Need an Environmental Interface in VSM? Ask Managers in
Crises.
Q. Lu, S. Byrne, K. Maani
The department of management science and information systems,
The University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand
Email Address: lu.qiang @world-net.co.nz
A Crisis is not just a fast changing event, even not a chaos, but an entirely irregular
turmoil. [*notel: In definition, Chaos is order (a pattern) within disorder (random
behavior).] The normal way in Beer's VSM to manage the external factors is that each
System | deals with its own local environment and System 3 coordinates through System
2 and monitors via auditing channel. But when a crisis is coming, total environment
becomes deadly uncontrollable and local environments in every recursion level are very
much correlated. Thus the normal coordinating/auditing loop will be over-loaded,
desperate and collapsed. [*note2: This phenomenon was observed by the first author,
who served for a company in Southeast Asia, with head quarter in Singapore and
subsidiaries in Malaysia, Indonesia, and Thailand during 1997-1998 crisis.]
A general regulator is needed with more variety and complexity built into it so as to
match the increasing variety and complexity outside, according to Ashby’s Law of
Requisite Variety. This regulator, called Environmental Interface (EI) in this paper, can
be a subjective or physical unit in between the environment and the organization. It has
three major functions: (1) like a buffer, to prevent the harmful signals inject into the
system directly and attack the valuable structures and channels; (2) like an optical filter,
to unify directions from sub-systems and recursive operations towards environment; (3)
to fully utilize the internal resources in "resolving" external variables.
The fact that the normal way fails shows System 3 is not enough to handle crises. So EI
gets top decision-makers even founding directors from Policy and Intelligent systems (or
System 5&4) involved in frontiers to sense, analyze and coordinate urgently emerging
issues in business context. In such cases, analogy reasoning of old adepts are vital to
grasp the perseverant principles for dealing with highly confusing behaviors of partners,
competitors, customers, and suppliers. [*note3: We saw too many young MBA holders
fell prey to analysis paralysis, or made defensive or arbitrary decisions based on gut
reaction rather than a cerebral thought process due to crisis-induced stress.]
Also the paper discusses how EI locates faulty or mal-functional sub-systems in terms of
meeting new requirements, and how EI could turn danger into opportunity in the acute
stage by changing organization from a "cybernetic" controller to an "organic" being,
without damaging the original structures and values.