Senate Charter Amendment: 1314-03A
UNIVERSITY SENATE
UNIVERSITY AT ALBANY
STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORK
Introduced by: Governance Council
Date:
Amendment RE: Charge of CAFFECoR
IT IS HEREBY PROPOSED:
•
That the amendment to the University Senate Charter below be adopted.
•
That this amendment go into effect immediately upon adoption.
I. Current Charter:
VII.6 The Executive Committee may establish subcommittees.
VII.7 Standing Subcommittees of the Executive Committee
VII.7.1 Two standing committees which shall report to the Senate through the Executive
Committee shall be appointed to be called upon as needed to author, review and implement
policies governing the conduct of the University community, and as needed, for alleged cases of
misconduct.
VII.7.3 Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression and Community
Responsibility
VII.7.3.1. Composition
VII.7.3.1.1. CAFFECoR shall consist of six Teaching Faculty, at least two of whom
shall be Senators and at least three at the level of Full Professor, who shall serve two-
year terms and up to four Professional Faculty.
VII.7.3.1.2. The members of CAFFECoR shall be nominated for Senate approval by the
Committee on Council Nominations of the Governance Council.
VII.7.3.1.3. The chair of CAFFECoR shall be selected by CAFFECoR from the
continuing members. This selection shall occur in the spring for a one-year term to
2
begin the following academic year. The chair shall serve on the Executive Committee of
the Senate.
VII.7.3.2. Responsibilities.
VII.7.3.2.1. The Senate affirms its commitment to the principle that the widest possible
scope for freedom of expression is the foundation of an institution dedicated to vigorous
inquiry, robust debate, and the continuous search for a proper balance between freedom
and community responsibility.
VII.7.3.2.2. CAFFECoR shall be responsible for establishing and interpreting policies
and procedures concerning academic freedom and ethics which shall govern the
conduct of the University community, and also for those matters for which it is given
responsibility by negotiated employment conditions.
VII.7.3.2.3. CAFFECoR shall serve as a hearing body available to those members of the
University Community who feel that their freedom of expression has been unfairly
suppressed.
VII.7.3.2.4. CAFFECoR shall be responsible for establishing procedures for
investigating and for oversight of investigation of charges brought against members of
the Faculty as specified in the Faculty Bylaws Article I, Section 2.2.4, except as
determined by CERS to be primarily matters of misconduct in scholarship and research,
or as specified by other University regulations. Issues may be brought to the Chair of
CAFFECoR, who shall then call a meeting as needed.
II. Overview of proposed revision
It is proposed that the role of hearing body for faculty, staff, and students’ grievance concerns be
removed from the charge of this committee and that language of its charge with respect to
policies governing the university community in matters of Academic Freedom, Freedom of
Expression and Community Responsibility be modified to clarify and better reflect its role as an
advisory, rather than a policy making body, and to codify successful past practices. Changes to
7.7.1, the description of the two standing subcommittees of the Senate Executive Committee,
address CAFFECoR’s inability to author and implement policy. This change coincidentally
resolves a contradiction between 7.7.1 and what CERS is able to do within the language of its
charge. The description suggests that CERS can implement policy, though CERS, like
CAFFECoR is not a policy-making body as its specific charge states.
3
IIA. Summary of proposed changes
To these ends, the following changes are required:
The removal of sections V11.7.3.2.3 and VII.7.3.2.4.
The addition of a directive statement for section VII.7.3.2.1, now subsumed under VII.7.2.
Clarification and expansion of VII.7.3.2.2, now subsumed under VII.7.3.2 as subsections
VII.7.3.2.1 and VII.7.3.2.2.
Modification of language of section VII.7.1
III. Proposed Revision to Senate Charter
In sum, it is hereby proposed that the revised section of the Senate Charter pertaining to
CAFFECoR should read as follows:
VII.7.1 Two standing committees which shall report to the Senate through the Executive
Committee shall be appointed to be called upon as needed to review and recommend policies
governing the conduct of the University community, and as needed, for alleged cases of
misconduct.
VII.7.3 Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and Community
Responsibility
VII.7.3.2. Responsibilities. The Senate affirms its commitment to the principle that the widest
possible scope for freedom of expression is the foundation of an institution dedicated to vigorous
inquiry, robust debate, and the continuous search for a proper balance between freedom and
community responsibility. Therefore the Senate charges the Committee with the following:
VII.7.3.2.1 The Committee has the responsibility to consider issues impinging academic
freedom, freedom of expression and community responsibility.
VII.7.3.2.2 The Committee shall recommend policies and review implementation of
policy and procedures pertaining to matters of academic freedom, freedom of expression
and community responsibility for both students and faculty.
IV. Rationale
When the Amendment on the Dissolution of CAFFECoR (1314-01A) introduced on September
30, 2013 did not receive the requisite number of votes to pass at the subsequent meeting on
October 21, 2013, the Governance Council took up the matter of revising the Charter to remove
the Committee’s role as a judicial body and to clarify its remaining function, that of sounding
board on campus policies that deal with academic freedom, freedom of expression, and
4
community responsibility. In the revision process, we reviewed the history of CAFFECoR,
formerly CAFE, and its activity over the past decade.
The original charge of CAFE [Senate Bill 197172-32] placed matters of academic freedom,
freedom of expression, and community responsibility explicitly within its purview:
1.2 The Council shall consider problems and recommend policies concerning matters of
academic freedom and responsibility.
1.3 The Council shall consider problems and recommend policies and standards of
professional ethics particularly as they relate to the interaction between academic
privilege and academic responsibility both within and without the university community.
1.4 The Council shall insure that procedures are available for student grievances
concerning professional behavior deemed to be in derogation of professional
responsibility and privilege.
Our review of the Senate minutes of the last 10 years shows that CAFE/CAFFECoR has taken up
issues that range from the impact of the Patriot Act on campus as it pertains to regards to
surveillance, international students, and constitutional rights, to the internal coherence of campus
policies regarding freedom of speech. It has also served as a resource for facilitating forums and
helping negotiate among constituencies where conflicting University policies have been
identified. (See Appendix 4)
In short, the changes we propose clarify the Committee’s function, reflect successful and useful
past practices, and provide a workable framework for supporting that function.
Appendices
1. Amendment on the Dissolution of CAFFECor (1314-01A)
2. Minutes of the University Senate Meeting, September 30, 2013
3. Minutes of the University Senate Meeting, October 21, 2013
4. CAFFECoR Activity (past ten years)
Appendix 1
Senate Charter Amendment No.: 1314-01A
UNIVERSITY SENATE
UNIVERSITY AT ALBANY
STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORK
Introduced by: Governance Council
Date:
September 30, 2013
Amendment RE: Dissolution of CAFFECoR
IT IS HEREBY PROPOSED THAT THE FOLLOWING BE ADOPTED:
•
That the proposed amendment to the University Senate Charter below be adopted.
•
That this amendment go into effect for the Spring 2014 Senate.
Current Charter:
VII.6 The Executive Committee may establish subcommittees.
VII.7 Standing Subcommittees of the Executive Committee
VII.7.1 Two standing committees which shall report to the Senate through the Executive
Committee shall be appointed to be called upon as needed to author, review and implement policies
governing the conduct of the University community, and as needed, for alleged cases of misconduct.
VII.7.3 Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression and Community Responsibility
VII.7.3.1. Composition
VII.7.3.1.1. CAFFECoR shall consist of six Teaching Faculty, at least two of whom shall be
Senators and at least three at the level of Full Professor, who shall serve two-year terms and up
to four Professional Faculty.
VII.7.3.1.2. The members of CAFFECoR shall be nominated for Senate approval by the
Committee on Council Nominations of the Governance Council.
VII.7.3.1.3. The chair of CAFFECoR shall be selected by CAFFECoR from the continuing
members. This selection shall occur in the spring for a one-year term to begin the following
academic year. The chair shall serve on the Executive Committee of the Senate.
VII.7.3.2. Responsibilities.
VII.7.3.2.1. The Senate affirms its commitment to the principle that the widest possible scope
for freedom of expression is the foundation of an institution dedicated to vigorous inquiry,
robust debate, and the continuous search for a proper balance between freedom and community
responsibility.
Appendix 1
VII.7.3.2.2. CAFFECoR shall be responsible for establishing and interpreting policies and
procedures concerning academic freedom and ethics which shall govern the conduct of the
University community, and also for those matters for which it is given responsibility by
negotiated employment conditions.
VII.7.3.2.3. CAFFECoR shall serve as a hearing body available to those members of the
University Community who feel that their freedom of expression has been unfairly suppressed.
VII.7.3.2.4. CAFFECoR shall be responsible for establishing procedures for investigating and
for oversight of investigation of charges brought against members of the Faculty as specified in
the Faculty Bylaws Article I, Section 2.2.4, except as determined by CERS to be primarily
matters of misconduct in scholarship and research, or as specified by other University
regulations. Issues may be brought to the Chair of CAFFECoR, who shall then call a meeting as
needed.
Proposed Revision:
It is proposed that CAFFECoR be removed as a standing committee of the Senate Executive Committee
and that Section VII.7.3 be removed from the Charter accordingly.
The following minor changes (in bold) are required to sections preceding Section VII.7.3.
VII.6 The Executive Committee has one standing subcommittee and may establish other
subcommittees as needed.
VII.7 Standing Subcommittee of the Executive Committee
VII.7.1 The Executive Committee’s standing subcommittee, which shall report to the Senate
through the Executive Committee, shall be appointed to discharge its responsibilities as specified in
VII.7.2.
Rationale:
The rationale for the dissolution of CAFFECoR is provided in the attached report from CAFFECoR. The
Executive Summary and Conclusion from that report are included here.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
After much deliberation, the Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression and Community
Responsibility (CAFFECoR) would like to suggest its dissolution. As a committee, we have spent much
time exploring the history of CAFE/CAFFECoR in efforts to better understand its ‘charge’. In doing so,
we have come to realize that faculty, staff, and students’ grievance concerns can already be addressed and
resolved elsewhere. This has not always been the case; when CAFノ was first established there was less in
place on campus to deal with freedom of expression and community responsibility. However, over time
our campus has developed procedures in a number of areas to address these issues. For example, the
Community Rights and Responsibilities document, which comes from the Office of Student Success,
fully addresses conduct on campus.
Appendix 1
Additionally, as a body, we do not have any authority and are not recognized by General Counsel as a
fiduciary part of the University at Albany. This means that the process of obtaining evidence and
rendering decisions cannot fall under our purview. , nor can we render any binding decisions. After
reviewing the current campus procedures in place, we realized that the need for a standing committee
seems to have disappeared. We would like to note that, should the need arise, an Ad-Hoc Committee
could be created to deal with specific situations.
CONCLUSION
CAFFECoR’s role as a judicial body is problematic and untenable. The remaining role—that of sounding
board on campus policies which deal with freedom of expression—could still be fulfilled, but it seems
that maintaining a standing committee for such a purpose is not necessary. We would recommend that the
SEC instead appoint an ad hoc committee should the need arise. For example, the Community Rights and
Responsibilities document is occasionally revised by the University Council, and should the Council
choose to consult with the faculty through the Senate, then an ad hoc committee would be appropriate.
One recommendation that follows from this suggestion is that members of such an ad hoc committee be
given some sort of training on the topic of freedom of expression and university regulations and policies,
perhaps in the same vein as the training received by CERS members.
Appendix 2
2013-2014 University Senate
Monday, September 30, 2013
2:45 pm, Campus Center Assembly Hall
Christine Wagner, Chair
Minutes
Present:
Jeanette Altarriba, Bryant Barksdale, Deborah Bernnard, Marc Cohen, Sridar
Chittur, Aiguo Dai, Anthony DeBlasi; Erzsebet Fazekas, Edward Fitzgerald,
Richard Fogarty, Cynthia Fox, Elizabeth Gaffney, Lynn Gelzheiser, Jennifer
Goodall, Yenisel Gulatee, Janell Hobson, Caitlin Janiszewski, Michael Jaromin,
Michael Jerison, Lani Jones, Jane Kadish, Genevieve Kane, Ann Kearney, Igor
Kuznetsov, Kajal Lahiri, Danielle Leonard, Andi Lyons, David Mamorella,
Daniel Markisello, Cylas Martell-Crawford, David McCaffrey, David McDowall,
Carla Meskill, Joe Messmer, John Monfasani, Melissa Murata, John Murphy,
Saggi Nevo, Gregory Nowell, James Pasquill, Greta Petry, Susan Phillips, John
Pipkin, Nathan Powers, Loretta Pyles, Helene Scheck, Lawrence Schell, John
Schmidt, Kabel Nathan Stanwicks, Joette Stefl-Mabry, Caro-Beth Stewart,
Christine Wagner, Kevin Williams, Oscar Williams, Ryan Witte, Mark Wolfe,
Elga Wulfert, Yan Zheng, Yuchi Young, Alan Zemel, James Zetka
Guests:
Jon, Bartow, Susanna Fessler, Chenaniah Henderson, Karin Reinhold, Kathie
Winchester
The meeting convened at 2:50 pm.
Chair Wagner made welcoming remarks and thanked everyone for their service. She announced
that for the future, meetings will start on time at 2:45 pm.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
A motion was made and seconded to approve the minutes of May 13, 2013. The motion was
approved by a show of hands.
PROVOST’S REPORT – SUSAN PHILLIPS
Provost Phillips delivered the following report on behalf of President Jones who was unable to
attend.
Appendix 2
The Provost referred to the weeklong inaugural celebration. She recapped the varied highlights
of the week which included faculty posters in the Campus Center; a sold out performance by
Carolee Carmello; and a conversation with the daughters of Desmond Tutu. The celebration was
capped by the inauguration ceremony on Saturday. A video extending a personal greeting from
Desmond Tutu to President Jones was played at the inauguration ceremony.
• The campus welcomed the class of 2017 with 2,571 incoming freshman who were
accepted out of 21,500 applicants. The average high school grade is 90.1 and SAT
scores showed an increase. The incoming class is very diverse with 41.9 percent of
the population being students of color. The University has enrolled 13,145
undergraduates and 4,595 graduates for a total enrollment of 17,740 students for 2013-
14. Enrollment for out of state and international students also increased. Provost
Phillips reported the start of the new Living Learning Communities in several
disciplines which includes Chemistry, Biology, East Asian Studies and History, as
well as many others.
• The writing and critical inquiry program was launched this semester and 16 new
faculty have been hired for the program. With the program in place, every first year
students will have the opportunity to be in a small class, a first on campus. The
faculty continues to grow with approximately 55 new full time faculty joining the
ranks this year. Many were hired under the SUNY 2020 plan.
• There will be a follow up to the academic retreat that was held over the summer.
Consideration will be given for programs in high need areas, career development
perspective and undergraduate experiences.
• The new building for the School of Business opened in August and will be a hub of
new business innovation.
• Recipients of the 2013 Citizen Laureate Awards have been named: Steve Embler is the
Academic Laureate and James Barba is the Community Laureate. They will be
honored at the annual ceremony in October.
• Provost Phillips provided an update on construction around campus. The new football
stadium opened with a home game. The game drew 11,000 attendees. The acquisition
of the Schuyler High School is complete and will increase available space downtown
by one-third. The building requires renovation but will be a major asset to the
university. The water tower and fountain are scheduled for completion this fall. The
new data center will open in March 2014. The Campus Center expansion is expected
to be completed in 2015. The design phase of the new ETEC facility will begin soon.
The Open SUNY Initiative outlined by Chancellor Zimpher in her State of SUNY address is
expected to go into effect in January of 2014. The initiative will complement our online teaching
and learning initiative. Currently we have five graduate programs and 121 graduate courses
being taught online, and 158 undergraduate courses being taught online. Open SUNY will create
a SUNY-wide catalog of online courses and programs. SUNY is looking for feedback and input.
Provost Phillips encouraged everyone to register their comments.
The provost reported updates concerning the separation of CNSE. An implementation team has
been formed and should be convening soon. Also, and campus advisory committee is being
Appendix 2
formed to assist President Jones on the process and issues concerning the separation. Updates
will be made on the progress.
The Startup NY program enacted by Governor Cuomo in June is a tax free program for
companies to start up on a SUNY Campus. Companies must create new jobs and tine into the
university academic mission. Consideration will be given to companies that would fit best for
UAlbany. The governor’s office is still working on regulations for the program which is
expected to begin in January.
Provost Phillips asked if anyone had questions. Senator Janiszewski asked when construction
would begin on the Campus Center. The provost did not have a start date at this time.
Senator Jerison asked if information was available about what the budgets would like for the
campus and CNSE and what detail had been approved with the pending separation. Provost
Phillips responded that no details have been approved at this point. An MOU was signed by
Chancellor Zimpher, President Jones and Sr. Vice President Kaloyeros that will sustain activities
currently supporting CNSE through the transition year. CNSE is still part of the University at
Albany as of this date and will not be separated until September 2014.
UNIVERSITY SENATE CHAIR’S REPORT –CHRISTINE WAGNER, CHAIR
President Jones, as part of the formal consultation process, met with the Senate Executive Committee on 6/13/13
and 7/17/13 to discuss the College of Nanoscale Science and Engineering’s pursuit to become an independent, free-
standing degree-granting structure within the SUNY System. In a memo (8/29/13) to Chair and Vice-Chair of the
Senate, President Jones asked the University Senate to recommend fifteen (15) individuals to serve on a campus
advisory committee that will assist the President, and UAlbany representatives on the SUNY Implementation Team,
in considering issues associated with this transition. In accordance with Article II.5.5 of the Faculty Bylaws, the
Senate Chair asked GOV to recommend individuals for the campus advisory committee. The recommended names
were provided to President Jones on 9/13/13. The Senate Executive Committee recommended that GOV form a
subcommittee to review internal Senate issues that may arise following the separation of CNSE.
UUP has raised the issue that the composition of CPCA, as defined by the Senate Charter, may be in conflict with
Article 33.1.c of the UUP Contract. Consequently, the Senate Officers met with UUP local chapter president, Jim
Collins, on 5/29/13 and again with Jim Collins and current local chapter president, Bret Benjamin, on 9/12/13.
Chair Wagner reported on the Senate’s role concerning the CNSE separation. President Jones met with
the Senate Executive Committee twice over the summer. At the president’s request, GOV met and
developed a roster of recommendations to serve on the Campus Advisory Committee. The names were
forwarded to President Jones who is taking the recommendations under consideration. Chair Wagner
said she expected to know soon the membership of CAC. Ryan Witte from the Student Association asked
if students would be part of the committee. Chair Wagner responded that she sent a memo to President
Jones recommending students be part of the committee or participate in an advisory capacity. Senator
Jerison asked if any consideration was made concerning allocation between the two entities when the
implementation team was formed. He also asked to what extent any agreements between UAlbany and
CSNE will be taken into account during the separation and if the University would be provided
information on how budgets are allocation. Chair Wagner deferred to the Provost for a response.
Provost Phillips said those details will be charged to the implementation team and the CAC. Chair
Wagner said she has asked President Jones to have a CAC spokesperson provide regular reports to the
Senate. She expects updates will be provided in the president’s and provost’s reports to the Senate as
well.
Appendix 2
Brief Welcome & Introduction: Christine Wagner
Chair Wagner reviewed the Senate schedule for the year. She made introductions of the Senate
officers, support staff and parliamentarian. The Chair recommended to Senators that they
become familiar with the Senate website and its contents.
Chair Wagner provided an overview of the Senate’s membership which includes ex officios,
senators at-large, teaching and professional faculty from each school and college, and student
senators. She reviewed the councils and standing committees that enable the Senate to carry out
its function.
Legislation presented to the Senate is done in the form of bills, resolutions and amendments and
these were briefly discussed. Senators were then presented with mock legislation to vote on
which provided them a brief practice session for using the iClickers. A discussion ensued about
rogue clickers being brought in the room and used. Senator Leonard said the use of iClickers can
be monitored. She spoke in her role as former Senate Secretary and the use of iClickers was
initiated during her term. Senator Leonard said the secretary has access to the voting data and
can discern whether or not a rogue clicker has been used at a meeting. CAFFECoR Chair
Fessler, who was the Senate Chair when the iClickers were initiated also addressed the issue.
She said any member of a constituency has the right to inquire about how their senator voted. Ex
officios do not have a constituency. If a rogue vote is attempted, it is eliminated from the vote
total.
OTHER REPORTS
UFS (University Faculty Senator’s Report) –Danielle Leonard, J. Philippe Abraham &
John Schmidt, SUNY Senators
The SUNY Faculty Senators are looking forward to attending the Fall Plenary which will take place October 24-26
at SUNY Maritime. We are also pleased to announce that the University at Albany will host the 166th Winter
Plenary January 23-25, 2014.
GSO (Graduate Student Association) – Caitlin Janiszewski, GSO President
•
We have a new name: Graduate Student Association
•
We also have a new constitution, are working on new bylaws, as well as a strategic plan to address our
most critical challenges.
•
We are working on strategies to encourage committee and council attendance (committee coordinator and
polling system).
•
Improve our communication mechanisms (listserv and now a newsletter).
•
Documenting our processes (developing programming and financial handbooks) to ensure efficiency and
continuity from year to year.
•
Working on a mission statement.
•
Expanding to downtown campus.
•
Developing a network of partnerships with offices and groups which already work to support graduate
students (ITLAL, GSEU, UUP, International Studies, Graduate Studies, Career Services, Library Services,
Financial Services).
•
Working to represent graduate student interests the best we can throughout the separation of CNSE from
UAlbany.
•
Taking the lead in facilitating the President's forum promised to us by President Jones.
Senator Janiszewski reported the GSA’s lead senator resigned and Melissa Murata has been appointed to
serve as acting lead senator. GSA is restructuring its process for developing handbooks and guidebooks.
Appendix 2
The GSA has set a date for the president’s forum for Monday, November 4 from 3:30-5:00. The president
is scheduled to speak at 4:30 pm. GSA will work with the Student Association on the event.
SA (Student Association) – Marc Cohen, Student Association Representative
2013-2014 Student Association Executive Board
President:
Francis Agyemang
Vice President:
Nick Butler
Chief of Staff:
Lee Stanton
Programming:
Ajon Crump
Marketing:
Steven Valentine
Legislative Affairs:
Marc Cohen
Academic Affairs:
Derek Ellis
Community Engagement:
Rose Avellino
Student Group Affairs:
Katie Thomas
Multicultural Affairs:
Rachel Arnaud
Gender and Sexuality:
Emma Suarez
Dippikill Outreach:
Alexis Klein
Programming:
•
Block Party on September 22 was a success. Great student turnout. Performances went for well over an
hour.
•
Next event is the world Within Reach Speaker Series: Behind the Obama Campaign on September 28. For
the first time, David Axelrod, David Plouffe and Jon Favreau will speak together in a public forum about
the campaign and other issues. The panel will speak and then answer questions.
Legislative Affairs:
•
Voter Registration Drive was a success, more than 50 forms received. We tabled for Constitution Day
during which we asked students questions about the Constitution and had information available for them.
•
Met with Clifford Kim about this year’s Legislative Agenda. Working on a number of issues including In
State Tuition for Veterans Bill, TAP Increases, and Capital Investment continuation.
Academic Affairs:
•
“Things I wish I Knew As A Freshman” program. Working on a list of items for incoming freshman to help
them better assimilate into the University community
•
Working with academic departments on campus to assist students with academic concerns and complaints
Student Group Affairs:
•
6 new student groups already, more to come
•
Now temporary groups need faculty advisors, used to just be permanently recognized groups
Multicultural Affairs:
•
Working on bring a Farmers Market to campus which would bring native foods from different countries to
campus
Gender and Sexuality Concerns:
•
Second Chance Prom
•
Coming Out Week
Dippikill Outreach:
•
Creating a new advertising poster
•
Trying to reach out to student groups that haven’t previously been to Dippikill
•
Working to help find groups easy and affordable transportation
SA Representative Marc Cohen reported on the success of the Speaker’s Series this past weekend. He
said approximately 1,500 people attended the event. The SA has a new voter registration drive and
forums will be held in each of the quads. Mr. Cohen reported there are eight new student groups this
year.
COUNCIL/COMMITTEE CHAIRS’ REPORTS:
Appendix 2
CAA (Council on Academic Assessment) – Deborah Bernnard, Chair
The Council on Academic Assessment met on Fri. Sept. 20. Chairs of the Academic Program Review Committee
and the General Education Assessment Committee were elected. Members of the Council chose the committee on
which they will serve for the 2013-2014 academic year.
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and Community
Responsibility) – Susanna Fessler, Chair
Nothing to report.
CERS (Committee on Ethics in Research and Scholarship) – Carolyn MacDonald, Chair
CERS is planning a training session.
COR (Council on Research) – John Monfasani, Chair
Nothing to report.
CPCA (Council on Promotions and Continuing Appointments) – Sanjay Putrevu, Chair
CPCA met on Sept. 6 and will meet again on Sept. 20.
GAC (Graduate Academic Council) – Ronald Toseland, Chair
The Graduate Academic Council had its first meeting and organized three committees.
GOV (Governance Council) – Joette Stefl-Mabry, Chair
GOV met on 09/09/13 to address:
1. the request of President Jones’ to recommend 15 names for the CNSE Advisory Committee, and
2. the co-chair of the President’s Advisory Committee on Campus Security’s request to recommend two
names of teaching faculty for the current open seat on that committee.
On September 13, 2013 the list of names for the CNSE Advisory Committee was sent to the Chair of the Senate who
forwarded the names to the President's office.
We also met on 09/23/13:
1. formed the ad hoc committee to examine and make recommendations re: CNSE and Senate separation
issues.
2. selected two names to send to the Campus Security Committee and
3. discussed the election for the new senator -at large.
LISC (Council on Libraries, Information Systems, and Computing) – Elizabeth Gaffney,
Chair
The first LISC Meeting was scheduled for Monday, September 23, 2013, from 3:00 – 4:30 PM in AS 122. This will
be a basic organizational meeting.
Chair Gaffney reported that LISC is working on populating its subcommittees.
UAC (Undergraduate Academic Council) – Richard Fogarty, Chair
Nothing to report.
ULC (University Life Council) –Michael Jaromin, Chair
The first meeting will be held on Monday, September 23rd. The ULC will also continue to work in conjunction with
the Office of Diversity & Inclusion on the Inclusive Excellence initiative.
Chair Jaromin reported that the President’s Council on Diversity and the University Life Council are
presenting a Dialogue in action series. The first event will be held on Monday, October 7 in the Campus
Center Ballroom. He encouraged everyone to attend.
UPPC (University Planning and Policy Council) –Andi Lyons, Chair
UPPC had its first meeting on Friday, September 20. At that time, Provost Phillips updated the Council on the
opportunities and issues surrounding Governor Cuomo’s Start-Up NY initiative. The Council plans to invite
Registrar Chico-Hurst to its next meeting, to provide an update on the Academic Calendar beyond 2014-15 and on
Appendix 2
the implementation of Chancellor Zimpher’s seamless transfer system. The next meeting is scheduled for Friday,
October 4, at 1pm.
Chair Lyons reported that Registrar Chico Hurst’s attendance has been confirmed for UPPC’s October
25 meeting to discuss the academic calendar.
NEW BUSINESS
Chair Wagner reported that she had received an email from Professor Alain Diebold, chair of the
CNSE governance body, informing her that all CNSE senators and council members were
resigning from all Senate positions which would take effect immediately. Professor Diebold
stated that CNSE is forming its own governance body and cited a conflict of interest in serving
on the University Senate. The changes reported below include replacement of CNSE members.
Approval of Senator Replacements:
Secretary Gulatee provided the details of the replacements of senators. A motion was made and
seconded to approve the new Senate membership. The motion passed with the following voting
results: Approved: 49; Opposed: 1; Abstained: 4
Election of Senators Selected by their Council as Council Chair:
Chair Wagner referred to Section 8.3.3 of the Senate Charter which outlines the procedure for
electing a council chair that is not a senator. The section states the following:
VIII.3.3. As stated in Article II Section 6.3 of the Bylaws, council chairs must be Senators.
If a council is unable to elect a chair from among its Senators, it may nominate its chair-
elect to be appointed for a one-year term as a Senator by the approval of the Senate.
This past spring, the following five non-senators were nominated and elected as chairs of
councils:
Deborah Bernnard—CAA; John Monfasani—COR: Sanjay Putrevu—CPCA; Ronald
Toseland—GAC; Elizabeth Gaffney—LISC. The five chairs require the Senate’s approval for a
one year term as a senator. A motion was made and seconded to approve them as senators. The
motion passed with the following voting results: Approved: 52; Opposed: 1; Abstained: 3.
Approval of Changes in Council Memberships
Secretary Gulatee reviewed the numerous changes that had occurred to council memberships
since they were approved at the penultimate Senate meeting this past spring. The updated
memberships include the graduate students as well. A motion was made and seconded to
approve the membership. The motion was approved with the following voting results:
Approved: 53; Opposed: 0; Abstained: 5.
Discussion of Charter Amendment 1314-01A (for vote on 10/21/13)
Appendix 2
Chair Wagner said the amendment was being introduced by the Governance Council which
passed the amendment this past spring. In accordance with the Charter, the amendment is being
circulated within the stated three week time frame before it can be voted on. The amendment is
being presented today only for discussion and will be voted on in October. The accompanying
report to the agenda was generated by CAFFECoR. CAFFECoR Chair Fessler spoke on the
amendment and report and read the Executive Summary of the report:
After much deliberation, the Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of
Expression and Community Responsibility (CAFFECoR) would like to
suggest its dissolution. As a committee, we have spent much time exploring
the history of CAFE/CAFFECoR in efforts to better understand its ‘charge’.
In doing so, we have come to realize that faculty, staff, and students’ grievance
concerns can already be addressed and resolved elsewhere. This has not
always been the case; when CAFÉ was first established there was less in place
on campus to deal with freedom of expression and community responsibility.
However, over time our campus has developed procedures in a number of
areas to address these issues. For example, the Community Rights and
Responsibilities document, which comes from the Office of Student Success,
fully addresses conduct on campus.
Additionally, as a body, we do not have any authority and are not recognized
by General Counsel as a fiduciary part of the University at Albany. This
means that the process of obtaining evidence and rendering decisions cannot
fall under our purview, nor can we render any binding decisions. After
reviewing the current campus procedures in place, we realized that the need for
a standing committee seems to have disappeared. We would like to note that,
should the need arise, an Ad-Hoc Committee could be created to deal with
specific situations.
Senator Scheck asked for a clarification of the following section of the report:
“CAFFECoR is “responsible for establishing and interpreting policies and
procedures concerning academic freedom and ethics” but this conflicts with
the authority of the Board of Trustees’ Policies.”
Chair Fessler responded that the Board of Trustees (BOT) policy state that overall SUNY policy
must be in accordance with New York State law. SUNY Central policy is the umbrella for
SUNY campuses and local policy cannot go against NYS law. SUN regulations state that the
responsible body is University Counsel.
Senator Fox said she was concerned about the necessity for abolishing the committee in light of
events of the past six months such as MOOCs, Start-Up NY and Community Engagement
initiatives. She felt it should be discussed in terms of academic freedom and as senators, and
said we have lots of information giving reasons for maintaining the committee. Senator Fox
continued, saying the original intent of the committee was not just to address grievances but all
things that concern academic freedom. Chair Fessler said BOT policy has a clear statement on
Appendix 2
freedom of speech in the classroom. A similar section appears in the UUP contract which
trumps most policies. CAFFECoR felt that if someone felt freedom of speech was being
restricted, it would be more a labor management issue addressed by UUP.
Senator Petry said a committee could still exist to discuss best practices. Chair Fessler
responded that was why the clause about the ad hoc committee was added. Every three year
University Counsel reviews best practices with Student Success. If in that cycle they feel the
need to consult with the Senate they could form an ad hoc committee. Maintaining a permanent
standing committee seems redundant.
Senator Scheck voiced concerns about going to an ad hoc committee with the changing
community entering into private enterprise on campus and the changing relationship with CNSE.
She said there would be room for discussion to address potential problems and best practices.
Chair Fessler said those things would not fall under the charge of CAFFECoR.
UAC Chair Fogarty said it was his understanding that CAFFECoR does not have a demanding
work load. Chair Fessler said confirmed his statement and said in the past five years the
committee has had one case brought to them which was turned over to the University Counsel.
Senator Kane said based on the dialogue she believed that an ad hoc committee would be
appropriate. Chair Fessler said CAFFECoR and CERS often have no duties during the course of
a year and an ad hoc committee would be formed in response to a need. Parliamentarian Howard
added that an ad hoc committee could be created every year but does not need to be case.
ADJOURNMENT
The meeting adjourned at 3:55 pm.
Respectfully submitted by
Gail Cameron, Recorder
Appendix 3
2013-2014 University Senate
Monday, October 21, 2013
2:45 pm, Alumni House
Christine Wagner, Chair
Minutes
Present:
Jeanette Altarriba, Bryant Barksdale, Deborah Bernnard, Sridar Chittur, Leona
Christie, Marc Cohen, Aiguo Dai, Anthony DeBlasi, Evgeny Dikarev, Richard
Fogarty, Michael Ford, Cynthia Fox, Elizabeth Gaffney, Lyn Gelzheiser, Yenisel
Gulatee, Janell Hobson, Caitlin Janiszewski, Michael Jaromin, Michael Jerison,
Genevieve Kane, Ann Kearney, Kevin Knuth, Igor Kuznetsov, Kajal Lahiri,
Danielle Leonard, Dan levy, Andi Lyons, David Mamorella, Daniel Markisello,
Cylas Martell-Crawford, David McCaffrey, David McDowall, Joe Messmer,
Antun Milas, John Monfasani, Saggi Nevo, Greta Petry, John Pipkin, Nathan
Powers, Christine, Preble, Sanjay Putrevu, Eliot Rich, Helene Scheck, Lawrence
Schell, John Schmidt, Emma Schwab, Kabel Nathan Stanwicks, Joette Stefl-
Mabry, Caro-Beth Stewart, Christine Wagner, Oscar Williams, Mark Wolfe, Elga
Wulfert, Alan Zemel, James Zetka
Guests:
Jon Bartow, Susanna Fessler, Karin Reinhold, Kathie Winchester
The meeting convened at 2:48 pm.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
The minutes of September 30 were passed as written with the following voting results:
Approved: 40; Opposed: 0 Abstained: 2
SENATE CHAIR’S REPORT – CHRISTINE WAGNER
President Jones has officially formed the Campus Advisory Committee (CAC), following formal consultation with
the Senate. As requested by President Jones, GOV provided a list of 15 recommended names for the committee. The
CAC consists of 15 members, 8 of whom were recommended by the Senate. The CAC will advise the President as
he works with the SUNY Implementation Team to develop the new relationship between UAlbany and CNSE. The
President will convene the committee in October 2013.
UUP UAlbany Chapter President, Bret Benjamin has sent an official memo to Senate Chair Wagner stating that
UUP has identified a conflict between the composition of CPCA, as defined by the Senate Charter, and Article
33.1.c of the UUP contract. President Benjamin requested that the Senate review the issue and take appropriate
action. Senate Chair Wagner forwarded the memo to GOV Chair, Joette Stefl-Mabry and asked that GOV review the
issue as soon as possible.
The Fall Faculty Meeting will be held on Tuesday, November 5th, with a back-up date of Thursday, November 7th.
Appendix 3
Chair Wagner reported that the SUNY Implementation Team has not yet met. The CAC has been
officially formed and will convene after President Jones receives a report from the implementation team.
The Senate will receive updates on the CAC activities from Senate Chair Wagner, a member of CAC, and
the CAC Chair. Chair Wagner was asked if there are student members on CAC and she responded that
there were. She was also asked if the membership has been made public. She responded that, to her
knowledge, it had not. She reported that 51% of the membership is composed of recommendations
forwarded to the president by the Governance Council.
OTHER REPORTS
UFS (University Faculty Senator’s Report) –Danielle Leonard, J. Philippe Abraham &
John Schmidt, SUNY Senators
The SUNY Faculty Senators are looking forward to attending the Fall Plenary which will take place October 24-26
at SUNY Maritime. We are also pleased to announce that the University at Albany will host the 166th Winter
Plenary January 23-25, 2014.
Senator Leonard reported the SUNY Senators will attend the fall plenary later this week at SUNY
Maritime College.
GSO (Graduate Student Organization) – Caitlin Janiszewski, GSO President
President's Forum: November 4th - from 4:10 to 5:30 in LC 25 (awaiting confirmation on reservation).
The President is going to receive a "worksheet" from the GSA and SA next week breaking down the top 4 issues we
want addressed (2 grad, 2 undergrad). We will also be sending out an agenda for the program.
Senator Janiszewski reported that a new lead senator has been elected. The GSA is finalizing a
worksheet for the President’s Forum which includes five topics for discussions. The document will be
forwarded to the President’s Office.
SA (Student Association) – Marc Cohen, Student Association Representative
Academic Affairs – Derek Ellis, Director
•
Continuing with the "UA U Should Know Program"- things students should know about UAlbany that they
might not already know.
•
Looking ahead to the career fair in February, and working on ways to get SA more involved in the fair.
Legislative Affairs – Marc Cohen, Director
•
Voter registration drive is coming to an end. We are going to be collecting forms from living areas over the
next few days and send them out by October 11
•
Beginning to discuss some preliminary plans for UAlbany Day
Community Engagement and Outreach – Rose Avellino, Director
•
Connect to Community Week will be the 16th-23rd intended to enhance community service and engagement
throughout the University Community
•
“Student Association Day of Service” - Pine Hills Cleanup October 27th 12-3 PM
Gender and Sexuality Concerns – Emma Saurez, Director
•
LGBTQ Friendly Fair on Friday, October 11 from 12-3 PM by the small fountain
•
Coming Out Reception, October 24th at 7 PM in the CC Ballroom
Senator Cohen reported that Lee Stanton is the new comptroller. Senator Cohen was elected as the new
chief of staff and will step down from his role as legislative director. A new director will be selected in
the coming weeks.
COUNCIL/COMMITTEE CHAIRS’ REPORTS:
CAA (Council on Academic Assessment) – Deborah Bernnard, Chair
Nothing to Report
Appendix 3
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and Community
Responsibility) – Susanna Fessler, Chair
Nothing to report
CERS (Committee on Ethics in Research and Scholarship) – Carolyn MacDonald, Chair
Nothing to report
COR (Council on Research) – John Monfasani, Chair
COR met on September 19 and organized itself for the coming year with the selection of chairs for its various
subcommittees.
Chair Monfasani reported the council is working on guidelines for FRAP and will complete a survey of
the FRAP results. Chair Wagner asked if members were still being sought for COR’s subcommittees.
Chair Monfasani said yes. Chair Wagner asked senators to put a word out to their colleagues who may
be looking for Senate service and to let them know they should contact Chair Monfasani.
CPCA (Council on Promotions and Continuing Appointments) – Sanjay Putrevu, Chair
The CPCA met on October 4. The next meeting is scheduled for October 18.
Chair Putrevu reported the council does not have any cases to review at this time.
GAC (Graduate Academic Council) – Ronald Toseland, Chair
Nothing to report
Jon Bartow, Vice Dean for Graduate Education, reported that GAC’s Committee on Educational Policy
and Procedure is in need of two members. Chair Wagner reminded everyone that serving on a
subcommittee is an excellent way to serve on the Senate.
GOV (Governance Council) – Joette Stefl-Mabry, Chair
GOV met on 10/07/2013.
GOV selected recommendations of Senate designees, at the request of Dr. Tine Reimers, in the Provost Office, to
serve on the varied Excellent Award Selection Committees. Additionally, GOV approved the lists that had already
been complied and forward the list of Senate designees and the approved lists to Dr. Reimers.
GOV named and began to explore charges for the Ad Hoc Committee to examine the larger issues of Senate changes
regarding the resignation of CNSE senators and Council Members. GOV determined the committee would be called
the Ad Hoc Committee on Senate Implications of the CNSE Transition. Presently three members of GOV are on that
Ad Hoc Committee and it was decided that a discussion to expand the membership of that committee, and its
charges, would take place at the next GOV meeting on 10/21/2013.
LISC (Council on Libraries, Information Systems, and Computing) – Elizabeth Gaffney,
Chair
Nothing to report
UAC (Undergraduate Academic Council) – Richard Fogarty, Chair
At its October 2nd meeting, the council approved revised learning objectives for the International Perspectives
category of the General Education Program. In light of senate and campus discussions of the category, the General
Education committee revised the learning objective, and then forwarded them to UAC for consideration. After
further modification to improve clarity and concision, with an eye to making clearer to faculty and students the
purpose and goals of courses in the category, the council adopted the revised learning objectives and has
communicated them to the Office of Undergraduate Education for publication and implementation. At the same
October 2 meeting, the council approved undergraduate student Patrick Cronin as a member of the General
Education Advisory Board.
ULC (University Life Council) –Michael Jaromin, Chair
Appendix 3
The University Life Council met on September 23, 2013. The Council confirmed that it would continue to support
and co-sponsor with the President's Council on Diversity the Dialogue In Action series which will begin on October
7th at 10:00 am in the CC Ballroom featuring Dr. David Kung entitled "Social Justice in Mathematics and Other
Fields". The Council is also seeking an update from the Tobacco Free task force and will share these as soon as we
receive any information. The council will be exploring other University life issues and asking for updates from
offices such as Conflict Resolution, Athletics, Residential Life, UAS/Dining and UPD. Other topics of interest were
concerns over the isolation of the East campus and the transfer student experience. Our next meeting will be on
October 28th.
Chair Jaromin reported the next session of the Dialogue in Action series will be held on November 4 with
Dr. Kristie Ford, Associate Professor of Sociology from Skidmore College as the guest speaker
UPPC (University Planning and Policy Council) –Andi Lyons, Chair
Chair Lyons reported UPPC will meet on October 25. The Provost and University Registrar will provide
updates at that time.
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Charter Amendment 1314-01A—Dissolution of CAFFECoR:
Chair Wagner said the timing requirements for circulation of the amendment have been fulfilled
and the accompanying report to the amendment resides on the Senate website. The amendment
was brought forth by CAFFECoR and was introduced by the Governance Council. Chair
Wagner reminded Senate members of the rules of debate. Everyone who wished to speak would
be provided an opportunity and the debate would be kept balanced by allowing people to speak
alternately either for or against the amendment. She asked CAFFECoR Chair Fessler to lead the
discussion.
Chair Fessler reminded everyone that the amendment is to eliminate CAFFECoR as a standing
committee but with the opportunity to assemble an ad hoc committee in the future. The proposal
does not suggest that concerns about academic freedom and freedom of speech are dismissed.
She said the role of other entities on campus make the role of CAFFECoR untenable. A debate
on the amendment followed.
Senator Petry spoke and said she respected the work that CAFFECoR members had done on the
amendment and the report. She referred to the statewide UUP delegation which she attended and
discussions took place about Open SUNY and seamless transfer. Senator Petry said campuses
will be confronted with major issues in light of Open SUNY about control of the curriculum and
quality of courses. She added that keeping CAFFECoR in place is a good idea to maintain best
practices.
Senator Fox agreed with Senator Petry’s position. She added that consideration be given to the
original intent of the committee in order to be proactive about upcoming issues like Open SUNY
for purposes of maintaining freedom about what is being taught. Senator Fox said that even
though the Senate is not a policy making body, she did not believe we should cede the right to
make recommendations about campus policy.
Appendix 3
Senator Scheck also agreed with Senators Petry and Fox. She said we have a responsibility to
one another for a mutual understanding among students, faculty and professionals as private
enterprise and new entrepreneurs are invited on campus.
Senator Levy suggested that the Senate could better assess the need of CAFFECoR by having a
better understanding of the functions of the other councils. He inquired as to whether some of
the concerns being expressed could be addressed by other councils. Chair Wagner said she
believed that some issues would fall under existing councils. While the Senate is advisory, we
could make recommendations. As an example, she said UAC could look at issues related to
Open SUNY and online courses, and could bring those concerns to the Senate. UAC Chair
Fogarty agreed. UPPC Chair Lyons said her council would address issues with resource
implications that might be related to Start-Up NY.
Senator Fogarty said that a number of the issues discussed would go before other committee, and
while he shared the concerns previously articulated, there were two important points related to
the justification of maintaining CAFFECoR: 1) CAFFECoR is not tenable or statutory; 2) the
committee has no business to conduct. The committee has had one case in five years. He said
people who serve on CAFFECoR felt they could serve on other councils and offer their services
more productively. Senator Fogarty advocated for an ad hoc committee to address issues that are
beyond academic freedom related to Open SUNY and seamless transfer. Senator Scheck said
UAC’s and UPPC’s concerns are not about academic freedom and freedom of expression. She
added that the power of the Senate is in the recommendation. Senator DeBlasi said if a standing
committee is dedicated to current issues, we need to assure that the agenda is formed in a way to
discuss those issues. An ad hoc committee could be formed with a very clear agenda to address
an issue such as Open SUNY.
As a point of clarification, CAFFECoR Chair Fessler reiterated the charge of CAFFECoR and
read from the Charter the following responsibilities of the committee:
VII.7.3.2.2. CAFFECoR shall be responsible for establishing and interpreting policies
and procedures concerning academic freedom and ethics which shall govern the
conduct of the University community, and also for those matters for which it is given
responsibility by negotiated employment conditions.
Chair Fessler clarified that the body which establishes policy is the University Council.
VII.7.3.2.3. CAFFECoR shall serve as a hearing body available to those members of the
University Community who feel that their freedom of expression has been unfairly
suppressed.
VII.7.3.2.4. CAFFECoR shall be responsible for establishing procedures for
investigating and for oversight of investigation of charges brought against members of
the Faculty as specified in the Faculty Bylaws Article I, Section 2.2.4, except as
determined by CERS to be primarily matters of misconduct in scholarship and research,
or as specified by other University regulations. Issues may be brought to the Chair of
CAFFECoR, who shall then call a meeting as needed.
Appendix 3
Concerning the last two responsibilities related to issues of grievances, Chair Fessler clarified
that procedures outlined in UUP’s contract must be followed and CAFFECoR has no role.
Senator Fox appreciated Chair Fessler’s clarification. She asked if the committee’s charge could
be redefined if the amendment to dissolve CAFFECoR did not pass. Chair Fessler said there
would have to be a motion from a council or individual to define the committee’s charge. Chair
Fessler added that the spirit behind the current amendment is that it’s not advantageous to keep
something in place that is not functioning. As long as it’s in place in the Charter, the Senate is
bound to populating the committee even if it does not do anything. She added that committee
members could be spending their time more productively. Senator Fox then asked if
CAFFECoR were dissolved, could a motion be brought forth to form a new council. Chair
Wagner responded that the Senate could vote to dissolve CAFFECoR and a motion could be
made to form a new council, or if the amendment is voted down, the charge of CAFFECoR
could be changed. Chair Fessler pointed out that since it was a Charter amendment, the rules are
slightly different. Parliamentarian Howard indicated that changes in the charge need to be noted
but an amendment would have to wait another month before conducting a vote. Senator Fox
asked if a friendly amendment could be introduced to the amendment on the floor. Chair
Wagner clarified that changing the charge of CAFFECoR would require a separate Charter
amendment from the one on the floor. Parliamentarian Howard indicated that a vote could not
be conducted until proper notice was given. Senator Fox proposed an amendment to the
amendment on the floor that CAFFECoR return to deliberation and consider how the charge of
the committee could be refocused on issues of academic freedom in the larger and more
philosophical sense. Chair Wagner said the language in the current amendment could not be
changed but the mission of the committee could be changed in a new resolution.
Senator Fogarty recommended that the Senate vote on the amendment on the floor. Further, he
recommended that parties interested in either maintaining the current body or creating a new
body do the required work instead of sending it back to CAFFECoR. Senator Kane suggested
that any new committee or ad hoc committee incorporate academic freedom and freedom of
expression into its charge. Chair Wagner reminded everyone that the amendment on the floor
still required a vote. A motion could be made to have GOV address the issue of creating a new
council but it could not be tied to the amendment on the floor. Debate on a new council and new
charges for CAFFECoR continued briefly. Chair Fogarty called the question to put the
amendment to a vote and the motion was seconded. A vote was conducted with the following
results: Approved: 32; Opposed: 13; Abstained: 4
The vote did not produce the required two-thirds approval of the Senators present as required by
the Senate Charter. Therefore, CAFFECoR remains in place.
NEW BUSINESS
Approval of New Senators:
Appendix 3
Secretary Gulatee reported that Professor Andrei Lapenas from Geography and Planning has
been elected to serve as the new CAS at-large senator. A vote was conducted approving Senator
Lapenas with the following results: Approved: 47; Opposed: 1; Abstained: 0
Approval of Changes in Council Memberships:
Secretary Gulatee reported several changes to the Senate councils comprised mostly of both
undergraduate and graduate student senators. Those changes appear in the document at the end
of these minutes. Council changes were approved with the following voting results: Approved:
46; Opposed: 1; Abstained: 1.
ADJOURNMENT
Chair Wagner requested a motion to adjourn. Before a motion was made, Senator Fox
commented that she appreciated the discussion that took place concerning CAFFECoR. She
added that the type of debate that took place is the purpose of the Senate. A motion to adjourn
was made and seconded and the meeting adjourned
at 3:55 pm.
Respectfully submitted by
Gail Cameron, Recorder
Appendix 3
Changes to Senators and Senate Councils
Senate meeting 10-21-13
Senators:
• Professor Andrei Lapenas (CAS/Geography & Planning)- CAS At –Large
Senator
Council membership changes:
CAA:
• Alam, Bushra – GS S – New Lead Senator replacing Melissa Muratta
• Ramnath, Shireen – UG S
COR:
• Demarco, Tina - GS
GOV:
• Stanwicks, Kabel
LISC:
• Schwab, Emma – UG S
UAC:
• Messmer, Joe – UG S
• Markisello, Daniel – UG S
• DeAngelo, Skyler - UG S
ULC:
• Lapenas, Andrei – Professor (CAS Geo & Pln.)
• Witte, Ryan – UG S
• Martell-Crawford, Cylas – UG S
UPPC:
• Augustin, Stephanie – UG S
Appendix 4
CAFFECoR Activity, FA 2003- SP 2013
AY 2003/04
9/22/2003
Professor Armstrong spoke to Legal Counsel, John Reilly and Associate Vice President for
Student Affairs, Carl Martin regarding
guidelines/policies on freedom
expression on
campus. This was in response to an email from Mr. Martin to Professor Pipkin during the
summer,
asking that go
policy development. One issue involved the distribution of
new spa
pers on campus; the
other issue involved guidelines for holding expressive events on campus. We agreed to
convene CAFE to discuss
these issues. C
who is on (medical) leave, would like to be copied on materials and kept
current on our
discussions. CAFE will have its first meeting on October 2, 2003.
10/27/2003
CAFE is reviewing structures and approval processes for faculty groups in connection with
Resolution 030[4]-02R.
11/3/2003 (continuation of 10/27/2003 meeting) minutes
Resolution 0304-02R, Resolution for Recognition of SUNY Albany Peace and Justice.
Presented by Professors Seidman, Cable, Benjamin, and Wittner. The resolution was moved
and seconded. Professor Seidman introduced the Resolution and explained that it was
developed because SUNY Albany Peace and Justice wanted to seek official recognition by
the University as a group. Discussion followed.
Student Senator Amid asked if the group tried to get Student Association recognition.
Professor Seidman said they need formal recognition as a faculty-based group. Someone
asked for examples of other faculty groups parallel to this group and Professor Seidman
said he is not aware that there are other faculty groups on this Campus. Professor
Armstrong agreed that there are not any to her knowledge, and added that there is no
policy toward the approval of such a group to her knowledge. CAFE has this issue on their
agenda, although they have not made much progress on it yet. Richard Collier suggested
that since there is no mechanism to set this issue, that the Senate should institute one.
Professor MacDonald made an amendment to provisionally accept it as a group and set
precedence and develop rules, she asked CAFE to get back to the Senate on setting rules.
Chair Pryse asked if those proposing the Resolution would accept Professor MacDonald's
suggestion as a friendly amendment to grant provisional resolution, it would be provisional
on CAFE developing rules on status. After some discussion, the amendment was
withdrawn.
Appendix 4
Professor Range asked if CAFE is the only place to consider this, what about ULC? Professor
Armstrong responded that ULC had a full agenda when this first came forward, so the
agreement was that CAFE would first look at it then send it to ULC for code review.
It was noted that in the first paragraph, the word "conduct" should be "contact." Also, the
third and fourth bullets regarding "event planning assistance" and "leadership
development services ..." should be stricken. When asked about how the group proposes to
pay for things, Professor Seidman said the group generates its own funds by donations.
A motion was made to vote on the Resolution with the three amendments. The Resolution
passed with 33 in favor and 5 abstentions.
12/1/2003
CAFE is meeting weekly, focusing on 1) where student newspapers may be displayed on
Campus; 2) policy guidelines for freedom of expression on campus; and 3) the impact of the
Patriot Act on Campus.
12/8/2003
Special Meeting of Full-time Teaching and Library Faculty Senators
Purpose is to elect Faculty Representative Senators to the Presidential Search
Committee
2/9/2004
CAFE has approved a bill designating distribution sites for newspapers on campus, and is
forwarding it to ULC. CAFE is also working on a second bill regarding greater clarification
of freedom of speech and freedom of expression on campus. Upcoming issues are: the
impact of the Patriot Act on campus as regards to surveillance, international students, and
constitutional rights.
3/1/2004
CAFE had its second meeting on the Patriot Act, which was specific to surveillance
implications, there are two more meetings planned on issues with the Patriot Act. Also, an
ad hoc committee of CAFE is working on a bill for freedom of expression on campus.
Professor Armstrong was contacted by the Chair and Co-Chair of the Action Committee of
the Student Senate regarding the return of the Genocide Awareness Project (GAP) to the
campus, which is scheduled for March 22, 2004. There is considerable concern with
undergraduates about this exhibit. She did meet with two student senators and tried to
pass on to them some of the awareness that CAFE gained about freedom of speech; CAFE
will attempt to conduct a forum on freedom of speech prior to the return of GAP on March
22nd.
4/19/2004
CAFE will submit bills on Freedom of Expression and the Newspaper Distribution Policy on
Campus to the Executive Committee at its next meeting. The Council will continue to
discuss the Patriot Act.
5/3/2004
Appendix 4
CAFE discussed the draft resolution to Affirm and Uphold Civil Rights and Civil Liberties at
the University at Albany that Professor Snyder brought to it. CAFE supports it; it will be
presented under “New Business.”
Bill Number 0304-24, Campus Distribution Policy for Newspapers and Other News
Periodicals, introduced by CAFE: Professor Armstrong introduced the bill. The bill
passed unanimously with no abstentions.
Bill Number 0304-25, Campus Policy on Freedom of Expression, introduced by
CAFE: Professor Armstrong introduced the bill and mentioned highlights of the bill, such
as calling for an office to deal with constitutional rights on campus to be designated by the
President, and allowing for a limited forum. A limited forum would “…support
spontaneous expressions and free speech of members of the University community.” The
bill further states that “Such expressions may be permitted by the University, without prior
reservation, only in such area or areas as may be designated by the University and subject
to regulations governing such activities...” After a lengthy discussion about spontaneous
expressions occurring during class sessions and the conflicts that may arise from such
spontaneous expressions, the bill passed 18 to two, with seven abstentions.
0304-08R Resolution on the Patriot Act, introduced by Professor Snyder: Professor
Snyder indicated that CAFE reviewed the resolution and recommends it as a way to protect
the University. The resolution was adapted from the New York City resolution. All were in
favor of passing the resolution with one abstention.
AY 2004/05
10/4/2004
Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and Community
Responsibility (CAFFECoR), Professor Lawrence Snyder, Chair: Professor Snyder
reported that the first meeting of the Committee will take place tomorrow. The Committee
will work with Associate Vice President for Academic Affairs, William Hedberg on the
implementation of two bills passed at last year’s Senate: Campus Distribution Policy for
Newspapers and Other News Periodicals, and the Campus Policy on Freedom of
Expression.
10/25/2004
Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and Community
Responsibility (CAFFECoR), Professor Lawrence Snyder, Chair: CAFFECoR has been
discussing the bill passed last year on freedom of expression and interacting with a
working group to produce recommendations on how that will be implemented. It is also
drafting a new bill on policy for recognition for faculty and staff organizations.
11/15/2004
No report.
Appendix 4
12/6/2004
No report.
2/7/2005
Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and Community
Responsibility (CAFFECoR), Professor Lawrence Snyder, Chair: CAFFECoR met
Thursday, February 4th to work on a "Policy for Recognition of Faculty and Staff
Organizations.” Chair Lawrence Snyder reported that Senate Bill 0304-24, "Campus
Distribution Policy for Newspapers and other News Periodicals" is about to emerge from
the office of Dr. Hedberg. Senate Bill 0303-25 "Campus Policy on Freedom of Expression"
is still being worked on there. Committee members were alerted that SUNY Trustee
Candace de Russy is requesting that the SUNY Board of Trustees endorse the "Academic
Bill of Rights.”
3/14/2005
Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and Community
Responsibility (CAFFECoR), Professor Lawrence Snyder, Chair: CAFFECoR met
Thursday, February 4th to work on a "Policy for Recognition of Faculty and Staff
Organizations.” Chair Lawrence Snyder reported that Senate Bill 0304-24, "Campus
Distribution Policy for Newspapers and other News Periodicals" is about to emerge from
the office of Dr. Hedberg. Senate Bill 0303-25 "Campus Policy on Freedom of Expression"
is still being worked on there. Committee members were alerted that SUNY Trustee
Candace de Russy is requesting that the SUNY Board of Trustees endorse the "Academic
Bill of Rights.”
4/11/2005
CAFFECoR is considering how the university responds to student grievances in matters not
related to academic grades.
5/2/2005
No report given.
2005/06
9/12/2005
No report given
10/10/2005
Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and Community
Responsibility (CAFFECoR), Lawrence Snyder, Chair
CAFFECoR met on September 15th. We have begun an exploration of our procedures to
deal with student grievances on matters other than grades. We will meet at 3:00 PM on
Wednesday, October 19th in A&S 122. Dean Sue Faerman, Student Association President
Mahaliel Bethea, GEO President Elizabeth Redkey and other student leaders will join
CAFFECoR in discussing these matters.
Appendix 4
11/21/2005
At the next meeting of the Executive Committee, CAFFECoR will recommend that an
Undergraduate Ombuds-office be formed. The Committee will also be considering the
“Academic Bill of Rights.”
12/19/2005
L. Snyder reported that they are bringing a resolution today concerning “The Academic Bill
of Rights.”
Senate Resolution 0506-03R. Resolution to Endorse the SUNY-wide Faculty Senate Bill
Opposing the “Academic Bill of Rights”: CAFFECoR: L. Snyder introduced the resolution,
explaining that the issue has been a concern for about a year. He distributed copies of a
document written by David Horowitz, a proponent of the Academic Bill of Rights (ABOR).
The stated justification for ABOR is to protect students from being subjected to ideological
indoctrination in their courses. To gather information on student concerns here on the
Albany campus, members of CAFFECoR met with students and Dean Faerman this fall.
They asked about grievances but did not specifically ask about political indoctrination. The
students did not raise the issue at all, suggesting that this does not appear to be a major
concern to the students. However, CAFFECoR plans to look into creating an Ombudsoffice,
similar to the newly created Graduate Ombudsoffice, to provide guidance to students who
may have grievances. The specific resolution introduced by CAFFECoR calls for an
endorsement of a resolution passed by the SUNY-wide Faculty Senate. The SUNY-wide
Senate has gone on record opposing ABOR on the grounds that there are adequate
protections for academic freedom in place, and that ABOR might actually lead to a greater
politicization of higher education by allowing for interference with curricular decisions
from outside of the academy. Questions were raised about the precise meaning of the
proposed resolution. The bill was passed with an overwhelming majority by a show of
hands.
2/13/2006
CAFFECoR has not met yet this semester. We will schedule a meeting soon.
3/20/2006
No report given.
4/24/2006
CAFFECoR met on March 30, with Bill Hedberg, Michael Jaromin, and Scott Birge, to discuss
the drafting of an Administrative Addendum for University Senate Bill # 0304-25, "Campus
Policy on Freedom of Expression." Michael Jaromin, Director of Student Activities, plans to
draft such an addendum and have it ready for comments by CAFFECoR members by the
end of Spring Break.
5/15/2006
Appendix 4
CAFFECoR met on March 30, with Bill Hedberg, Michael Jaromin, and Scott Birge, to discuss
the drafting of an Administrative Addendum for University Senate Bill # 0304-25, "Campus
Policy on Freedom of Expression." Michael Jaromin, Director of Student Activities, plans to
draft such an addendum and have it ready for comments by CAFFECoR members.
AY 2006/07
9-25-06
Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and Community
Responsibility, (CAFFECoR): Lawrence Snyder, Chair. CAFFECoR is organizing its first
meeting. It will be reviewing the "Guidelines and Procedures for Campus Freedom of
Expression, Protests, Demonstrations" submitted by Michael Jaromin, Director of Student
Activities, University at Albany.
The Governance Task Force on Academic Integrity and Tolerance: Chair Dewar
reported that she met with the Dean of Graduate Studies and the Dean of Undergraduate
Studies, Marjorie Pryse and Sue Faerman respectively, and representatives from the
Student Government. She asked for feedback from Senators; if they would like to see
Senate involvement in this on this Task Force.
10-23-06
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) -- Lawrence Snyder, Chair. CAFFECoR met September 28
with John Murphy and Michael Jaromin, Director of Student Activities, to review the draft
administrative guidelines for the Senate Bill 0304-25, "Campus Policy on Freedom of
Expression".
11-25-06
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and Community
Responsibility) -- Lawrence Snyder, Chair. Nothing to report.
12-18-06
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility): Lawrence Snyder, Chair. The Chair of CAFFECoR met with
Erika Snyder, a reporter for the Albany Student Press, ASP. She will be writing an article
soon on academic freedom, political correctness, and the possible role of CAFFECoR for
undergraduates.
Appendix 4
2-12-07
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility), Lawrence Snyder, Chair: No report.
3-12-07
From the Senate Chair’s Report, by Diane M. Dewar:
• Faculty Forum: Chair Dewar announced the Faculty Forum will be held on
Tuesday, March 27, 2007. The topic will be: Developing an Honor Code at the
University, with a community-type framework. More information is available on the
Senate website.
• Honor Code Committee: Chair Dewar asked for volunteers from the GAC and
CAFFECoR to join the committee.
CAFFECoR did not submit a report.
4-19-07
No report given.
5-14-2007
From the Senate Chair’s Report, by Diane M. Dewar:
• Integrity Issue: The issue of academic integrity will go to CAFFECoR for next year.
CAFFECoR did not submit a report.
AY 2007/08
9-24-2007
Election of Senators:
The following four individuals were nominated by the Senate Executive Committee as
Senators, and will serve as Council Chairs:
CAFFECoR: Sanjay Goel, IT Management, School of Business
Appendix 4
CERS: Zai Liang, Sociology
LISC: Lawrence Raffalovich, Sociology
UAC: Karin Reinhold-Larsson, Mathematics and Statistics
10-22-07
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility), Sanjay Goel, Chair. The committee had and organizational
meeting to plan the agenda for 2007-2008 activities. The committee reviewed the
outstanding issues from the previous year that needed to be completed. Specifically the
committee was interested in reviewing the Diversity Committee Report and the Honor
Code being created at UAlbany and the “Freedom in the Classroom Report” issued by AAUP
in 2007. There was also some sentiment that the issue of performance enhancing drugs in
academics needs to be examined by the committee since misuse of drugs like Ritalin,
Adderall, and Dexedrine was becoming rampant. There are both medical and ethical issues
associated with the misuse of these drugs.
11-26-07
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility), Sanjay Goel, Chair. There is no report.
12-17-07
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Sanjay Goel, Chair. In response to the Report of the
Provosts' Task force on Academic Integrity, CAFFECoR passed a resolution recommending
against the adoption of an “Honor Code” that will be introduced today.
Resolution No. 0708-04: (CAFFECoR) Resolution on Academic Integrity:
The Resolution was introduced by Professor Sherman. There was discussion and a friendly
amendment was made for the Committee to seek results from comparison universities that
have instituted an honor code. After more discussion, that amendment was withdrawn
because it became unclear if the document was a resolution or a report. Another motion
was made to send the document back to the Committee with a charge to review it based
upon feedback from the Senate discussion, and for further clarification. Another motion
was placed on the floor about including students in future discussions. Parliamentarian
Gibson was called upon to organize the process; he cited the rules.
Discussion concluded with a motion to send the proposal back to the committee for review,
include students in that review, and to bring back a report or recommendation to the
Senate. That motion was approved with one opposition and five abstentions.
2-11-08
Appendix 4
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility), Sanjay Goel, Chair. Nothing to report; the committee is
meeting February 22nd.
3-10-08
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility), Sanjay Goel, Chair. The Council met on Friday, February
22, 2008 and discussed two issues: 1) past issue of resolution on academic integrity which
was discussed on the senate floor on December 17, 2007 and sent back to CAFFECoR. The
committee deliberated over the discussions in the senate and concluded that there is no
impact of the honor code on academic freedom. Should an honor code be proposed for
adoption CAFFECoR would be one of the groups that should be consulted. We will consider
converting our resolution to a report to be submitted at a later date. The committee also
started its deliberations on the issue of use of performance enhancing drugs in academics,
such as, Adderall, Ritalin, and Provigal. The deliberations are continuing and are expected
to result in an informative report.
4-14-08
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Sanjay Goel, Chair. CAFFECoR is currently in the process
of investigating the impact of academic performance-enhancing drugs on academic
freedom and community responsibility. On March 14, 2008, Dolores Cimini, Director of
Middle Earth Counseling Center, gave a presentation to the group which highlighted usage
patterns, demographics, and health effects of using drugs such as Adderall, Concerta, and
Ritalin to give a better understanding of the issue. She also discussed what is currently
being done at the University at Albany to assess and deal with students who seem to be
abusing drugs and alcohol, in general - behavior which is found to have similar usage
patterns. Sally D’Alessandro, Associate Director of Conflict Resolution and Civic
Responsibility was also present to offer her perspective in terms of the legal restrictions
and disciplinary actions pertaining to un-prescribed use of such drugs at the University.
While CAFFECoR believes that enforcing legal use is not easy, it should not preclude the
University from taking a position on the issue and alerting the University community to its
existence. The Committee does plan to have future meetings with individuals from the
University Police Department and/or the Disabled Student Services center to gain a better
understanding of the situation before recommending future steps.
5-12-08
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility)-Sanjay Goel, Chair. CAFFECoR is continuing the process of
investigating the impact of academic performance-enhancing drugs on academic freedom
Appendix 4
and community responsibility. At the last meeting on April 18, 2008, John McGuire, one of
the two members of the K-9 Unit in UPD gave an informative presentation on “Narcotics
and Law Enforcement,” which was tailored based on the presentation he normally gives to
Residential Life to focus on stimulants (which most academic performance-enhancing
drugs are). He covered how drugs are obtained around campus, what drugs are being used,
and how student users are discovered and dealt with. In addition, he discussed the
different drug schedules (classifications) based on addictive level, and the effects of illegal
stimulants including amphetamines and methamphetamines compared to more legal
stimulants, e.g. coffee. The committee meeting attendees proposed to begin write-up of a
report calling for individual responsibility and providing access to what the associated
risks are with use of these drugs, as well as discussing recommendations based on
academic research.
AY 2008/09
9-22-08
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) Malcolm Sherman, Chair: The goal is to get a recorder.
10-20-08
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Malcolm Sherman, Chair CAFFECoR has met and
discussed various issues it might wish to address.
11-17-08
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Malcolm Sherman, Chair
CAFFECoR is investigating campus policies on freedom of expression. Our concern was
prompted by the unacceptable (“Red Light”) rating that FIRE, the Foundation for Individual
Rights in Education, gave the campus in its national listing of colleges. FIRE’s rating rests
only on our published standards; FIRE does not allege the rights of any specific individuals
have been violated.
CAFFECoR’s first step is to bring together the various campus policies bearing on freedom
of expression. These can be variously found in the Community Rights and Responsibilities
pamphlet, in the Just Community statement, in rules established by the Office of Diversity &
Affirmative Action, in the “Policy for Freedom of Expression” in the Undergraduate Bulletin,
and in a CAFFECoR statement adopted by the Senate as "Campus Policy on Freedom of
Expression," Bill No. 0304-25.
At least some CAFFECoR members are concerned that while certain statements
unequivocally endorse freedom of expression, other policies imply that First Amendment
Appendix 4
rights can be subordinated to other values. For example, an Office of Diversity &
Affirmative Action pamphlet prohibits “racism,” and adds that “individuals’ rights to free
speech shall be *considered* [emphasis added] in cases involving verbal statements or
other forms of expression.” Does the University have some measure of discretion in
deciding whether to uphold First Amendment rights? In contrast Just Community
principles commit the university to allowing the “free expression of ideas no matter how
outrageous.” But Community Rights and Responsibilities prohibits “.using language that
demonstrates hatred against other persons because of national origin, race, age, religion,
gender, sexual orientation, disability, veteran status, color, creed or marital status.” Also
prohibited are “sexually explicit derogatory statements which are offensive or which cause
the recipient discomfort or humiliation . . . .”
Single instances of such behavior might well be social crimes, but “offensiveness” is not a
constitutionally permitted criterion for punishing speech. The Office of Diversity and
Affirmative Action includes as examples of sexual harassment “sexual jokes or innuendos
and flirtations, e.g., repeated requests for dates.” But it recognizes elsewhere that the legal
standard for harassment is behavior that is “severe, persistent and pervasive.” CAFFECoR
would appreciate input from members of the university community, particularly from
anyone who has ever been threatened with sanctions for statements or actions they see as
protected by the First Amendment. We might eventually propose a campus forum on
freedom of expression on campus.
When a preliminary account of this investigation was reported at the November 3 Senate
Executive Committee meeting it was recalled that, two years ago, then Vice President
Anderson had discussed FIRE’s “red light” rating at an SEC meeting. Some discussion then
ensued, but no records seem to have survived. Dozens of e-mails on this topic have been
circulating among current exec committee members who heard Anderson’s account.
Community Rights & Responsibilities can be found at
http://www.albany.edu/judicial/docs/CRR2007-2010.pdf . It was adopted by University
Council, and is enforced by the Office of Conflict Resolution & Civic Responsibilities.. For the
Just Community Principles see
http://www.albany.edu/undergraduate_bulletin/principles_of_just_community.html. For
rules enforced by Diversity/Affirmative Action see
http://www.albany.edu/affirmative_action/racial_discrimination.html. An August 2002
brochure on Racial Discrimination and Harassment is at
http://www.albany.edu/affirmative_action/racial_discrimination.html. For the
Undergraduate Bulletin’s “Policy for Freedom of Expression” see
http://www.albany.edu/undergraduate_bulletin/regulations.html. The grad bulletin
contains a similar statement. Also relevant is
http://www.albany.edu/research/FreedomofExpression.htm. CAFFECoR’s statement
“Campus Policy on Freedom of Expression,” (unanimously adopted by the Senate) can be
found at http://www.albany.edu/senate/2003-2004_legislation.htm/. FIRE’s web address
is www.thefire.org. For their evaluation of this campus see
http://www.thefire.org/index.php/schools/1120
Appendix 4
12-15-08
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Malcolm Sherman, Chair
CAFFECoR requested the SEC to support a Faculty Forum next semester on campus
freedom of expression policies.
2-09-09
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Malcolm Sherman, Chair
CAFFeCor has not yet met this semester. I expect our next meeting will be devoted to
planning a faculty forum on campus freedom of expression policies.
3-09-09
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Malcolm Sherman, Chair
The committee met February 25 to discuss further planning for the Faculty Forum on
freedom of speech issues.
4-06-09
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Malcolm Sherman, Chair
CAFFECoR will be sponsoring a forum on campus freedom of expression policies on
Thursday evening, April 16 at 7PM in the Campus Center Assembly Hall. Format and
panel members have yet to be finalized.
5-04-09
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Malcolm Sherman, Chair
CAFFECoR met on Wednesday April 29 to discuss the impact of the forum on freedom of
expression and to assess what next steps might be considered (by next year's CAFFECoR).
We expect the issues we raised to be on the agenda of the University Council (which must
approve any changes to Community Rights and Responsibilities). At the forum Susanna
Fessler showed that our harassment standards were very similar to those which a federal
appeals court overturned at Temple University. We have reason to believe our attorneys
have been asked to look into this matter. The Committee hopes to have a recorder next year.
Appendix 4
AY 2009/10
9-21-09
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Susanna Fessler, Chair
CAFFECoR had its organizational meeting on September 2. Susanna Fessler was elected
chair for the ’09—’10 year. Agenda items for the ’09-’10 year were also discussed. There
are, in essence, two holdover issues: the inconsistencies of campus policies on speech, and
the "Red Light" rating given to our campus by the Foundation for Individual Rights in
Education (FIRE). The Committee agreed that these “holdover” issues should remain on our
agenda this year, and that involving university counsel and the President’s office would be
a good first step.
A third, new issue for CAFFECoR in ’09-‘10 was presented: it is unclear whether both
students and faculty/staff operate under ONE campus policy on conduct or if there are two
PARALLEL policies, perhaps with slight differences. In other words, we may have a double-
standard in place. Further investigation should reveal whether this is an area of concern.
10-19-09
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Susanna Fessler, Chair
The committee continues to collect data and materials to resolve the problem of conflicting
freedom-of-speech policies on campus. It appears that Senate Bill 0304-25, which was
passed by the Senate, was not reviewed at the Presidential level, and we propose that this
happen this year.
CAFFECoR met on Monday, October 12th to discuss the following issues: 1) A recent report
in the ASP about students’ freedom of speech being restricted in the residence halls, 2) Our
efforts to unite the policies on campus between the offices of Affirmative Action, Student
Success, and the Senate, and 3) the drafting of formal procedures should a university
community member ask for CAFFECoR’s assistance in a case of speech code. Nothing
formal has been drafted apropos of these issues, but each has been delegated to committee
members.
11-16-09
Appendix 4
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Susanna Fessler, Chair
We continue to work on bringing policy into a cohesive whole. We’ve also been asked by
Student Success to do an “in-service” for students/young professional staff in the Residence
Halls on First Amendment issues, especially as they might pertain to the issues they face on
a daily basis. This event will probably take place in the Spring 2010 semester.
CAFFECoR met on Monday, November 9th to discuss the revisions to the Community Rights
and Responsibilities document. This document is revised every three years, and the current
version "expires" in 2010. The Vice President for Student Success will work with CAFFECoR
on these revisions. Our intent is to bring the document in line with current New York State
law and practice.
12-14-09
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Susanna Fessler, Chair
CAFFECoR met on November 9th to discuss revision of the Community Rights and
Responsibilities (CRR) document. At this point we have a compiled version of the CRR with
member suggestions and await final member approval before it is forwarded to Student
Success and Conflict Resolution for their review. Of note is that, in the course of inputting
suggested changes, the chair of CAFFECoR has noted sections which are pertinent to ULC
and LISC also. For example, if the CAFFECoR changes take effect, one part of the policy on
computer usage (LISC’s purview) would also have to be changed. The electronic version of
the revised CRR draft has been circulated to SEC members, but the chair of CAFFECoR
would like to emphasize that this draft has not yet been finalized by CAFFECoR.
Constructive criticism is welcome. CAFFECoR will meet one last time this semester on
Monday, December 14th to finish reviewing changes to the CRR.
Chair Fessler reported that CAFFECoR met earlier today and finalized revisions to the
Community Rights and Responsibilities document. The document will be forwarded to
Student Success next week.
2-8-10
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Susanna Fessler, Chair
We continue to work on changes to the "Community Rights and Responsibilities"
document. We are also waiting on whether Senate bill 0304-25, which was passed by the
Senate but never signed by the president in 2004, then resuscitated by CAFFECoR this year,
Appendix 4
will be signed by the president. Some CAFFECoR members will be conducting an "in
service" session for Res Life staff in the dorms on Wednesday, February 10 on the subject
of Freedom of Speech in the dorms.
3-8-10
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Susanna Fessler, Chair
Two members of CAFFECoR conducted an “in service” training session for the Res Life
professional staff on Wednesday, February 10th. The topic was free speech in the residence
halls: what defines it, how to handle borderline situations, and ways to engage the student
body in meaningful dialogue that promotes both free speech and diversity. A follow-up
session took place with the student staff.
4-12-10
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Susanna Fessler, Chair
CAFFECoR has submitted the following bill to today’s Senate meeting recommending:
DELETION OF “PRINCIPLES FOR A JUST COMMUNITY” FROM UNIVERSITY
DOCUMENTS
IT IS HEREBY PROPOSED THAT THE FOLLOWING BE ADOPTED:
The “Principles for a Just Community” statement be removed from the Community Rights
and Responsibilities
That the Bill be forwarded to the President for approval and implementation.
BACKGROUND:
The “Principles of a Just Community” statement was first approved by the Senate in 89-90.
A revision was last made in 00-01. The initial rationale for the 89-90 bill was not explicitly
included therein, but seems to have been an administrative response to off-campus
incidents in the New York City area. The revisions in 00-01 were sponsored by ULC; the
background section of that bill stated that “There have been requests for minor revisions to
this document. In response to those requests, the University Life Council reviewed it and
approved the proposed revisions.”
The 89-90 bill proposed that the “’Principles for a Just Community’ be endorsed by the
University Senate, and that these principles be included in all appropriate publications and
otherwise disseminated throughout the University Community.” Consequently, the PJC
currently appears, among other places, at the front of the “Community Rights and
Responsibilities” and the Undergraduate Bulletin.
Appendix 4
In a recent review of the “Principles of a Just Community” as a part of a comprehensive
review of the “Community Rights and Responsibilities,” CAFFECoR discovered a number of
passages in the former which conflicted with the text in the latter. For example, the
“Principles of a Just Community” states, “the University must allow the free expression of
ideas, no matter how outrageous” whereas the CRR states, “The University at Albany
strives to protect all members of the University at Albany community by prosecuting bias
or hate crimes that occur within the campus jurisdiction” where “bias or hate crimes” are
defined as “Engaging in behaviors or using language that demonstrate hatred or bias
against other persons because of national origin, ethnicity, race, age, religion, gender,
sexual orientation, disability, veteran status, color, creed, or marital status.”
Moreover, CAFFECoR found that on occasion the PJC seemed to contradict itself. For
example, one passage states “…this academic community…must…be just. There is no
definitive theory of justice.”
In sum, CAFFECoR was concerned that these passages would cause confusion among
students and other members of the university community. After careful consideration,
CAFFECoR decided that any attempted revisions of the “Principles of a Just Community”
would only further complicate the document. And, because freedom of speech is already
addressed elsewhere in the CRR, the best solution was to delete PJC from CRR.
The members of CAFFECoR would like to stress that this action is not tantamount to
eliminating the concept of justice, or the importance of justice, on this campus.
Rather, this action is an attempt to clarify campus policy for the entire community.
The PJC will remain on other university documents, unless another Senate Council or
Committee proposes otherwise.
Community Rights and Responsibilities:
CAFFECoR Chair Fessler introduced the bill which is a straight forward proposal to remove
the Principles of a Just Community (PJC) section from the Community Rights and
Responsibilities (CRR) document. CAFFECoR is not proposing that PJC be removed from
any other documents at this time.
There was a brief discussion concerning the aspirational principles of PJC. John Murphy,
who worked with the Committee that formulated PJC, said those principles were viewed as
essential ingredients of justice at that time. Chair Fessler responded that members of
CAFFECoR were concerned with the lack of clarity of PJC as it pertains to CRR. There was
no further discussion on the bill. A motion to approve the bill was made and seconded, and
the bill was passed.
5-10-10
Appendix 4
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Susanna Fessler, Chair
The Chair of CAFFECoR met with the Vice President for Student Success on Tuesday, May 4
to go over the final revisions to the “Community Rights and Responsibilities” document. All
CAFFECoR suggestions and concerns have been addressed with one exception—the policy
on internet usage is still under revision by the Chief Information Officer. To make the CRR
more user friendly, however, Student Success plans to re-format the document with links
to pertinent campus offices and policies. When that is done, the part of the CRR that
addresses internet usage will link to ITS (instead of reiterating the ITS policy verbatim).
The University Council will consider the new CRR draft at its next meeting.
AY 2010/11
9-27-10
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Pradeep Haldar, Chair
Nothing to Report
10-18-10
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Pradeep Haldar, Chair
The CAFFECoR Committee met and discussed agenda items to pursue for the next academic
year. This included follow-up from last year on items such as the Community Rights and
Responsibilities document, Affirmative Action Website, and Organizing a Residence Hall
Workshop related to Freedom of Speech and Expression. We also discussed the survey
request from SUNY University Faculty Senate and campus budget issues.
Also in the Minutes for that date, from Senate Chair Eric Lifshin’s Report:
“On Oct 12 Chair Lifshin met with Chairs Leonard of ULC and Haldar of CAFFEEoR, Vice-
Provost Faerman, and Associate VP, Miriam Trementozzi and Dean Robert Bangert-Drowns
who co-chair the Committee on University-Community Engagement to discuss possible
Senate involvement in community engagement activities. Such a relationship is consistent
with achieving a Carnegie designation in community engagement, which is viewed as both
Appendix 4
the right thing to do and beneficial to the status of UAlbany. It was agreed that Associate
VP Trementozzi will give a 15 minute presentation to a future SEC meeting both to provide
an overview of community engagement activities and to discuss how other university
senates are approaching this opportunity.”
11-15-10
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Pradeep Haldar, Chair
Response to President’s request on budget cuts: This does not appear to be an activity
directly related to the mission of CAFFECoR, however, if there are any affects on Academic
Freedom of Freedom of Expression, the committee will be ready to take-up the case.
The committee has reviewed a request that indicated a student’s freedom of speech may
have been violated. However, after careful review, the committee felt this was not the case
and didn’t find it necessary to pursue. The committee is following up on the Community
Rights & Responsibilities Document.
12-13-10
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Pradeep Haldar, Chair
Committee is considering introducing bill on CRR document.
Workshop on Freedom of Expression for students is being organized in Residence Hall
during the middle of January.
Survey on ethics forwarded by provost was completed and submitted.
UAC (Undergraduate Academic Council) – JoAnne Malatesta, Chair
The UAC continues to meet each Wednesday. There has been continued discussion about
the use and retention of the Violation of Academic Integrity Reports. The Council has
agreed that it would be most productive to establish an ad hoc committee to review this
policy and will be inviting the GAC to join this committee as it directly impacts both
graduate and undergraduate students.
Chair Malatesta reported that UAC will be discussing issues related to the faculty integrity
report and how the report is utilized. GAC and CAFFECoR should be part of the
discussion as well.
Appendix 4
2-14-11
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Pradeep Haldar, Chair
Next meeting is scheduled for last week in February.
GAC (Graduate Academic Council) – Laurence Kranich, Chair
GAC met on January 24 to continue its consideration of CAA program assessments. In
addition, the Council was informed by the Dean of Graduate Studies that the graduate
student support allocations for 2011-12 have been made. All programs have been
adversely affected. The average budget cut across departments was 15%. The Chair of
GAC’s Committee on Educational Policy and Procedure will serve on an ad hoc joint
committee of UAC, GAC, CAFFECoR and Graduate Studies to review the violation of
academic integrity policies. Finally, the Council resumed its discussion of CAA
assessments at its meeting on February 11.
3-14-11
No report.
4-11-11
No report.
5-9-11
No report.
AY 2011/12
9-26-11
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Aran Mull, Chair
CAFFE-CoR held its first meeting September 19th. Chair Mull reported the Committee
received a complaint this week and will develop policy and procedure for moving a
solution forward.
Appendix 4
10-24-11
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Aran Mull, Chair
The committee held our first meeting on September 19th. The committee will be
addressing development of committee policy and procedure for managing complaints
received (none currently exists), re-introduction of a bill addressing the Principals of a Just
Community language and continuing training with Residential Life staff on freedom of
expression issues. A meeting schedule has been forwarded to Gail Cameron for publication
to the Senate web site. On September 22nd CAFFE-CoR received a complaint. A committee
is being formed to address the complaint.
11-21-11
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Aran Mull, Chair
CAFFECoR met on October 17th and will be forwarding a bill to remove the Principles for a
Just Community language from remaining University documentation following a final
determination regarding what publications still include that language. The committee is
moving forward with the development of a policy and guidelines for managing complaints
brought before the committee and has asked University Counsel to determine whether they
may advise the committee regarding policy development.
12-12-11
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Aran Mull, Chair
The committee met last on November 14th. A bill to remove the “Principles for a Just
Community” statement from all University documentation was completed and forwarded
for the consideration of the SEC. The University Counsel has offered the opinion that they
may not act in an advisory capacity and we are reviewing our options regarding the current
complaint as well as enacting complaint management guidelines for the committee going
forward.
2-6-12
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Aran Mull, Chair
Appendix 4
Three training sessions were held with the Department of Residential Life staff addressing
First Amendment and Academic Freedom issues in the residential hall environment.
Senate Bill 1112-08: “Principles for a Just Community” Statement—Removal from
University Documents (CAFFECoR)
CAFFECoR Chair Mull discussed the bill and provided background information. In 2010
CAFFECoR proposed that Principles of Just Community (PJC) be removed from the
Community Rights and Responsibilities (CRR). President Philip declined to sign the bill but
asked that reconsideration be given to remove PJC be removed from all University
documents. PJC was removed from CRR at the time. The bill being presented today
addresses the concerns of the President. There was no further discussion. The bill was put
to a vote and approved with the following results: Approved: 39; Opposed: 14; Abstained:
7.
3-5-12
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Aran Mull, Chair
CAFFE-CoR met Monday, February 13th to continue work on a draft complaint management
process. Edits completed in the meeting have been compiled and forwarded to the
committee membership
4-2-12
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Aran Mull, Chair
The committee met on March 12th to review the revised Responsible Use of Information
Technology policy and continued work on the committee’s policy for managing complaints
brought to the committee.
4-30-12
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Aran Mull, Chair
The committee met on March 12th to review the revised Responsible Use of Information
Technology policy and continued work on the committee’s policy for managing complaints
brought to the committee.
Appendix 4
Chair Mull reported he was able to find a document from 1973 outlining procedure for
CAFFECoR to handle a complaint. The document will be posted on CAFFECoR’s web page.
LISC (Council on Libraries, Information Systems, and Computing) – Nancy Newman,
Chair
LISC met on April 2 with Susanna Fessler to discuss the advisability of sending the revised
"Responsible Use of IT" Policy to the Senate. It was agreed that such a policy falls under the
purview of LISC and should be forwarded to the Senate as a Bill when the revisions are
completed. The IT Committee will meet again about the Policy after receiving input from
CAFFECoR and University Counsel. Mary Casserly reported that the Library is beginning to
fill vacant positions and that the first stage of renovations (as part of the UA campus plan)
is advancing.
5-14-12
No report.
AY 2012/13
9-24-12
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Leslie Saint-Vil, Chair
Susanna Fessler, a member of CAFFECoR, reported in Chair Saint-Vil’s absence. The
committee met once but did not have a quorum. The committee will be revisiting an issue
from last year concerning guidelines on how CAFFECoR handles a complaint. The current
language is over 25 years old.
10-22-12
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Leslie Saint-Vil, Chair
Yet again, CAFFECoR has nothing to report. I hope to have something to report in the near
future.
Senator Fessler, a member of CAFFECoR, reported that the committee met last week. The
committee is tracing its history to define its charge and role.
11-19-12
Appendix 4
No report.
In discussion of the proposed Writing Program Proposal put forward by UAC, “Senator
Griffith commended the initiative to improve undergraduate writing but had concerns
about the hiring of 14-15 lecturers. In the context of academic freedom they would be
considered contingent labor. Senator Griffith said the lecturers would be integrated with
full time faculty without voting rights. He also had concerns about positions being non-
tenure track. He recommended that CAFFECoR give this consideration. ”
12-17-12
No report.
2-11-13
No report.
3-11-13
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Leslie Saint-Vil, Chair
We will be meeting on March 4th at 2:45.
Senator Fessler reported that the council met last week. The committee reviewed its
description in the Charter and discussed its changes since the committee was established
under the previous Bylaws. The committee will approach the SEC to discuss potential
dissolution of the committee in the future.
4-08-13
CAFFECoR (Committee on Academic Freedom, Freedom of Expression, and
Community Responsibility) – Leslie Saint-Vil, Chair
Senator Fessler reported that at the request of the SEC, CAFFECoR is in the process of
circulating a proposal for its dissolution. Once completed, the proposal will be sent to the
SEC.
4-29-13
Appendix 4
GOV (Governance Council) – Christine Wagner, Chair
GOV met on 4/1/13. GOV discussed procedures for conducting a vote on an amendment to
the Faculty Bylaws regarding the process by which items are placed on the Senate agenda.
This amendment was passed by GOV and approved by the SEC in the fall of 2012. An
electronic vote of all voting faculty will be conducted via MyUAlbany in the coming weeks.
GOV continued a discussion regarding Section XI: IRCUAP of the Senate Charter. UAC Chair,
Rick Fogarty attended the GOV meeting to discuss procedures by which courses and
programs come through UAC. A motion that Section XI: IRCUAP had been erroneously
inserted into the Charter and should be removed was carried unanimously. This motion
was presented to and supported by the SEC on 4/15/13. Elections for Senators-at-large,
SUNY Senators and UAS Board members were conducted on MyUAlbany the week of 4/1-
4/7. The Committee on Council Nominations has been formed and will meet on 4/24/13 to
constitute the Senate Councils and Committees for next year. This will be presented to the
Senate for approval on 4/29/13. GOV will meet again on 4/22/13.
Chair Wagner announced the upcoming dates of the vote for the Bylaws Amendment. The
online election will be held May 1 through May 10. She reviewed the instructions for
voting through MyUAlbany. At its last meeting, GOV discussed the dissolving of CAFFECoR
and voted unanimously to dissolve the committee. Chair Wagner will present the motion to
the SEC.
5-13-13
GOV (Governance Council) – Christine Wagner, Chair
GOV met on 4/22/13. GOV discussed the report from CAFFECoR recommending the
dissolution of CAFFECoR as a standing committee of the Senate Executive Committee.
Senator Susanna Fessler attended GOV as a guest as a representative from CAFFECoR.
Senator Fessler explained that all as a body, CAFFECoR has no authority and is not
recognized by General Counsel. In addition, all faculty, staff and student grievances can now
be addressed and resolved elsewhere. GOV passed a motion that a GOV ad hoc
subcommittee be formed to draft a Senate Charter Amendment proposing the dissolution
of CAFFECoR and that Section VII.7.3 be removed from the Charter. GOV, upon the request
of the Senate Officers, reviewed the Bylaws Article II. Section 6 – Senate Councils and
Committees and interpreted term limits on Councils to be 3 consecutive terms on a single
Council. Following the third term on a Council, membership on another Council in the next
year is permitted. A vote on the Faculty Bylaws Amendment 1213-01BA will take place on
MyUAlbany from May 1-10. The Committee on Council Nominations will meet on 4/24/13.
The Call for Nominations for Vice Chair of the Senate was distributed by email to all Voting
Faculty on 4/4/13 with a deadline for nominations of 4/22/13. GOV will meet again on
5/6/13 for its final meeting of the academic year.
Chair Wagner reported GOV met on May 6 and considered a draft of a Charter amendment
to dissolve CAFFECoR. The amendment will be presented to the SEC in the fall. Senate
Appendix 4
councils have been meeting this week to elect chairs for the 2013-2014 year. The process
is expected to be completed by the end of the week.
Appendix 5
Academic Freedom
and Educational Responsibility
A STATEMENT FROM THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF AACU
1818 R Street, NW, Washington, DC 20009
www.aacu.org
Copyright © 2006 by the Association of American Colleges and Universities. Permission to
photocopy is granted for
non-commercial use. The following credit line must appear on the first page of every copy:
“Reprinted with permission.
Copyright 2006 by the Association of American Colleges and Universities.” For excerpts,
the following credit line must
be used: “Excerpted with permission from Academic Freedom and Educational
Responsibility. Copyright 2006 by the
Association of American Colleges and Universities.”
ISBN 0-9763576-9-0
Academic Freedom and Educational Responsibility is available for download (in PDF
format) from www.aacu.org.
Printed copies are available for purchase from AAC&U; discounted rates are available for
bulk orders of ten copies or
more. For additional information or to place an order, visit www.aacu.org, e-mail
pub_desk@aacu.org, or call
202.387.3760.
Association
of American
Colleges and
Universities
Contents
Preface. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . iii
Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . v
Academic Freedom and Educational Responsibility . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1
Intellectual Diversity and the Indispensable Role of Liberal Education . . . . . . . . . 2
What Is Not Required in the Name of Intellectual Diversity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
Academic Freedom and Scholarly Community . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
Intellectual Diversity and the Development of Judgment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
Teaching Students to Form Their Own Judgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5
The Ideal Versus the Real . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7
Chair
Ronald A. Crutcher
President, Wheaton College
Past Chair
Appendix 5
Elisabeth A. Zinser
President, Southern Oregon University
Vice Chair
Robert A. Corrigan
President, San Francisco State University
Treasurer
R. Stanton Hales
President, The College of Wooster
President of AAC&U
Carol Geary Schneider
Ex Officio/Chair, ACAD
Virginia M. Coombs
Provost and Vice Chancellor for Academic Affairs
University of Wisconsin – River Falls
Sharon Stephens Brehm
Senior Advisor to the President, Indiana University
Anthony Carnevale
Senior Fellow, National Center on Education and the
Economy
Christopher C. Dahl
President, State University of New York College at
Geneseo
John J. DeGioia
President, Georgetown University
Rosemary DePaolo
Chancellor, University of North Carolina at
Wilmington
Bobby Fong
President, Butler University
Kati Haycock
Director, The Education Trust
Richard H. Hersh
Senior Fellow, Council for Aid to Education
Shirley S. Kenny
President, State University of New York at Stony Brook
Elaine P. Maimon
Chancellor, University of Alaska Anchorage
Gary Orfield
Professor of Education and Social Policy, Harvard
University
Appendix 5
Eduardo J. Padron
District President, Miami Dade College
Thomas L. “Les” Purce
President, The Evergreen State College
Arnold Rampersad
Senior Associate Dean for the Humanities, Stanford
University
Jamienne S. Studley
President, Public Advocates, Inc.
Daniel F. Sullivan
President, St. Lawrence University
Beverly Daniel Tatum
President, Spelman College
Carolyn G. Williams
President, City University of New York Bronx
Community College
Academic Freedom and Educational Responsibility was approved by the 2005 Board of
Directors of
the Association of American Colleges and Universities:
iii
Preface
On behalf of the Association of American Colleges and Universities (AAC&U), we are
pleased to
present Academic Freedom and Educational Responsibility. This statement, framed and
approved by
AAC&U’s board of directors, is designed to provide the larger context missing from
current public
debates about intellectual diversity in undergraduate education. It addresses many of the
myths and
misrepresentations that have been perpetuated through the insistent external campaign to
encourage
political oversight of teaching and learning practices on college and university campuses. In
particular,
the statement clarifies the vital role of diverse perspectives in helping students develop
their
own knowledge and intellectual capacities.
Self-appointed political critics of the academy have presented equal representation for
conservative
and progressive points of views as the key to quality. But the college classroom is not a talk
show.
Appendix 5
Rather, it is a dedicated context in which students and teachers seriously engage difficult
and contested
questions with the goal of reaching beyond differing viewpoints to a critical evaluation of
the
relative claims of different positions. Central to the educational aims and spirit of academic
freedom,
diversity of perspectives is a means to an end in higher education, not an end in itself.
Including diversity is a step in the larger quest for new understanding and insight. But an
overemphasis
on diversity of perspectives as an end in itself threatens to distort the larger responsibilities
of intellectual work in the academy.
In publishing Academic Freedom and Educational Responsibility, we invite college and
university
leaders to use it actively to inform public and campus discussions about the academy’s role
in both
exploring the contentious issues of our time and providing contexts for civil dialogue and
constructive
inquiry. This statement can be used to good effect in any number of contexts, including
discussions—
with trustees and regents, with faculty and departments, with administrators and staff, and
especially
with students—about the educational principles at stake in the academic freedom debate.
Robert A. Corrigan
Chair of the Board of Directors
Carol Geary Schneider
President
v
Acknowledgments
The Board of Directors of the Association of American Colleges and Universities extends its
warm
thanks to Dr. Jerry Gaff, senior scholar at AAC&U, for his work in bringing this statement
from
concept to completion. The board further thanks the many colleagues from member
colleges and
universities and from sister organizations who responded to earlier drafts.
In framing this statement, the board has drawn on concepts that were first articulated in
the
1991 publication The Challenge of Connecting Learning, which was crafted by members of
the
Appendix 5
national advisory committee for an Association of American Colleges (now AAC&U)
initiative on
liberal learning and “study-in-depth.”
Challenge was written by Jonathan Z. Smith, the Robert O. Anderson Distinguished
Professor of
the Humanities at the University of Chicago. The board thanks Professor Smith and the
other members
of the national advisory committee for their leadership and vision. AAC&U’s work on
study-indepth
was supported by generous grants from the Ford Foundation and the U. S. Fund for the
Improvement of Postsecondary Education.
The board also acknowledges AAC&U’s signal debt to William S. Perry Jr. of Harvard
University,
whose landmark work on the study of students’ intellectual and ethical development in the
college
years helped illuminate the importance of these issues for a generation of faculty members,
student
affairs leaders, and researchers on student learning. The board thanks Dr. Lee
Knefelkamp, professor
of psychology and education at Teachers College, Columbia University, and senior scholar
at
AAC&U, for her assistance in shaping this statement and for her leadership in making
students’
intellectual and ethical development a core theme in AAC&U’s work on the aims and
outcomes of
student learning in college.
Finally, the board thanks David Tritelli, AAC&U’s senior academic editor, and Darbi
Bossman,
AAC&U’s print production manager and graphic designer, for their expert assistance in
bringing
the statement to publication.
1
Association of American Colleges and Universities
Academic freedom and responsibility have long been topics for public concern and debate.
Academic
freedom to explore significant and controversial questions is an essential precondition to
fulfill the
academy’s mission of educating students and advancing knowledge. Academic
responsibility requires
Appendix 5
professors to submit their knowledge and claims to rigorous and public review by peers
who are
experts in the subject matter under consideration; to ground their arguments in the best
available
evidence; and to work together to foster the education of students. The Association of
American
Colleges and Universities (AAC&U), in concert with the American Association of
University
Professors, helped establish the principles of academic freedom early in the twentieth
century, and
recently AAC&U joined with other associations to reaffirm them.*
Today, new challenges to academic freedom have arisen from both the right and the left.
On the
right, conservative activist David Horowitz, founder of Students for Academic Freedom,
has fashioned
an “academic bill of rights” that is being considered in several states ostensibly as a means
of
protecting “conservative” students from alleged indoctrination by the purportedly
“liberal” views of
faculty. This bill inappropriately invites political oversight of scholarly and educational
work. On the
left, anti-war protests by students have interrupted speeches by proponents of current
national policies.
Some protestors have sought to silence—rather than debate—positions with which they do
not
agree. These challenges prompt AAC&U to revisit the basic principles involved and to
discuss the
role of academic freedom.
There is, however, an additional dimension of academic freedom that was not well
developed in
the original principles, and that has to do with the responsibilities of faculty members for
educational
programs. Faculty are responsible for establishing goals for student learning, for designing
and
implementing programs of general education and specialized study that intentionally
cultivate the
intended learning, and for assessing students’ achievement. In these matters, faculty must
work collaboratively
with their colleagues in their departments, schools, and institutions as well as with relevant
Appendix 5
administrators. Academic freedom is necessary not just so faculty members can conduct
their
individual research and teach their own courses, but so they can enable students—through
whole college
programs of study—to acquire the learning they need to contribute to society.
As faculty carry out this mission, it is inevitable that students will encounter ideas, books,
and people that challenge their preconceived ideas and beliefs. The resulting tension
between
* The Association of American Colleges (now the Association of American Colleges and
Universities) began work on this
issue in the early 1920s. Then, through a series of joint conferences begun in 1934,
representatives of the American
Association of University Professors and of the Association of American Colleges
established the principles set forth in
the 1940 Statement of Principles on Academic Freedom and Tenure. In 2005, the
Association of American Colleges and
Universities, along with twenty-eight other higher education organizations, endorsed
Academic Rights and Responsibilities,
the American Council on Education’s statement on intellectual diversity on college and
university campuses.
Academic Freedom and
Educational Responsibility
2
Academic Freedom and Educational Responsibility
the faculty’s freedom to teach—individually and collectively—and the students’ freedom to
form
independent judgments opens an additional dimension of academic freedom and
educational
responsibility that deserves further discussion, both with the public and with students
themselves.
The clash of competing ideas is an important catalyst, not only for the expansion of
knowledge but
also in students’ development of independent critical judgment. Recognizing this dynamic,
many wellintentioned
observers underline the importance of “teaching all sides of the debate” in college
classrooms.
Teaching the debates is important but by no means sufficient. It is also essential that
faculty
help students learn—through their college studies—to engage differences of opinion,
evaluate evidence,
Appendix 5
and form their own grounded judgments about the relative value of competing
perspectives. This too
is an essential part of higher education’s role both in advancing knowledge and in
sustaining a society
that is free, diverse, and democratic.
Intellectual Diversity and the Indispensable Role of Liberal Education
In any education of quality, students encounter an abundance of intellectual diversity—
new knowledge,
different perspectives, competing ideas, and alternative claims of truth. This intellectual
diversity
is experienced by some students as exciting and challenging, while others are confused and
overwhelmed
by the complexity. Liberal education, the nation’s signature educational tradition, helps
students
develop the skills of analysis
and critical inquiry with particular
emphasis on exploring and evaluating
competing claims and different
perspectives. With its emphasis on
breadth of knowledge and sophisticated
habits of mind, liberal education
is the best and most powerful
way to build students’ capacities to
form their own judgments about complex or controversial questions. AAC&U believes that
all students
need and deserve this kind of education, regardless of their academic major or intended
career.
Liberal education involves more than the mind. It also involves developing students’
personal
qualities, including a strong sense of responsibility to self and others. Liberally educated
students
are curious about new intellectual questions, open to alternative ways of viewing a situation
or
problem, disciplined to follow intellectual methods to conclusions, capable of accepting
criticism
from others, tolerant of ambiguity, and respectful of others with different views. They
understand
and accept the imperative of academic honesty. Personal development is a very real part of
intellectual development.
Appendix 5
Beyond fostering intellectual and personal development, a liberal education also enables
students
to develop meaning and commitments in their lives. In college they can explore different
ways to
relate to others, imagine alternative futures, decide on their intended careers, and consider
their
larger life’s work of contributing to the common good.
Building such intellectual and personal capacities is the right way to warn students of the
inappropriateness
and dangers of indoctrination, help them see through the distortions of propaganda,
All competing ideas on a subject do not
deserve to be included in a course or
program, or to be regarded as equally
valid just because they have been asserted.
3
and enable them to assess judiciously the persuasiveness of powerful emotional appeals.
Emphasizing
the quality of analysis helps students see why unwelcome views need to be heard rather
than
silenced. By thoughtfully engaging diverse perspectives, liberal education leads to greater
personal
freedom through greater competence. Ensuring that college students are liberally educated
is essential
both to a deliberative democracy and to an economy dependent on innovation.
What Is Not Required in the Name of Intellectual Diversity?
There are several misconceptions about intellectual diversity and academic freedom, and
we address
some of them here.
1 In an educational community, freedom of speech, or the narrower concept of academic
freedom, does not mean the freedom to say anything that one wants. For example, freedom
of speech does not mean that one can say something that causes physical danger to
others. In a learning context, one must both respect those who disagree with oneself
and also maintain an atmosphere of civility. Anything less creates a hostile environment
that limits intellectual diversity and, therefore, the quality of learning.
2 Students do not have a right to remain free from encountering unwelcome or
“inconvenient
questions,” in the words of Max Weber. Students who accept the literal truth of creation
narratives do not have a right to avoid the study of the science of evolution in a
biology course; anti-Semites do not have a right to a history course based on the premise
that the Holocaust did not happen. Students protesting their institution’s sale of clothing
Appendix 5
made in sweatshops do not have a right to interrupt the education of others. Students do
have a right to hear and examine diverse opinions, but within the frameworks that
knowledgeable
scholars—themselves subject to rigorous standards of peer review—have determined
to be reliable and accurate. That is, in considering what range of views should be
introduced and considered, the academy is guided by the best knowledge available in the
community of scholars.
3 All competing ideas on a subject do not deserve to be included in a course or program, or
to
be regarded as equally valid just because they have been asserted. For example,
creationism,
even in its modern guise as “intelligent design,” has no standing among experts in the life
sciences because its claims cannot be tested by scientific methods. However, creationism
and
intelligent design might well be studied in a wide range of other disciplinary contexts such
as
the history of ideas or the sociology of religion.
4 While the diversity of topics introduced in a particular area of study should illustrate the
existence of debate, it is not realistic to expect that undergraduate students will have the
opportunity to study every dispute relevant to a course or program. The professional
judgment
of teachers determines the content of courses.
Association of American Colleges and Universities
Academic Freedom and Scholarly Community
A college or university is a dedicated social place where a variety of competing claims to
truth can be
explored and tested, free from political interference. The persons who drive the production
of knowledge
and the process of education are highly trained professors, and they, through an elaborate
process
of review by professional peers, take responsibility as a community for the quality of their
scholarship,
teaching, and student learning. Trustees, administrators, policy makers, and other
stakeholders also
have important roles to play, but the faculty and their students stand at the center of the
enterprise.
The development of a body of knowledge involves scientists or other scholars in developing
their
best ideas and then subjecting them to empirical tests and/or searching scholarly criticism.
Appendix 5
Knowledge is not simply a matter of making an assertion but of developing the evidence for
that
assertion in terms that gain acceptance among those with the necessary training and
expertise to
evaluate the scholarly analysis. In order to contribute to knowledge, scholars require the
freedom to
pursue their ideas wherever they lead, unconstrained by political, religious, or other
dictums. And
scholars need the informed criticism of peers who represent a broad spectrum of insight
and experience
in order to build a body of knowledge.
One of the great strengths of higher education in the United States is the integration of
scholarly
research and educational communities. Students benefit enormously when their learning is
guided
by thoughtful and knowledgeable scholars who come from diverse backgrounds and who
are trained
to high levels in a variety of disciplines.
A discipline consists of a specialized community that, through intense collective effort, has
formulated
reliable methods for determining whether any particular claim meets accepted criteria for
truth. But assertions from any single disciplinary community as to “what is the case” are
themselves
necessarily partial and bounded, because other disciplinary communities can and do
provide different
perspectives on the same topics. Economists, for example, see poverty through one set of
lenses,
while political scientists and historians contribute different, and sometimes directly
competing,
perspectives on the same issue.
Any assertion from a particular individual or a specific intellectual community is
necessarily simpler
than the complexity it attempts to explain and describe. This is the central reason both
scholars
and students must work within a communal setting that involves multiple academic
disciplines, and
that fosters an ethos of communication, contestation, and civility. By creating such
communities of
inquiry, the academy ensures that no proposal stands without alternatives or arrogates to
itself the
Appendix 5
claim of possessing the sole truth. The advancement of knowledge requires that intellectual
differences
be engaged and explored even as individuals with different points of view are also
respected.
Intellectual Diversity and the Development of Judgment
Although one often hears that faculty “impart knowledge” to students, the reality is that, in
a good
liberal education, substantial time is devoted to teaching students how to acquire new
knowledge for
themselves and how to evaluate evidence within different areas of knowledge. To do this
well, professors
in the classroom also need academic freedom to explore their subjects—including contested
questions and real-world implications—with their students.
4
Academic Freedom and Educational Responsibility
5
To help students think critically about a subject or problem, faculty members need to take
seriously
what students already know or believe about that topic and engage that prior
understanding so new
learning modifies the old—complicating, correcting, and expanding it. This process of
cultivating a
liberal education is a journey that transforms the minds and hearts, and frequently the
starting
assumptions, of those involved—both teachers and students. Because knowledge is always
expanding,
the eventual destination is uncertain.
To develop their own critical judgment, students also need the freedom to express their
ideas
publicly as well as repeated opportunities to explore a wide range of insights and
perspectives.
The diversity of the educational community is an important resource to this process;
research
shows that students are more likely to develop cognitive complexity when they frequently
interact
with people, views, and experiences that are different from their own.
Expressing one’s ideas and entertaining divergent perspectives—about race, gender,
religion, or cultural
values, for example—can be frightening for students. They require a safe environment in
order
Appendix 5
to feel free to express their own views. They need confidence that they will not be subjected
to
ridicule by either students or professors. They have a right to be graded on the intellectual
merit of
their arguments, uninfluenced by the personal views of professors. And, of course, they
have a right
to appeal if they are not able to reach a satisfactory resolution of differences with a
professor.
Learning to form independent
judgments further requires
that students demonstrate openness
to the challenges their
ideas may elicit and the willingness
to alter their original views
in light of new knowledge, evidence,
and perspectives. Just as
a crustacean breaks its confining
shell in order to grow, so students may have to jettison narrow concepts as they expand
their
knowledge and develop more advanced analytical capacities. As they acquire the capacities
to
encounter, grasp, and evaluate diverse points of view, they also gain more nuanced,
sophisticated,
and mature understandings of the world. Every college student deserves to experience the
intellectual
excitement that comes from the capacity to extend the known to the unknown and to
discern previously unsuspected relationships.
Students may, in the end, reaffirm the worldviews and commitments that they brought
with them
to college. But they should do so far more aware of the complexity of the issues at stake and
far better
able to ground their commitments in analysis, evidence, and careful consideration of
alternatives.
Teaching Students to Form Their Own Judgments
Research shows that students tend to develop intellectual and ethical capacities through a
series of
predictable stages. Students frequently enter college with a “black and white” view of the
world,
see things as either good or bad, and expect their professors and textbooks to serve as
definitive
Appendix 5
authorities. Part of the job of becoming educated involves breaking out of this dualistic
mindset.
Association of American Colleges and Universities
Students cannot be left with the notion that
there is no legitimate way—
beyond arbitrary choice—to determine the
relative value of competing claims.
Students’ growing awareness of intellectual diversity frequently leads to a second cognitive
stage
that may be described as naive relativism. Once students see that ideas and methods are
contested,
and that their teachers may differ among themselves about interpretations of truth on
certain questions,
students often decide that “any idea is as good as any other.” While this is a predictable
phase
in their intellectual development, it is a phase that their teachers must recognize and
challenge.
Students cannot be allowed to be content with the notion that there is no legitimate way—
beyond
arbitrary choice—to determine the relative value of competing claims.
Thus it is vital that liberal education be organized to help students progress to a third,
more
mature, mental framework in which they form judgments—even in the face of continuing
disagreement—
about the relative merits of different views, based on careful evaluation of assumptions,
arguments, and evidence. One of the central purposes of majoring in a particular discipline
or academic field is to come to the understanding that different fields of endeavor provide
well-grounded intellectual criteria for making decisions about alternative claims. Using
these criteria,
students can learn to discriminate by arguing the evidence, with the understanding that
arguments exist for the purpose of clarifying
ideas, evaluating claims, considering consequences,
and making choices.
In this process, it is important that students
be asked to assess competing points of view
and to address them in making their own arguments.
A good analysis does not simply ignore
competing perspectives; rather, it takes them
thoughtfully and carefully into account. Students need to learn, through the kind of
extended
Appendix 5
and direct experience afforded by study in depth as well as general education courses, to be
able to state why a question or argument is significant and for whom; what the difference is
between developing and justifying a position and merely asserting one; and how to develop
and provide evidence for their own interpretations and judgments.
Accomplishing this kind of educational result cannot be taken for granted or left to
students’
unaided musings. There must be curricular space, capable guides and models, and a
supportive
institutional culture to encourage students as they learn to develop their own critical
judgments.
Freedom to learn is indispensable for both students and professors as they examine and
assess disparate points of view within and across disciplinary boundaries. In the best
designed
college curricula and assessments, ample opportunity exists for students both to work on
these
intellectual skills and to demonstrate to the community their level of achievement in
analyzing
complex questions.
Further, this kind of intellectual journey often has the greatest impact on students when
they
apply their knowledge and inquiry skills to issues and problems beyond the academy.
Students sometimes
envision education as being removed from the “real world,” but direct involvement with
communities
beyond the academy can illustrate the actual power and significance of their learning. In
such community settings, students may encounter new forms of intellectual diversity, forms
that
emerge from working with people whose histories, experiences, perspectives, and values
may be
6
Academic Freedom and Educational Responsibility
A good analysis does not simply
ignore competing perspectives;
rather, it takes them thoughtfully
and carefully into account.
7
decidedly different from their own—and also, perhaps, from that of the scholarly
community.
Service learning, community-based learning, community action research, internships,
study
Appendix 5
abroad, and similar experiences all provide opportunities for authentic learning that
engage students
in using their critical skills to understand and to better the world.
Those outside the academy readily see the enrichment value of providing students with
hands-on
experience in community or organizational settings. However, they must also recognize
that realworld
learning may involve students with issues and problems that have been highly politicized.
Indeed, some of the same experiences that enhance the knowledge, skills, and motivation of
students
to become more engaged in civic betterment are precisely the ones that are politically
contested.
As a result, faculty whose courses include community-based learning experiences often find
that
they must help students assess controversial topics that—at first glance—might be thought
extraneous
to the subject of the course. When such controversial topics emerge, faculty have to use
their
professional judgment in deciding whether to devote class time to them. If they do, they
have a
responsibility to ensure that students hear and assess diverse views on these topics.
The Ideal versus the Real
Academic freedom is sometimes confused with autonomy, thought and speech freed from
all constraints.
But academic freedom implies not just freedom from constraint but also freedom for
faculty
and students to work within a scholarly community to develop the intellectual and personal
qualities
required of citizens in a vibrant democracy and participants in a vigorous economy.
Academic freedom
is protected by society so that faculty and students can use that freedom to promote the
larger
good.
This document articulates an ideal that is based on historic conceptions of academic
freedom
and extends those precepts to include responsibilities for the holistic education of students.
In
reality, practice often falls short of these norms. Departments and sometimes whole
institutions
Appendix 5
do not always establish widely shared goals for student learning, programs may drift away
from
original intentions, and assessments may be inadequate. Some departments fail to ensure
that
their curricula include the full diversity of legitimate intellectual perspectives appropriate
to
their disciplines. And individual faculty members sometimes express their personal views
to students
in ways that intimidate them. There are institutional means for dealing with these matters,
and in all of these areas, there is room for improvement. The key to improvement is clarity
about the larger purpose of academic freedom and about the educational responsibilities it
is
designed to advance.
Association of American Colleges and Universities
About AAC&U
AAC&U is the leading national association concerned with the quality,
vitality, and public standing of undergraduate liberal education. Its members
are committed to extending the advantages of a liberal education to all
students, regardless of academic specialization or intended career.
Founded in 1915, AAC&U now comprises more than 1,000 accredited
public and private colleges and universities of every type and size.
AAC&U functions as a catalyst and facilitator, forging links among
presidents, administrators, and faculty members who are engaged in
institutional and curricular planning. Its mission is to reinforce the
collective commitment to liberal education at both the national and
local levels and to help individual institutions keep the quality of student
learning at the core of their work as they evolve to meet new economic
and social challenges.
Information about AAC&U membership, programs, and publications can
be found at www.aacu.org.
1818 R Street NW • Washington, DC 20009 • 202.387.3760 • www.aacu.org