John Logan, Sociology- Social and Behavioral Sc:ienees
mi.na ,J:aaroix - UniveNti.t'i .t.Jbraty
*Joseph Morehead -'School of Library and Information Science
*{Jeof'9e6 San.toni. :Jr~n.ch - Jlum.an.i.tlea an.d :J.i.n.e .Artc.
(
*William simmons, Psychology - Social and Behavioral Sciences
·Myron taylor, English - Huma.nlties and Fine Arts
Non-Teaching Faeuity:
I
. ! :
+*1l~teoon. Arm.lli'l. .... CAs:bA
*marc Sali.och - Con:ti.nul.n.g StwJ.i.ec.
*Crai.r; :boran.
·.
!kVi:v~o~qu~ * (2;1 .. {P~tr ~CY"~~ ·.
COUNC:tt.. OW 'tpucAtiONAL POLICY
Ex Officio:
'.::, '-·
Dean' s Coune i 1 Appt. :
· Teaching Faculty:
Vineent O'Leary, President
Judith Ramaley, Vice Pres iden~ for Academic Atfai rs.
~ohn Hartiga.n, Vice President f-or Finanee an<l. 'B,usiness
Frank Pogue, Vice Pres l.dent for St-udent Affairs
John Shumaker,· Acting Vice President for 'Research ·an.d
Educational Development
Lewis Welch 1 Vice President for"~nive-r:sity Affairs
Vi.n.ce Aceto - Schoot of J!i.bNU"i .and. 9nlormation. Si:i.fn.ce
:Jhomao .An.deroon. - School of dlu6in.eac.
· ·
1
Robert :t:>cmovan.. en.9ei.c.h - Jluman.ittea ai&d. :J.i.n.e Artc..
j
:li:FraneiM Frank, Linguistics - Humanities and ~ine Artis
*Wleti.arn Jlammond. T[la.themati.c6 - Science an.d mathifmati.cc. i
:~~:sung Bok Kim, History - Social and behavioral [~eieneeit
.Keith Ratcei.Pf, Ph'i6i.C6 -Science an.d mathema.ti.co
j'
i~
+*Donald Reeb, Ecoq,prnics - Social and Behaviorlil Sehttces
9ameo Riedel, Political Science - {Jra.dua.te School of
Public AIPai.ro ..
:li:Kay Shaffer - Unl:versity Libra:ry
*t;Jioria. :beSote - Affirmative .Action.
:~!:Richard Farrell ~· Graduate Studies
* ~ obert g i.boon - Ctl e
Und.ervJ.rad.ua.te~:
-«J:te.ai'l-Be.t.z.-
::~!:hD~:~g ..
0~ d1f4 r~--ClM<LJ
*Paul Neuhedel
·
*Alan ~iner '
Asterisks indicate sena,tors
___/_
··
Italics indicate firsj:.Lyear appointments
+Appointment contipgent
(
·· .. ,_
(
-2-
GRADUATE ACADEMIC COUNCIL
Ex Officio:
Judith Ramaley, Vice President for Academic Affairs
John Shumaker, Acting Vice President for Research and
Educational Development
Teaching Faculty:
*Abdo &zaktini, Public Adm~tra.tion- graduate School of
Public Alfai.N
*Alfred Cali, educational Admi.nlotra.tion - education
. Ruth ':1raJ ey. - JJa.wt elj .J1brarci
*Robert JJardt -School oP Cri.mi.na! 9u6tice
Aki.ra 9n.omata. Ph'l6i.co - Sctence and mathematico
Michael ~avanagh - School of Business
*9uan Steen, JJir.tory - Social and d3ehavioral Sci.enceo
*Aui-U6tine_Zitet!i., JJ~pan.i.c and 9tati.an Studi.eo ,- JJumani.ti.eo
and. :J.i.ne Art o
· · - - ·--
-
Non-Teaching Faculty:
Sohn. &rtow- education
Undergraduates:
'* Robi.n .t:emoi.n.er
'-..,{) "'
cf'/1 .
/}
~~·
Graduates:
GZ). .1-c:r::<~ -*"l!f2oa&.ead
LIBRARY COUNCIL
Ex Officio:
Teaching Faculty:
Undergraduates:
Graduates:
John Shumaker, Acting Vice President for Research and
Educational Development
Joseph Nitecki, Director of University Libraries
X enneth Able, d3i..oto9'f - Science and mat he matico
*Hassaram Bakhru, Physics - Science and Mathematics
*SWvi.a &mard., ClaAoi.c6 - JJumani.ti.eo and :J.i.ne Arto
*Xendalt 13irr, JJGtory -Social and d3ehavioral Sci.en.ce6
+*Tflarti.n. edetm.an., poei.ti.cat Science - Social and d3ehavi.oral
Sci.enceo
+Arnold Foster, Sociology - Social and Behavioral Sciences
+*Kojmir Frinta, Art - Humanities and Fine Arts
Norman Hoyle - School of Library and Information Science
Max Siporin - School of Social Welfare
+*Richard Wilki.n.!.on., An.thropolo9y -Social and d3ehauioral
Sci.en.ce6
*Sal Peredrti.a
+~Salford
Asterisks indicate senators
Italics indicate first-year appointments
+Appointment contingent
EX Officio:
"J;eaehing Facult)':
COUNCIL•GJI USMJtCH
'
.....
· Ex .of'f.ieio.:
.J·ud:it.h Rce:rna.1.,y,, Vi·ee ~Pre:sident for Ae.ademi·.e .Affa:i<rs
·R·Q.'f 13en.eMcm .• Ph'l~ic6 - :Sc:te.n.ce and ma:them.atic~
~ill'iam ·C1o13son, ·Ch•mht·rJ - :seienee and Matiheme.ttes
1cRone.l·d 1"·4t'it';e11,, S.Qci,o.lo;y - Soci·al and 'Be:b.a:vi:oral ·sclenees
.Robert !;re·tNte~ .:Jren;ch. ... Jlun:r.on.Ctle• ,fJ.Iild :J.in.:e ..Art~>
9ohn f}W'J:fUilt# ,poetticat Sden.ce - t;J~te S.cho.ot .qp
Pubttc .A/Pairo .
*Sopht:e ../!J..Wen.6kll, Slqvtc -.. JJumaniUL#o :Q.Ild :J.in.e .Arto
'*9ohn. Pipkin., geofi'Yiph'f - S<>c:kll ,cw;t B.eluwiofYJI Sc·Len.ce,6
Atu:.-.on 'aosent>la·t;t - 'S.ebool. of .Social We'lfar.e
'*Pe·ter llt®
*'fl.eiJ Shapiro
·.;·
\
John S·bumaker, •. Aeti>ng Vte.e 'President for Res.ea•teh and
td•ucatione.l ~~velopmen1t
Frank l>iSa.n;to. ,Di~ec'tor of :Research
*Rlebard Alba., soei;ol•o,gy ·~ Socta.1 and Beb.avior.al :sdence·s
*rlet6on. CI.W, Ph'f~ic6 .. S.de.n.ce and Ule!tthematic.o
*Thoma1> Ptl.ndrldge -
Sebo~1 ~f ,Busine.J$
*9am.eo !]:Uii.am.,lli.PSo~'l - :Sc~n.ce .QJ'IiJ. 117a:themat:Lc:6
*Geof?e .JJa.t>tin~t>. &·n.c;tit.h ~ JJ.uman.i.tie·t. and :J.in.e .Artt.
*r~obert JJ.offmM, JIC..·tory- S.ocUrl and .d3eM.vlonal Sciencet.
*Oli:ve:r tHk;ollo'ff., :Jt'ducation.al P.s.r.ehology - Education
mW'¥ Seth. Wi.nn.. :1n1n.ck - Jl.ui'TUlll.itie:t. ,cwJ. :J..ine .Anto
'Ro.6~<UVI.e :0
113f'!ien ... Con:tin,:uing. Stud.i.eo
~MAe=Atd~;Hcz- ~~·ri-o/J.fli?.r ~-0-rf..!bU
I'< t.c:hard. .l!apiduo
.
+t'ran·k :P;o,gue, Vi .. ci !Presiden't. fcGr Studen't Af·fai·rs
NeU :B.r·own, Dean .:of Student A·fh.irs
,,
:'MiCke ·Barth - School o:f Business
*'9ohn. ~etcuw. g,eo.lo'ill - Science and mathem4tko
~&trton. G·ummer - School oP .(Yf Socid WBIPwe
CIP'il Xn.ob!au.ch. &n.9ti.t~h - JJu.m.a.n.itiet. and 3in.e .Arto
~tPau1 Leonard - .School .of Busi.neu
Asteri.sks indicate senators
· n.alies l·ndieate fh.·st-yea·r appointme.nt.s
+Appoi·tl:tme:nt eontim~ent
.. ~ '
(
(
(
'I
.
-4-
STUDENT AFFAIRS COUNCIL (Continued)
Non-Teaching Faculty:
Undergraduates:
Graduates:
Vernon Buck - EOP
Richard Collier - CUE
*Richard Oh.eerki.N;- Reg.i.6trar'o Office
.Kath'l Wi..n.cheoter - Con.ti..n.u.i.ng. Stu.d.i.eo
*:blan.el:d.bril
Richard Golubow
*l)au<jlat. .K a.han
* .ci6a .Kerr
Daniel Robb
3oh.an.n.a. Sarra.c co
.J'.o.uren. Walter
UNDERGRADUATE ACADEMIC COUNCIL
Ex Officio:
Teaching Faculty:
Non-Teaching Faculty:
Undergraduates:
Judith Rrumaley, Vice President for Academic Affairs
Harry Hamilton, Dean of Undergraduate Studies
*Jeffrey Berman, English -Humanities and Fine Arts
*Jerome Hanley, Theatre - Humanities and Fine Arts
.Kathleen. .Ken.d.alt, Commu.n.i.catioM -Social an.d. d3ehauioral
Sci.en.ceo
*William Lanford, Physics - Science and Mathematics
+*::lhoma.6 macgreCjor, mathem.atico -Science an.d. mathematlco
aan. mc:t:xm.ald, 7] eacher l:du.cati.on. - l:du.cation
*Samuel McGee Russell, Biology - Science and Mathematics
*Chri.6topher Smi.th, {;eog.ra.ph'l -Social an.d tBeha.viorat Scien.ceo
/Sonn.ie Stei..n.bock, Philoooph'l - Jluman.itieo an.d. :fine Arto
*Dean Taylor, Economics - Social and Behavioral Sciences
*John Levato - School of Business
Asterisks indicate senators
Italics indicate first-year appointments
+Appointment contingent
I .
,i
jl
'
~
t.~wh We:·ldi'•
V'i.e~ Pres•i.dent e·o·t· trn.i.vettdty AU'aha~
No.tbett. Ztdun'•· t>ttte.etor of U·nlversity Auxilh;ty s~n:vices
Jame~. WUUt~~ttuii., tllbectct" of Cmt\ptts seeurri.t.J
*Ohe€it;l.c>rg &.r1er,, t'ducattolfll!ll Pt.'lchoBogv- -· Cducat.liott.
*ICrlc 61:o·ck;,, Chemltstlf'tl - !J'c;l'tmce and rrtathemc:d/itr;·4
*l»rothv.· C'hf<
.. . t6tiM.· · .6tt~ :.. Umv.ert.Et! .l.£bf'(U'ff.
. · ·.
. . .
J!et1Mrd .Ka.6tl:e•., m&tJl>.C ""JIUtnatttftB6· (JJif.(;£ ~ltte ~tt
Albe~ttl Sweetger - tciool dli 8\tl~trie-*:s
ll'
*W'em£en Jt:orotuJ! -· fn&titutianaS' ft'ttiie'rih
lie:hf.t-d: 'Jta&t.Or "'" trinant!:bi. Aids
t
•n·.l/)oef't: i!ho.vS~t.,
li'Robtirt 3atf
.. · :e.Vi
*::Jathiftt Swtvt. '
,
·, .
J(atht; Shoofu,. ~ acur'li.~uJ.:fnt;r\ Clntlif'·
Gwen( WUlc;,\11&hlJ"J - P.etsoi'Ute•l ·
+lts·G(Iph 3ox :.. Pl'tin€ ·
I
,
,,
'
As ter·i sks indicate senetots.
'ItaHes i.ndica.te ffrst.-year a:ppoint:.ment.s
+A:ppoi.ntment eontt.flgen.t..
'
(
f
(.
Bill No. 8384-01
UNIVERSITY SENATE
STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORK AT ALBANY
CHANGE IN MEMBERSHIP OF
THE STUDENT AFFAIRS COUNCIL
SUBMITTED BY:
Executive Committee
September 7, 1983
IT IS HEREBY PROPOSED:
1.
That the membership of the Student Affairs Council be
changed to include the Vice President for Student
Affairs as an Ex Officio member.
2.
That this become effective immediately.
Bill No. 8384-02
UNIVERSITY SENATE
STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORK AT ALBANY
PROPOSED STUDENT CONDUCT MODEL
PROPOSED BY:
The Task Force on Student Ethics and Cheating
September 19, 1983
IT IS HEREBY PROPOSED:
I.
That the attached recommendation from the Task Force on
Student Ethics and Cheating be approved by the
University Senate for implementation.
II.~- That this be implemented in the Fall of 1983 for a
period of two academic years and be reviewed by the
Senate in the Spring of 1985.
ATTACHMENT
·\·:·:·:·:·::··:·
TO:
FRCM:
SUBJECT:
STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORK AT ALBANY
1400 Washington Avenue
Albany, New York 12222
August 1, 1983
The University Senate
Task Force on Cheating and Student Ethics
Patricia Rogers, Chair
Proposed Student Conduct Model to accommodate cases of
academic dishonesty (1983-85)
There is demonstrated concern on the campus that cases alleging academic
dishonesty on the part of students be adjudicated fairly and under the purview
of a majority of teaching faculty and the appropriate Senate structure.
It is proposed that the Comnittee on Student Conduct be restructured as
follows:
Mernbershi~ of the Committee on Student Conduct for 1983-84 will consist of ten
members of the teaching faculty, six students, and three members of the
non-teaching faculty.
The appointments to the Committee on Student Conduct
will be made jointly by the Chair of the University Senate Executive
Committee, the Vice President for Academic Affairs, and the Vice President for
Student Affairs.
Each Vice President or her/his designee will serve as ex
officio/consultative member of the Committee on Student Conduct.
TWo memoers
of the teaching faculty will be named as Chair and Vice Chair of the Committee
on Student Conduct.
(The Chair and Vice Chair need not be members of the
Student Affairs Council, though they will periodically report to that-Council
within the reporting procedure outlined below.)
·
The Office of the Vice President for Student Affairs will administer the
student conduct system which deals with the judicial/disciplinary process
on the campus and shall notify the Dean of the appropriate college and
the chair of the appropriate department that a case has been initiated.
This includes reviewing allegations, developing 'logging' and follow-up
systems, establishing dates and times for hearings, assigning cases to
appropriate bearing bodies or officers, notifying those involved of
bearings, training those who serve as chairs and/or members of· judicial
bodies, receiving recommendations following hearings, notifyin~ those
involved of outcomes, developing periodic reports, dealing wit appeals,
advising and consulting with faculty and staff, and providing for
periodic system review and revision.
In dealing with allegations of academic dishonesty, the Office of the
Vice President for Student Affairs will have the responsibility to draw
(
l
(
'
r .
; .;:.
I
from the membership of the Committee on Student Conduct five members of
the faculty, of whom at least four will be teaching faculty, and two
students. This body will be assigned responsibility for hearing that
case of academic dishonesty.
The group will be chaired by either the
Chair or Vice Chair (previously named) of the Committee on Student
Conduct.
Appeals stemming from cases of academic dishonesty will be
adjudicated by a sub-committee of the Student Affairs Council which will
consist of three (3) members of the teaching faculty, one (1) student,
and one (1) member of the non-teaching faculty, all drawn from the
Student Affairs Council.
Appointments to the Appeals Committee will be
made jointly by the Chair of the Senate Executive Committee, the Chair of
the Student Affairs Council, the Vice President for Academic Affairs, and
Vice President for Student Affairs.
A member of the teaching faculty
will be named Chair of the Appeals Committee.
In dealing with cases which do not involve allegations of academic
dishonesty, the Office of the Vice President for Student Affairs will
designate a heat'ing gr0up d-rawn from the-membership of the Coomittee on-
Student Conduct consisting of three teaching faculty, 1 member of the
non-teaching faculty, and four students.
The Chair or Vice Chair will
serve as convenor and chair.
Appeals stemming from cases which do not
involve allegations of academic dishonesty will be adjudicated by the
Student Affairs Council.
All members of the Committee on Student Conduct and appeal bodies will be
trained early in the Fall semester by the staff of the Office of the Vice
President for Student Affairs.
Due to the number of cases which
sometimes arise at the same time, the configuration described above makes
it possible for two hearing groups to be convened at the same time.
This
kind of "jury pool" guards against quorum difficulties and provides for
the involvement of larger numbers of faculty in impacting the campus
environment.
The Director of Judicial Affairs shall prepare monthly reports for the
Executive Committee of the University Senate, the Student Affairs
Council, the Vice President for Academic Affairs, and the Vice President
for Student Affairs.
The Chair of the .Committee on Student Conduct shall
develop and submit an independent report to those named above and, in
addition, shall provide a periodic report on student conduct to the
University faculty.
The Vice President for Student Affairs is charged
with the responsibility for providing the technical and budgetary support
to implement this provision.
It should be noted that recommendations of the Committee on Student
Conduct are implemented by the Office of the Vice President for Student
Affairs. Therefore, all recorrmendations stemming from allegations of
academic dishonesty will be reviewed by the Vice President for Academic
Affairs and the Vice President for Student Affairs (or her or his
designee) prior to implementation.
This proposal requires only approval by the appropriate Senate mechanisms
and the University President in order to be implemented in the Fall, 1983
to be reviewed in Spring 1985 by the Senate Executive Comnittee.
TASK FORCE ON CHEATING AND STUDENT ETHICS
Membership
Administration (ex officio and consultative)
Judith A. Ramaley, Vice President for Academic Affairs
Frank G. Pogue, Associate Vice President for Research and
Educational Development
Neil C. Brown, Dean for Student Affairs
Faculty
Ronald A. Bosco, Department of English
Frank G. Carrino, Hispanic and Italian Studies
Michele Deasy, College of Continuing Studies
Paul A. Leonard, School of Business
Warren E. Roberts, Department of History
Patricia A. Rogers, Department of Physical Education
Susan R. Sherman, School of Social Welfare
Edward S. Thomas, Jr. , Department of Mathematics
Harold R. Story, Department of Physics
Studentc:
Richard Schaffer, President, Student Association
Lauren Walter, Student Affairs Council
Recorder
Crystal J. Hutchins, University Senate Office
(I
(
(
UNIVERSITY SENATE
STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORK AT ALBANY
1983-1984 Meeting Schedule
EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
August 29
October 17
November 21
January 30
March 5
April 9
UNIVERSITY SENATE
September 19
October 31
December 5
February 6
March 19
May 7
1984-1985 Organizational Meetings:
April 23 (Senate)
April 30 (Senate)
Faculty Forums
September 28
November 7
February 29
April 2
UNIVERSITY SENATE
STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORK AT ALBANY
Attendance_Policy
TI1e following policy was approved by the Faculty at its meeting on August 29,
1972:
AJticle II 2 Section 2. 9 - Replacement of Senators
2 , 91 Absentee Senators : .
1he seat of a senator shall be declared vacant in any of the
following cases:
1.
The senator declines to accept his election.
2.
The senator misses four consecutive Senate meetings.
3.
'l11e senator misses over fifty percent of the Senate
meetings in one academic year.
The· Executive Conuni ttee of the Senate shall declare when a
seat is vacant.
In extenuatjng circwnstances the Executive
Committee may declare an exception to the rule.
In both
cases the Executive Committee must report its action to the
Senate for its approval.
1\hen a vacancy is declared the seat shall be filled in one
of the following ways, to be determined by the Committee
on Nominations and Elections:
1 .
Elected Senators
a.
Designation of the available person with the next
highest number of votes in the last previous
election from the constituency involved,
b. If no such person is available, election or
appointment by an appropriate body in the con-
stituency :involved.
2.
Appointed Senators
Selection of a new senator by the President.
Bill No. 197071-01
UNIVERSITY SENATE
STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORK AT ALBANY
Powers of the University Senate
INTRODUCED BY:
Executive Committee
It is hereby proposed that the following be enacted:
I.
That because the powers and responsibilities of the Faculty of State Univer-
- -sity- of -New-York -at-Albany,- al-l of- which;,- with the -exception of- specific- - -
reservations, the Faculty has delegated to the SUNYA Senate, are vaguely
stated as " ••• the development of the educational program of the University
and ••• the conduct of the University's instruction, research and service
programs, subject to the provisions of the New York State Education Law
and the Policies of the Board of Trustees" (Article I, Section 3.1), the
Senate assumes upon itself the obligation to interpret the extent of those
powers and responsibilities.
Unless otherwise specifically directed by
the Faculty, the Senate will construe its charge (Article I, Section 3.2)
in the broadest possible sense.
II. That the Senate assumes that any policy, practice, or condition within the
University which in its judgment significantly affects the quality of the
institution's legitimate functioning is a proper concern of the Faculty,
and hence, of the Senate.
III. That the Senate, recognizing that the powers of the Faculty, and hence, its
own, are limited by State Law, by the policies of the Board of Trustees, by
the policies of the SUNYA Council, and by the prerogatives vested in the
President of SUNYA, assumes that the Faculty properly expects to be consulted
regardin,g any proposed change in these policies and regulations, and hence,
the Senate expects to be so consulted.
IV.
That, although the Faculty, and hence, the Senate has no authority, beyond
that of individual citizenship, for the governance of local, county, state,
and national political jurisdictions, some policies and actions of external
governmental bodies significantly affect the quality of the University's
legitimate functioning, and on such matters the Faculty might properly be
expected to register its approval or disapproval, as appropriate.
When,
therefore, and only when, a situation·external to the University is demon-
strated to the Senate's satisfaction to affect significantly the quality
of the University's functioning, the Senate may appropriately express its
approval or disapproval and if circumstances seem so to warrant, will seek
endorsement of its action from the Faculty and the student body, through
Bill No.. 197071-01
.. · 2 '
·'
Paa~ _·
:refe:tendmn.. lt sha.ll be the J.:esponsib.iUty o.f the s:po:n~Q.;~;a of li'.ny reSfolu ...
tion not. calling fat' changes :in the pol:iaies at' pJ.:aaedut'es of: the Univet'sity
itself to demonet:rate, in the text of the -pt'ollose..d resol.ution, the bea:r;ing
of the s.u.bject matte:r upon. the funati,ming of the Uni:verait:y~
v.
That the E:.~eeoutive Committee of the Senate shall not rule on the ap.prap:r·i.a.te ...
ness. of a p:ropos.al brought befot-e itt unless. it i.s. aqting for the; Senate. wheu
that. body is unable to act,
Exae.pt. in that con.ting.encyt the JliJ~:~M~ut.ive
Comm.ittee will e.itheJ: t'e.fer a pl'opos.al t.o an appt'op.da.t.e Coq:ncil or plac.e. it
on the Sena.te' e ag.enda.
A Coqncil may recomm.e.n.d f.ot'· o.l£ agains.t a p:rop.os.al
referred to it, ot' ma.y propalile amen.dments.:.
VI.
That this bill take eff.ect on Oc.tobet' l, 19 70.
MOTiON APPROVED .... SEPTEMBER. 20, 1970
(
(
(
Bill No. 197374-01
UNIVERSITY SENATE
STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORK AT ALBANY
Rules of Order
INTRODUCED BY:
Executive Committee
In aaaor>danae with the FaauZty By-Zaws, Ar>tiaZe II, Seation 5.23, (The Exeautive
Committee shaZZ make Peaommendations for> impr>oving the oper>ation and maintaining
the or>der>Zy pr>oaess of the Senate), the Exeautive Committee pr>oposed adoption of
BiZZ No. 197374-01.
This BitZ is an attempt to eZiminate some of the aonfusion
whiah oaaasionaZty exists, and to identify past pr>aatiae in the mat~~ Qf_co~n~ __ _
- viZ r>epvr>ts;- - Th~- reaommenaati?Yns- aPe acifiiiisiien t-w1- fh -Robe1'ts' -IiUtes of Or>der>,
and otar>ifY seZeated Senate pr>oaedUPes.
I. It is hereby proposed that the Senate adopt the following Rules of Order:
1. If a Senate meeting is still in session at 5 p.m., the parliamentarian
shall so inform the Chairman.
The Chairman will call for an appropriate
motion, which might be one of the following:
1.1 To adjourn (implies no topic on the floor) •
1.2 To table the current topic until the next regular meeting; to
be followed by a motion to adjourn.
1.3 To recess until
(for example, the following Monday at
3 p.m.).
1.4 To continue discussion until (specific time).
1.5 To move the previous question; to be followed by a motion to
adjourn, recess, or continue business until (specific time).
2.
That insofar as possible, speakers on a topic be alternated as to
their pro or con positions, with the exception that no Senator shall be
denied the right to speak at least once during the debate.
3.
That Council reports be handled in the following fashion:
3.1 All Council reports shall be submitted in writing and shall
clearly distinguish between information and recommendations
for action.
3.2 Recommendations for action shall be in the form of a bill
and shall be discussed and acted upon under "new business".
3.3 The informational section of a Council report may be questioned
while the report is on the floor.
If a Senator wishes to
challenge any action taken by the Council, he shall do so by
making an appropriate motion under "new business".
II. That this bill take effect immediately.
MOTION APPROVED- SEPTEMBER 17, 1973
Bill No. 8182-01
UNIVERSITY SEN~TE
STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORK AT ALBANY
Rules of order
INTRODUCED BY:
Executive committee
In aaaordanae with the FaauUy By~CMs, Artia"Le II, S~ation 5. 23 (The
Executive Committee shaU make reaommendations for inrproving the
operation and maintaining the orderty process of the Senate), and
in or>der to imptement the reso"lution approved by the Faau"lty in its
meeting of February 24, 1981, the Exeautive Committee pr.oposes
adoption of the foUowing:
I. Whenever a majority of those Faculty senators present and voting
take a position on an academic matter and it does not carey, and
whenever these Faculty senators constitute more than 40 per cent
of the total Faculty membership of the Senate, the President
shall be notified.
a.
When a vote has been taken on an issue, two or more Faculty
senators may seek to invoke the provisions of this standing
rule.
b.
The chair of the <Senate shall then determine whether or not
the issue is an academic one.
The ruling of the chair can
be appealed only by a Faculty senator and if an appeal is
presented only Faculty senators may vote on the appeal.
c.
When it has been determined that the issue is an academic one,
the chair shall proceed to conduct another vote on the issue.
II. This bill shall take effect immediately.
This bill was approved at the September 14, 1981 Senate Meeting
(
(
CLASSIFICATION OF MOTIONS ACCORDING TO-PRECEDENCE
Second
Amend-
Debat-
Required
Interrupt
Needed
able
able
Vote
Speaker
PRIVILEGED MOTIONS
(In order of precedence)
Fix time of next meeting
yes
yes
3
1/2
no
no
Adjourn
yes
no
no3
1/2
no
Recess
yes
yes
no
1/22
no
Question of privilege
no
no
no
ch.
yes
SUBSIDIARY MOTIONS
(In order of precedence)
Lay on the table
yes
no
no
1/2
no
Previous question
yes
no
no
2'?
I .J
no
Limit debate
_
y~s_-
y~s_
-no ___
--- 2/_3_
_no
-Post:po-rfe To a- certa1n time
yes
yes
yes·
1/2
no
Refer to a committee
yes
yes
yes
1/2
no
Committee of the whole
yes
yes
res
1/2
no
Amend
yes
yes
1/2
no
Postpone indefinitely
yes
no
yes
1/2
no
MAIN MOTIONS
(No order of precedence)
Main motion for general
business
yes
yes
yes
1/2
no
Take from the table
yes
no
yo
1/2
no
Reconsider
yes
no
1/2
yes
Rescind
yes
yes
yes
2/3
no
Make special order of
business
yes
yes
yes
2/3
no
INCIDENTAL MOTIONS
(No order of precedence)
2
Question of order
no
no
no
ch.
yes
Appeal from decision of chair
yes
no
1
1/2
yes
Suspend rules
yes
no
no
2/3
no
Object to consideration
no
no
no
2/3
yes
Parliamentary inquiry
no
no
no
ch.
yes
Request for information
no
no
no
ch.
yes
Withdraw a motion
no
no
no
1/2
no
1.
Debatable only when the motion to which it is applied was debatable.
2.
Requires only chair's decision; majority vote if appealed from chair.
3.
Original motion not debatable; amendment debatable.
NOTE:
1/2 means one more than half of those voting (simple majority); 2/3 means
two-thirds of those voting.
1. :Pr.evious question
2. SUJ:?P!llllld .1)¥\:Jle~
'3, ·:.ti:IJllt ;d¢:bat•e
4. '.[:C.wke f:~om ·the t.aJ>.l'e
5 • Ma·ke :~.:p:e¢.:Lal o'!''d:e:r :,qif :,bU..sli:n'es-s
.TO PE..LA'l .AC'rlt.G.N.
-. ····"'·
..
···-
..
6. ·pqstpmie :to a :o/ett-a·in ·ti!m;e
7 • 'L.aY C?P:
~he · ;t?:P:~·e
, 8. Ref.er to c·o.romi tte.e
9. Object to J.:>.ons~d.e'tat\i'on
10. Withdraw a mot,ia:n
11. Postpone indefinit¢1;y
12. CollllJl,:i,t;:tee of tbe whole
13. Recona:Lder
14. Re.scind
·1,5. Question of .privi1ege
16. Q\l.estion .of ord,.et'
17. A;ppeal fr.QJ.,ll de.C;Ls.i,on of chai·t
18. Pa,rli.a;mentary inq.t;J,iry
19.. Requeo$t tor i;nformatio1.l
20. A;<;ljo:urn
21. Fi~ t;ime of next meeting
22. Recess
;second
)_N'@:~~h!\\1
yes
'.Y,'es
o/<es
"~es
·:yes
·,yes
yres
.f:r¢1:$
:.n:o
''Jil.O
\Yes
y:~s
yes
'~0
ti.b
.y,es
:tl;b
riO
'Y·es
y~es
y·es
·:Antend-
·.JE>•ebat~
;~!l?~~e
.. ~b~e
:no
·no
no
no
:y·es
.'no
no
rn:o
.Y:'e·s
.y:.e'$
·)"es
yes
·no
.)1o
y.es
yes
·no
n·o
no
rto
rto
:yes
no
1
yes
yM
no
no
no
tlb
tiO
1
no
tto
no
tm
rto
no.
yes
. 3
ti@3
yes
no
· Re'q·uli:t'!:fd
:V9':t;!'}.
'2/3
'";
'2/.3
/;;{?>
.11 ..
·'1'2
1//3
li/'2
1F2
/il2
2'/.3
aJ2
1/2
1/2
1/.'2
2/3
dh. 2
2
¢h..
1/2
eh.
ch,
1/2
i/2
lP2
L
Debatable on:Ly when t;he motiion to wh;i.o:h :tt i:s· a;ppl.i.eC! ·wa-s. &etbtita,l;;le.
2.
Requires. on;l;y chair's decl$if;on.;
m~j.orllit:Jy · vnhe if app~a.led frotn chair.
3.
01r::lgin1:11 motion not dehatab1e; apt~ndrt\ent dsba,tab,la.
.ffim.1terrupt
SJ>eaker
no
no
no
no
·'no
no
rro
no
')t'e<s
ho
ito
y·es
no
y·eE1
y~s
yes
yes
y~s
uo
rto
no
NOTE.:
1/2 m.efl.ns one mo·r.e. than ha.l:f oJ tho:s~ voting. (simple majot:;fty).; 2/3 tneari:s
two-thirds of those voting.
(
f
(
