Mikulskiene, Birute with Birute Pitrenaite, "Participatory policy modelling for operational policy stream: the stakeholders and public administration perspective", 2012 July 22-2012 July 26

Online content

Fullscreen
Participatory policy modelling for operational policy stream: the
stakeholders and public administration perspective
Birute Mikulskiene, Birute Pitrenaite

Department of Management, Faculty of Politics and Management, Mykolas Romeris University, Lithuania.

Abstract

An introduction of the participatory element into the existing policy making scheme
challenges the whole policy making practice, since unmanageable stakes have a risk to mask the
proper distribution of interests and hide needs of the society. The particular interest of this research
is to describe participatory modelling procedures and construct the model by means of system
dynamics that capacitates an input of policy stakeholders via a rational balance of interest
expression in policy making and policy administration streams. The primary intention is to use
these modelling techniques for the description of participatory procedures and apply them to
governance of wider public policy issues. The model primarily is targeted to introduce such
mechanisms to the policy making process that enable control of the completeness of the stake
representation and to balance the stake representation. Equally the model has to protect policy

makers from narrow interest advocacy against the public interest.

Keywords: participatory policy modelling, research based evidence, system dynamics, public
administration, stakeholders.

Introduction
An introduction of the participatory element into the existing policy making scheme challenges the
whole policy making practice, since unmanageable stakes have a risk to mask the proper
distribution of interests and hide needs wider of the society. Accordingly, the permanent practical
task for all policy making cycles is to decide what stakes could represent themselves as legitimate
policy actors. This question goes in hand with the second question: how to engage those who have
the stakes to participate in policy making processes and how to make a policy making process
manageable in a transparent, equitable and rational manner.

Taken into account that the real policy formation process is more complex than linear and
many parallel processes have direct or indirect impact on the final policy decision, the stream policy
process model (as a combination of minimum three separate and compete streams of problems,

solutions and actors) according to Kingdon (2003) is analysed to describe the route of decision
formulation. However even the stream model faces complications to describe the full policy design
using any static models. As a consequence, the dynamic approach is of greater importance. The
participatory system dynamic approaches could be integrated into the existing static policy design
and elaborate more detailed constructions of interactions between stakeholder impacts on policy.

A particular interest of this research is to describe participatory modelling procedures and
construct the model by means of system dynamics that capacitates policy stakeholders’ input via a
rational balance of the interest expression in policy making and policy administration streams. An
involvement of a broad range of stakeholders is a costly and time consuming issue that could result
in a no result zone and overload the decision making system with unmanageable stock and
confronted stakes. The intention is to use these modelling techniques for the description of
participatory procedures and apply them to governance of wider public policy issues.

The model primarily is targeted to introduce such mechanisms to the policy process that
enable control of the completeness of the stake representation. On the other hand, the model needs
to balance stake representation and let reduce the prominence of clear and powerful stakes instead
of strengthening new and not conceptualised stakes (public interest mostly). Equally the model has
to protect policy makers from narrow interest advocacy against public interest recognised as an
equally treated stakeholder. The public interest as well as the evidence producers could be analysed
separately from the whole list of stakeholders as additional stock.

Participation policy paradigm

In the context of increasing demands of public equality, multiplicity of interests and complexity of
the problems modem society is facing, a single and although well informed actor cannot be
considered as a proper decision maker. Furthermore, the classic institution of representative
democracy with cooperation of hierarchical bureaucracy of the executive power in the chain of
governing is neither a single nor the main actor any longer. Shifting the politics of representation to
the practice of interactive policy making (Klijn, 2011) is being developed as superposition of
confronting interests and higher uncertainty policy makers are faced. The previous distinction
between policy making and policy implementation is not appreciating any more when the
participatory policy paradigm is discussed.

The participatory policy recognises wider participation of policy actors (policy makers and
policy administrators as state and local governments, non-governmental organisations, local
communities, industries, businesses, scientists) in policy creation with demand for qualitative
decision making (Ansell et al, 2008).
Participatory methods typically cover different ways of stakeholders’ (considering public
society or local community as a single stakeholder) empowering while policy regulation is planning
and making decisions. Despite the fact that participatory public policy approaches are described
normmatively, and new understanding of governance such as meta- governance, network governance,
interactive policy making (Klijn, 2011) are on the elaboration stage, the policy framework is still
practising where elected politicians act outside policy networks and hierarchical bureaucracy seek
manoeuvre in between legitimate policy framework and policy networks. Though clearly drawing
the guidelines of the causes of such tensions (some stakes are representing themselves to politicians
and others to public administrators), this understanding fails to solve practical operational issues
how to align interest of policy actors and how to make policy making and policy administration
efficient as an integrated framework. Therefore, additional efforts such as a participatory modelling

could be needed.

Systems dynamics — participatory modelling.

System dynamics is an approach to design management solutions using computer simulation
proposed by Forrester (1969). Despite the fact that system dynamics is widely used for management
issues in different areas such as public health (Trochim, 2006), natural resources management
(Mendoza and Prabhu, 2006; Dreyer, M. and Renn, 2011), IT addiction (Park et al, 2010), project
management (Lyneisa et al. 2007), policing (Carter et al, 2011) with special attention paid to
participatory components (Mendoza et al, 2006; Tako et al, 2010; Stave, 2010; Dreyer, 2011),
scholars still report lack of studies concerning the public policy at public governance level
(Ghaffarzadegan et al, 2011).

While discussing the participatory modelling, scholars have in mind both types of
involvement: “active and direct involvement of stakeholders in model formulation and in the
process of building the model itself (Mendoza et al, 2005) and stakeholders as only users of the
model (Dreyer et al, 2011). Additionally, details concerning the policy design, the model
components and their functionality could be more precisely determined during participatory policy
modelling in cooperation with stakeholders (Bérard, 2010). As group model building, there are
some components needs to be respected. It is participants and their interaction, modelling
procedure, facilitating and sessions logistics (Andersen et al, 1997). Furthermore, models of
participatory system dynamics introduce a complementary purpose to enhance the system and social
learning (Vennix, 1999) and have added values for social capital development when the

stakeholders are involved in the modelling process (Rouwette et al, 2002; Stave, 2010).
Since policy makers unsurprisingly generally express the lack of demand to use models for
decision making as some scholars are reported (Webler et al, 2011), some rationality needs to be
respected. Producing a usable model of participatory system dynamic, one should respect the main
characteristics of public policy problems listed as follows (Ghaffarzadegan et al, 2011):

¢ Policy resistance. Its occurs when at later policy development stages the external
environment influences the process (new policy actors coming, blocking the ideas,
asking for feedback, delaying procedures and prolonging the time between policy action
and policy outputs). This could be represented by feedback loops.

e The need for and cost of experimentation — since policy is not reversible, small scale
experiments and adjustment of policy is appropriate to reach better outputs.

e The need to achieve consensus between stakeholders. Otherwise social pressure (e.g.
lobbyists, citizens, political opponents) could damage the policy implementation stage
and break the confidence of policy makers; as a consequence the long term goal loses
the competition against short term goals.

e Overconfidence of policy actors (e.g. policy makers) and sensitiveness to reach the
decision too quick.

e The need to have endogenous perspective as an organisational learning instrument as a
safeguard against undesirable mistakes.

Application of system dynamics in policy design stages using stock and flow diagram

helps to define decision rules “when new policy will become operational” (Wheat, 2010).
Additionally the dynamic approach could help to understand the dynamic pattern of the policy
process as an integrated system and to find week points which could hamper manageable actions
towards better and more coherent making of political decisions. The target is to find out the most
crucial point of adjustment for the whole system to act automatically in the plausible way with
sustainable feedback processes (Vennix, 1999). Moreover, such type of modelling could have more
benefits than just direct instructions how to proceed, and enhance mutual stakeholder understanding
and acknowledge as complementary effect of the model (Baldwin et al, 2004). The so called small
systems dynamics models (Ghaffarzadegan et al, 2011), where just a few the most important stocks
are connected by 7-8 loops, produce aggregated models and give a unique opportunity to describe

the system in a simple and clear manner.

Methodology
Modelling of participatory system dynamics starts from scratching the preliminary model, which is
further corrected according the obstacles and wishes derived from individual interviews with the
policy actors: policy administrators at the operational level of policy outlining and other policy
actors who were intentionally invited into the policy process by policy makers. Those policy actors
are considered to be stakeholders. The policy arena of the Ministry of Education and Science and
the Ministry of Health of Lithuanian has been chosen to reconstruct the policy streams in terms of
stakeholder management.

The interviews were conducted in January-March, 2012. We interviewed 13 public
administrators (7 — from Ministry of Education and Science and 6- from Ministry of Health) and 5
researchers who participated in different interest representation groups in 2010 when policy content
was outlined. Policy actors were asked “to generate policy stories” (Andersen and Richardson,
1997) with the purpose to gain knowledge about policy processes and collect the attitudes of the
public administrators towards stakeholders’ input. The interviews with respondents other than
public administrators let us evaluate the intention of public administrators to employ stakeholders’
knowledge.

It is important that all selected variables had to be measurable in both qualitative and
quantitative way, however the qualitative weighting is more applicable for the selected stocks. For
that purpose expert based evaluation could be employed (e.g. a substantial number of experts could
be interviewed and asked to rank the variables and assign the number they valued), however this

issue is outside the scope of the present research.

Results: attitudes of public administrators and scientists towards the stakeholder input into
policy

This section presents the key issues that were identified after the interviews. Based on these issues,
the requirements for the participatory model were determined. For the interviews the following
questions were used:

e How are stakeholders invited to participate in the policy making process?

e How do stakeholders engage into the policy formation?

e What is the input of stakeholders to the policy making process?

e What are the results public administrators pursue working together with stakeholders?

e Whatis the role of public administrators?
Arena for stakes representation: Stakeholders’ input is recognised in the eyes of public
administrators, although a feeling that institution of public administration are accepted more often
as targeted stakeholders than any other part of stakeholders outside public authorities remained. Not
surpassingly, almost every interviewee stressed that the stakeholder primary is sought for
consultation purposes. Despite the fact that our interviewees confirmed the necessity of
stakeholders’ input into the policy making process, almost everybody pointed out that they see no
differences between formal or informal engagement and interaction of any stakeholders whose
competence the public administrator respects. Some of respondents stressed informal
communication to a greater extent - face to face against formal transparent way of action.
Meantime, there were felled plenty of ways how stakeholder could promote their interest other than
mere communication with the public administration. For instance, direct application to the policy
maker at the parliamentary level is widely used, mostly at the stage when consensus is achieved in
the way to restrict initial set of interest. In such case some stakes gain more advantages.

Completeness of interests. The interviewees were very concerned about the completeness
of stake representation in the policy making process. Meanwhile the invited participants are usually
the same selected purposefully at one or another policy stage using an existing network of actors
that have already participated in the policy process in the past.

Some stakes could be represented but public administrators complain that it is difficult take
into account their interest and their support is week. For instance, patient associations hardly ever
appreciate research based evidence and feel lack of activity.

The role of public interest. Public interest is perceived as something very important and
could be represented by the whole society or consumers, however interviewees stated that the
society representation is week and they raise their awareness of such representation from the media
that is expensive and not very much rewarded way of engagement.

Research based knowledge. There is no doubt that research based knowledge is
acknowledged in policy formulation. Interviewees call for “argumentation”, “evidence”, “expert
knowledge”, and “scientific proof’. However critical attitudes towards using research based
knowledge could be traced. Since the best policy actors are deemed only those who possess
evidence of proof and could be perceived as qualified experts, any participation and mandate of
stakeholders are left outside the focus. As a consequence, only knowledge sharing with various

stakeholders is employed.

Requirements and constrains for participation modelling
The essential characteristics of any policy making models is to be simple (minimizing the variables
and feedback loops) and easily readable in the terms of policy makers are accustomed. Therefore
the small models of system dynamics are instrumental. Nevertheless a created model must be
sufficiently rigorous (Mendoza et al, 2006) to produce hard evidence and stimulate application for
the real policy changes. When proposing any new models, some requirements need to be respected
and certain constraints followed.

Taken in to account the characteristic of the policy problems and the knowledge acquisition

from the interviews, the model must meet the following requirements:

e to indicate a transparent, legal and manageable correct arena for stakes’ expression — any
stakes could be expressed via the same entrance to the policy arena and should be
analysed using the same procedure.

e to control completeness of the stake representation during the policy process — the model
should make sure that all possible stakes (supportive and confronting) are engaged;

e to seek balanced stake representation (to let decrease the expression of the clear and
powerful stakes among emerging new and not yet conceptualised stakes (public interest
mostly);

e to make clear emphasis on the public interest among other stakeholder interests;

e to highlight the research based evidence and underline the right manageable point to
empower its impact;

e to evaluate the policy making practice in terms of participation quality. We discuss a
participatory model that primarily helps to make a policy output and additionally could
be valuable to evaluate policy results by means of qualitative interest representation.

Constrains could be analysed in the light of the model adoption process and accepted wider
than a stimulus to minimize resistance to the new way of action rather than requirements. Since the
main constraint for the model could be drawn as an objective to protect policy makers from a
narrow interest advocacy against the public interest, it could safeguard policy makers from illegal
pressing on one well expressed stake and restrict the policy stream to ignore other interests even

unintentionally.

Conceptual model for participatory policy

Policy actors. The five independent variables representing policy actors were distinguished.
Defining the groups of policy actors, the differentiation among certain stakeholders was made
conceming the targeted interests. Policy makers and public administrators (two variables) were
analysed as separate actors or legal representatives of state or local authorities. From the remaining
essential set of stakeholders, research based evidence producers (one variable) are analysed as a
separate interest group according to huge scholars’ attention that is given to the science policy
interface (Hirasuna et al. 2010) and supported by literature produced on the evidence based policy
(Head, 2010). Therefore whereas from one perspective, research based evidence producers could be
percept as equally treated stakeholders, from the other perspective they could be analysed as
individual policy actors with the mission to inform policy makers that not just their own stake
should be presented. Not disaffirmed the scientists’ interest to policy process and outcomes, the
research based evidence has the other very important meaning to the policy — it is safeguarding
rationality and democratic decision making (Webler et al, 2011). And the last group that is worth
having as a separate variable is the public interest the stake of which are usually less conceptualised
and more complicated to define.

Feedback loops. The group interests have two ways to initiate new policy changes. One is
a direct trigger of a policy maker. The group interest, if it is clear determined, has a direct impact on
new policy initiatives via stakeholder’s power of impact. The search for supporting research based
knowledge could be loaded afterwards. Higher power on a stake increases policy makers’ attention.
However there is a threshold when policy makers’ attention concerts to debates. The magnitude of
interest can be measured in different ways: for instance the represented sector of profit gain, the
number of members represented, activity level, the rate of investment in interest representation. The
interest power is the ration of successful initiatives with the total number of initiatives in a certain
policy domain. The reinforcing mechanism is generates when the new policy initiative determines
the objection and critique from the side of either those, whose stakes has lower power of impact or
stakes were ignored at some extent or newly conceptualised stakes (public interest in particular).
New policy initiatives could seek for supporting research based evidences.

The other way to initiate policy changes are to promote research based evidence collection
and do research communication using scientists as independent experts. Interest groups could seek
research based evidence for their own benefits, but the success of this way strongly depends on the
policy makers’ sensitivity to evidence. The sensitivity to evidence increases together with certain
amount of produced evidences.

Public interest as a single but very essential stakeholder could use the same way to make
impacts on new policy initiatives as described using the path via interest power. However the fact
that public interest could be used to hide a real group interest should be taken into consideration.
Such cases are reported in the public media and noted to by health policy administrators, whereas
industry based group interests use the way of public interest representation to make their message
known to policy makers without any open connections with real stakes.

To sum up, there are three complementary ways to inform policy makers about certain
interests and all these ways are jointly used to stimulate attention of policy makers using different
channels (media, public interest imitation, research orders and result communication).

Model representation. The dynamic model of participatory policy was created on the
bases of coupling of different streams of:

e problems conceptualised at policy makers level,

¢ solutions at operational policy administration level,

e political environment and actors at stakeholder representation level.

Public
interest
power/public

engagement ~ \
+

Policy makers \ Policy making
attention + 1 knowledge

+ af “>
'» Increase of policy olicy learning ~~

/ maker's consideration

/ yer \

/ | ne Quality of

/ J ne operational
sensitivity to olicy level \

evidence peu \

| *

| \ \

|
Powerof | --\/_, | Research based |
interest | 77>] evidence for policy / \ \

Knowledge / |
» \ generation speed |

“¢
Operational knowledge
+X ____+ at public administration
_% Rate of accutnulation of level
_~” operational knowledge >
Policy makers — ’ /
sensativity to /
operational *~——— Stakeholder
knowledge competition

Quality of
representation: Pull of active and
stakeholder organized
framework A interests \
Representation Benetisy
x of interest »

Figure 1. Stock and flow structure for the participatory policy model for balancing stakeholders

input.
The conceptual model could be adapted to the policy process if stocks in dynamic model
would be transferred to the policy process stages as other scholars are analysed (Tako et al, 2010).
The proposed dynamic model has five stock variables, that correspond to policy makers (2
variables), public administrators, research based evidence providers and others stakeholders that act
in an associated way. Figure 1 represents stock and flow structure for the participatory policy model
of stakeholders’ input balance. Every stock variable is in units of available knowledge.

The problem stream is engaged by the policy response at the moment when the knowledge
capacity of the emerged issue reaches an obvious state and demonstrates a critical level. Indication
of stock accumulation could be produced either by research based knowledge or individual interest
emerging and directly expressed in the view towards policy makers. The effective political response
to a stakeholder appeal strongly depends on the power of interests, while effectiveness of evidence
depends on policy makers’ sensitivity to the evidence. An input of public administration knowledge
to policy making is a set of legal operational knowledge that could be the background for further
debating. Available operational knowledge is considered as an independent variable and describes
the organisational learning that appears every time when the policy cycle is finished.

The main constrain of safeguarding the policymakers from illegal pressing could be
realised by introducing distinguished arenas’ dedicated to two different purposes — interest
expression and interest balance — with their alignment. At the flow of policy makers’ consideration,
all stakes with different origins have a chance to manifest; however the solution stream, where
completeness of the interest is pursued, is launched after the stock of policy makers reach the level
for debating.

When the problem stream is launched and policy makers are convinced to start debating,
the process is delegated to the operational policy level to search for proper and acceptable solution
in an alignment with existing interests.

The political environment stream uses a two stock structure that represents stakeholders,
research based evidence producers and public interests.

Quality of operational policy level (coherency). Seeking to secure a policy outlining
from the dangerous single stakeholder influence or the occasional narrow perspective of the issue
the participatory policy approach could be applied at the operational level of the policy
formation/solution searching stream. Participatory policy content fully depends on the quality of the
operational policy level. The quality of that level depends on the following aspects: the ability
timely recognise stakes and engage equal balance of stakeholder for solution searching, the

competence to use research based evidence, self confidence and freedom for intermediate decision
policy makers confidence to use public administration sector as experts for policy
operationalization.

Quality of representation: stakeholder framework stakes competition. Policy outlining
at the solution stream proceeds via engaging those who have interest to represent their self’s. The
strategy firstly is based on awaking the competition of interest and leading the process to the stake
alignment afterwards. The success of interest alignment depends on both the public administration
ability to mediate and stakeholder representation ability. Talking about the stakeholder
representation, we have in mind an organisation framework that lets stakes to develop in a
democratic, open and systematic way of real interest representation instead of an incidental manner.

Research based evidence for policy. The aggregate amount of research that produces
obvious evidence for policy could be generated equally outside solution stream and inside public
administration institution. From the perspective of the participatory policy creation, R&D domain
could produce evidence for policy making process and offer “‘access to more sustainable solutions”
(Taylor et al, 2011). On the other hand that knowledge could be percept as the expert based advice
for both policy makers and policy administrators and could be conceptualized as extemal
knowledge about the issue. However the network like structure of the stakeholders where the actual
policy details are elaborated and conceptualized force to search for more complex knowledge flow
shaping new legislation creation and producing actionable evidence. The acceptance of research
output that is generated intentionally with the purpose to inform policy makers strongly depends on
interpretation and a possible impact on society. We can draw five main functions of the R&D input
to policy solutions: to inform policy actors, to advice policy actors, to present the evidence, to keep
process rational and to alert policy makers about possible impact of regulation.

Public interest power/public engagement. The role of society in public policy is highly
valuable and sometimes is conceived as competition with research based knowledge and
stakeholders interest. Although the society is perceived as a single stakeholder, it is rational to
analyse its input into policy separately since the power of interest representation is substantially
lower than that of others. Participation of the society on the participatory policy operationalization
level is a very sensitive issue for policy administrators seeking both to enhance real engagement and
to secure the process from an unmanageable flow of huge and diverse actors. Trying to avoid
putting society representatives to an open competition with others stakes, the society could be
granted a role as an external control and act with the policy makers at the problem and policy

environment stream where policy draft prepared at solution stream is tested.

Conclusions
The focus of this paper is on the conceptual policy creation model based on the stakeholders’
participation with the purpose to manage their influence via a study of system dynamics. Policy
streams have been introduced for modelling of system dynamics. Small system models for
participatory engagement can be helpful for modelling policy processes and balancing the
confronted interests of different powers of interest. The stock and flow diagram based on interviews
of policy actors was created seeking to make connections with different policy streams. An
organisational framework flexible to react to the diverse stage of interest conceptualisation and their
development during the policy creation cycle is proposed.

It is difficult to analytically test the model precisely since to measure the stakeholder
power or knowledge needed for decision are rather a qualitative task than a quantitative one. These
difficulties are magnified when the full set of stakeholder interests is simulated to power coefficient.
A higher level of integration is a costly tool in terms of accuracy as the use of this model for sector
interest integration produces rather substantial simulations. The results of this study is not targeted
to predict exact policy output, but it provides a better understanding about interest representation
and competition for an actionable policy making process (the model protect policy makers from
narrow interest advocacy against public interest). Therefore, the model is mostly valuable managing

knowledge needed for decision and defining the moment proper for regulation adoption.

Acknowledgment

This material is based on the work MIP-109/2011 supported by the Research Council of Lithuania.

References

Andersen, DF, Richardson, GP. 1997. Scripts for group model building. Syst. Dyn. Rev., 13(2):
107-129.

Andersen, DF, Richardson, GP, Vennix, JAM. 1997. Group model building: adding more science to
the craft. Syst. Dyn. Rev., 13: 187-201.

Ansell C, Gash A. 2008. Collaborative Governance in Theory and Practice. J Public Adm. Res.
Theory 18 (4): 543-571.

Baldwin LP, Eldabi T, Paul RJ. 2004. Simulation in healthcare management: a soft approach
(MAPIU). Simulation Modelling Practice and Theory 12(7-8): 541- 557.
Bérard, C. 2010. Group Model Building Using System Dynamics: An Analysis of Methodological
Frameworks. The Electronic Journal of Business Research Methods 8(1): 35 — 46.

Carter D, Moizer JD. 2011. Simulating the impact of policy on patrol policing: introducing the
emergency service incident model. Syst. Dyn. Rev., 27: 331-357.

Dreyer M, Renn O. 2011. Participatory Approaches to Modelling for Improved Leaming and
Decision-making in Natural Resource Governance: an Editorial. Env. Pol. Gov. 21: 379-385..

Forrester JW. 1969. Urban Dynamics. Pegasus Communication, Waltham, MA.

Ghaffarzadegan N, Lyneis J, Richardson GP. 2011. How small system dynamics models can help
the public policy process. Syst. Dyn. Rev., 27: 22-44.

Lyneisa JM, and Fordb DN. 2007. System dynamics applied to Project management: a survey,
assessment, and directions for future research. Syst. Dyn. Rev., 23(2/3): 157-189.

Head BW. 2010. Reconsidering evidence-based policy: Key issues and challenges. Policy and
Society 29: 77-94.

Hirasuna DP. Hansen SB. 2010. Is social science research useful to state legislators? International
regional science review, 32 (4): 429-444.

Kingdon J. 2003. Agendas, Alternatives, and Public Polices. Boston: Little Brown.

Klijn EH. 2011. Democratic legitimacy criteria in interactive governance and their empirical
application. In Torfing J, Triantafillou P. 2011. Interactive policy making, metagovernance and
democracy, ECPR Press.

Koppenjan J, Kars M, van der Voort H. 2011. Politicians as metagovernors — can metagovernance
reconcile representative democracy and network reality? In Torfing J, Triantafillou P. 2011.
Interactive policy making, metagovernance and democracy, ECPR Press.

Lee D, Ahn, J. 2005. Rewarding knowledge sharing under measurement inaccuracy. Knowledge
Management Research & Practice 3: 229-243.

Mendoza G.A. Prabhu R. 2005. Combining participatory modelling and multi-criteria analysis for
community-based forest management. F orest Ecology and Management. 207: 145-156.

Mendoza GA, Prabhu R. 2006. Participatory modeling and analysis for sustainable forest
management: overview of soft system dynamics models and applications. Forest Policy and
Economics 9: 179-196.

Park BW. Ahn JH. 2010. Policy analysis for online game addiction problems. Syst. Dyn. Rev., 26:
117-138.

Rouwette, EAJA, Vennix, JAM, van Mullekom, T. 2002. Group model building effectiveness: a
review of assessment studies. Syst. Dyn. Rev., 18(1): 5-45.
Stave KA. 2010. Participatory system dynamics modeling for sustainable environmental
management: Observations from four cases. Faculty Publications (SEPA). Paper 188.

Tako A.A, Kotiadis K, Vasilakis C. 2010. A conceptual modelling framework for stakeholder
participation in simulation studies. Proceedings of the 2010 Operational Research Society
Simulation Conference (SW10), 23-24 March, Worcestershire, UK, 2010, 76-85, ISBN: 0
303440 46 6.

Taylor TRB, Ford DN, Yvon-Lewis SA, Lindquist E. 2011. Science, engineering, and technology
in the policy process for mitigating natural—societal risk. Syst. Dyn. Rev., 27: 173-194.

Trochim, WM, Derek, AC, Milstein, B, Gallagher, RS, Leischow, SJ. 2006. Practical challenges of
system thinking and modeling in public health. American Journal of Public Health, 96(3): 538-
546.

Vennix, JAM. 1999. Group Model-Building: Tackling Messy Problems. Syst. Dyn. Rev., 15(4):
379-401.

Webler T, Tuler S, Dietz T. 2011. Modellers' and Outreach Professionals' Views on the Role of
Models in Watershed Management. Env. Pol. Gov. 21: 472-486.

Wheat ID. 2010. What can system dynamics learn from the public policy implementation literature?
Syst. Res. 27: 425-442.

Metadata

Resource Type:
Document
Description:
An introduction of the participatory element into the existing policy making scheme challenges the whole policy making practice, since unmanageable stakes have a risk to mask the proper distribution of interests and hide needs wider of the society . The particular interest of this research is to describe participatory modeling procedures and construct the model by means of system dynamics that capacitate an input of policy stakeholders via a rational balance of interest expression in policy making and policy administration streams. The primary intention is to use these modeling techniques for the description of participatory procedures and apply them to governance of wider public policy issues. The model primarily is targeted to introduce such mechanisms to the policy making process that enable control of the completeness of the stake representation and to balance the stake representation. Equally the model has to protect policy makers from narrow interest advocacy against the public interest.
Rights:
Date Uploaded:
January 1, 2020

Using these materials

Access:
The archives are open to the public and anyone is welcome to visit and view the collections.
Collection restrictions:
Access to this collection is unrestricted unless otherwide denoted.
Collection terms of access:
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Access options

Ask an Archivist

Ask a question or schedule an individualized meeting to discuss archival materials and potential research needs.

Schedule a Visit

Archival materials can be viewed in-person in our reading room. We recommend making an appointment to ensure materials are available when you arrive.