Ozdemir, Ebru; Barlas, Yaman; Oner, M. Atilla, "Dynamic Analysis of the Viability of Alternative Energy Sources in Meeting the Electricity Demand", 2002 July 28-2002 August 1

Online content

Fullscreen
Dynamic Analysis of the Viability of
Alternative Energy Sources in Meeting
the Electricity Demand

Ebru Ozdemir, Yaman Barlas M. Atilla Oner
Bogazici University, Yeditepe University,
Dept. of Industrial Eng. Dept. of Management
80815 Bebek, Istanbul - Turkey 81120 Kayisdagi,
Tel: ++(90) 212 358 15 40; x.2073 Istanbul -Turkey
Fax: ++(90) 212 265 18 00 maoner@yeditepe.edu.tr

ybarlas@boun.edu.tr

KEYWORDS
National energy planning, electric power, dynamic energy modeling, renewable energy
ABSTRACT

There are concerns that “traditional” energy sources (like coal and natural gas)
may be inadequate in overcoming some challenges, such as pollution, costs and
sustainability in the long term. Such traditional energy sources are either heavy
polluters, environmentally unfriendly and/or are non-renewable by nature. So there is
an increasing trend toward “alternative” and renewable energy sources such as
biomass, solar and wind power. Many studies on future energy supply show that
renewables will grow faster than any other method of electricity generation in the future
But the viability of alternative and renewable energy sources in meeting the electricity
demand in the long term has often been challenged. It has been argued that it is
unrealistic and infeasible to meet a significant part of the electricity demand by
alternative sources, because such sources are not only uncertain and inadequate, but
they also exhibit high variability by nature. In this research we build a dynamic model
in order to investigate if alternative energy sources can play a viable role in meeting the
electricity demand in the long term. The model is constructed and calibrated using
relevant energy and electricity data of Turkey. Different investment policies are
investigated, based on cost considerations, on environmental indicators and other
criteria. Results of different policy scenarios reveal the importance and viability of
alternative energy sources under different conditions. We also investigate
scenarios/policies that encourage energy savings.

INTRODUCTION

Long term energy planning faces several hard challenges, including pollution and
other environmental concerns, costs (invetsments and operations) and long-term
sustainability in meeting the increasing demand. There are concerns that the
“traditional” energy sources (such as coal and natural gas) may be inadequate in
overcoming these challenges in the long term. Such traditional energy sources are either
heavy polluters, environmentally unfriendly and/or are non-renewable by nature. After
the oil crisis of the 1970s, the importance of renewable energy for electricity generation
has increased so that they now provide nearly 20% of the world’s primary energy
requirement. The environmental benefits of power generation by renewables rather than
combustion of fossil fuels have been the major driving force of this development.
Particularly, in reducing the greenhouse and acid gas emissions associated with fossil
fuel power generation, renewables are perceived to be a necessity. So there is an
increasing trend toward “alternative” energy sources such as biomass, solar and wind
power. Among the more traditional energy sources, there is increasing emphasis on
“renewable” sources such as hydropower and geothermal. Many studies on future
energy supply show that renewables will grow faster than any other method of
electricity generation in the future (IEA, 2002a,b).

But the viability of alternative and renewable energy sources in meeting the
electricity demand in the long term has often been challenged. It has been argued that it
is unrealistic and infeasible to meet a significant part of the electricity demand by
alternative sources, because such sources are not only uncertain and inadequate, but
they also exhibit high variability by nature. (As electricity can not be acculumated, it
requires effective and precise planning; it has to be generated just in time, parallel to the
demand).

Dynamic systems modeling has been a noteworthy tool in the investigation of
energy-economy interactions, conservation, environmental effects of energy planning
policies, and the impact of privatization (Naill, 1973, 1992; Ford, 1983, 1985, 1997;
Bunn and Larsen, 1992; Amlin and Backus, 1985, 1996). In this research we build a
dynamic model in order to investigate if alternative energy sources can play a viable
role in meeting the electricity demand in the long term. The model is constructed and
calibrated using relevant energy and electricity data of Turkey. Turkey constitutes a
major energy market and it is expected that a large gap will occur between energy
consumption and demand in the future. (WEC TNC, 2000b). Our aim is to analyze
electricity supply and demand conditions and to investigate the alternative ways of
meeting Turkey’s electricity need via renewable sources for medium and long terms.
While seeking a balance in electricity supply and demand, CO) equivalent emission
rates of the sources used in electricity generation process are considered as an indicator
of environmental and ecological destruction in resource allocation policies.

THE MODEL

In the model, the emphasis is especially given to the allocation of future capacity need
to renewable sources and non-renewable sources under different policies. The whole
system involves the future electricity need as an exogenous input or a function of
current consumption. The model is constructed and analyzed by using sector approach.
The structure of the model is given in Figure 1 as a whole. There are nine sectors
representing the sources selected for electricity generation process and three sectors for
the calculations of current electricity demand, projected future demand and cost and
emission accumulations. The sectors are grouped as renewables and non-renewables.
Non-renewable ones include Lignite Power Sector, Natural Gas Power Sector, Oil
Power Sector and Hard Coal Power Sector. Renewables include Hydropower Sector,
Wind Power Sector, Small-Scale Hydropower Sector, Geothermal Power Sector and
Solar Power Sector. The sectors included in the model are the ones that compose 97.2
per cent of the total capacity and generate 99.5 per cent of the total electricity generated
as of 1998. (The LPG, Naphtha and Multi Fuel power plants are not included in the
model). Therefore, analysis will be done for the determined sectors constituting most of
the capacity. Within each sector, the allocated future capacity need is compared to the
existing capacity and then construction is started if there is a capacity gap found by the
calculation of expected capacity and the desired level of under construction capacity.
The sectors diagram is illustrated in Figure 1.

The year 1990 is accepted as the base year. Since the available real data belonging to
the electricity consumption and generation of Turkey are up to 1998, the validation of
the major variables is done for eight years. The future electricity demand data available
is up to 2010 and 2020. The model firstly will run for 25 years, from 1990 to 2015 for
the medium term analysis, and the results will be examined. A long term, 55-year-
simulation will also be done for a general analysis of the situation of the sources in the
long term.

[a v —|

| —_ — Current RENEWABLES |

N | Electricity Need | |

Tagniteb | Sector l > Hydropower Sector | |

ignite Power
Sector < |
| _ | Wind Power Sect |
ind Power Sector

I Future Electricity Ht |

I | Natural Gas Power Pau Need Sector . ii ee |
|

ry | Small-Scale |

| | “

| Oil Power Sector | | |

aoe! Solar Power Sector | |

| ed |

| Hard Coal Power | Costs and | |

(aa SSC al C Emissions Sector L} >| Geothermal Power |

| | ee |

\ |

a eee ee

Figure 1. Sector Diagram

a) Current Electricity Need Sector

In Current Electricity Need Sector, the gross installed capacity is transformed to the net
installed capacity by dropping the average internal consumption rate of the power
plants. After subtracting the network losses, using the average ratio published by the
government, the available net electricity generation capacity can be obtained. At the
same time, gross electricity consumption value is allocated to the sectors by considering
their capacity ratios in the total after 1999. (Before 1999, the historical allocation
coefficients which are generated by taking the average share of the related sector’s
electricity generation in the total electricity generated between 1990 and 1998 are used
in meeting the current electricity need).

Essential variables of the sector are; Current Gross Electricity Consumption, Total
Electricity Generation and Total Installed Capacity. (See the Appendix and Ozdemir
2002 for more information). The actual historical gross electricity consumption and the
future demand projection by the Ministry of Energy and National Resources (ETKB)
(together with two alternative extrapolations used in the model) are shown in Figures 2
and 3.

L | 1: Real Gros£lecCons90 98
4: 110000.00y

1 80000.004

1990.00 1992.00 1994.00 1996.00 1998.00

| | | Graph 2 (Untitled) Years 17:06 12 May 2002 Sun

Figure 2. Real Gross Electricity Consumption from 1990 to 1998 (GWh/year)
(WEC TNC, 2000a)

1 50000.00-

—— ETKB GrDmd Exp. Trend
000.000

ETKB GrDmd Quad.Trend __ ETKB GrDmd Real]

3.500.000

3.000.000

2.500.000

2.000.000

GWh

1.500.000

1.000.000
500.000 a

0

aaa e tn ene annua nrytrtes
gsses SLE agcsagaaezri rs
Sa RA RAR RR RRR AR A SA

Figure 3. Extrapolated Gross Electricity Demand Forecast of ETKB, by Exponential
and Quadratic Trends
b) Future Electricity Need Sector

Future Electricity Need Sector first involves the calculation of the future electricity need
for five years into the future by using the current electricity consumption. This sector
then allocates the future gross electricity generation demand in terms of GWh to the
sectors of renewables and non-renewables by considering the remaining electricity
generation potential of the renewables. Different allocation rules and parameters are
used for non-renewable resources, which constitute different scenario runs.

The main variables in the sector are Future Gross Electricity Consumption, Future
Electricity Generation Demand, Total Potential of Renewables (which is not used yet),
Requested Priority of the Renewables and Priority of the Non-Renewables. (See the
Appendix and Ozdemir 2002 for more information).

c) Lignite Power Sector: A Representative of Non-Renewable Sources

In Lignite Power Sector, the processes of gross electricity generation by Lignite Power
Plants, lignite depletion from total lignite reserve, lignite import and capacity
investments are represented. Once new power capacity is invested, it undergoes a first
order delay before it becomes operational. The installed capacity is then assumed to
retire after a third order delay, representing average life of a typical plant. Figure 4
shows the stock-flow diagram of the sector.

Electricity generation is driven by the variable CurLPNeedAllocGWh that is the amount
of electricity generation to be met by Lignite Sector. In calculation of this amount, an
initial fraction is used in the historical period, 1990-1998, and then, for the new policy
analysis, a smooth transition is done from the initial fraction to the new one which is the
fraction of its electricity generation capacity in the sector total. Yearly electricity
generation causes a decrease in lignite reserve. If yearly lignite production does not
provide the required lignite amount then lignite is imported.

The variable FutLPNeedAllocGWh is the other driver of the sector. This variable
represents the future electricity need allocated to lignite power sector. It is a portion of
future non-renewable electricity need calculated in Future Need Sector. For 1990-1998,
a historical installation fraction is used in this process. Then, for policy analysis, a
smooth transition is done to a new installation fraction. In the scenario analysis, the
installation fractions are based on the cost and emission release ratios of lignite power
sector compared to other non-renewables. Finally, by comparing the expected capacity,
under construction capacity against their desired (needed) values and considering the
retired capacity, new capacity to be constructed is calculated according to the lignite
power need, according to a stock adjustment heuristic.
EFI LIGNITE POWER An

LignitoResveTON,

LigPr LigimpotedTON —“LigTotafsaTON Frain \LigemaTonpaine
YeatyMaxt}gProdTo! YoarFhtaxt if Poacwpyear
Yeatytfyoop TON GurGrsElectGenAllocbyNationIGWh
Cur PNeodaliovgwh
TgPP Con Rayo snbyLPG Wh
Bercwn Grelecceh oy Pawn
Tsmthcaphi LigcapFract Inival
DomLigResPotGwn
Towit{dRescwn fap itewn Lig CapFract *
ProcessTime Transett
LPUNConeMw ——_LPICL Leic\ mw Lpica Mw
TotGrsCapGwWh
LigResttteinTotal LP instald fine Retiro PRetiy2 LP Retired
ucDelay LPB Delay
Le Avallpbility gece
PCaputil
LP OperColtparwh
sxWorking Hour gaan
@tLPIC MW TotalCost
NeedtP Install LP QW
Le Prony ara a
Full PNeedAgGWh
ant Lewistalicos
LP instFraet
TotalNonRenReseneGWwh FutNRENNeedGwh LPinstCosiperMW

Figure 4. Lignite Power Sector

d) Hydropower Sector: A Representative of Renewables

The structure of Hydropower Sector is given in Figure 5. The starting point in the
electricity generation process within the Hydropower Sector is the variable
GrsElectGenbyHPGWh. The same logic of the non-renewable sectors described above
is also valid for the renewable sectors in electricity generation step. However, an
important difference is the structure of “electricity generation potential” of renewable
sectors. There are maximum estimated levels of yearly gross electricity generation
potentials for each renewable sector. The total of the installed capacity and under
construction capacity is a part of total potential. Therefore, the potential of renewables
is defined as the potential not used yet. The nature of the renewables allows to re-use of
the potential through possible reinvestment, after the utility ends its useful life. So, the
retired capacity flows in the stock the potential not used yet.

In the investment step of the sector, although the same structure with the non-renewable
sector is used, there is a difference in the installation fractions. New installation fraction
for hydropower is given by the ratio of hydropower sector’s potential within the total
potential of renewables not used yet. Through this approach, it is assumed that the
dependence to a single source can be avoided.
EEI ron a=

“a EleciGenbySmi@yHYDROICGWA GrélectGenbySHPGWh

HPpotNotUsedGihyear

|smiBighYOROICGWh HP UCMW HPICI MW wee SMW
‘ Hp PofMade at
=a rey oi J ce)
‘ HPAvallabiiy Ontine Rate —-HBRetiret HpRetie3
Transit
apr

gd Workin:
HPUC Delay > aerial
tian
HeSmtfsapFe £
" HPCapLtil eee

TotiPiogwh SmIBighYDROIC MW

ToWPIC MW,
NeedAP mw

Instaif Baw
fectGenb yHP Gis HPF ali HPPwalcost
HPCapFrac inital

ara

ToIRENPotGWn
perCost
Transktf

HPEmisT ONperaWh HPOperCosiperGivh

HP Priority aes a! FutRENNeedGWh laces
RENindFrackjut PPinstracRevied
Figure 5. Hydropower Sector
VALIDATION

First, the structure of the model is tested by a range of structure tests, including
dimensional consistency tests and extreme condition test. Results of these tests show
that the model structure does not have any significant structural flaw. Due to space
restrictions, these tests are not included in this paper. Instead, we illustrate some of the
most informative behavior validity tests, done for period 1990-1998.

a) Total Installed Capacity and Electricity Generation Validation (1990-1998)

Figure 6 demonstrates the real installed capacity (Curve 2) of the years 1990 to 1998
and model-generated behavior (Curvel) in the same period. Although in the beginning
years the model results and real data are close to each other, a little deviation is
observed because of the initial fractions after the year 1994. On the other hand, the trend
is similar so the model is accepted valid with respect to this behavior.
| 1: TotiCMW 2: RealGrossCapacityMW 90 98
1] 26226 2

a]

1990.00 1991.60 1993.20 1994.80 1996.40 1998.00
| | if TotalCapacity MW (Untitled) Years 20:36 14 May 2002 Tue

Figure 6. Total Installed Capacity Validation

2] 16315.0

On the electricity generation side, the real and model-generated behaviors are given in
Figure 7. It is seen in the figure that both gross electricity generation (Curve 1) and net
electricity generation (Curve 3) values obtained from the model are close enough to the
historical data set (Curve 2 and Curve 4 respectively). It is obvious that they have the
same growth patterns.

(TT 4: torcnetecicencwn 2; RealGroséElecGener90 98%: TotNetElectGenGwh 4
1 125000.00y
2

3
4:

; —
2 «2500 004
4 —————
1
B
3
& a.00 :
1990.00 1992.00 1994.00 1996.00 1998.00
LT | TotalGenMode! and Really United) __—_Yeam 1952 14 May2002 Tue

Figure 7. Total Electricity Generation Validation

b) Total Installed Capacity Validation for Non-Renewable and Renewable Sources
(1990-1998)

Figure 8 presents the behaviors of total non-renewable and renewable sector
capacities (MW). Model generated behavior for non-renewable sector (Curve 1) is
close to the real behavior (Curve 2). On the other hand, behavior of the renewable sector
(Curve 3) shows valid pattern till 1993, after which model continues to invest in
renewables at some given fraction of the total electricity need. But there is a sudden stop
in the investments in renewables after 1993 in real life, which the model is unable to
represent. Yet the electricity generation behaviors of both sectors do fit real data, as can
be observed in Figure 9.

(TE ronnie ww 2% RealNONRENCapMW 00 98. ToIRENIC MW 4 RealRENCaphw9098

: 1200.00

ait

A

F
1990.00 1992.00 1994.00 1996.00 1998.00
Ha Renew vs NonFen Cap MW (Untied) Yeas 248 14May2002 Tue
Figure 8. Total Installed Capacity Validation for Non-Renewable and Renewable
Sectors
[TM | ToiceanenciociGonawh 2 RealNONRENEleciGon 9008 Gr TOLGRRENEIedGenGWh 4 RealRENEleciGen 90 96

‘ 2100.05

:

4 7 |
4 a

pee |

2765.0

1990.00 1992.00 1994.00 1996.00 1998.00

nm Renew vs NonRenew Gener (Untitled) Yeas 2148 14 May 2002 Tue
Figure 9. Total gross electricity generation validation for non-renewable and renewable
sectors

e Lignite power, as a non-renewable sector validation illustration

Lignite Power Sector generates 30 per cent of total electricity in Turkey. So, the
validation of lignite power sector is an important one. Model-generated and real lignite
power installed capacities (Curve 1 and 2) and electricity generations (Curve 3 and 4)
between 1990 and 1998 are shown in Figure 10. The amount of lignite used in

electricity generation is given in Figure 11 together with the real data.

[HE roueicmw 2: Real PIC 3: GxEiecGenbyLP Wh 4: RealLPIC GWin
4 214.00
Z
3) 25519009
t
ez
g
E
2 2069.19 ae,
1
3] 4896.00
3
2 wis
796000 Te0e00 78100 728600 728800
nnn Lignit vate (Utited) Yeas 218 14May 2002 Tue

Figure 10. Total installed capacity and gross electricity generation validation for Lignite

Power Sector

a]

1)
2:

al

RealLigniteUsed TON

6.50e+0079

4.50+007

It

| 4

2: LigTotalUsedT ON

2.50e+007
1990.00

1992.00
Lig ton (Untitled)

1994.00

Years

1996.00 1998.00
22:14 14 May 2002 Tue

Figure 11. Validation of amount of lignite used in electricity generation (Ton)

Figures 10, 11 demonstrate that the main behaviors of the model variables are
sufficiently close to the real data in the Lignite sector. Behavior validity of non-

renewable resources is illustrated next.

e Hydropower, as a renewable sector validation illustration

Hydropower Sector constitutes approximately 40 per cent of total electricity generation
in Turkey. Model-generated installed capacity and electricity generation behaviors are
shown in Figure 12. The graphs demonstrate reasonably close fits to real data.

poke

“ * eee |

———

“ |
2: ——
3
i 500000
Ta90.00 1992.00 198400 198600 198 00
rtd Smal and Big Hye validate (United) Yeas 2288 14 May 2002 Tue

Figure 12. Total Installed Capacity and Gross Electricity Generation Validation for
Hydropower Sector

SIMULATION EXPERIMENTS
Firstly, medium term simulations (from 1990 to 2015) and then long-term experiments
(from 1990 to 2045) are done. In all simulations, DT is taken as 0.25. In creation of the

scenarios, a combination of some decision parameters listed in Table 1 are considered.

Table 1. Alternative scenarios for medium-term runs

Demand Forecast Scenarios
RENEWABLE Within Renewables Within Non-Renewables
Weight Installation Fractions Installation Fractions
Historical Priorities Historical Inst. Fractions Historical Inst. Fractions
0,5 Potential Based Fractions Cost Based Inst. Fraction
0,5 Potential Based Fractions Emission Based Inst. Fraction
0,5 Potential Based Fractions Combined Cost&Emission Based Inst. Fraction
0 Potential Based Fractions Cost Based Inst. Fraction
0 Potential Based Fractions Emission Based Inst. Fraction
0 Potential Based Fractions Combined Cost&Emission Based Inst. Fraction
1 Potential Based Fractions Cost Based Inst. Fraction
1 Potential Based Fractions Emission Based Inst. Fraction
1 Potential Based Fractions Combined Cost&Emission Based Inst. Fraction

A gradual transition from historical policies to the new ones is captured by using a
transition effect given in Figure 13. The values representing the historical policies are
given in Table 2 and Table 3. These fractions are used in determining electricity
generation shares and capacity investment shares respectively. In various
scenario/policy formulations, the investment fractions (variable) are formulated as:
(transition_effect)*(historical fraction)+(1-transition_effect)*(new fraction)

transition effect

1
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003
YEARS

Figure 13. Policy Transition Effect

Table 2. Historical Electricity Generation Fractions of the Sectors

Lignite Power Plants 0.316 Hydropower Plants 0.393
Hard Coal Power Plants 0.024 Small Scale Hydropower Plants 0.011
Oil Power Plants 0.068 Geothermal Power Plants 0.001
Natural Gas Power Plants 0.187 Wind Power Plants 0
Solar Power Plants 0

Table 3. Historical Capacity Investment Fractions of the Sectors

Lignite Power Plants 0.53 Hydropower Plants 0.971
Hard Coal Power Plants 0 Small Scale Hydropower Plants 0.027
Oil Power Plants 0 Geothermal Power Plants 0.002
Natural Gas Power Plants 0.47 Wind Power Plants 0
Solar Power Plants 0

Medium Term Experiments:
a) Future Projections of Historical Policies:

If historical policies are continued, then the behaviors of total and installed capacities of
renewable and nonrenewable sectors are presented in Figure 14.
| 1: TotlCMW 2: TotREN IC MW 3: TotNREN IC MW
1 81000.005

1
2: 43500.004
3: Le |e |
Lge | oot" =
1
2: ee
3: 6000.00:
1990.00 1995.00 2000.00 2005.00 2010.00 2015.00
| | | TotalCapacity MW (Untitled) Years 19:29 15 May 2002 Wed

Figure 14. Total Installed Capacity (MW)

In Figure 15, it is observed that electricity import starts after 1998. The import reaches a
value of 98,667.19 GWh/year in 2015. It is apparent that the total gross capacity (Curve
1) is not completely used in (Curve 2) to meet the demand (curve 3). Since the historical
fraction is taken as constant, electricity generations are not affected by the generation
capacities of the sectors, current electricity generation allocation to the sectors via the
historical data is not robust after year 1998. Although total gross capacity is higher than
the demand till year 2007, the electricity generation is smaller than the demand. This
situation shows the problem with continuing the historical allocation fractions.

| mn 2: TotGrélectGenGWh 3: CurGreElecGenDmdGWh 4: GrsElectimpRealzdGWh
1] 418318.04
2
3:
4
7 |
2 |
@ 209157.524
: | =
- =I
bee
1 L——* |
2:
3 el
4 0.00 y
4990.00 4995.00 2000.00 2005.00 2010.00 2018.00
Hal Total Cap Gen and Cons (Untitled) Years 1956 15 May 2002 Wed

Figure 15. Gross Electricity Capacity, Generation, Demand and Import (GWh)
| 1: TotalCost 2: TotEmission
1

1.82010114
2 1.866+008

1 9.106+010] LA

1990.00 1995.00 2000.00 2005.00 2010.00 2015.00

Ni TotalPanorama: pi (Untitled) Years 23:00 16 May 2002 Thu

Figure 16. Total Cost and Emission (USD and Ton)

1 0.00
2 3.77e+00

b) Renewable/Non-Renewable Equally Weighted Policy (0.5 Each)

¢ Cost based non-renewable installation fractions.

The cost fractions used as installation fractions in non-renewable sectors are computed
as follows.

Lignite Power Installation Fraction: 19%
Hard Coal Power Installation Fraction: 21%
Oil Power Installation Fraction: 15%

Natural Gas Power Installation Fraction: 45%

Each fraction determines the electricity amount of individual non-renewable resources
according to their relative costs.

This scenario gives priority to renewables 50 per cent, the same as non-renewables after
year 1999. The future gross need is allocated according to the priority levels of sectors.
Then, within each sector group (i.e. renewables and non-renewables), the allocated
future need is allocated to the sectors involved in the group. Within this frame, the
electricity generation results of the simulation can be observed as in Figure 17 and
Figure 18. In Figure 17, Curve | shows that a huge investment has been made to the
renewable sectors, so the capacity has increases sharply and reaches 128,091.89 MW in
2015. It is also important that the renewable power plants work with a low availability.
In order to generate the same amount of electricity, renewable sectors generally require
higher capacity than the non-renewable ones. It is also seen that there is not any
considerable electricity import.
(MBE +: Torcrscapewn 2 TotGrélectGenGwh 3: CurGrEleciGenDmdGwh 4: GrélectimpRealziGwn
4] 500068.25
2
3
3
1
2) aso0s4.194
; ot
i a
, ——
2
3
a 0.00
4990.00 1995.00 2000.00 2005.00 2010.00 2015.00
PT | rouge aa concriNed) Yes ae TenarRIE TAR

Figure 17. Gross Electricity Capacity, Generation, Demand and Import (GWh)

It is seen in Figure 18 that total cost is rather higher than the result of reference model
(see Figure 16). Its value is almost four times of the reference runs value. Total
emission released at 2015 is approximately 13 per cent higher than the reference run
emission level at the same year.

(MM 1 otaicos 2 1

1: B79et0114

2 211e+008

4: 43901011

2 1:24e+008

aT
1 0.00 ee, ——
2 3.77e+007-
4990.00 1995.00 2000.00 2005.00 2010.00 2015.00

Ni TotalPanorama: p1 (Untited) Years 01:38 19 May 2002 Sun

Figure 18. Total Cost and Emission (USD and Ton)

e Emission based installation fractions.

Emission based fractions are computed for the non-renewable sectors and assigned as
follows:
Lignite Power Installation Fraction: 21%
Hard Coal Power Installation Fraction: 21%
Oil Power Installation Fraction: 29%

Natural Gas Power Installation Fraction: 29%

Each fraction determines the electricity amount of individual non-renewable resources
according to their relative emission levels.

The system behavior in electricity generation process is the same as the previous runs.
Briefly, a capacity excess is observed after 2002. The important result through this
policy is obtaining low emission levels. In Figure 19, Curve 5 depicts the yearly
released emission levels. For comparison of non-renewable and renewable electricity
generation capacities, observe Curve 2 and Curve 3.

[WME totcrscapawn 2: TotNRENICGWh 3: ToIRENICGWh 4: TotalCost 5: TotEmission

4: §00068.254

2 207377.82

3: 288252.67

4 8.95et011

5: 2:106+008 as

4: 250034.13

2 137894:43

3: 187626.34]

4 4.4Be+011

5 1124e+008

‘i 0.00

2 6841104

3 2700.01

4 0.

5 3.778400 T t 1

4990.00 1995.00 2000.00 2005.00 2010.00 2015.00

Nall [| TotalPanorama: pi (Untifed) Years 19:03 03 Jun 2002 Mon

Figure 19. Total Gross Capacity, Non-renewable and Renewable Capacity (GWh),
Cost and Emission (USD and Ton)

¢ Combined cost & emission based fractions

Combined cost and emission based fractions are computed for the non-renewable
sectors and assigned as follows:

Table 4. Combined Cost and Emission Based Installation Fractions

INSTALLATION | OPERATION
cosT COST EMISSION COMBINED
FRACTIONS FRACTIONS | FRACTIONS FRACTIONS
NON-RENEWABLES % % % oduct %
Lignite Power Plants 0,19 0,34 0,21 0,01357 0,20
Natural Gas Power Plants 0,45 0,28 0,29 0,03654 0,55
Oil Power Plants 0,15 0,14 0,29 0,00609 0,09
Coal Power Plants 0,21 0,24 0,21 0,01058 0,16
TOTAL 0,06678 1,00

Each fraction determines the electricity amount of individual non-renewable resources
according to their relative “combined cost and emission” levels.

This scenario does not yield electricity import since the capacity is too high compared
to reference behavior. Total emission released, shown in Figure 20, is a little higher then
reference behavior result. The levels of the fuel imports are also depicted in Figure 21
for this scenario.

(IIE +: totemission 2: EmisRelbyLP 3: EmisRelbyHCP 4: EmisRelbyOP _5: EmisRelbyNGP
1: 2.09e+008

2] 80361007

3

3

5

4: 1.23e+008
2:
S| 4,09e+007] |
5: [4 =

lee" A Le |

ml

4: 3.77@+007
2 a | gaa | coceeaen|
3 ne | te
5] 1502000.00—— 7

4990.00 1995.00 2000.00 2005.00 2010.00 2015.00

En Emision NREN (Untitled) Years 20:21 16 May 2002 Thu

Figure 20. Emission Levels of Whole System and Non-Renewable Sectors

(EE 2: ottmpon 2: NGImportedmm3 3: LigimportedTON 4: HCimportedTON
1: 4.005
2 2286590
3: 1.00
4: 2.00e+007
4: 0.00 | L
2 12633.20.
3: 0.00
4: 1.00e+007
4 -1.00 ge |
2 2400.49
3: =1.00 =
4 0 -
1990.00 1995.00 2000.00 2005.00 2010.00 2015.00
| | Fuel Import (Untitled) Years 20:21 16 May 2002 Thu

Figure 21. Fuel Imports
c) Renewable Oriented Policy

¢ Combined cost & emission based fractions.

Figure 22 demonstrates that renewable oriented capacity investments create capacity
excess and energy need can be entirely met. Total cost and emission levels are given in
Figure 23. It is seen in Figures 22 and 23 that the total costs reach very high levels
whereas the emission levels are quite low compared to other policies.

r | 1: TotGrsCapGWh 2: TotGrslectGe... 3: CurGrsElectG... 4: GrsElectImpR... 5: GlobalPotinve.

1] 501404.8%
2]
3;
4
|
1]
2]
3} 25070242]
4
Fs
roa
1] aa
2]
3! | ere
4]
51 00: elit -
1990.00 1995.00 2000.00 2005.00 2010.00 2015.00
Hl TotalGenModel and Reality (... Years 07:46 19 May 2002 Sun

Figure 22. Total Electricity Capacity, Generation, Demand and Imports (GWh)

1 | 4: TotalCost 2: Total CostofNREN 3: TotalCostofREN
1 1.32040 129
2
3:
1
2 6.600011]
3:

——————
000i

1990.00 1995.00 2000.00 2005.00 2010.00 2015.00

| {| Coss (Untitled) Years 13:59 16 May 2002 Thu

Figure 23. Cost levels of whole system and sector groups

| 1: TotEmission 2: TotEmisREN 3: TotEmisNREN
1

1.320008)
2
3:

ag
4
2] 6.826400 A ea
3: jp—~3-—— | |
es et
; Lae |
2 j}—~2—— |
3: 4550000.00 T T
1990.00 1995.00 2000.00 2005.00 2010.00 2015.00

| { f TotEmis (Untitled) Years 13:59 16 May 2002 Thu
Figure 24. Emission Levels of Whole System and Sector Groups

d) Non-Renewable Oriented Policy

e¢ Combined cost & emission based fractions.

Figure 25 shows that total gross electricity demand is met by capacity till 2013 with an
excess capacity. Afterwards, all installed capacities are completely used in meeting the
need. Through this policy, it is seen in Figures 26 and 27 that while total cost at the end
of simulation is lower than the result of renewable-oriented policy, the emission level
released is quite higher. The levels of fuel imports are illustrated in Figure 27. The trend
in import of natural gas is increasing with this policy while oil import becomes stable
for a while and again begins to increase.

(MT +: Toicrecapewn 2: TolGrElectGenGWh 3: CurGrEleciGenDmdGWwh 4: GsElectimpRealzdGwn
1] 418315.0

2

3

i

4
2] anstsr.sal
bs
peed A
4]
2:
3
4 0.00: - ’ =
4990.00 1995.00 2000.00 2005.00 2010.00 2015.00
HE TotalGenModel and Reality (Untitled) Years 22:30 26 May 2002 Sun

Figure 25. Total electricity capacity, generation, demand, and total cost and emission
r | 1: LigimportedTON 2: HClmportedTON, 3: NGImportedmm3 4: OilTotalUsed TON
4] 3.01e+0074

3: 41545.80
4: 7472000.00

413
3] 1.ste+007

3: 21973.15]
4: 4266000.00

4 —<y
a
2 0.00
3 2400.49 =
4: 1060000.00+ 7 r
1990.00 1995.00 2000.00 2005.00 2010.00 2015.00
EE Sources Imported (Untitled) Years 22:30 26 May 2002 Sun

Figure 26. Fuel imports

[WM 1. totaicos 2: TotEmission

2.53e+011
3.10e+008,

4: 1.260+011,
2: 1.74e+008

cH 0.00
2: 3.77e+007-

1990.00 1995.00 2000.00 2005.00 2010.00 2015.00

NS TotalPanorama: p1 (Untitled) Years 22:30 26 May 2002 Sun

Figure 27. Cost levels of whole system and sector groups

Table 5 gives the comparative values of major variables for all runs done for
medium term analysis. To summarize, at the end of simulation, in year 2015, it is
observed that gross electricity demand can be satisfied by total install capacity with
negligible electricity imports for all policies. But, there are capacity excesses occurring
with renewable/non-renewable equally weighted policy, renewable oriented policy and
historical policy. In Table 5, it is observed that the minimum level of accumulated
emission can be obtained by renewable oriented policy emission based non-renewable
installation. Furthermore, non-renewable oriented policy with combined cost and
emission non-renewable installation policy gives the minimum level of accumulated
cost as at 2015. But note that in non-renewable oriented policies there are significant
fuel imports (as seen already in the figures discussed) not included in the above cost
figures, implying that these latter underestimate the total costs of non-renewable
policies. Also note that “electricity import” is shown as a separate variable in the table,
and its cost is not included in the accumulated cost entry. Therefore, accumulative costs
in the base run significantly underestimate the actual total cost in cases where there are
electricity imports (i.e. BASE RUN).

Long- Term Experiments:

Conservation Scenario:

In the conservation scenario, the first assumption is based on consumption efficiency.
Electricity saving by all consumers will be promoted via different methods and a 10 per
cent saving is assumed to be realized in total. For this purpose a “savings effect” has
been developed and presented in Figure 28. There are two curves; current savings effect
and future savings effect. It is assumed that current savings effect plays its role on
current consumption after the year 2000. Its value reaches 10 per cent in 2015. 15 year-
delay to have a stable savings ratio is assumed to be an acceptable delay since the social
attitudes may not change so easily. In this project, it is assumed that a 10 per cent saving
can be realized in 15 years, from 2000 to 2015. When calculating the future
investments, savings effect has to be estimated. Therefore, current savings effect is
transformed to future savings effect by shifting the beginning year to five year earlier.
For instance, in computing the future electricity generation demand the value of current
savings effect as of 2000 will be taken into account in 1995.

— current savings effect — future savings effect

0.100
0.090
0.080
0.070 = L
0.060

0.050 f-
0.040

0.030
0.020
0.010
0.000 AA

S Sv gh gO oo DP WM gk © SO
ss sf eS A x
PMP IH HES SL as

Ratio

Yam Ao
a

o>
Vv
LP PP

YEARS

Figure 28. Current and Future Savings Effect

The second aspect of the conservation policies is about the network losses. It is assumed
that network losses can be reduced down to 10 per cent from 18 per cent in ten years.
Figure 29 demonstrates the assumed change in network losses. The change begins in
2000 and ends in 2010, and then the network losses ratio stays stable at 10 per cent. 10
year-delay is assumed sufficient to improve the network. Note that the variable network
losses is used in the calculation of total available net electricity generation capacity,
total domestic net electricity consumption and current electricity consumption.
Table 5. Comparative values of main variables at year 2015 for different policies

Historical Policy

Renewable and Non-

Renewable Oriented

Non-Renewable

Continued Renewable Equally Policy Oriented Policy

(BASE RUN) Weighted Policy
Yearly Gross Electricity Demand (GWh) 418,315 418,315 418,315 418,315
Yearly Total Gross Capacity (GWh) 396,388
\Cost Based Non-Renewable Installation 499,544 501,404 412,711
Emission Based Non-Renewable Installation 495,285 501,351 408,168
\Cost&Emission Based Non-Renewable Installation 499,944 501,418 414,901
Yearly Gross Electricity Generation (GWh) 319,647
\Cost Based Non-Renewable Installation 418,315 418,315 412,711
[Emission Based Non-Renewable Installation 418,315 418,315 408,168
ICost&Emission Based Non-Renewable Installation 418,315 418,315 414,901
Capacity Utilization (%) 81
\Cost Based Non-Renewable Installation 84 83 100
[Emission Based Non-Renewable Installation 84 83 100
\Cost&Emission Based Non-Renewable Installation 84 83 100
[Accumulated Electricity Import (GWh) 676,578
\Cost Based Non-Renewable Installation 968 1,001 9,279
[Emission Based Non-Renewable Installation 978 1,013 28,661
\Cost&Emission Based Non-Renewable Installation 966 996 4,411

[Accumulated Emission (TON)

2,494,745,945

\Cost Based Non-Renewable Installation

2,530,792,503

2,077,950,814

3,148,299,523

Emission Based Non-Renewable Installation

2,518,259, 709

2,076,055,485

3,131,547,098

\Cost&Emission Based Non-Renewable Installation

2,518,857,427

2,078,248,515

3,132,302,283

[Accumulated Cost (USD)

181,998,202,073

\Cost Based Non-Renewable Installation

903,577,816,723

1,319,034,250,869

264,914,478,716

Emission Based Non-Renewable Installation

920,722,722,471

1,320,243,730,763

288,889,548,266

\Cost&Emission Based Non-Renewable Installation

895,648,108,291

1,318,435,346,773

252,628,869,496

Network Losses Ratio

YEARS

Figure 29. Network Losses Effect

e Future projections of historical policies with savings

The reference model behaviors are examined by long term simulation. The existing
policies yield a growing electricity import (curve 4) even though conservation policies
are applied after 1999. In 2045, the gross electricity import becomes 689,040.34 GWh
which is 27 per cent of the gross electricity demand. Total cost and emission levels are
illustrated in Figure 31.

(MM +: totcrscapcwn 2: TotGrElectGenGWh 3: CurGrsElecGenDmdGWh 4: GrsElectimpRealziGWn
1] 2530000.00)

2

3

4:

1265000.004

| :
bees

1990.00 2001.00 2012.00 2023.00 2034.00 2045.00

Bene

Bene

Hl Total Cap Gen and Cons (Untitled) Years 23:40 20 May 2002 Mon

Figure 30. Total Electricity Capacity, Generation, Demand and Import (GWh) with
Savings (Historical policies continued)

(ME rotaicost 2: TotEmission

4: 1.2h0+0124

2 1106e+009 |

1: 6.2ter014} |

2 5.47e+008 |

; x ee te |

2 3.77600; t

1990.00 2001.00 2012.00 2023.00 2034.00 2045.00

Ni TotalPanorama: pi (Untied) Years 23:40 20 May 2002 Mon

Figure 31. Total Cost and Emission with Savings (Historical policies continued)

Figure 32 shows the historical policy results without savings for long term
simulation. It is observed that 765,890.71 GWh electricity import occurs if existing
policy continued. Note that, total cost and emission levels reach 1.37x10'? USD and
1.17x10° Tons respectively. Consequently, the conservation scenario under historical
policy yields 90 per cent reduction in total cost level, emission level and electricity
import respectively, compared to historical policy without savings as of 2045.

¥ 2: TotGrElectGenGWh 3: CurGrsElecGenDmdGWh 4: GrElectimpRealzdGWh
2809000.004

1404500.004

Bene

i | o4|

1990.00 2001.00 2012.00 2023.00 2034.00 2045.00

Sens

0.00:

Hl Total Cap Gen and Cons (Untitled) Years 23:45 20 May 2002 Mon

Figure 32. Total Electricity Capacity, Generation, Demand and Import (Gwh) without
Savings. (Historical policies continued)
e Renewable/ Non-Renewable Equally Weighted Policy with Combined Cost and
Emission Based Non-Renewable Installation Scenario

It is seen in Figure 33 that electricity need is met by the capacity. Since the installation
policy changes in 1998, firstly a capacity excess occurs but after 2012 the capacity
balances itself in the long term. It is also important that the decrease in network losses
also decreases the discrepancy between capacity and electricity generation. It is seen
that there is no electricity import. Figure 34 shows the levels of total cost and emission.
The import levels of non-renewable sources are also illustrated in Figure 35.

(HE §: totcrscapewn 2 TotGrEleciGenGWh 3: CurGnElectGenDmdGWh 4: GeEleclimpRealziGwh
1] 2671000.00y

2

3:

4

1

2] 4338500.004

4

1 en ae

3 and al

4 0.00

1990.00 2001.00 2012.00 2023.00 2034.00 2045.00
El Total Cap Gen and Cons(Untited) Years 11:32. 17 May 2002 Fri

Figure 33. Total Electricity Capacity, Generation, Demand and Import with Savings

[HE  rotaicost 2: TotEmission

4: 8.030012

2 1134e+009 |

4: 4.016+012] |

2 6.90e+008 |

x a0 | |

2 3.7e+0074 r

1990.00 2001.00 2012.00 2023.00 2034.00 2045.00

NG TotalPanorama: p1 (Untitled) Years 13:19 19 May 2002 Sun

Figure 34. Total Cost and Emission with Savings

r | 4: HClmportedTON 2: LiglmportedTON 3: NGImportedmm3 4: OillmportedTON

1.45¢+008
1:31¢+008
160146.74
2.530+007

Sens

7.23e+007

6.55e+007]
81273.62

1.27e+007

Sens

0.00
0.00
2400.49
0.00 aE
1990.00 2003.75 2017.50 2031.25 2045.00

ll Graph 1 (Untitled) Years 11:36 17 May 2002 Fri

Figure 35. Fuel Imports with Savings

BENS

e Renewable Oriented Policy with combined cost and emission based renewable

installation scenario.

With this policy, almost the same behavior of renewable/nonrenewable equally
weighted policy is observed. Only the levels of emission and costs differ.

Table 6 shows the final values of main variables with and without savings in the
long term. The table also illustrates base run results for each scenario for comparison. It
is seen that renewable oriented policy has the second lowest capacity utilization, after
the base run, with 89 per cent under pessimistic scenario and 94 per cent under
optimistic scenario. The minimum accumulated emission level is obtained by
renewable-oriented scenario, which is 42 per cent lower than the level of base run in
pessimistic demand scenario and 35 per cent lower in optimistic demand scenario with
savings. On the other hand, lower accumulated costs are realized by non-renewable
oriented policy. Just as in Table 5, observe again that costs of electricity import are no
included in the cumulative cost figures, so that cumulative costs in the BASE RUN
(involving large imports) significantly underestimate the actual costs. Also observe that
when all policies are compared under with and without savings scenarios (upper and
lower values of Table 6) installed capacities, gross electricity generation, cumulative
costs and emissions are all reduced in the savings case.
Table 6. Comparative values of main variables at year 2045

Historical Policy || Renewable and | % change Renewable % change || Non-Renewable % change
Continued Non-Renewable | relative to | Oriented Policy | relative to | Oriented Policy relative to
(BASE RUN) | Equally Weighted | base run base run base run
Policy
Without Savings
Y early Gross Electricity Demand (GWh) 2,809,338} 2,809,338} 2,809,338} 2,809,338}
Yearly Total Gross Capacity (GWh) 2,602,731 2,970,358} 3,163,656} 2,795,393
Y early Gross Electricity Generation (GWh) 2,043,448} 2,809,338} 2,809,338} 2,795,393
Capacity Utilization (%) 79| 95) 89) 100
Accumulated Electricity Import (GWh) 10,575,233} 966} = -100 1,030 -100 374,738] -96
[Accumulated Emission (TON) 18,307,022,490} 22,315,047,564| 22 10,420,223,636 -43 35,810,450,735 96
Accumulated Cost (USD) 1,371,923,799,802} 8,975,694,543,560| 554 15,721,991,293,058} 1,046 1,898,757,227,591 38
With Savings
Yearly Gross Electricity Demand (GWh) 2,529,809) 2,529,809] 2,529,809| 2,529,809]
Yearly Total Gross Capacity (GWh) 2,343,684 2,670,608} 2,843,256} 2,515,024]
Y early Gross Electricity Generation (GWh) 1,840,769} 2,529,809] 2,529,809] 2,515,024
Capacity Utilization (%) 79] 95 89 100}
Accumulated Electricity Import (GWh) 9,469,188} 1,147 -100 1,233 -100 366,346] -96
[Accumulated Emission (TON) 16,680,081,913} 20,243,447,3 16} 21 9,729,129,559| -42 32,212,823,513 93
Accumulated Cost (USD) 1,240,717,418,284] 8,025,681,996,049] 547 13,970,948,914,251} 1,026 1,714,442,356,681 38

CONCLUSION

The electricity need of Turkey has been met mostly by non-renewable sources. The
main goal of this study is to investigate whether renewable sectors can play an
important role in the total electricity generation, to meet the electricity need of Turkey
in the future, with different allocation policies. This question is investigated by
constructing a dynamic simulation model which represents the energy planning
dynamics in electric power sector in Turkey. The validation tests are mostly based on
information published by World Energy Council Turkish National Committee in 1998.
Since much of the data on technological aspects of power plants and fuel production
rates differ year by year, the averages of the related parameters are used in the model.
Nevertheless, validity tests show that the model-generated behavior is consistent with
the literature and available data and the model adequately represents the electricity
generation, power plant installation and reserve depletion structures of Turkey.

First, a cost-oriented policy is used in the allocation of future electricity need to
different energy sources and different renewable and non-renewable installation priority
policies are tested. If the renewable and non-renewable sectors have equal priorities for
future investments, electricity import does not occur and renewable sectors capacity
grows significantly. In case of emission-oriented scenarios, the behavior of the system
does not change with respect to renewable versus non-renewable priorities. The same
fundamental behaviors emerge with different costs and emissions. Generally, emission-
based allocation scenarios create lower emission level, but high installation and
operation costs. With respect to the emission level, the best results are obtained from
renewable-oriented scenarios, but they produce high capacity installation costs. The
emission level and installation and operation costs of non-renewable sectors are finally
combined to yield combined installation fractions. Renewable and non-renewable
policies result in different levels of capacity, cost and emission.

A conservation oriented scenario is also implemented by assuming a gradual reduction
in network losses and an increase in consumption efficiency. Long term analysis, until
year 2045, is done with or without conservation assumptions over a period of 10 years.
Combined cost and emission based non-renewable installation policy is used under two
projections; optimistic and pessimistic ones.

Since energy production is a very broad and complex issue, the model can be extended
in different aspects. The demand side of the model can be influenced by the capacity
excess and a feedback loop can be constructed between installed capacity and demand.
Furthermore, the demand can be enhanced in itself. Moreover, emission and cost levels
can directly influence the capacity installation and electricity generation fractions,
constituting further feedback loops that allow more adaptive installation and allocation
decision.
References:

Amlin, J. and G. Backus, 1996, Utility Models for the New Competitive Electric
Markets, Systematic Solutions, Inc., Ohio, U.S.A.

Backus, G. and J. Amlin, 1985, Combined Multidimensional Simulation Language,
Database Manager and Sensitivity Confidence Analysis Package for System Dynamics
Modeling, Proceedings of the 1985 International System Dynamics Conference,
Keystone, CO.

Bunn, D. and E.R. Larsen, 1992, “Sensitivity of Reserve Margin to Factors Influencing
Investment Behaviour in the Electricity Market of England & Wales”, Energy Policy,
Vol. 29, p. 420-429.

Ford, A., 1983, “Using Simulation for Policy Evaluation in the Electric Utility
Industry”, Simulation, pp.85-92.

Ford, A., 1985, “Short Lead Time Technologies as a Defense against Demand
Uncertainty”, in Plummer, E., Oatman, E., and Gupta, P., Strategic Management and
Planning for Electric Utilities, Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.

Ford, A., 1997, “System Dynamics and The Electricity Power Industry”, System
Dynamics Review, Vol. 13, No. 1, pp.57-85, Spring.

Naill, R., 1973, ‘The Discovery Life Cycle of a finite resources: A Case Study of US
Natural Gas”, Toward Global Equilibrium, ed. D. Meadows and D. Meadows, Wright-
Allen Press.

Naill, R., 1992, “A system dynamics model for national energy policy planning”,
System Dynamics Review, Vol.8, No.1, pp.1-19, Winter.

WEC TNC (World Energy Council Turkish National Committee), 2000a, 1998 Energy
Statistics Report, Ankara, Turkey, 8-12 May 2000.

WEC TNC (World Energy Council Turkish National Committee), 2000b, 1998 Energy
Report, Ankara,Turkey, 8-12 May 2000.

IEA (International Energy Agency), 2002a, Benign Energy? The Environmental
Implications of Renewables, http://www.iea.org/pubs/studies/files/benign/index.htm

IEA (International Energy Agency), 2002b, The Evolving Renewable Market,
http://www.iea.org/pubs/studies/files/evoree99/index.htm
“Hydropower Sector
here

Appendix 1. Model Structure
Appendix 2: Model Equations
Costs and Emissions
TotalCost = TotalCostofNREN+TotalCostofREN
TotalCostofNREN = HCPTotalCost+LPTotalCost+NGPTotalCost+OPTotalCost
TotalCostofREN = GTPTotalCost+HPTotalCost+SHPTotalCost+SPTotalCost+WPTotalCost
TotEmisNREN = EmisRelbyHCP+EmisRelbyLP+EmisRelbyNGP+EmisRelbyOP
TotEmisREN = EmisRelbyGTP+EmisnRelbyHP+EmisRelbySHP+EmisRelbyWP+EmisRelbySP.

TotEmission = TotEmisNREN+TotEmisREN

CURRENT ELECTRICITY NEED
CurActGrsElectConsGW = CurGrsElectConsGWh*(1-CurSavingsEffect)

CurGrsElectGenA llocbyNationICGWh = MIN (CurGrsElectGenDmdGWh, TotGrsCapGWh)
CurGrsElectGenDmdGWh = CurActGrsElectConsGW*(1+InternalConsRatio)
CurNetElectConsGWh = CurActGrsElectConsGW *(1-NetworkLossRatio)
GrsElectImpExpectdGWh = CurGrsElectGenDmdGWh-CurGrsElectGenA llocbyNationICGWh
GrsElectImpRealzdGWh = CurGrsElectGenDmdGWh-TotGrsElectGenGWh

InternalConsRatio = 0.034

TotDomNetElectConsGWh = TotNetElectGenGWh*(1-NetworkLossRatio)

TotGrsCapGWh = TotNRENICGWh+TotRENICGWh

TotGrsElectGenGWh = TotGrsNRENElectGenGWh+TotGrsRENElectGenGWh
TotGrsNRENElectGenGWh = GrsElecGenbyHCPGWh+GrsElecGenbyNGPGWh+GrsElecGenbyOilGWh+GrsElecGenbyLPGWh

TotGrsRENElectGenGWh =
GrsElectGeby WPGWh+GrsElectGenbyGTPGWh+ GrsElectGenbyHPGWh+GrsElectGenbySHPGWh+GrsElectGenbySPGWh

TotICMW = TotNREN_IC_MW+TotREN_IC_ MW
TotNetCapAviforEndUseGWh = TotNetCapGWh*(1-NetworkLossRatio)

TotNetCapGWh = TotGrsCapGWh*(I-InternalConsRatio)

TotNetElectGenGWh = TotGrsElectGenGWh*(|-InternalConsRatio)

TotNRENICGWh = TotHCPICGWh+TotLPICGWh+TotNGICGWh+TotOPICGWh

TotNREN_IC_MW = TotHCPIC_MW+TotLPIC_MW+TotNGPIC_MW+TotOPIC_MW

TotRENICGWh = TotGTPICGWh+TotHPICGWh+ TotSHPICGWh+TotSPICGWh+TotWPICGWh

TotREN_IC_MW = TotGTPIC_MW+TotHPIC_MW+TotSHPIC_MW+TotSPIC_MW+TotWPIC_MW

CurSavingsEffeet = GRAPH(time)

(1990, 0.00), (1991, 0.00), (1992, 0.00), (1993, 0.00), (1994, 0.00), (1995, 0.00), (1996, 0.00), (1997, 0.00), (1998, 0.00), (1999,
0.00), (2000, 0.0025), (2001, 0.0055), (2002, 0.009), (2003, 0.012), (2004, 0.0155), (2005, 0.0215), (2006, 0.0295), (2007, 0.0375),
(2008, 0.0465), (2009, 0.0575), (2010, 0.072), (2011, 0.0825), (2012, 0.089), (2013, 0.093), (2014, 0.0965), (2015, 0.0995), (2016,
0.0995), (2017, 0.0995), (2018, 0.0995), (2019, 0.0995), (2020, 0.0995)

NetworkLossRatio = GRAPH(time)

(1990, 0.18), (1991, 0.18), (1992, 0.18), (1993, 0.18), (1994, 0.18), (1995, 0.18), (1996, 0.18), (1997, 0.18), (1998, 0.18), (1999,

0.18), (2000, 0.179), (2001, 0.178), (2002, 0.176), (2003, 0.174), (2004, 0.17), (2005, 0.166), (2006, 0.16), (2007, 0.15), (2008,
0.138), (2009, 0.124), (2010, 0.1), (2011, 0.1), (2012, 0.1), (2013, 0.1), (2014, 0.1), (2015, 0.1)
FUTURE ELECTRICITY NEED
FutActGrsConsGWh = FutGrsEleeConsGWh*(1-FutSavingsEffect)
FutGrsElectDmdGWh = FutActGrsConsGWh*(1 +InternalConsRatio)
FutNRENNeedGWh = FutGrsElectDmdGWh*NRENPriority
FutRENNeedGWh = FutGrsElectDmdGWh*RENPriorityAdjusted
NRENPriority = 1-RENPriorityAdjusted

RENinitialPriority = 0.65

RENInstFracAdjust = GTP_Inst_FractHP_Inst_ Frac+SHP_Inst_Frac+SPInstFrac+WPInstFrac

RENPriority Adjusted = IF TIME<1999 THEN min(RENinitialPriority,(TotRENPotG Wh/FutGrsElectDmdGWh)) ELSE
min(RENSmthPriorityReq,(TotRENPotGWh/FutGrsElectDmdGWh))

RENPriorityRequested = 0.5

RENSmthPriorityReq = RENPriorityRequested*TransEff*RENinitialPriority*(1-TransEf)

TotRENPotGWh =
HPpotNotUsedGWhyear+WPpotNotUsedGWhY ear SHPpotNotUsedGWhyear+GTPpotNotUsedGWhyear+SP_potNotUsedGWh
Year

FutSavingsEffect = GRAPH(time)

(1990, 0.00), (1991, 0.00), (1992, 0.00), (1993, 0.00), (1994, 0.00), (1995, 0.003), (1996, 0.006), (1997, 0.009), (1998, 0.012),
(1999, 0.016), (2000, 0.022), (2001, 0.03), (2002, 0.038), (2003, 0.047), (2004, 0.058), (2005, 0.072), (2006, 0.083), (2007, 0.089),
(2008, 0.093), (2009, 0.097), (2010, 0.1), (2011, 0.1), (2012, 0.1), (2013, 0.1), (2014, 0.1), (2015, 0.1)

GEOTHERMAL POWER

GTPIC1_MW(t) = GTPIC1_MW(t- dt) + (GTP_Online_Rate - GTPRetire1) * dt

INIT GTPICI_MW = 15/3

INFLOWS:
GTP_Online_Rate = GTPUC_MW/GTPUC_Delay

OUTFLOWS:

GTPRetirel = GTPICL_MW/(GTPIC_Delay/3)

GTPIC2_MW(t) = GTPIC2_MW(t - dt) + (GTPRetirel - GTPRetire2) * dt

INIT GTPIC2_MW = 15/3

INFLOWS:
GTPRetirel = GTPICl_MW/(GTPIC_Delay/3)
OUTFLOWS:

GTPRetire2 =

STPIC2_MW/(GTPIC_Delay/3)
GTPIC3_MW(t) = GTPIC3_MW(t - dt) + (GTPRetire2 - GTPRetire3) * dt

INIT GTPIC3_MW = 15/3

INFLOWS:
GTPRetire2 = GTPIC2._ MW/(GTPIC_Delay/3)

OUTFLOWS:
GTPRetire3 = GIPIC3_ MWi(GTPIC_Delay/3)
GTPpotNotUsedGWhyear(t) = GTPpotNotUsedGWhyear(t - dt) + (GTP_Pot_Added - GTPotUsage) * dt

INIT GTPpotNotUsedGWhyear = 18750-85

INFLOWS:
GTP_Pot_Added = GTPRetire3*GTPAvailability*GTPCapUtil*MaxWorkingHour
OUTFLOWS:

GTPotUsage = GTPInitiateGWh

GTPTotalCost(t) = GTPTotalCost(t - dt) + (GTPInstallCost + GTPOperCost) * dt

INIT GTPTotalCost = 0

INFLOWS:
GTPInstallCost = GTPInstalled*GTPInsCostperMW

GTPOperCost = GrsEleetGenbyGTPGWh*GTPOperCostperGWh
GTPUC_MW(t) = GTPUC_MW(t- dt) + (GTPInstalled - GTP_Online_ Rate) * dt

INIT GTPUC_MW=0

INFLOWS:
GTPinstalled = GTPotUsage/(GTPCapUtil*GTPA vailability*MaxWorkingHour)* 1000
OUTFLOWS:

GTP_Online_Rate = GIPUC_MW/GTPUC_Delay

DesiredUC_GTP = GTPRetire3*GTPUC_Delay

EmisRelbyGTP

1rsElectGenbyGTPGWh*GTPEmisTONperGWh

FutGTPNeedAllocGWh = IF TIME<1999 THEN (GTPFraclnitial*FutRENNeedGWh) ELSE
(FutRENNeedGWh*GTPSmthInsFrac)

GrsElectGenbyGTPGWh = IF TIME<1999 THEN (CurGrsElectGenA llocbyNationICGWh*GTPCapFract_Initial) ELSE
(CurGrsElectGenAllocbyNation|CGWh*GTPSmthCapFract)

GTPAvailability = 0.69

GTPcapFraet = TotGTPICGWh/TotGrsCapGWh
GTPCapFract_Initial = .001

GTPCapUtil = 1

GTPEmisTONperGWh = 75

GTPFracInitial = 0.002

GTPIC_Delay = 30

GTPInitiateGWh =
MIN(MAX(0,(InstallGTP_MW*GTPAvailability*GTPCapUtil* Max WorkingHout/1000)),GTPpotNotUsedGWhyear)

GTPInsCostperMW = 1450000
GTPInstFractRevised = GTP_Inst_Frac/RENInstFracAdjust
GTPOperCostperGWh = 0.0177* 1000000

GTPSmthCapFract = GTPcapFract*TransEff+GTPCapFraet_Initial*(1-TransEff)
GTPSmthInsFrac = (GTPFraclnitial*(1-TransEfi))+(GTPInstFractRevised*TransEff)

GTPUC_Delay =2

GTP_Inst_Frac = GTP_Poten_Rate*GTP_Priority

GTP_Poten_Rate = GTPpotNotUsedGWhyear/TotRENPotGWh

GTP _Priority = 1

InstallGTP_MW = (NeedGTP_MW-TotGTPIC_MW)/AT1+(DesiredUC_GTP-GTPUC_MW)/AT2+GTPRetire3
NeedGTP_MW = FutGTPNeedAllocGWh/GTPAvailability/GTPCapUtil/Max WorkingHour* 1000
TotGTPICGWh = TotGTPIC_MW*GTPAvailability*GTPCapUtil*Max WorkingHour/ 1000

TotGTPIC_MW = GTPIC]_ MW+GTPIC2_ MW+GTPIC3_ MW

HARD COAL POWER
HCPIC1_MW(t) = HCPIC1_MW(t- dt) + (HCP_Online_Rate - HCPRetire1) * dt

INIT HCPICI_MW = 332/3

INFLOWS:
HCP_Online_Rate = HCPUC_MW/HCUCDelay

OUTFLOWS:

HCPRetirel = HCPIC1_MW/HCPIC_Delay/3

HCPIC2_MW(t) = HCPIC2_MW(t- dt) + (HCPRetirel - HCPRetire2) * dt

INIT HCPIC2_MW = 332/3

INFLOWS:

HCPRetirel = HCPIC1_MW/HCPIC_Delay/3

OUTFLOWS:

HCPRetire2 = HCPIC2_ MW/HCPIC_Delay/3

HCPIC3_MW(t) = HCPIC3_MW(t - dt) + (HCPRetire2 - HCPRetire3) * dt

INIT HCPIC3_MW = 332/3

INFLOWS:
HCPRetire2 = HCPIC2_ MW/HCPIC_Delay/3

OUTFLOWS:

HCPRetire3 = HCPIC3_ MW/HCPIC_Delay/3

HCPTotalCost(t) = HCPTotalCost(t - dt) + (HCPInstallCost + HCPOperCost) * dt

INIT HCPTotalCost = 0

INFLOWS:
HCPInstallCost = HCP_Installed*HCPInsCostperMW
HCPOperCost = GrsEleeGenbyHCPGWh*HCPOperCostperGWh

HCPUC_MW(t) = HCPUC_MW(t- dt) + (HCP_Installed - HCP_Online_Rate) * dt
INIT HCPUC_MW = 150

INFLOWS:
HCP_Installed = max(0,InstallHCP_MW)

OUTFLOWS:

HCP_Online_Rate = HCPUC_MW/HCUCDelay

HCReserveTON(t) = HCReserveTON(t- dt) + (- YearlyHCDepletionTON) * dt

INIT HCReserveTON = (1124000000+23323000)

OUTFLOWS:
YearlyHCDepletion TON = DomGenbyHCPGWh*HCUseperGWh

CurHCPNeedAllocGWh = IF TIME<1999 THEN (CurGrsElectGenA llocbyNationICGWh*HCCapFract_Initial) ELSE
(CurGrsElectGenAllocbyNationICGWh*HCSmthCapFract)

DesiredUC_HC = HCPRetire3*HCUCDelay
DomGenbyHCPGWh = min(GrsElecGenbyHCPGWh,DomHCResPotenGWh)
DomHCResPotenGWh = YearlyMaxHCProd*HCPPConsRatio/HCUseperGWh/ProcessTime

EmisRelbyHCP =

‘sEleeGenbyHCPGWh*HCEmisTONperGWh

FutHCPNeedAllocGWh = IF TIME<1999 THEN (FutNRENNeedGWh* HCP InstFractInitial) ELSE
(FutNRENNeedGWh*HCPSmthInstFract*HC_Priority)

GrsElecGenbyHCPGWh = MIN (TotHCPICGWh,CurHCPNeedAllocGWh)

HCAvailability = .80

HCCapFract_Initial =
HCCapUtil = 1
HCEmisTONperGWh = 1112.5

HCImported TON = max(0,(HCTotalUsedTON-Y earlyHCDepletionTON))
HCPIC_Delay = 30

HCPInsCostperMW = 1450000

HCPOperCostperGWh = 0.035*1000000

HCPPConsRatio = .16

HCProdFr = 0.05

HCPSmthinstFract = HCP_InstFract*TransEff+HCP_InstFractlnitial*(1-TransEf)
HCP_InstFract = .16

HCP_InstFractInitial = 0

HCResRateInTotal = TotalPotHCEnergyGWh/TotalNonRenReserveGWh
HCSmthCapFract = HC_CapFract*TransEff+HCCapFraet_Initial*(1-TransEff)
HCTotalUsed TON = GrsElecGenbyHCPGWh*HCUseperGWh

HCUCDelay = 4

HCUseperGWh = 813

HC_CapFract = TotHCPICGWh/TotGrsCapGWh
HC Priority = 1
InstallHCP_MW = (NeedHCP_MW-TotHCPIC_MW)/AT1+(DesiredUC_HC-HCPUC_MW)/AT2+HCPRetire3
NeedHCP_MW = FutHCPNeedA llocGWh/HCAvailability/HCCapUtil/Max WorkingHour* 1000
TotalPotHCEnergyGWh = HCReserveTON*HCPPConsRatio/HCUseperGWh/ProcessTime

TotHCPICGWh = (HCPICL_MW+HCPIC2_MW+HCPIC3_MW)*HCAvailability*HCCapUtil*Max WorkingHour/1000
TotHCPIC_MW = HCPICL_MW+HCPIC2_ MW+HCPIC3_ MW

YearlyMaxHCProd = HCReserveTON*HCProdFr

HYDROPOWER
HPICIMW(t) = HPICIMW(t- dt) + (HP_Online_Rate - HPRetirel) * dt

INIT HPICIMW = (6764.3-186.05)/3

INFLOWS:
HP_Online_Rate = HP_UC_MW/HPUC_Delay

OUTFLOWS:

HPRetirel = HPICIMWi(HPIC_Delay/3)

HPIC2MW(t) = HPIC2MW(t - dt) + (HPRetire! - HPRetire2) * dt

INIT HPIC2MW = (6764.3-186.05)/3

INFLOWS:
HPRetirel = HPICIMW/(HPIC_Delay/3)

OUTFLOWS:

HPRetire2 = HPICDMWi(HPIC_Delay/3)

HPIC3MW(t) = HPIC3MW(t - dt) + (HPRetire2 - HPRetire3) * dt

INIT HPIC3MW = (6764.3-186.05)/3

INFLOWS:
HPRetire2 = HPICDMWi(HPIC_Delay/3)

OUTFLOWS:

HPRetire3 = HPIC3MWi(HPIC_Delay/3)

HPpotNotUsedGWhyear(t) = HPpotNotUsedGWhyear(t - dt) + (HP_Pot_Added - HPotUsage) * dt

INIT HPpotNotUsedGWhyear = (430000-23147.6)-691.2

INFLOWS:
HP_Pot_Added = HPRetire3*HPAvailability*HPCapUtil*MaxWorkingHour
OUTFLOWS:

HPotUsage = HPInitiateGWh

HPTotalCost(t) = HPTotalCost(t - dt) + (HPInstallCost + HPOperCost) * dt

INIT HPTotalCost = 0
INFLOWS:
HP InstallCost = HPInstalled*HPInsCostperMW

HPOperCost = GrsElectGenbyHPGWh*HPOperCostperGWh
HP_UC_MW(t) = HP_UC_MW(t- dt) + (HPInstalled - HP_Online_Rate) * dt

INIT HP_UC_MW = 2806.7

INFLOWS:
HPInstalled = HPotUsage/(HPCapUtil*HPA vailability*Max WorkingHour)* 1000

OUTFLOWS:

HP_Online_Rate = HP_UC_MW/HPUC_Delay

DesiredUC_HP = HPRetire3*HPUC_Delay

ElectGenbySmIBigHYDROICGWh = GrsElectGenbyHPGWh+GrsElectGenbySHPGWh

EmisnRelbyHP = GrsEleectGenbyHPGWh*HPEmisTONperGWh

FutHPNeedAllocGWh = IF TIME<1999 THEN (HPFraclnitial*FutRENNeedGWh) ELSE (FutRENNeedGWh*HPSmthinsFrac)

GrsElectGenbyHPGWh = IF TIME<1999 THEN (CurGrsElectGenA llocbyNationICGWh*HPCapFract_Initial) ELSE
(CurGrsElectGenAllocbyNation|CGWh* HPSmthCapFract)

HPAvailability = 0.45

HPcapFract = TotHPICGWh/TotGrsCapGWh

HPCapFract_Initial = 393

HPCapUtil = |

HPEmisTONperGWh = 200

HPFracInitial = .971

HPIC_Delay = 45

HPInitiateGWh = MIN(MAX(0,(InstallHP_MW*HPAvailability*HPCapUtil*MaxWorkingHour/1000)), HPpotNotUsedGWhyear)
HPInsCostperMW = 1200000

HPInstFractRevised = HP_Inst_Frac/RENInstFracAdjust

HPOperCostperGWh = 0,0005*1000000

HPSmthCapFract = HPeapFract*TransEffHPCapFract_Initial*(1-TransEff)
HPSmthInsFrac = (HPFracInitial*(1-TransEfi))+(HPInstFractRevised*TransEff)
HPUC_Delay = 6

HP_Inst_Frac=HP_Poten_Rate*HP Priority

HP_Poten_Rate = HPpotNotUsedGWhyear/TotRENPotGWh

HP _Priority = 1
InstallHP_MW = (NeedHP_MW-TotHPIC_MW)/AT1+(DesiredUC_HP-HP_UC_MW)/AT2+HPRetire}
NeedHP_MW = FutHPNeedAllocGWh/HPAvailability/HPCapUtil/MaxWorkingHour* 1000
SmIBigHYDROICGWh = TotHPICGWh+TotSHPICGWh

SmIBigHYDROIC_MW = TotHPIC_MW+TotSHPIC_MW

TotHPICGWh = TotHPIC_MW*HPAvailability*HPCapUtil*Max WorkingHout/ 1000
TotHPIC_MW = HPICIMW+HPIC2MW+HPIC3MW
TransEff = GRAPH(time)

(1990, 0.00), (1991, 0.00), (1992, 0.00), (1993, 0.00), (1994, 0.00), (1995, 0.00), (1996, 0.00), (1997, 0.00), (1998, 0.00), (1999,
0.095), (2000, 0.245), (2001, 0.675), (2002, 0.88), (2003, 1.00)

LIGNITE POWER

LigniteReserveTON({t) = LigniteReserveTON(t - dt) + (- YearlyLigDepTON) * dt

INIT LigniteReserveTON = (8374372000+462457000)

OUTFLOWS:
YearlyLigDepTON = DomGenbyLPGWh*LigUseperGWh
LPICI_MW(t) = LPICI_MW(t- dt) + (LP_Online_Rate - LPRetire1) * dt

INIT LPIC]_MW = 4896.2/3

INFLOWS:
LP_Online_Rate = LPUNConsMW/LPUCDelay

OUTFLOWS:

LPRetirel = LPICL_MW/LPIC_Delay/3

LPIC2_MW(t) = LPIC2_MW(t- dt) + (LPRetirel - LPRetire2) * dt

INIT LPIC2_MW = 4896.2/3

INFLOWS:
LPRetirel = LPIC]_MW/LPIC_Delay/3

OUTFLOWS:

LPRetire2 = LPIC2_ MW/LPIC_Delay/3

LPIC3_MW(t) = LPIC3_MW(t- dt) + (LPRetire2 - LPRetire3) * dt

INIT LPIC3_ MW = 4896.2/3

INFLOWS:
LPRetire2 = LPIC2_ MW/LPIC_Delay/3
OUTFLOWS:

LPRetire3 = LPIC3_ MW/LPIC_Delay/3

LPTotalCost(t) = LPTotalCost(t - dt) + (LPInstallCost + LPOper

INIT LPTotalCost = 0

INFLOWS:
LPInstallCost = LP_Installed*LPInstCostperMW.

LPOperCos

GrsElecGenbyLPGWh*LPOperCostperGWh
LPUNConsMW(t) = LPUNConsMW(t- dt) + (LP_Installed - LP_Online_Rate) * dt

INIT LPUNConsMW = 1212
INFLOWS:

LP_Installed = max(0,InstallLP_MW)
OUTFLOWS:

LP_Online_Rate = LPUNConsMW/LPUCDelay
ATI =2

AT2=2

CurLPNeedAllocGWh = IF TIME<1999 THEN (CurGrsElectGenA llocbyNationICGWh* LigCapFract_Initial) ELSE
(CurGrsElectGenAllocbyNationICGWh*LigSmthCapFract)

DesiredUC_LP = LPRetire3*LPUCDelay

DomGenbyLPGWh = min(GrsElecGenbyLPGWh,DomLigResPotGWh)
DomLigResPotGWh = YearlyMaxLigProdTON*LigPPConsRatio/LigUseperGWh
EmisRelbyLP = GrsElecGenbyLPGWh*LigEmisTONperGWh

FutLPNeedAllocGWh = IF TIME<1999 THEN (FutNRENNeedGWh*LP_InstFractInitial) ELSE
(FutNRENNeedGWh*LigSmthInstFract*LP_Priority)

GrsElecGenbyLPGWh = MIN (TotLPICGWh,CurLPNeedAllocGWh)
InstallLP_MW = (NeedLP_MW-TotLPIC_MW)/AT1+(DesiredUC_LP-LPUNConsMW)/AT2+LPRetire3
LigCapFract_Initial =.316

LigEmisTONperGWh = 1112.5

LigimportedTON = Max(0,(LigTotalUsedTON-YearlyLigDepTON))
LigProdFr= 0.10

LigResRatelnTotal = TotalLigResGWh/TotalNonRenReserveGWh
LigSmthCapFract = Lig_CapFract*TransEff+LigCapFraet_Initial*(1-TransEff)
LigSmthinstFract = LP_InstFract*TransEff+LP_InstFractInitial*(1-TransEff)
LigTotalUsedTON = GrsElecGenbyLPGWh*LigUseperGWh

LigUseperGWh = 1593

Lig_CapFract = TotLPICGWh/TotGrsCapGWh

LPAvailability = 0.90

LPCapUtil = 1

LPIC_Delay = 30

LPInstCostperMW = 1600000

LPOperCostperGWh = 0.025*1000000

LPUCDelay = 4

LP_InstFract = 20

LP_InstFractlnitial = .53

LP Priority = 1

MaxWorkingHour = 365*24

NeedLP_MW = FutLPNeedAllocGWh/LPAvailability/LPCapUtil/MaxWorkingHour* 1000

ProcessTime = |
TotalLigResGWh = (LigniteReserve TON*LigPPConsRatio/LigUseperGWh)/ProcessTime

TotalNonRenReserveGWh = TotalLigResGWh+TotalPotNGEnergyGWh+TotalP otOilEnergyGWh+ TotalPotHCEnergyGWh
TotLPICGWh = TotLPIC_MW*LPAvailability*LPCapUtil*Max WorkingHour/1000

TotLPIC_MW = LPICI_MW+LPIC2_ MW+LPIC3_ MW

YearlyMaxLigProdTON = LigniteReserveTON*LigProdFr

YearlyMaxLinProdGWhyear = (YearlyMaxLigProdTON/LigUseperGWh)/ProcessTime

LigPPConsRatio = GRAPH(time)

(1990, 0.65), (1991, 0.66), (1992, 0.685), (1993, 0.715), (1994, 0.755), (1995, 0.795), (1996, 0.825), (1997, 0.85), (1998, 0.85)

NATURAL GAS POWER
NGPICI_MW(t) = NGPIC1_MW(t- dt) + (NGP_Online_Rate - NGPRetirel) * dt

INIT NGPIC1_MW = 2210/3

INFLOWS:
NGP_Online_Rate = NGPUC_MW/NGUCDelay

OUTFLOWS:

NGPRetirel = NGPIC1_MW/NGPIC_Delay/3

NGPIC2_MW(t) = NGPIC2_MW(t- dt) + (NGPRetirel - NGPRetire2) * dt

INIT NGPIC2_MW = 2210/3

INFLOWS:
NGPRetirel = NGPIC1_MW/NGPIC_Delay/3

OUTFLOWS:

NGPRetire2 = NGPIC2_MW/NGPIC_Delay/3

NGPIC3_MW(t) = NGPIC3_MW(t- dt) + (NGPRetire2 - NGPRetire3) * dt

INIT NGPIC3_MW = 2210/3

INFLOWS:
NGPRetire2 = NGPIC2_ MW/NGPIC_Delay/3

OUTFLOWS:

NGPRetire3 = NGPIC3_ MW/NGPIC_Delay/3

NGPTotalCost(t) = NGPTotalCost(t - dt) + (NGPInstallCost + NGPOperCost) * dt

INIT NGPTotalCost = 0

INFLOWS:
NGPInstallCost = NGP_Installed*NGInsCostperMW

NGPOperCost = GrsElecGenbyNGPGWh*NGPOperCostperGWh.

NGPUC_MW(t) = NGPUC_MW(t- dt) + (NGP_Installed - NGP_Online_Rate) * dt

INIT NGPUC_MW = 345.4
INFLOWS:
NGP_Installed = max(0,InstalINGP_MW)

OUTFLOWS:

NGP_Online_Rate = NGPUC_MW/NGUCDelay

NGReservemm3(t) = NGReservemm3(t - dt) + (- YearlyNGDepmm3) * dt
INIT NGReservemm3 = (18530-3537+2219)

OUTFLOWS:

YearlyNGDepmm3 = DomGenbyNGPGWh*NGUseperGWh

CurtNGNeedAllocGWh = IF TIME<1999 THEN (CurGrsElectGenA llocbyNationICGWh*NGCapFract_Initial) ELSE
(CurGrsElectGenAllocbyNationICGWh*NGSmthCapFract)

DesiredUC_OP = NGPRetire3*NGUCDelay

DomGenbyNGPGWh = min(GrsElecGenbyNGPGWh,DomNGResPotenGWh)
DomNGResPotenGWh = YearlyMaxNGProd*NGPPConsRatio/NGUseperGWh/ProcessTime
EmisRelbyNGP = GrsElecGenbyNGPGWh*NGEmismm3perGWh.

FutNGPNeedAllocGWh = IF TIME<1999 THEN (FutNRENNeedGWh*NG _InstFractlnitial) ELSE
(FutNRENNeedGWh*NGSmthinstFract*NGP_Priority)

GrsElecGenbyNGPGWh = MIN (TotNGICGWh,CurtNGNeedA llocGWh)
InstallNGP_MW = (NeedNGP_MW-TotNGPIC_MW)/AT1+(DesiredUC_OP-NGPUC_MW)/AT2+NGPRetire}
NeedNGP_MW = FutNGPNeedAllocGWh/NGA vailability/NGCapUtil/MaxWorkingHour* 1000
NGAvailability = 0.85

NGCapFract_Initial = 187

NGCapUtil = 1

NGEmismm3perGWh = 825

NGImportedmm3 = Max (0,(NGTotalUsedmm3-Y earlyNGDepmm3))

NGInsCostperMW = 680000

NGPIC_Delay = 40

NGPOperCostperGWh = 0.03*1000000

NGPPConsRatio = .60

NGP_InstFract = .55

NGP Priority = 1

NGResRatelnTotal = TotalPotNGEnergyGWh/TotalNonRenReserveGWh

NGSmthCapFract = NG_CapFract*TransEff+NGCapFraet_Initial*(1-TransEff)
NGSmthinstFract = NGP_InstFract*TransEff+NG_InstFraetInitial*(1-TransEff)
NGTotalUsedmm3 = GrsEleeGenbyNGPGWh*NGUseperGWh

NGUCDelay = 3

NGUseperGWh = 0.238

NG_CapFract = TotNGICGWh/TotGrsCapGWh

NG_InstFractlnitial = 47
TotalPotNGEnergyGWh = NGReservemm3*NGPPConsRatio/NGUseperGWh/ProcessTime
TotNGICGWh = TotNGPIC_MW*NGAvailability*NGCapUtil*MaxWorkingHour/1000

TotNGPIC_MW = NGPICI_MW+NGPIC2_MW+NGPIC3_ MW

YearlyMaxNGProd = NGReservemm3*NGProdFr

NGProdFr = GRAPH(time)

(1990, 0.01), (1991, 0.0115), (1992, 0.017), (1993, 0.0285), (1994, 0.0605), (1995, 0.0755), (1996, 0.0845), (1997, 0.0935), (1998,
0.1)

OIL POWER

CrudeOilReserveTON(t) = CrudeOilReserveTON(t - dt) + (- YearlyOilDepTON) * dt

INIT CrudeOilReserveTON = (977185000-106586000+33725000)

OUTFLOWS:
YearlyOilDepTON = DomGenbyOPGWh*OilUseperGWh
OPIC2MW(t) = OPICZMW(t- dt) + (OPRetirel - OPRetire2) * dt

INIT OPIC2MW = (1552+546)/3

INFLOWS:
OPRetirel = OPICMW/OPIC_Delay/3

OUTFLOWS:

OPRetire2 = OPIC2MW/OPIC_Delay/3

OPIC3MW(t) = OPIC3MW(t- dt) + (OPRetire2 - OPRetire3) * dt

INIT OPIC3MW = (1552+546)/3

INFLOWS:
OPRetire2 = OPIC2MW/OPIC_Delay/3

OUTFLOWS:

OPRetire3 = OPIC3MW/OPIC_Delay/3

OPICMW(t) = OPICMW(t - dt) + (OP_Online_Rate - OPRetirel) * dt

INIT OPICMW = (1552+546)/3

INFLOWS:
OP_Online_Rate = OPUNConsMW/OPUCDelay
OUTFLOWS:

OPRetirel = OPICMW/OPIC_Delay/

OPTotalCost(t) = OPTotalCost(t - dt) + (OPInstallCost + OPOperCost) * dt

INIT OPTotalCost = 0

INFLOWS:

OPInstallCost = OP_Installed*OPInsCostperMW
OPOperCost = GrsEleeGenbyOilGWh*OPOperCostperGWh

OPUNConsMW(t) = OPUNConsMW(t - dt) + (OP_Installed - OP_Online_Rate) * dt
INIT OPUNConsMW = 0

INFLOWS:

OP _Installed = max(0,InstallOP_MW)

OUTFLOWS:

OP_Online_Rate = OPUNConsMW/OPUCDelay

CurOPNeedAllocGWh = IF TIME<1999 THEN (CurGrsElectGenA llocbyNationICGWh*OilCapFract_Initial) ELSE
(CurGrsElectGenAllocbyNationICGWh*OilSmthCapFract)

DesiredUCOil = OPRetire3*OPUCDelay

DomGenbyOPGWh = min(GrsElecGenbyOilGWh,DomOilResPotenGWh)
DomOilResPotenGWh = YearlyMaxOilProd*OilPPConsRatio/OilUseperGWh/ProcessTime
EmisRelbyOP = GrsElecGenbyOilGWh*OilEmisTONperGWh

FutOPNeedAllocGWh = IF TIME<1999 THEN (FutNRENNeedGWh*OP_InstFractlnitial) ELSE
(FutNRENNeedGWh*OPSmthinstFract*Oil_Priority)

GrsElecGenbyOilGWh = MIN (TotOPICGWh,CurOPNeedA llocGWh)

InstallOP_MW = (NeedOP_MW-TotOPIC_MW)/AT1+(DesiredUCOil-OPUNConsMW)/AT2+OPRetire3
NeedOP_MW = FutOPNeedAllocGWh/OPA vailability/OPCapUtil/Max WorkingHour* 1000
OilCapFract_Initial = .068

OilEmisTONperGWh = 825

OillmportedTON = Max(0,(OilTotalUsedTON-Y earlyOilDepTON))

OilProdFr = 0.05

OilResRateInTotal = TotalPotOilEnergyGWh/TotalNonRenReserveGWh

OilSmthCapFract = Oil_CapFract*TransEff+OilCapFract_Initial*(1-TransEft)
OilTotalUsedTON = GrsElecGenbyOilGWh*OilUseperGWh

OilUseperGWh = 277

Oil_CapFract = TotOPICGWh/TotGrsCapGWh.

Oil_Priorit
OPAvailability = .60

OPCapUtil = 1

OPIC_Delay = 30

OPInsCostperMW = 2000000

OPOperCostperGWh = 0.06* 1000000

OPSmthInstFract = OP_InstFract*TransEf+OP_InstFractlnitial*(1-TransEft)
OPUCDelay = 4

OP_InstFract = .09

OP_InstFractinitial = 0

TotalPotOilEnergyGWh = CrudeOilReserve TON*OilPPConsRatio/OilUseperGWh/ProcessTime
TotOPICGWh = TotOPIC_MW*OPAvailability*OPCapUtil*Max WorkingHour/1000

TotOPIC_MW = OPICMW+OPIC2MW+OPIC3MW

YearlyMaxOilProd = CrudeOilReserveTON*OilProdFr

OilPPConsRatio = GRAPH(time)

(1990, 0.05), (1991, 0.0532), (1992, 0.057), (1993, 0.066), (1994, 0.0795), (1995, 0.0907), (1996, 0.0968), (1997, 0.099), (1998,
0.1)

SMALL SCALED HYDROPOWER

SHPICI_MW(t) = SHPICI_MW(t- dt) + (SHP_Online_Rate - SHPRetire1) * dt

INIT SHPICI_MW = 186.05/3

INFLOWS:
SHP_Online_Rate = SHPUC_MW/SHPUC_Delay

OUTFLOWS:
SHPRetirel = SHPICL_ MW/(SHPIC_Delay/3)

SHPIC2_MW(t) = SHPIC2_MW(t - dt) + (SHPRetire! - SHPRetire2) * dt

INIT SHPIC2_MW = 186.05/3

INFLOWS:
SHPRetire] = SHPICI_MW/(SHPIC_Delay/3)

OUTFLOWS:

SHPRetire2 = SHPIC2_MW/(SHPIC_Delay/3)

SHPIC3_MW(t) = SHPIC3_MW(t - dt) + (SHPRetire2 - SHPRetire3) * dt

INIT SHPIC3_MW = 186.05/3

INFLOWS:
SHPRetire2 = SHPIC2_MW/(SHPIC_Delay/3)

OUTFLOWS:

SHPRetire3 = SHPIC3_ MW/(SHPIC_Delay/3)

SHPpotNotUsedGWhyear(t) = SHPpotNotUsedGWhyear(t - dt) + (SHP_Pot_Added - SHPotUsage) * dt

INIT SHPpotNotUsedGWhyear = 32900-3695

INFLOWS:
SHP_Pot_Added = SHPRetire3*SHPA vailability*SHPCapUtil*MaxWorkingHour
OUTFLOWS:

SHPotUsage = SHPInitiateGWh

SHPTotalCost(t) = SHPTotalCost(t - dt) + (SHPInstallCost + SHPOperCost) * dt

INIT SHPTotalCost = 0

INFLOWS:

SHPlnstallCost = SHPInstalled*SHPInsCostperMW
SHPOperCost = GrsElectGenbySHPGWh*SHPOperCostperGWh
SHPUC_MW(t) = SHPUC_MW(t- dt) + (SHPInstalled - SHP_Online_Rate) * dt

INIT SHPUC_MW =8.8

INFLOWS:
SHPInstalled = SHPotUsage/(SHPCapUtil*SHPA vailability*MaxWorkingHour)*1000
OUTFLOWS:

SHP_Online_Rate = SHPUC_MW/SHPUC_Delay

DesiredUC_SHP = SHPRetire3*SHPUC_Delay

EmisRelbySHP = Gi

‘ElectGenbySHPGWh*SHPEmisTONperGWh

FutSHPNeedAllocGWh = IF TIME<1999 THEN (SHPFraclnitial*FutRENNeedGWh) ELSE
(FutRENNeedGWh*SHPSmthinsFrac)

GrsElectGenbySHPGWh = IF TIME<1999 THEN (CurGrsElectGenA llocbyNationICGWh*SHPCapFract_Initial) ELSE
(CurGrsElectGenAllocbyNationICGWh*SHPSmthCapFract)

InstallSHP_MW = (NeedSHP_MW-TotSHPIC_MW)AT1+(DesiredUC_SHP-SHPUC_MW)/AT2+SHPRetire3
NeedSHP_MW = FutSHPNeedAllocGWh/SHPA vailability/SHPCapUtil/ Max WorkingHour* 1000
SHPAvailability = 0.60

SHPeapFract = TotSHPICGWh/TotGrsCapGWh

SHPCapFract_Initial = .011

SHPCapUtil = 1

SHPEmisTONperGWh = 200

SHPFraclnitial = .027

SHPIC_Delay = 45

SHPlInitiateGWh =
MIN(MAX(0,(InstallSHP_MW*SHPAvailability*SHPCapUtil* Max WorkingHout/1000)),SHPpotNotUsedGWhyear)

SHPInsCostperMW = 750000
SHPInstFractRevised = SHP_Inst_Frac/RENInstFracAdjust

SHPOperCostperGWh = 0.0005*1000000

SHPSmthCapFract = SHPeapFract*TransEff+SHPCapFract_Initial*(1-TransEft)
SHPSmthinsFrac = (SHPFraclnitial*(1-TransEff))+(SHPInstFractRevised*TransEff)
SHPUC_Delay = I

SHP_Inst_Frac = SHP_Poten_Rate*SHP_Priority

SHP_Poten_Rate = SHPpotNotUsedGWhyear/TotRENPotGWh

SHP_Priority = 1

TotSHPICGWh = TotSHPIC_MW*SHPAvailability*SHPCapUtil*MaxWorkingHour/1000

TotSHPIC_MW = SHPIC1_MW-+SHPIC2_ MW+SHPIC3_ MW

SOLAR POWER,

SPICI1_MW(t) = SPICL_MW(t- dt) + (SP_Online_Rate - SPRetirel) * dt
INIT SPICI_ MW =0

INFLOWS:
SP_Online_Rate = SPUC_MW/SPUC_Delay

OUTFLOWS:

SPRetirel = SPIC|_MWi(SPIC_Delay/3)

SPIC2_MW(t) = SPIC2_MW(t- dt) + (SPRetirel - SPRetire2) * dt

INIT SPIC2_ MW =0

INFLOWS:
SPRetirel = SPIC|_MWi(SPIC_Delay/3)

OUTFLOWS:

SPRetire2 = SPIC2_MWi(SPIC_Delay/3)

SPIC3_MW(t) = SPIC3_MW(t- dt) + (SPRetire2 - SPRetire3) * dt

INIT SPIC3_ MW =0

INFLOWS:
SPRetire2 = SPIC2_MW/(SPIC_Delay/3)

OUTFLOWS:

SPRetire3 = SPIC3_MW/(SPIC_Delay/3)

SPTotalCost(t) = SPTotalCost(t - dt) + (SPInstallCost + SPOperCost) * dt

INIT SPTotalCost = 0

INFLOWS:
SPlnstallCost = $PInstalled*SPInsCostperMW

SPOperC

= GrsElectGenbySPGWh*SPOperCostperGWh
SPUC_MW(t) = SPUC_MW(t- dt) + (SPInstalled - SP_Online_ Rate) * dt

INIT SPUC_MW =0

INFLOWS:
SPinstalled = SPotUsage/(SPAvailability*SPCapUtil*Max WorkingHour)*1000

OUTFLOWS:

SP_Online_Rate = SPUC_MW/SPUC_Delay

SP_potNotUsedGWhYear(t) = SP_potNotUsedGWhYear(t - dt) + (SP_Pot_Added - SPotUsage) * dt
INIT SP_potNotUsedGWhY ear = 80000000

INFLOWS:

SP_Pot_Added = SPRetire3*SPAvailability*SPCapUtil*MaxW orkingHour

OUTFLOWS:

SPotUsage = SPinitiateGWhyear
DesiredUC_SP = SPRetire3*SPUC_Delay

EmisRelbySP =

‘sElectGenbySPGWh*SPEmisTONperGWh

FutSPNeedAllocGWhyear = IF TIME<1999 THEN (SPinstFraclnitial*FutRENNeedGWh) ELSE
(FutRENNeedGWh*SPSmthInsFrac)

GrsElectGenbySPGWh = IF TIME<1999 THEN (CurGrsElectGenA llocbyNationICGWh*SPCapFract_Initial) ELSE
(CurGrsElectGenAllocbyNationICGWh*SPSmthCapFract)

InstallSP_MW = (NeedSP_MW-TotSPIC_MW)AT1+(DesiredUC_SP-SPUC_MW)/AT2+SPRetire3
NeedSP_MW = FutSPNeedAIlocGWhyear/SPA vailability/SPCapUtil/Max WorkingHour* 1000
SPAvailability = .30

SPcapFrae = TotSPICGWh/TotGrsCapGWh

SPCapFract_Initial = 0

SPCapUtil = 1

SPEmisTONperGWh = 175

SPIC_Delay = 25

SPInitiateGWhyear =
MIN(MAX(0,(InstallSP_MW*SPAvailability*SPCapUtil*MaxWorkingHour/1000)),SP_potNotUsedGWh Year)

SPInsCostperMW = 6000000
SPinstFrac = SP_Poten_Rate*SP_Priority
SPinstFracinitial = 0

SPInstFractRevised = SPInstFrac/RENInstFracA djust
SPOperCostperGWh = 0.20* 1000000

SPSmthCapFract = SPeapFrac*TransEff+SPCapFract_Initial*(1-TransEff)
SPSmthInsFrac = (SPInstFracinitial*(1-TransEff))+(SPInstFractRevised*TransEff)
SPUC_Delay = 1

SP_Poten_Rate = SP_potNotUsedGWhY ear/TotRENPotGWh

SP_Priority = 1

TotSPICGWh = TotSPIC_MW*SPAvailability*SPCapUtil*Max WorkingHour/1000

TotSPIC_MW = SPIC1_MW+SPIC2_MW+SPIC3_MW

WIND POWER
WPICI_MW(t) = WPICI_MW(t- dt) + (WP_Online_Rate - WPRetire!) * dt

INIT WPIC]_ MW =0

INFLOWS:
WP_Online_Rate = WPUC_MW/WPUC_Delay

OUTFLOWS:

WPRetirel = WPICl_MWi(WPIC_Delay/3)

WPIC2_MW(t) = WPIC2_MW(t- dt) + (WPRetirel - WPRetire2) * dt

INIT WPIC2_MW =0
INFLOWS:
WPRetirel = WPIC]_MW/(WPIC_Delay/3)

OUTFLOWS:

WPRetire2 = WPIC2_MWi(WPIC_Delay/3)

WPIC3_MW(t) = WPIC3_MW(t- dt) + (WPRetire2 - WPRetire3) * dt

INIT WPIC3_MW =0

INFLOWS:
WPRetire2 = WPIC2_MWi(WPIC_Delay/3)

OUTFLOWS:

WPRetire3 = WPIC3_MWi(WPIC_Delay/3)

WPpotNotUsedGWhY ear(t) = WPpotNotUsedGWhY ear(t - dt) + (WP_Pot_Added - WPotUsage) * dt

INIT WPpotNotUsedGWhY ear = (400000+180000)

INFLOWS:
WP_Pot_Added = WPRetire3*WPA vailability* WPCapUtil*MaxWorkingHour
OUTFLOWS:

WPotUsage = WPinitiateGWh

WPTotalCost(t) = WPTotalCost(t - dt) + (WPInstallCost + WPOperCost) * dt

INIT WPTotalCost = 0

INFLOWS:

WPlnstallCos

WPlnstalled* WPInsCostper-MW
WPOperCost = GrsElectGebyWPGWh*WPOperCostperGWh
WPUC_MW(t) = WPUC_MW(t- dt) + (WPInstalled - WP_Online_Rate) * dt

INIT WPUC_MW=0

INFLOWS:
WPlnstalled = WPotUsage/( WPA vailability* WPCapUtil*MaxWorkingHour)*1000

OUTFLOWS:

WP_Online_Rate = WPUC_MW/WPUC_Delay

DesiredUC_WP = WPRetire3*WPUC_Delay

EmisRelbyWP = GrsElectGebyWPGWh*WPEmisTONperGWh

FutWPNeedA llocGWh = IF TIME<1999 THEN (\WPFraclnitial*FutRENNeedGWh) ELSE (FutRENNeedGWh*WPSmthInsFrac)

GrsElectGebyWPGWh = IF TIME<1999 THEN (CurGrsElectGenAllocbyNationICGWh* WPCapFract_Initial) ELSE
(CurGrsElectGenAllocbyNation[CGWh* WPSmthCapFract)

InstallWP_MW = (NeedWP_MW-TotWPIC_MW)/AT1+(Desire(UC_WP-WPUC_MW)/AT2+WPRetire3
NeedWP_MW = FutWPNeedA llocGWh/WPA vailability/ WPCapUtil/Max WorkingHour* 1000

TotWPICGWh = TotWPIC_MW*WPAvailability* WPCapUtil*Max WorkingHour/ 1000
TotWPIC_MW = WPIC]_MW+WPIC2_MW+WPIC3_MW
WPAvailability = 0.30

WPcapFrac = TotWPICGWh/TotGrsCapGWh
WPCapFract_Initial = 0

WPCapUtil = 1

WPEmisTONperGWh = 75

WPFraclnitial = 0

WPIC_Delay = 25

WPInitiateGWh =
MIN(MAX(0,(InstallWP_MW*WPAvailability*WPCapUtil* Max WorkingHour/1000)), WPpotNotUsedGWhY ear)

WPlnsCostperMW = 1450000
WPlnstFrac = WP_Poten_Rate*WP_Priority

WPInstFractRevised = WPInstFrac/RENInstFracAdjust

WPOperCostperGWh = 0.045*1000000

WPSmthCapFraet = WPeapFrac*TransEff+WPCapFract_Initial*(1-TransEff)
WPSmthinsFrae = (WPFracInitial*(1-TransEfi))+(WPInstFractRevised*TransEft)
WPUC_Delay = 1

WP _Poten_Rate = WPpotNotUsedGWhY ear/TotRENPotGWh

Back to the Top

WP Priority = 1

Metadata

Resource Type:
Document
Rights:
Date Uploaded:
December 19, 2019

Using these materials

Access:
The archives are open to the public and anyone is welcome to visit and view the collections.
Collection restrictions:
Access to this collection is unrestricted unless otherwide denoted.
Collection terms of access:
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Access options

Ask an Archivist

Ask a question or schedule an individualized meeting to discuss archival materials and potential research needs.

Schedule a Visit

Archival materials can be viewed in-person in our reading room. We recommend making an appointment to ensure materials are available when you arrive.