University at Albany - State University of New York
2006-07 University Senate
Minutes of September 25, 2006
Diane M. Dewar, Chair
Members
Present:
J. Philippe Abraham, Bradley Armour-Garb, Joel Berkowitz, Tom Bessette, Scott Birge,
Roger Bisbing, Katharine Briar-Lawson, Gerald Burke, Ana M. Cervantes-Rodriguez,
Maria Chau (President GSO), Fan Pen Chen, Nick Chiuchiolo (President SA), Richard Collier
(Senate Secretary), Edward Cupoli, Diane M. Dewar (Senate Chair), Sue Faerman,
Sally Friedman, Mary Gallant, Robert Gibson, Andrew Haas, Frank Hauser, Susan Herbst,
Anne Hildreth, Timothy Hoff, Heather Horton, Reed Hoyt (Senate Chair-Elect), Allen Israel,
Jon Jacklet, Rachel Jean-Baptiste, Donald Keenan, Laurence Kranich, William Lanford, Eric
Lifshin, Kathryn Lowery, Irene Lurie, Carolyn MacDonald, Matthew Martens, Steven
Messner, Robert Miller, John Monfasani, Gwendolyn Moore, John Murphy, Joy Newman,
Olimpia Pelosi, Marjorie Pryse, Sanjay Putrevu, R. Michael Range, Joan Savitt, Lawrence
Schell, John Schmidt, David Shub, Lawrence Snyder, Lynn Videka, ThomasWagtowicz
(GSO Lead Senator), Rose Marie Weber, Wendy West, Daniel White, Kehe Zhu
Guests:
Seth Chaiken, Computer Science
Nick Chiuchiolo, GSO President
Casey William Crandall, SA President
Dean Paul Leonard, School of Business
Sheila Mahan, Assistant Vice President for Academic Affairs
Daniel J. Smith, Student member of GAC
Paul Truchan, III
Edelgard Wulfert, Psychology Chair
Minutes:
The minutes of May 15, 2006 were approved
Welcome: Senate Chair Dewar asked for a moment of silence to honor President Hall and members
lost during the year. She also noted the continued “paper reduction” plan carried over
from last year and introduced Provost Herbst.
Provost’s Report, by Susan V. Herbst, Provost and Executive Vice President for Academic
Affairs (Officer in Charge):
The Provost’s Prepared Notes:
1.
Presidential Search
I have no news to share
I am officer in charge for now; it is possible we will have an interim president but I do
not know and have no information
There is no timetable on a national presidential search, but when there is information,
George Philip, Chair of the University Council – will announce it.
Accurate news on leadership will come from only two sources: Chancellor Ryan and
George Philip.
2. Our Course: What is our course and are we staying it?
Our course has not changed. It is academic excellence and achievement
Beyond that, we are flexible and always were. Kermit did not have a rigid or even structured
master plan or any sort. There is no secret plan.
A grand master plan does not exist and – in both his and my view – was not needed for the
UAlbany. We have our established values, and from those – academic excellence and
achievement – we do not waiver. But we are, and must be, innovative, and extraordinarily
flexible, focusing on projects, most of which you know and I’ll mention in the time I have
today.
We must be very sophisticated about external cues – from SUNY, from our elected officials,
from our alumni. That’s what a great university with aspirations does, and that’s what we’ll
do.
So yes, we stay the general course, but our course is the course of any great university: focus
on faculty research, on student excellence, on learning and on our external community and
alums.
3. planning
One of the pleasant surprises for me, upon landing here, is that most all divisions had already
been engaged in some form of strategic planning over the years. So while compact planning
had its particularities, I found many strong ideas/plans already in development.
We now have compacts for most all departments and units. Like any plans, they won’t be useful
for very long. Maybe two to three years. But at any one time we should know our roadmap,
so this is a good thing. I think of it as I do writing a book: You may not know what it will
look like in the end, but at any given moment you should be able to say where it is heading, or
you’ll never progress.
We will go ahead with a streamlined version of selective investment this fall. Call went out; you
have it from your deans. (To deans/Vice Presidents, to UPC, to Selective Investment
Committee and to me.)
Still setting aside 800k for faculty lines and 1M one time funds.
Two major changes: unlike match of last year, all lines are fully funded. And this year you may
pitch for senior or junior lines.
Kermit’s original idea was to add 100 new junior faculty lines to the university over five years,
and as you know, we search for the first 20 right now. 100 lines was not a promise set in stone
and should not have been seen that way. It was a goal, and it was – as Kermit said many,
many times in public – based on a stable and hopefully expanding campus economy.
I have studied the budget and 100 lines may or may not be in reach over five years. We will see.
One of the challenges of that plan, and it is something he and I discussed before his death, is
that it demanded the deans make matches with funds they don’t have, and it does not account
for faculty set up costs. So we were going to re-visit the entire matter.
Most important was that the 100 line goal was determined before study of course availability.
That study is nearly done, and does not somehow logically lead to the appt of 100 new junior
faculty over five years. He’d have been interested in this finding.
So, we take a middle path, cautious but still grows the faculty. Let us expand but be
extraordinarily careful with our finances. We still have a 4M deficit I simply will not make
matters worse on my watch.
I promise you that the next president is very unlikely to pursue compact planning or selective
investment in the manner of this past year. Not because it was wrong, but because they will
have their own ideas, on how to plan, on priorities, on a budgeting system and on the entire
campus financial plan. For example, they might want to pay down the debt faster or slower.
4. Our undergraduate Students
This faculty has long cared about students, and this past year we accelerated programs and
energy directed toward their success, through schools, departments and in Student Success.
Projects underway, all of which YOU participated in:
Honors College
Blue Ribbon Writing; I thank Bob Yagelski for leading this effort
Course Availability
Study of retention/I thank Wayne Locust and the Retention Committee
FYE
Transfer coordinator
Student housing; alumni quad developer
International programs – Ray Bromley
AA and SS: tolerance, integrity, diversity, citizenship
5. Graduate Affairs
won’t say much here as Marjorie Pryse, Dean of Graduate Studies, just visited UPC and has
been working with many senior faculty leaders all year.
our priorities:
- higher stipends
- more rigorous march to excellence across programs
- accountability: we do need to be sure the 13M we have for grad support is spent wisely
- we need to be attuned to national metrics, such as the NRC data collection now underway
- let’s place our graduate students well, do best by them.
6. Economic Development: a theme song for the state of NY
All cues from SUNY and from our elected officials underscore the need for research universities
to contribute to the economic development of NYS. Now more than ever, as the state loses
population.
We must re-orient a bit around this, and keep it top of mind into the future as we plan and grow,
uptown, downtown and on the east campus. Serving the state in this regard is non-negotiable,
and I urge you to have Charlie Williams speak to the faculty after the election in November to
elaborate on our political and economic environment.
It’s a good thing. And there is no need to worry if you do research – as I do! - that does not have
clear impacts on the economy. But the university as a whole must contribute, and it is
something Kermit and I discussed daily.
7. Development/fundraising
of highest priority
no campaign, but major gifts and alumni, can count this year
we must grow endowment; we have no protection
deans work on priorities, but I tell you right now that – under ANY president - major
fundraising will be directed toward:
a) Capital – high priority at present is a School of Business building/free up room on podium
b) Scholarships
c) Endowed professorships
d) Non-earmarked contributions to endowment
* We have a highly experienced Vice President development with a fine team; find her with
questions.
8. Our faculty
although there is no precise number, we need to grow and we will, within the limits of the
campus financial plan. Again, we will absolutely not take on more debt.
Empire lines: let’s be hopeful
Better support – Lynn Videka will continue as Vice President of Research; she has terrific
plans. Suggest you work with her and invite her to large meetings
CETL
9. The city of Albany
Our relations are strong and on many levels. We continue Albany High, but not the students on
campus (never the plan). Mayor is a terrific partner; we look forward to mid-city
development, with him and St. Rose.
10. Finally: Stability. Are we stable, should we be worried?
Absolutely not. I’ll let Steve Portch give the bigger national picture on leadership change at
universities, but in larger research universities, things do not turn on a dime so they are quite
stable, due primarily to a tenured faculty, staff with continuing appointments, professionals at
all levels here to stay.
No one likes uncertainty, and I realize that. But we focus on leading, research and teaching, all
will be well.
I want to leave you with two statistics:
According to recent NSF data reports, we are 100th in the nation in federal funding for research.
This is excellent, and indeed astounding, given that we have no medical school or longtime
engineering school. Just incredible and we should be very proud.
In the Carnegie Classifications, there is a category – the highest category for research activity –
called (creatively) “very hi research activity”. There are only 96 institutions in this category
of 4,387 in the nation. We are one of those 96. The University at Albany is a special place
and it is an important place, as a leader in research.
The future is bright here in my view. This university will be what we make it, and we have
within our power to make it great!
[End of Provost’s Notes]
SUNY Senate Report, presented by R. Michael Range: Senator Range reported that he attended the
Fall Planning / Orientation meeting in September at SUNY Systems Administration. Details will
transpire at the next Senate meeting. The main item discussed was that the Governor passed legislation
naming the President of the SUNY Senate, a member of the SUNY Board of Trustees. The effective
date is not yet known. Professor Range also reported that no one from UAlbany is on any of the
standing committees for the SUNY Senate. He explained that there are about a half-dozen different
committees constituted with approximately 65 individuals from colleges all over the State, none from
UAlbany.
Senate Chair Report, presented by Diane M. Dewar:
Presidential Search Committee: Chair Dewar reported that she spoke with George Philip about the
make-up of the Presidential Search Committee. He indicated that he is looking for gender and ethnic
diversity and that he wants a slightly larger committee this year (more than 15) maybe 17, including the
following:
-six faculty representatives that focus across the campus schools and professional schools
-two deans
-four members from the University Council
-one representative from the Athletics Department
-one from the Alumni Association
-one from the Albany Foundation or the community at large
-one graduate and one undergraduate student
The process will be slow and deliberate for the reason that there is an uncertainty in state government;
there is not great urgency. The goals are to create UAlbany as a flagship university center. Chair
Dewar reported that Chairman Philip did ask the Senate to begin thinking about who would be willing to
serve on the committee, and that a ‘head hunter’ has been hired. Chairman Philip said he is happy to
speak at a Senate meeting about this and Chair Dewar suggested that after the election in November
might be best for that.
The Governance Task Force on Academic Integrity and Tolerance: Chair Dewar reported that she
met with the Dean of Graduate Studies and the Dean of Undergraduate Studies, Marjorie Pryse and Sue
Faerman respectively, and representatives from the Student Government. She asked for feedback from
Senators; if they would like to see Senate involvement in this on this Task Force.
2007-2008 Council Volunteer Forms: Chair Dewar reported that next year’s volunteer forms will be
distributed electronically; similar to how the Campus Clean-up Day volunteer sign-up forms are done.
This will help expedite the sorting process and provide more accuracy. Some of the paper forms are
submitted sloppily and are difficult to read.
Council Reports:
Council on Academic Assessment (CAA): William Lanford, Chair. No report.
Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and Community Responsibility,
(CAFFECoR): Lawrence Snyder, Chair. CAFFECoR is organizing its first meeting. It will be
reviewing the "Guidelines and Procedures for Campus Freedom of Expression, Protests,
Demonstrations" submitted by Michael Jaromin, Director of Student Activities, University at Albany.
Committee on Ethics in Research and Scholarship (CERS): Elga Wulfert, Chair. CERS met on
August 31, 2006 to discuss an amendment to the existing policy. For reasons beyond the committee's
control, work on this amendment had to be postponed until later in the fall.
Council on Research (COR): Andrew Haas, Chair. Interim Vice President for Research Videka gave
a brief overview of Research, including end-of-year data regarding total awards received, expenditures
by discipline, awards by sponsor type, number of animal subjects and human subject protocols, increase
in invention disclosures and in patent applications. COR will continue discussion and take appropriate
action regarding the following: ICR Distribution Policy; Revisit Senate By-Laws;
Decentralization/Centralization of Administrative Services; Centers/Institutes Evaluation. Under new
business, a request was made for the FRAP–A Review Committee to provide more detailed feedback for
applicants who do not receive the award.
Council on Promotions and Continuing Appointments (CPCA): David Shub, Chair. CPCA had
unfinished business at the end of the 2005/2006 academic year. A quorum could be obtained that
permitted the Council to meet several times during the summer break. With the exception of one case
that had been tabled for additional information, all cases were cleared and we have no backlog entering
this academic year. Provost Herbst has informed the Deans of a strict schedule for receipt of files at her
office for the current academic year, which should allow the Council to complete all cases on time.
Graduate Academic Council (GAC): Sally Friedman, Chair. Nothing to report for GAC except the
Senate has to approve three graduate students for service on the committee.
Governance Council (GOV): Reed Hoyt, Chair. On August 28th, the Governance Council held its
organizational meeting. Committees were established, and the issues for the coming year were outlined.
These include: recommendations for new senators as needed, the inauguration of the Honors College
and the necessity of involving governance in the formation of its oversight committee, the establishment
of one-credit courses for incoming frosh, the construction of handbooks, and the status of the
Presidential search. The Council will need to elect a member of the Committee on Council
Nominations. The Council again met on September 18th to discuss some of the matters listed above.
Correspondence to individuals and Councils is being sent, but there is no legislation coming from the
Council at this time. The Council will continue to work on handbooks and will consult with the
Provost’s office regarding Excellence Awards.
Council on Libraries, Information Systems, and Computing (LISC): Daniel White, Chair. The
Council will be revisiting the issue of email as official means of communication and the impact of the
current budget situation on scholarly journal subscriptions and other library resources. CIO Christine
Haile gave a report to the Council, on email as a means of communication. The Dean of Libraries
reported about reduction of periodicals, and noted that the Elsevier dilemma will not be affected by
reductions
Undergraduate Academic Council (UAC): John Monfasani, Chair. The UAC has met twice, held
discussions on several issues, but not taken any actions.
University Life Council (ULC): Joan Savitt, Chair. ULC met on September 18th and began
discussing the following issues: mandatory health insurance, a carry-over issue from 2005-06; textbook
prices; ways to improve faculty/student relationships; and housing issues for international students and
visiting scholars. ULC eagerly await the appointment of undergraduate student representatives to the
Council, which meets on Mondays at 3 p.m.
University Planning and Policy Council (UPC): Steven Messner, Chair. UPC met on September
21st. Marjorie Pryse, Dean of Graduate Studies, briefed the council on Guidelines for the Allocation and
Award of Graduate Student Support Funding, 2007-08. Council members raised some concerns and
offered suggestions. Dean Pryse encouraged council members to communicate additional concerns
directly to her. The Council also considered recommendations from the Ad Hoc Committee on Student
Satisfaction. The Council voted to endorse the recommendation of creating an Ombuds Office for
undergraduate students and conveying this endorsement to UAC in hopes of introducing a joint
resolution to the Senate. The Council has begun discussing other recommendations of the committee.
Student Association Senate Presentation by Nick Chiuchiolo, SA President:
SA President Chiuchiolo presented on the “24/7” role of the SA in helping to improve retention, and also
gave a full description on what the Student Association offers.
Council Memberships: After some discussion on the composition of councils and committees, not
being very diverse, it was moved to vote on the tentative approval of the 2006/07 roster while work is
done to try to get compliance with the Senate Charter. Chair Dewar noted that it is very difficult to be in
compliance with the Charter, as there are not people willing to serve/volunteer for councils and
committees. A motion was made and unanimously approved to tentatively approve the current
membership lists.
Other Business: A motion was made to donate money to the scholarship fund in honor of President
Hall again this year. All approved.
Meeting Adjourned.
Respectfully Submitted,
Jayne VanDenburgh, Recorder
