Najad Amiri, Ali Askary with Mohammad Taqi Kian and Iman Naderi, "Increasing Mobile Operator Revenue Out of VAS, A System Dynamics Approach", 2008 July 20-2008 July 24

Online content

Fullscreen
In the name of God

Increasing Mobile Operator Revenue Out of VAS,
A System Dynamics Approach

Ali A. Nejad Amiri

Graduate School of Management & Economics
Sharif University of Technology
Azadi Avenue, Tehran, Iran
AliAskary_n_a@yahoo.com

Mohammad T. Kian

Graduate School of Management & Economics
Sharif University of Technology
Azadi Avenue, Tehran, Iran
mtkian@yahoo.com

Abstract

Telecommunication industry is not comparable with many industries in view of rapid
market and technological change. In this industry, Mobile Communications is one of the
most attractive segments. The new and novel trends can be seen in Telecommunication
industry from time to time which suggesting various dynamics and relationships in this
industry development.

In this article, we will examine and analyze existing trends in mobile operators’ services to
find out the position of Value Added Service (VAS). Then, existing dynamics in delivering
Mobile VAS will be deduced through VAS value chain analysis and its market
characteristics. We will simulate and execute the proposed dynamic model and get
acquainted with the behavior of model elements and analyze them. Finally, two policies
will be suggested and with the analysis of results of these two policies, some
recommendations will be made for mobile network operators to maximize their revenues
out of VAS.

Keywords: Mobile VAS, Mobile Commerce, Value Chain, System Dynamics
1- Introduction

Telecom industry historically, due to its intrinsic monopoly and its tremendous impact on
human lives, has been a profitable industry. With the beginning of deregulation in 80’s and
advent of mobile phones and internet, the telecom industry experienced increased
competition. As in the beginning of the deregulations due to increased productivity, the
revenues of telecom companies went high, however, with increased competition, the profit
margin of these companies reduced. This fact with technology development persuaded the
mobile phone operators to deliver new kind of services in addition to voice services.
Mobile phone operators for attracting more subscribers and increasing revenue per user,
started to deliver Value Added Services (VAS) including short messaging system (SMS),
data transmission and internet connection services (GPRS),controlled internet portal, new
voice services like voice inbox, multimedia messaging services(MMS),videoconferencing ,
location based service(LBS) and TV broadcast on mobile phones.

With delivering of VAS from operators, many applications can be developed using these
basic services like SMS, MMS, geographic positioning and connecting to internet. In this
study, some basic services like SMS and mobile internet which are delivered from mobile
network operators are called Value Added Services or VAS. Mobile Services or M-
Services also suggesting some applications, generally delivered by third parties companies
which are different form network operators, including M-Banking and M-Commerce.

2- Problem definition

The main problem on which we will focus in this article is related to this fact that in mobile
operators’ services market, especially when the market is going toward the saturation and
maturity, the value added service (VAS) of each operator will be the most important factor
of operators’ competition. As the voice market reaches saturation continued industry
growth is contingent on the development of new mobile data services or VAS (1).

From the introduction of mobile phone services to the market until the saturation of this
market, the main service that mobile phone operators offer was the voice service. However,
saturation of voice service industry and increased competition in the market gave rise to
offering new services and utilizing new strategies by different operators to enable them to
get more market share and profitability out of this industry.

Considering Porter Generic strategies (2), we can find out that the main direction of
operators’ movement in the market will be nothing except differentiation and offering new
features in their services. In this position, cost leadership strategies should be used
vigilantly or in combination with focus strategy since it may develop price war and lower
profit for each operator.

The most significant factor and differentiation method in the saturated and mature service
market is offering Value Added Services or VAS in addition to voice service which will
give rise to more market share and market development.
Our main problem in the study is “How an operator can exploit VAS, considering
dynamics of the Mobile core and augmented services and M-Commerce, to increase its
revenue and success in competition”.

To get more knowledge into the significance of the VAS in the mobile operators’ services
market, we will exhibit in the following diagrams (fig. 1) the statistics about the mobile
phone penetration, services and revenues in Iran and world.

This diagram (fig. 1) is demonstrating the statistics about the subscriber growth rate in Iran.

20000000
15000000
10000000
5000000 |
of =
1994 2005 += 2006-—s mid 2007

Figure 1: Iran mobile operators’ subscribers
Source: Iran Telecommunication Company Report, August 2004

As indicated in figure 1, the growth rate of subscribers is exponential which is according to
the offer of voice services by operators; however this exponential trend will not be stable
which the growth trend of other countries is approving this claim.

Mobile subsoribers and ponctration rate in UK st voare

Met tse

fe Total able cbse (nian) ERB Mobsn atrcunr tase vhs napulaon

Figure 2: UK mobile penetration rate
Source: IDATE
According to figure2, in UK, Exponential growth slowed when the market is approaching
to maturity. In fact, growth rate is logistic, S-shaped form. The trend is observed not only in
UK but also in many other developed countries. The following diagram (fig.3) displays the

above point.

Evolution of Mobile Penetr:

n Rates in Europe

120
es wen
Ss ds
100 3h
2 %
2 80 by art
2 =
= 2
5 60 {RS
s ye
%
5 40
2
2
B 20
=
o+4
May-90 Jan-93 Oct-95 Ju-L98 Apr-O1 Jan04 Oct-06 JulLog
——Denmark Finland —— France —— Germany
— Netherlands —— Norway — Sweden _ ——UK

Figure 3: mobile penetration rate in eight countries

Similar trend is predicted for Iran, i.e. in future, penetration rate growth in Iran will have
remarkable decline. The next chart (fig. 4) is Iran mobile penetration rate forecast:

36.0%
55.0%.
sox 330%

—

zoccocce
a

15000000
10000000 }-
5000000 |
04

[m Number of Total Mobile Lines |

2008 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016

Mobile Penetration *

Figure 4: Iran penetration rate growth prediction
Source: Iran Telecommunication Company Report
Another concern is decreasing trend of Revenue per User (RPU) in Iran (3) and other part
of world as indicated in figure 5.

Global evolution of ARPU and total Revenues

14 460
42 400
350
= 10
H 00 FP
= $
= 8 &
3 — ae
a 4ee0-2000 2006-2010 a=
2 | wos omg 160
44 Manet pee Sam
foctome: isu Ja 100
W. Europe: 85% -15,8%
21 cesamena 49% $46 50
ote Sen a
oO o

1999 2000-2001.» 2002.-S- «2003» 2004S 2006 += 2010

‘SOURCE Deloitte Research

Figure 5: Global trend of mobile operators Revenue & RPU.
Source: Deloitte Research

The above diagram (Fig.5) is exhibiting both total revenue and revenue per user of mobile
operators’ services in the world. Considerable decline of RPU is seen in the diagram,
nevertheless total revenue keep increasing. Obviously the main reason of increasing total
revenue, despite of RPU decrease, is mobile network subscribers’ increase, however as
indicated before, mobile network subscribers will decline in Iran and similarly in other
countries. Therefore, with existing operators’ strategies, applications and _ services,
operators’ revenue will decline certainly. This prediction is confirmed by “Deloitte
Research” in figure6.

Operators’ solution for this issue is VAS which is widely accepted and used. Following

figure (fig. 6) confirm the assertion.
Mobile worldwide revenues*

USS billion
Tra = Se
31%
877
365
Data $35. 680 10%
ast
Voice |
2001 2008 20008

*2001-2005E from Yanks

O65, Strategy Analytics 0806,

Ov im 08.05

Figure 6: Mobile worldwide revenue, dividing voice and data share
Source: Yankee group
As observed in figure6, revenue growth of voice service between 2001 and 2005 was %10,
whereas revenue growth of VAS service was %31. This difference is predicted to increase
in the future. All above trends and forecasts indicates significant role of VAS in mobile
operators’ service market which should be carefully observed and considered.

3- VAS Industry Review
3-1- VAS Value Chain

VAS value chain includes both concepts of M-service and VAS (4). Significant players in
the VAS market can be recognized with Study of VAS value chain which are categorized
as follows (5):

e Network operators: These operators provide the infrastructure for M-Services with
delivering of VAS. Hence, delivering any M-Services from any independent
companies is depending on delivering VAS from operators.

e Service providers: deliver M-Services on VAS and sell them. Operators usually
propose some special platforms on which M-Services providers deliver their
services and is charged to a percentage between 10 to 25 percent for using of
platform.

¢ Content Providers: These companies provide required contents like text, voice,
music, picture and film for service-oriented contents and sell them to M-Service
provider companies. In immature market and in most cases, M-Service providers
deliver the required contents themselves.

e Mobile Phone and Equipment manufacturer: These companies have crucial roles for
VAS prevalence with their equipments which support these services. In many cases,
new VAS is introduced to the market with cooperation of both operators and
equipment manufacturers.

e Infrastructure Providers: These companies provide backbone of mobile phone
network for operators regarding hardware and equipments and should deliver
required service quality for VAS.

e VAS End Users: These users, eventually determine whether VAS is successful or
not.

¢ Government: With approved rules and regulations and its monitoring activities is
affecting VAS a lot.

Operators are cores in the value chain (5). On the one hand, operators possess network
infrastructure and large customer resources. On the other hand, Service Providers can only
provide services to end users through the network infrastructures owned by the operators.
These two facts make the mobile network operators have absolute advantages in the value
chain. However, this means also that the operators must be responsible for maintaining a
good and healthy value chain.

3-2-VAS System lock-in and Growth Engine

System lock-in (6) can be observed clearly in operators’ services. In a simple case, when an
operator is delivering only the voice service or talking possibility, each individual will not
change his/her phone number after receiving the number from operators. This fact is shown
in the following cause-and-effect diagram (fig.7).

Number of people who
uw know an individual with

jo his/her number x

An individual motive +
to keep the number

Figure 7: Voice Service lock in cause-and-effect diagram

Not only in voice but in VAS and M-Services, System Lock-in and path dependence can be
recognized. A local service provider can be considered as an example, when delivering its
Location-Based Services (LBS) to mobile network subscribers according to their
geographical position. Each subscriber can find required local businesses e.g. nearest
restaurant or auto repair shop in an area easily through services provided by local service
providers.

Local businesses are placed at one end of these services and subscribers or customers of
these businesses are at the other end. In the following diagram (fig.8), the existing
dynamics in delivering of M-services is exhibited.

Mobile network
F Subscribers’ interest

ervice \ The M-Service
M-Service reputation & to use the M-Service % reputation

Competitive opportunity } ~~ / Xi ee Be
/ \

Ft
Mobile network subscribers
using the M-Service
a

\ +

\ »
Extra people interest
to use the M-Service

Existing businesses

Using the M-Service
+4 be

\
‘“ Competitors &
other Businesses \
Tendency Businesses interest 3
to use the M-Service

Figure 8: M-Service Cause-and-effect Loop Diagram
Such dynamics will be observed in most of M-Services contents which give rise to rapid
adoption of M-Services among Mobile network subscribers and various businesses.

VAS growth engine (7) is related to both voice and M-Service growth engine, however, the
number of mobile network subscribers, the volume of M-Services delivering to subscribers
through VAS, general economic condition in the society and government regulations are
also another effective factors on VAS growth. VAS growth dynamic will be exhibited in
our proposed model.

4- Model Assumptions & Dynamic Hypotheses:

1-VAS supply usually is more than VAS demand. In other word, VAS operators
permanently have satisfied any VAS demand with required investment, equipments and
technology.

2- In proposed model, the number of subscribers are assumed constant, i.e., the mobile
operators market reached to a saturation and maturity. This assumption is to some extent,
contradictory with real world conditions; however, it not only helps us to simplify the
problem but also, will let us to concentrate on our main dynamics.

3- Our main target in the model is to maximization of the operator revenue. Two factors
affect the revenue. One is the VAS subscribers and the other is VAS average usage rate of
subscribers, hence we can increase the revenue of the operator with these two factors.

4- In our proposed model, the price of operator services is assumed constant and is not
considered a factor of revenue increase since the operators service market is under perfect
competition conditions. Based on Economics science, in perfect competition conditions the
price is constant. This assumption has been entered in our model due to unknown VAS
service price elasticity and will help to model authenticity.

5- M-Adoption is considered the adoption of mobile phone and services in the society.
There is no upper limit for this adoption and can be increased without any limit. Following
three factors affect M-adoption based on facts addressed in references (8) and (9):

e External Factors: This factor is out of the control of operators and is considered as
environmental factor. Society welfare condition, income per capita, cultural
readiness, literacy level and government policies and regulations can be categorized
in this field. All of external factors are considered constant.

e VAS Communicating: This is related to the volume of advertising and
communicating by operators and has direct impact on M-adoption.

e VAS M-Services: These services are delivered by independent companies to
operators subscribers. The VAS adoption in society will increase if these services
expand.
6- M-services growth is affected by VAS subscribers (10).In other words, the companies
which is delivering M-services will expand their businesses only when VAS subscribers
will be ample.

7- VAS Prevalence Rate: The VAS Prevalence rate is a function of advertisement of VAS
operators and rate of M-Adoption.

8- Three factors impact the VAS subscribers’ growth rate:

e Number of mobile operator subscribers: this factor is considered as a limit for VAS
subscribers.

e VAS prevalence rate: It is clear that for higher prevalence rate, the adoption of
operator VAS is more.

e VAS current subscriber: For more VAS subscriber in a society, more people get
acquainted with this service and consequently, this has positive impact on number
of subscribers (8).

9-The revenue of operators’ VAS is calculated by multiplying of VAS subscribers’ average
usage in VAS subscribers’ number. The average usage rate in our model is currency unit.

10-The average usage rate of each subscriber has direct relationship with M-Services and
M-Adoption in a given society.

11- With increase in mobile operator subscribers gradually in time, due to operators’
competition and economy of scale, each subscriber average usage, i.e. revenue per user
(RPU) will decrease.

12- In our supposed model, due to market saturation, the market development is not taken
into account, however, under some circumstances; there is the possibility of transfer of
subscribers from an operator to other operator due to its VAS, i.e. increased subscribers of
an operator is coming from other operators.

5- Dynamic Model

The model which is exhibited below has two parts:

1-The first part is “operator A” whose revenue should be maximized

2-The second part is the “other operators” against which our benefits should be considered.

For each operator, similar variables are applied separately. In addition to operators’ specific
variables, three “stock variables” is observed in the model which is treating like contextual
and environmental variables and it is supposed that have equal effect on all operators
variables. These variables can be seen in the middle of model as model symmetrical line.
Op A VAS Com. for

Operator A
Non-VAS Users

A M-Services Operator A
Mobil users
Operator A
FI users switch
Operator A VAS Revenue
Operator A VAS
Diffusion Rate Operator A VAS
Users proportion
Operatdt A VU ;
Growdl Rate M-Adoptior perator A VAS
Operator A VAS AiSeniess Usage per Leer
Communicating Operator A as.
VAS Users
VAS A M-Services
Communicating
_ Economies of
; i k &
ME Aden M-Services =) ———— pr scak &
M-readiness M-Services VAS Users Increase market |_Competition

promotion, ae
External a

Factors(Economic,
social, cultural)

Other Operators VAS
Diffusion Rate
Other Operators VAS FI>
Communicatis

_~

a

_

‘ther Operators VAS
Usage per User

M-Services
Other Operators

VAS Users

Other Opéfators VU

Growth Rate
Other Operators VAS

i Users proportion \

oO = Other Operators

~ Other Operators L_Mobile users

Users switch
a

<M- Adoption

Other Operators VAS Revenue

A users

Other Operators
> Non-VAS Users
6- Simulation and Analysis

Our targeted variable in the model is the operator A “revenue”. Operator A revenue is
increasing with the increase of number of VAS subscriber and VAS subscribers average
usage .In the figure 10, we can see that the operator revenue at first is increasing and then

decreasing.
The reason for this behavior can be understood with
the observation and analysis of the behavior of
Current effective factors as shown in figure 10. The main
Operator A VAS Revenue reason of operator revenue decrease is related to
200 M decreasing subscription in operator network from one
150M hand and reduction in revenue per subscriber from
100M other hand. | Current
The reason for
50M reduction in | Operator A VAS Usage per User
0 revenue per 20
Operator A VAS Users subscriber can 15
8M be sought in 10
6M 7 figure 11: 5
4M 0
2M "Economies of scale & Competition"
0 200
Operator A VAS Usage per User 150
20 100
15 50 :
10 0
5 "M-Adoption"
0 60
o 50 100 45 of
Time (Month) 4
30 y
: 15 :
Figure 10
0
As can be seen in figure 11, the factors like mobile "M-Services"
phone VAS adoption (M-Adoption) in the society 400
and the volume of operators’ services using VAS (M- 300
Services) is increasing which cause an increase in
subscriber average usage, however, two other factors 200
including competition and economy of scale result in 100
reduction of subscriber average usage. In our 0 ee
suggested model, these two contradictory factors 0 _ 30 100
have been considered and formulated. Time (Month)

Figure 11

7- Policy Analysis

Two variables which can affect the revenue of operators are the “subscriber average usage
of VAS” and “the number of VAS subscriber “.As the maximization of revenue of operator
is the target of this model, so two policies can be considered. The first policy is attempting
to affect on the first variable and the second policy affecting on both two variables. In the
proposed model, some real world conditions have not been considered due to model
assumptions. Two example of these real world conditions are price reduction and market
development. In fact, due to perfect competition assumptions, we supposed service prices
as stable. Market development policy can not be applied due to proposed model
assumptions as well.

Hence, two following policy can be deduced and proposed:
7-1-Advertising and communicating policy for operators’ VAS:

This policy is applied to model through Operator A VAS Advertising variable and result is
shown in the following diagram (fig.13):

a ——
Cw a oe ae a UA SS ee Ue yk me eo
os 0 5 0 5 8 5 09 5 O 5 ©

Operator A VAS Revenue; After Communicating increase — — —
Other Operators VAS Revenue : After Communicating increase — -—.—.—-—------------
Figure 12
As indicated in diagram (fig.12), in similar condition, this policy will increase the revenue
of Operator A in comparison to other operators. The following diagram (fig.13) is
suggesting the Operator A revenue before and after the increase of Operator A VAS
Advertising variable.

100M
100M

0 Pees

a a
Tine Non)

Operator A VAS Revenue: before Communicating increase

Operator A VAS Revenue: After Communicating increase —.—.—.-.------------0--
Figure 13

Operator A revenue at first is increasing and then decreasing on which the following results
can be deduced:

e According to dynamic hypotheses & model assumptions, the operator advertising
not only will give rise to increased VAS usage rate among opeator subscribers, but
also incease the VAS adoption in society which is beneficial for all operators.

e Increased VAS usage rate and M-adoption will result in increased revenues of
operators, nevertheless, increased competition and economy of scale will have
contrary and decreasing effect on revenue.

Due to decreasing effect of advertising and communicating policy, this policy should
handle with care and be up to a level with which both of our targets including increased
subscription and avoiding price war will be satisfied.

7-2 - Operator’ s particular M-service application:

Another policy which can be applied is about the M-service offer by operators themselves.
These M-services is regularly offered by some other independent companies which their M-
services are delivered on the basis of operators’ network. Operators, themselves, can offer
these M-services through different ways, e.g. through entertainment services or news
service or through an agreement with M-services companies. In any case, the operator
should deliver these services and reserve it as a relative advantage for itself against other
operators.

For implementing of this policy we need to change our model as depicted in the following
figures (fig.14 &15):
‘Op A VAS Com fir
A M-Sewices
M-Adopt “ge

ior

= Operator A VAS

Operator A VAS

OperabrA VAS

— Commmnizating

Economies of

ae Figure 15

As shown in above figures, two changes have been applied to proposed model. In figure 14,
M-services of Operator A is introduced and in the figure 15, the advertising of these
services applied. The result of implementing of this policy is depicted in figure 16:

80M
100M

6 ae
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Time (Month)

Operator A VAS Revenue : After Specific M-Services
Operator A VAS Revenue : Before Specific M-Services

Figure 16

As shown in the diagram (fig.16), this policy can increase the revenue of the operators
through two ways:

First, M-service usage increases VAS average usage rate of Operator A, without positive
effect on the other operators VAS usage rate.

Second, the advertising of these services will result in operator A VAS prevalence rate
increase without any effect on general M-adoption and other operators.
8- Conclusion

e Due to rapid changes of Telecom industry regarding market and technology, companies
in this industry definitely need to some powerful instruments to analyze their businesses
effectively and profitably. System dynamics is within these powerful instruments
especially in Telecommunication.

e The future of mobile phone market is considered for mobile VAS and mobile data.
According to proposed model and its behavior in this article, the competition in this
industry has complicated dimensions, e.g. Advertising can backfire and carry negative
effects on the operators market as resulted in first policy, however, using VAS value chain
which indicated in the second policy can establish competitive advantage for operators.

¢ In this article, our study concentrated on some parts of VAS Value Chain for the benefit
of operators; however, there are plenty of rooms to work on other dimensions of VAS
Value Chain to get the fullest benefit out of this concept for this industry.

9- Acknowledgement

The authors would like to appreciate Professor Ali N. Mashayekhi who stimulated our
interest in System Dynamics. We also express gratitude to Keyvan Vakili and A. Haery for
their contributions in this research.

10- References

1. The European market for mobile data:evolving value chains. Carleen F. Maitlanda, Johannes M.
Bauerb, Rudi Westerveld. 2002, Telecommunica _ ons Policy, pp. 485504.

2. Porter, M. Competitive Advantage. New York : Free Press, 1985.
3. Motamedi. /ran Telecomunication current situation. [interv.] Ahmadi. december 19, 2007.

4. The mobile commerce value chain: analysis and future developments. Barnes, Stuart J. 2002,
Interna onal Journal of Informa on Management, pp. 9108.

5. Bernhard, Holtkamp. Mobile ValueAdded Services in China: Project Summary Report. s.|.: VAS
China Project, January 2006.

6. Arnoldo C. Hax, Dean L. Wilde. The Delta Project: Discovering New Sources of Profitability. New
York : Palgrave, 2001.

7. Sterman, J. Business Dynamics: Systems Thinking and Modeling for a Complex World. Boston,
MA : McGraw-Hill, 2000.

8. Adoption of Mobile Commerce: Role of Exposure. Khalifa, Mohamed and Cheng, K. N. Sammi.
Hawaii : IEEE Computer Society, 2002. the 35th Interna onal Conference on System Scienes.
9. Adoption of Mobile Devices/Services — Searching for Answers with the. Carlsson, Christer, et al.
Hawaii : IEEE Computer Society, 2006. 39th Interna onal Conference on System Sciences.

10. Value-Added Services in Mobile Commerce: An Analytical Framework and. Anckar, Bill and

D’Incau, Davide. Hawaii : IEEE Computer Society, 2002. the 35th Interna onal Conference on
System Sciences.

11. Turban Efraim, Rainer R. Kelly Jr. and Potter Richard E. Introduction to Information
Technology. s.|. : John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 2005.

12. Commerce Ministry Planning Deputy. /ran national E-Commerce report. Tehran : E-Commerce
Development Office, 2005.

13. 3G telecommunica on operators’ challenges and roles: A perspec _ véing-Feng Kuoa, Ching-
Wen Yu. 2006, Technova on, pp. 13471356.

Metadata

Resource Type:
Document
Description:
Telecommunication industry is not comparable with many industries in view of rapid market and technological change. In this industry, Mobile Communications is one of the most attractive segments. The new and novel trends can be seen in Telecommunication industry from time to time which suggesting various dynamics and relationships in this industry development. In this article, we will examine and analyze existing trends in mobile operators’ services to find out the position of Value Added Service (VAS). Then, existing dynamics in delivering Mobile VAS will be deduced through VAS value chain analysis and its market characteristics. We will simulate and execute the proposed dynamic model and get acquainted with the behavior of model elements and analyze them. Finally, two policies will be suggested and with the analysis of results of these two policies, some recommendations will be made for mobile network operators to maximize their revenues out of VAS.
Rights:
Date Uploaded:
December 31, 2019

Using these materials

Access:
The archives are open to the public and anyone is welcome to visit and view the collections.
Collection restrictions:
Access to this collection is unrestricted unless otherwide denoted.
Collection terms of access:
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Access options

Ask an Archivist

Ask a question or schedule an individualized meeting to discuss archival materials and potential research needs.

Schedule a Visit

Archival materials can be viewed in-person in our reading room. We recommend making an appointment to ensure materials are available when you arrive.