Jambekar, Anil, "A Season of Resolutions, Continuous Improvement and Systems Thinking", 2005 July 17-2005 July 21

Online content

Fullscreen
A Season of Resolutions, Continuous Improvement and
Systems Thinking

Anil B. Jambekar
School of Business and Economics
Michigan Technological University
Houghton, MI 49931
abjambek @ mtu.edu

Abstract

As New Year rolls in, many of us take on challenge of personal change. Many set goals
to lose weight; do more exercises; watch less television; do more studying; do less
partying; or to shed a habit such as smoking. Over last fifteen years in our Quality
Management course students were asked to work on a term-long personal continuous
improvement projects. The students were briefly introduced to basic concepts of causal
loop diagrams and were encouraged to use them to clarify their theories regarding their
own progress or lack of it. The basic premise is that the result students obtain and the
dynamics they experience are built into the structure of their worldview and they learn if
they can communicate and influence their worldview. This paper uses systems thinking
lens to discuss the improvement framework and the experience reported by students.

Keywords: Resolution. Personal change. Continuous improvement. Systems thinking.
Introduction

The concept of personal quality as promoted by Roberts and Sergesketter [1993] may be
thought of as a tool for personal empowerment. In order to learn the process of
continuous improvement, students enrolled in our traditional quality management course!
are required to undertake a personal continuous improvement project. The course is
normally offered in the spring term that begins in the month of January and hence, many
choose their theme based on their own New Year’s resolution. After reviewing almost
couple of hundred plus reports, it became quite clear that the learning experience can be
preserved by using causal loop diagrams [Jambekar, 1995].

As our world is becoming interconnected, many believe systems thinking is an essential
tool in helping to mange effectively. In business, it can help employees and managers to
understand the complexity of a process so they can reengineer or improve it. In academic
world, it can assist students reflect and construct meanings out of interconnectedness of
elements that make up their personal systems. According to O’Conner and Mc Dermott
[1997], systems thinking help to discern some structural rules, some sense of pattern of
behavior and events every day, so individuals can prepare for the future to gain some
influence over it. Systems are all around us and if we view what is happening around us
through systems thinking lens, we could generate some sense of control, be more
effective dealing with problems following better thinking strategies, and form a basis for
clear thought and communication. Systems thinking and continuous improvement
concepts and tools are essential tools in helping individuals to manage themselves and
others. Kim [1992] observed that by integrating systems thinking with quality concepts
organizations can connect conceptual understanding with operations.

A key concept advanced by systems thinking is that leverage for organizational
transformation comes from the ability to view interdependency among various elements
of the system and locating leverage points to influence current actions [Senge, 1990].
However, today’s fast paced world, our experiential and operational domain is made up
of events and reactive or responsive actions. To act on a system, one needs to separate
oneself from the operational domain to see interdependencies and move out in time to
understand underlying time-varying behavior.

There is growing recognition that much learning is embedded in the day-to-day activities.
Direct instructions can be one of the many stimuli for learning. Personal quality
improvement involvement [Roberts and Sergesketter, 1993 ; Sergesketter, 2004]
facilitates learning from the construction of meaning in the flux of using tools and pattern
of events. If the framework can be augmented by enabling students to articulate their
world-view using the systems thinking tool of causal loop diagramming, it is possible for
them to reflect on their experience in a detached way. It then becomes likely for the
participants to move into solution space and break the undesirable pattern of behavior.

At least in theory viewing the progress or lack of progress toward desired goal through
systems thinking lens can help students to recognize normally hidden dynamically subtle
structures and their influence on the recorded patterns of behavior.

The purpose of this paper is to describe the entire pedagogical experience using systems
thinking perspective. Next section briefly describes the limits to growth archetype as
applied to resolution induced efforts. Then following sections summarize the pedagogical
process, recurring structures as inferred from student reports, and observations about the
course objectives, student experience of meeting their own goals and ability to use the
causal loop diagramming to describe their world-views.

Resolution Induced Efforts and Limits to Success

It is generally known that many fail in meeting their resolutions. The limits to growth
[Senge, 1990] archetype is useful for understanding the ineffective system dynamics
operating when efforts are normally motivated by resolutions alone. There is a
reinforcing process that operates on its own for a period of time. Then it runs against a
balancing or stabilizing process. Figure 1 shows the underlying causal loop [Sterman,
2000]. The reinforcing loops R1 and B2 work synergistically in early periods during
which the focused performance measure influences the motivational level and adjusts
intensity and appropriateness of efforts. Assumption is that the individuals can determine
required efforts and intensity of efforts associated with their own targeted performance
goal.

It should be noted that if the intensity and appropriateness of efforts are inadequate,
individuals may not see any improvements and thus the process may come to halt on its
own. Students’ initial plans are carefully checked as a part of the project requirements to
determine what is considered to be acceptable level of intensity and appropriateness of
the efforts. They are asked to consult appropriate people or do some research into their
chosen theme.

Targeted performance

measure Resolution
* \
Perceived need to adjust a
i eae
4n2) level of appropriateness and Motivation to act
intensity of efforts oD) onresolution
Rate of of
improvement — Jmprovement Resolution
+ induced efforts
process

Appropriateness and
intensity of efforts

Improvement
B3 limiting process

Competing desired
performance
measures

Figure 1. Limits to resolution induced improvements

Of course, in everyday life with so many stimuli flooding one’s senses, it is very difficult
to pay attention to any one thing at any one time. There are always overlapping priorities
at any given time. As the competing performance measures in other areas of interests
begin to drop the motivation to continue the efforts to improve resolution induced
performance also drops. As time passes, the continuous improvement efforts are
diminished and eventually discontinued.

Figure 2 augments the figure | by addition of variables that reflect the project efforts. The
loop R4 shows the process that connects students’ continuous improvement efforts to
their progress toward completing the course sanctioned requirements to obtain the grade.
It is assumed that the semester is long enough in duration to let the resolution induced
motivation to maintain sustained efforts. Needless to say that some students who are

only interested in the grade could embellish the documentation that may not completely
and/ or correctly reflect their true efforts.

Desired grade__, Perceived gap between

+ current documentation and
final report

Grade performance
Rq Ynduced motivation

+ —_———- Targeted performance
+ measure

Resolution
z te
Rate of documentation of
efforts, performance, and E 4
observations 4n2) Perceived need to adjust :
c level of appropriateness and Motivation to act
Rate of ae
‘ intensity fo efforts on resolution
improvement Jnprovement RI
te process + Resolution +

induced efforts
Appropriateness and ors

intensity of efforts

Improvement
limiting process

Competing desired (3h
performance

measures

Figure 2. Course project intervention

Ideally, the project can be considered successful if extrinsic motivation provided by the
course project requirements and intrinsic motivation induced by the resolution (the
tentative commitment to change or improve) together overcome the countervailing
competing performance limiting processes. Hope is that the students would form better
habits and behaviors. Next section briefly summarizes the pedagogical process.

Pedagogical Process

There are three basic requirements for individuals to succeed in the change efforts: 1)
they have to be ready, 2) they have to be aware, and 3) they must practice new habits.
Because the course is offered during spring semester that begins in January and it is
assumed that many of the students are ready to undertake some change that is beneficial
to them. In the past many adopted habits and behaviors that take on life of their own and
have become self-defeating. The course requirements bring these habits into full
awareness. Quality management framework and tools offer a means to organize and
communicate their experience and enable students to drill deeply into their own system to
identify root causes and take responsibility for their own actions. Practice means
awareness to consciously choose and practice new habits in the present. It is assumed that
the project requirements keep awareness in the forefront for the length of the semester.
Because the feedback from their own actions is rapid while working within the
framework of personal continuous improvement, it becomes possible to learn about the
important systemic issues in a relatively short duration.
Specific objectives of this project are to learn:

e the difficulty of managing change firsthand,

e the difference between commitment and compliance,

¢ to collect and organize data and to understand critical role of self-discipline in
collecting data,

¢ to use process improvement and problem solving road map or storyboard,
to apply qualitative and quantitative data management tools, and
to communicate their thinking that supports their actions with the aid of various
tools.

The students are provided with the following steps of instructions to begin organizing
their project:

Step 1: Identify an area of personal quality that after its improvement will lead to
enhancement of one’s productivity, reduction in waste, improved health, etc. Select an
area, which has been relatively bothersome. The area of improvement selected should
have the following characteristi

1. The problem issue is important for productivity, self-esteem, or growth.

2. The problem is chronic, rather than a one-time event.

3. The problem has a known history, which one can describe.

4. There have been attempts to solve the problem before, with little or no success.

¢ Sketch a time-dependent behavior (approximate) of this variable over time and also
include in the sketch at what relative position this variable ought to be after the
improvement, if any? The problem is the gap between where individual wants to be
and where he/she will end up with the continuation of the past behavior.

Step 2: Assume that the improvement theme related performance measure is a function
of habits. Make a list of at least five habits that influence the area of the personal quality
selected. For an example, for the theme "Reduction in Weight" one may choose eating
between meals, eating deserts, not excising, not drinking eight glasses of water, etc. as
potential habits, defects, or opportunities missed.

Step 3: For each of the habit selected, provide an operational definition. For an example,
eating between meals means putting edibles in the mouth each time between meals will
be called a defect. An operational definition must be related to the root cause.

Step 4: Prepare a check-sheet (worksheet) to record the defects, deviations from
standards of behavior, or opportunities missed related to the theme.

Optionally, the students are then asked to use first week or two to record their worksheet
without making any changes in their behavior. They are then given an opportunity to
modify their list of items on the worksheet after couple of weeks.
Then they are asked to continue to make entries into their check sheet and encouraged to
write down any time and space specific observations that can relate to their entries using
“5-whys” quality tool of managing quality at the source. Every couple of weeks the
students are advised to use as many quality tools as possible to document their work to
demonstrate their progress or lack of progress. Objective here is to have students also
learn the mechanics of applying tools. Over the length of the semester students generate
their own theories why some things work or do not work.

One lecture is devoted to introduce basics of causal loop diagrams that include the
concepts of balancing and reinforcing loops, behavior over time and some examples *%
Some suggestions for further learning are offered. Students are then asked to provide
their insights in their own words and wherever possible to use causal loop diagrams to
make their theories explicit. During the course of the semester they are encouraged to
discuss their theories concerning their progress or lack of progress with their instructor.

Student experiences and recurring structures

The completed student reports offer many personal stories. The typical types of projects
selected over and over again by students are listed in Table 1.

Table 1: A Typical List of Personal Quality Projects Themes

Improving grade or study habits

Losing weight through diet

Keeping living space clean

Managing time

Improve standing with a friend or family
Reduce coffee intake

Reduce alcohol intake

Improve writing skills

Improve English communication _ (International students)
Improve health through exercise
Improve communication skills

Investing in future capability (music)

After reviewing their narratives and diagrams attempting to explain their theories,
“Limits to success,” “drifting goals,” “success to successful” and “shifting burden”
archetypes were consistently noted and are described below.

Limits to success

A reinforcing loop among the variables ‘proactive defect identification and reflection,’
‘defects elimination through well thought out actions’ and ‘enthusiasm’ operated
unimpeded for a while. However, many participants found that the process created

conflict in other parts of their life that ultimately reduced then initial enthusiasm. The

limiting factor appeared to be ability to balance needs. The diagram is shown in Figure 3
Defects

Taking actions to
reduce defects

. 4k)
Defect monitoring Batiusiasti

+ and a ae
Emotional -
stress
@

a

Other needs + Confusi
‘onfusion

Ability to
balance needs

Figure 3. Limits to success

Drifting Goals

Several students after few weeks into their project modified the operational definitions of
some of the defects. The result is improved demonstrated performance. This clearly
appeared to be an example of drifting goals archetype as shown in Figure 4. Participants
were allowed to modify defect definitions to reflect better understanding. Originally
many defined some defects very tightly to demonstrate their sincerity toward this project.
However, in most cases redefinition of defects by relaxing their interpretations has been
equivalent to modification of a goal to meet the target.
Redefining
defects

(2s Tendency to

redefine defects

Defects to
record

te)

Taking actions to
reduce defects

ae

Figure 4. Drifting goals

Success to successful

Many participants related how the actions needed to support their projects competed with
other endeavors. Figure 5 shows this archetype. In the beginning increased attention to
defect reduction did not yield immediate results and hence, when opportunities for
activities presented to participants, some of the effort diverted toward these competing
activities that yielded much quicker payoffs in other areas.
Project
performance results

a
Cy )
Time allocated to defect

reduction action follow
through

e

Time available for
other desirable
tn)

+

+

Other desirable
results

Figure 5: Success to suceesful
Shifting burden- addiction

Some stories had litany of excuses why participants could not carry out their planned
activities to reduce defect levels. Usually they couched in terms of some specific
circumstances that prevented them from focusing on their planned activates. This is
clearly resembles shifting burden archetype as shown in Figure 6.

Blaming
circumstances

+
Planned
activities Gy)

+

+ Masking need to follow
through with planned
RI EK
Performance activities
problem

Focus on planned
4p2) activites
+

Accomplished level
of planned activites

Figure 6. Shifting burden

Next section summarizes general interpretations and observations about the entire
experience.

Interpretations and Observations

The learning from participation in this type experience depends upon the commitment
with which one participates. The following list represents a collection of lessons learned
as reported.

e Understanding the Deming’s first principle about “constancy of purpose” and
commitment;

e Recognizing that individual habits are part of the system and that individuals act
according our own view of how system works;

e Appreciating resistance to change first hand;

e Understanding the difference between treating symptoms and treating the root
causes;
e Making connection between defects and own responsibility;

¢ = Malleability of world-view one and thus making make difference with their
efforts;

e¢ Recognizing we are victims of our own systems.

The list reflects many salient features of many systems observed in private and public
sectors. Total quality management practitioners can relate to the lessons participants learn
by engaging in such an experiment. It can be concluded based on the reported lessons
learned; the course objectives have been met.

Majority of the students reported that they did not succeed in achieving their goals,
though they considered the project was interesting, worthwhile, and educational.
Approximately twenty five percent of the students concluded their reports by expressing
their intention of continuing the project in the future. For those who self reported some
success moving toward their goals, one cannot necessarily claim that the involvement in
the project was the only contributing factor. Their ulterior motive to influence the grade
cannot be ruled out, even though they were informed that the grade did not depend on
their success in meeting their goals.

From written reports submitted, it can be concluded that most students appreciated and
even appeared to enjoy drawing causal loop diagrams. Those who reviewed archetypes
prior to building their own diagrams did better job. However, majority of student
generated diagrams were overly complicated and did not always reflect the theories they
were trying to communicate in their narratives. One reason might be that this was their
first experience and did not see the importance of ability to communicate their insights
using causal loop diagrams. Second explanation is that the causal loop diagramming is
considered to be just another quality tool that most felt that they need to use it as a part of
the report. Majority did not realize that the development of a causal loop diagram is an
iterative process and purpose is to communicate one’s theory or assumptions using
minimum number of well-chosen variables and concepts. This observation also reflects
that students received a very brief exposure to systems thinking concepts. However, if the
purpose of the drawing causal loop diagrams is to stimulate one’s thinking, then the
process can be considered to be partially successful.

Conclusions

Kim (1992) made observations indicating that quality management and system dynamics
have complementary strengths that can greatly enhance ability to improve performance
through more balanced learning perspectives. Quality management tools and concepts are
particularly useful working in operational domain of process management and
improvement, whereas systems thinking concepts and tools are useful to enhance
conceptual learning. While operational learning focuses on what and how of doing a task,
conceptual learning emphasizes the why of doing a task. Efforts in applying systems
thinking tools help surface assumptions and norms that have been previously hidden.
This paper verifies these observations to some extent.
The results from this type of pedagogical experiment are gratifying from perspective of
the major focus of the course. The term long engagement offered students some
experience in the area of quality improvement and also provided an opportunity to reflect
on their own world-view of how things work. If the evidence that learning is an
observable change (or no change) in behavior due to experience, then the framework
generates that learning. Systemic thinking has little effect unless the tools and concepts
change the way people perceive the situation.

One key lesson most participants took with them was that the implementation of any
technology or a program requires skills, will and commitment. The leverage avails itself
when the problems can be viewed from a systemic perspective. A systems perspective in
an event driven operational domain requires us to make a connection between an event,
pattern of events, and systemic structures. A personal quality management project
supplies one hands-on means of experiencing this connection.

Notes

1. Quality Management course is a junior level course offered during spring semester.
Many students make New Year resolutions and hence, the term paper on applying
continuous improvement to self offers them an opportunity to see if they can stick to
their resolutions and get some academic credit as well. The work reported here is a
reflective piece based on several boxes of reports collected over time. Total number
of usable reports was over one hundred and hence, the sample was large enough to
develop some tentative observations.

2. The lecture covered very basics and asked students to further explore the topic by
reviewing key chapters from The fifth discipline [Senge, 1990]. The lecture is also
used to inform students that more rigorous perspective on the topic that included
significant computer based modeling can be learned in an elective course on Systems
Thinking and Dynamic Modeling.

References

Jambekar, Anil B. 1995. Systems thinking, personal quality, and learning, Executive
Development, Vol. 8, Number 4, pp. 37-40

Kim, Daniel H. 1992. Toward Learning Organizations: Integrating Total Quality Control
and Systems Thinking, Pegasus Communications Reprint Series, Cambridge, Mass.
O’Conner Joseph and Mc Dermott, Ian. 1997 The Art of Systems Thinking (San
Francisco, CA, Thorsons)

Roberts, H.V. and Sergesketter, B. F. 1993 Quality is Personal ,New York, N.Y., Free
Press.

Senge, P. 1990. The Fifth Discipline,New York, NY, Doubleday.

Sergesketter, B. F. 2004. Create a Better life With Quality tools. Quality progress,
August 2004, pp. 25-30.

Sterman, John D. 2000. Business Dynamics, McGraw-Hill Higher Education.

Metadata

Resource Type:
Document
Description:
As New Year rolls in, many of us take on challenge of personal change. Many set goals to lose weight; do more exercises; watch less television; do more studying; do less partying; or to shed a habit such as smoking. For several years in our Quality Management course students were asked to work on a term-long personal continuous improvement projects. The students were briefly introduced to basic concepts of causal loop diagrams and were encouraged to use them to clarify their theories regarding their own progress or lack of it. The basic premise is that the result students obtain and the dynamics they experience are built into the structure of their worldview and they learn if they can communicate and influence their worldview. This paper uses systems thinking lens to discuss the improvement framework and the experience reported by students. Majority of students did not make the progress toward their goals as much as they would have preferred. The student generated diagrams to explain their theories were either too simple or overly complicated, awkward and partially flawed. However, it can be claimed that the process of using the tool to clarify their thinking itself was worthwhile. After reviewing their narratives and the diagrams, several archetypes were consistently noted.
Rights:
Date Uploaded:
December 31, 2019

Using these materials

Access:
The archives are open to the public and anyone is welcome to visit and view the collections.
Collection restrictions:
Access to this collection is unrestricted unless otherwide denoted.
Collection terms of access:
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Access options

Ask an Archivist

Ask a question or schedule an individualized meeting to discuss archival materials and potential research needs.

Schedule a Visit

Archival materials can be viewed in-person in our reading room. We recommend making an appointment to ensure materials are available when you arrive.