Jacobsen, Chanoch with Yitzhak Samuel, "Planned Organizational Change: Theory, Model, Data and Simulation", 1989

Online content

Fullscreen
PLANNED ORGANIZATIONAL CHANGE:
THEORY, MODEL, DATA AND SIMULATION
Chanoch Jacobsen and Yitzhak Samuel

Technion - Israel Institute of Technology,
Haifa 32000, Israel.

‘THE PROBLEM

Organizations have to adapt to their environments in order to survive
(Lawrence and Lorsch, 1967; Weick, 1969; Galbraith, 1967). Hence, recur-
rent structural changes are strategic responses of organizations to the
growing turbulence of modern society (e.g., Tichy, 1983). While most
organizations can alter their strategies, structures and procedures to some
extent, many changes do not achieve their stated goals because of inertial
forces blocking the way (Hannan and Freeman, 1984). Many of the factors
affecting organizational change processes have already been identified (cf.
Zaltman and Duncan, 1977), but we still lack a comprehensive view that
integrates the various interplaying forces (Nadler, 1981; Carnell, 1986).

One of the early industrial dynamics studies attempted to do just that
(McPherson, 1965). Inevitably, some crucial factors that were identified
only later, such as type of change, pacing, employee resistance and the need
for compensation (Krupp, 1972), are missing from the model. There are also
conceptual problems with the model because information variables were
treated as levels (cf. Jacobsen and Bronson, 1987). Most importantly, while
the plotted output appears reasonable enough, no data are shown comparing
model behavior with reality, leaving the empirical adequacy of the model
unknown. With our model we seek to remedy these deficiencies by deriving
its variables from well-grounded theory, basing its parameters on updated
research findings, and comparing its behavior with empirical data.

THEORETICAL STRUCTURE

1. Performance. Planned organizational change is most likely whenever a
perceived gap between desired and actual performance is too wide to be
closed by routine managerial remedies (March and Simon, 1958; Downs, 1967;
Daft, 1986:266).
105

2. Jarget. Change targets vary in size in proportion to the performance
gap. The larger the target, the more difficult and costly will be the
transition (Miller and Friesen, 1980; Nadler, 1981).

3. Simplicity. Change programs fall into three major types, according to
the simplicity of their implementation: technical, political, or cultural
(Tichy, 1983).

4. Cost. Any organizational change incurs certain costs: fixed costs as
well as variable costs (Mirvis and Macy, 1983:503).

5. Resistance. Any change program will trigger resistance from those who
prefer the status quo. The more individuals there are who feel threat-
ened by the change, the greater the resistance will be (Lawler, 1986:33).

6. Involvement in decisions about the change has been repeatedly found
effective in overcoming resistance (Kanter, 1986:192).

7. Inducements. Since involvement cannot eliminate all resistance nor
guarantee cooperation, additional compensatory mechanisms are frequently
needed, e.g., wage boosts, bonuses, promotions, etc..

8. Paging. The crux of change implementation is its pacing. Crash
programs do not allow for proper learning of new procedures, while sluggish
implementation causes stress and fatigue. Both increase resistance and
reduce performance.

The overall theoretical structure shown in Figure 1 has three major feed-
back loops, all hinging on the inherent resistance to change. This ref-
lects our hypothesis that any planned organizational change will tempora-
rily impair the organization’s performance. The change will improve per-
formance only after the initial dip (due to either costs, diffuculty,
resistance or bad pacing) has been offset by an increase in involvement or
compensation (Hopwood, 1979). However, a participatory management style
can set involvement sufficiently high to overcome resistance even without
inducements, while exogenous constraints on the ability to offer compensa-
tion can limit involvement and thus maintain the resistance. The flow
diagram of the model is shown in Figure 2, followed by the code in DYNAMO
(fully documented copies are available from the authors) .

106

PERFORMANCE

RESISTANCE >

INDUCEMENTS <1
EXOGENOUS
CONSTRAINTS:
FIGURI
causaL-Loor
READY

SIMPLICITY 4 cost 2

OF CHANGE

Sg

CHANGE TARGET

cHaNGE “*

SUITABILITY
QF PACING

git

il
PARTICIPATORY
MANAGEMENT

E
DIAGRAM

»

\
ee
TeuRve «= SIMPLE

FIGURE 2
FLOW ~ DIAGRAM
107

***** ORGANIZATIONAL CHANGE: MODEL 4 ***#x

NOTE ONE TIME UNIT EQUALS ONE MONTH
NOTE *** INITIALIZATIONS FOR DATA SET 01 OF FIRM ALPHA ***

c 5 Desired Performance (DIMENSIONLESS)
é .176 Initial Performance (DIMENSIONLESS)
C CHANGE=1.33 Needed Improvement Factor (DIMENSIONLESS)
C MSTYLE=12 Management Style (BCT. EMPLOYEES)
C FXCOST=0.05 Fixed Costs Fraction (DIMENSIONLESS)
C SIMPLE=0.8 Implementation Probability (DIMENSIONLESS)
A EXTCON.K=TABLE (TEXTCN, TIME.K,0,12,3) External Constraints

T  TEXTCN=0/.2/.5/.8/1 (DIMENSIONLESS MULTIPLIER)
A LCURVE.K=TABLE (TCURVE, TIME.K, 0, 30,3) Normal Learning Curve

T  TCURVE=0/3/7/16/33/50/67/84/93/97/100 (PCT. EMPLOYEES)
A INTRO.K=TABHL (TINTRO, TIME.K, 0, 30,3) Introduction Pace

T TINTRO=5/22/25/53/53/87/100/100/100/100 (PCT. EMPLOYEES)
c Compensation Delay (MONTHS)
L  RESIST.K-RESIST.J+DT* (OPPOSE .JK-ACCEPT . JK)

N RESIST=35 Resisters (PCT. EMPLOYEES)
L READY.K=READY .J+DT* (ACCEPT . JK-OPPOSE.JK)

N  READY=100-RESIST  Cooperators (PCT. EMPLOYEES)
NOTE *** BUXILIARY VARIABLES ***

A INVOLV.K=MSTYLE*TABLE (TINVOL, RESIST.K, 0,100, 10) - Involvement
T TINVOL=1/.97/.9/.8/.67/.5/.33/.2/.1/.30/0 (BCT. EMPLOYEES)
A NINDUC.K=TABLE (TINDUC, RESIST.K,0,100,10)+(PUTOFF*.05) Needed Ind.
 TINDUC=10/20/40/60/80/30/95/100/100/100/100 (PCT, EMPLOYEES)
A DELIND.K=DLINF1(NINDUC.K,PUTOFF) Delayed Inducements (PCT. EMP.)
A INDUCE.K=DELIND.K*EXTCON  Inducements Given (PCT. EMPLOYEES)
A CURPER.K=INIPER*RFRES.K*CHANGE Current Performance (RATIO)
A RFRES.K=TABHL (TRFRES, RESIST.K, 0,100, 20) Resistance Reduction
T TRERES=1/.9/.7/.4/.2/.1 (D-LESS MULTIPLIER)
A EFFECT.K=CURPER.K/DESPER Effectiveness (RATIO)
A TARGET.K=TABLE (TTARG,EFFECT.K,0,1,.1) Change Target

] TTARG=50/48/45/41/35/23/15/9/5/2/0 (PCT. EMPLOYEES)
A SUCCES.K=1-(1-SIMPLE)*(TARGET.K/100)) | Success Chances (PRBLTY.)
A VACOST.K= (TARGET .K/100) + ( (TARGET .K/100) *FXCOST)

NOTE Variable Costs (PROBABILITY)
A PACING.K=INTRO.K* ( (SUCCES .K+VACOST .K) - (SUCCES .K*VACOST.K) )

NOTE Implementation Pacing (PCT. EMPLOYEES)
A IMPACT.K=PACING.K-LCURVE.K Change Impact (PCT. EMPLOYEES)
A NEGIMP.K=CLIP (IMPACT.K,-IMPACT.K,IMPACT.K,0) Absolute Impact

NOTE (BCT. EMPLOYEES)
108

A EFIMP .K=TABLE (TEFIMP, NEGIMP .K, 0,100, 10) Pacing Effect
T  TEFIMP=0/.03/.08/.2/.35/.5/.65/.8/.92/.97/1 (MULTIPLIER)
NOTE wee RATES 4%
R  OPPOSE.KL=READY.K*EFIMP.K Opposition Rate (PCT. EMPLOYEES/MONTH)
A EFINV.K=TABLE (TEFINV, INVOLV.K,0,100,10) Involvement Red. Factor
T - TRFINV=0/.03/.08/.2/.35/.5/.65/.8/.92/.97/1 _ (MULTIPLIER)
A EFIND.K=TABLE (TEFIND, INDUCE.K,0,100,10) Inducement Red.Factor
{ TEFIND=0//03/.08/.2/.35/.5/.65/.7/.92/.97/1 (MULTIPLIER)
R ACCEPT.KL=RESIST-K* ( (EFINV.K+EF IND -K) ~ (EFINV.K*EFIND .K) )
NOTE Acceptance Rate (PCT. EMPLOYEES/MONTH)
END

DATA AND SIMULATION

The data we have tried to reproduce with this model come from a major elec-
tronics firm in Israel that switched to matrix organization in October 1984.
Figure 3 shows the performance data (D) measured in monetary terms for the
subsequent 18 months, along with the model variable CURPER (M). Table 1
gives the exact values of some of the simulated variables, indicating that
the theory and model are empirically adequate at least for this data set.
The initial dip in performance is clearly evident but, just as clearly,
performance declined sharply after fourteen months because of poor pacing,
leading the firm to initiate another change.

PERFORMANCE _ (OUTPUT/INPUT)

0. 900 1. 050 1,200 1.350 1,500 DM
On - - - - ee ee ee ee ee eee eee ~ ee ee eee
Mot + + +
o+ + + +
N + + + +
TO + + + +
H+ + + +
Ss + + + +
+ + + +
+ + + +
+ + + +
W0- - - ee eee ee ee eee " jr ee ee ee ee ee
+ + +
+ + +
+ + +
+ + +
+ + +
+ + +
+ + +
18+ +

FIGURE 3
D = DATA M = MODEL
TABLE 1
DATA1 AND SIMULATED VALUES OF SELECTED VARIABLES

TIME DATAL CURPER RESIST PACING NEGIMP
00 1.1730 dcLTSt 35.000 4.9462 4.9462
ol 1.1720 1.1692 35.244 10.550 9.5501
02 1.2120 1.1558 36.106 16.145 14.145
03 1.1270 1.1316 37.649 21.721 18.721
04 1.1070 1.1204 38.369 22.697 18.363
05 1.1330 1.1550 36.155 2 ee 18.055
06 1.2890 1.2225 31.841 24.783 17.783
07 1.2690 1.2693 28.849 34.095 24.095
08 1.2310 1.2524 29.929 43.336 30.336
09 1.1620 1.2051 32.953 52.507 36.507
10 1.2710 1.2254 31.653 52.546 30.880
11 1.2780 1.3059 26.504 52.704 25.370
pes 1.4130 1.3888 21.206 52.845 19.845
is 1.3210 1.4007 20.444 64.165 25.499
14 1.4570 1.3343 24.690 75.325, 30.992
15 1.2510 1.2539 29.829 86.346 36.346
16 1.1850 1.2336 31.128 90.579 34.912
ae 0.9300 1.2565 29.668 94.956 33.623
18 1.0540 1.2783 28.274 99.338 32.338

CONCLUSION

One successfully reproduced data set is, of course, insufficient evidence
of empirical adequacy, and further tests on additional data sets are needed
before we can claim that the theory is correct. Our model reflects the
view that planned change in organizations sets different forces into motion
which interact in dynamic and complicated ways. "If causal links are
ignored, either because they are new, or because their effects in the past
have been benign, or because the world is inherently too complex,
then changes that seem locally adaptive may produce unanticipated or
confusing consequences. Concurrent, parallel processes of prima facie
sensibility may combine to produce joint outcomes that are not intended by
anyone and are directly counter to the interests motivating individual
actions" (March, 1981:566). Our model and empirical example underline the
wisdom of that statement.

REFERENCES

Carnell, C.A., 1986. Managing strategic change: An integrated approach.
Long Range Planning, : 105-15.

Daft, R.L. 1986. Organization Theory and Design. St. Paul, MN: West.

Downs, A. 1967. Inside Bureaucracy. Boston: Little, Brown.
110

Galbraith, J. 1977. Organization Design. Reading, MA: Harvard
University Press.

Hannan, M.T. and Freeman, J. 1984. Structural inertia and organizational
change. American Sociological Review, 49:149-64.

Hopwood, A.G. 1979. Towards the economic assessment of new forms of work
organization. Pp.101-22 in C.L. Cooper and E. Mumford (eds.), The Quality
of Working Life in Western and Eastern Europe. New York:

Greenwood Press.

Jacobsen, C. and Bronson, R. 1987. Defining sociological concepts as
variables for system dynamics modeling. System Dynamics Review, 3:1-7.

Kanter, R.M. 1986. Managing the human side of change. Pp. 192-5 in G.
Brehm and K. Becker (eds.), Managing and Organizing for Change. New
York: Ginn Press.

Krupp, 8. 1972. Towards a theory of organizational change. Pp. 147-161
in Berger, Zelditch and Anderson (eds.), Sociological Theories in
Progress, Vol. 2, New York: Houghton Mifflin.

Lawler, E.E. 1986. High Involvement Management. San Francisco:
Jossey-Bass.

Lawrence, P.R. and Lorsch, J.W. 1967. Organization and Environment:
Managing Differentiation and Integration. Boston: Harvard University
Press.

March, J.G. and Simon, H.A. 1958. Organizations. New York: Wiley.

March, J.G. 1981. Footnotes to organizational change. Administrative
Science Quarterly, 26: 463-77.

McPherson, L.F, III. 1965. Organizational Chang: An Industrial Dynamics

Approach. Industrial Management Review, 6(2) :51-63.

Miller, D. and Friesen, P. 1980. Archtypes of organizational transition.
Administrative Science Quarterly, 25:268-99

Mirvis, P.M. and Macy, B.A. 1983. Evaluating program costs and benefits.
Pp. 501-527 in S.E. Seashore, et al. (eds.), Assessing Organizational
Change. New York: Wiley.

Nadler, D. 1981. Managing organizational change: An integrative
perspective. Journal of Applied Behavioral Sciences, : 191-211.

Tichy, N.M. 1983. Managing Strategic Change: Technical, Political, and
Cultural Dynamics. New York: Wiley.

Weick, K.E. 1969. The Social Psychology of Organizing. Reading, MA:
Addison-Wesley.

Zaltman, G. and Duncan, R. 1977. Strategies for Planned Change. New
York: Wiley.

Metadata

Resource Type:
Document
Description:
Organizations have to adapt to their environments in order to survive (Lawrence and Lorsch, 1967; Weick, 1969; Galbraith, 1967). Hence, recurrent structural changes are strategic responses of organizations to the growing turbulence of modern society (e.g., Tichy, 1983). While most organizations can alter their strategies, structures and procedures to some extent, many changes do not achieve their stated goals because of inertial forces blocking the way (Hannan and Freeman, 1984). Many of the factors affecting organizational change processes have already been identified (cf. Zaltman and Duncan, 1977), but we still lack a comprehensive view that integrates the various interplaying forces (Nadler, 1981; Carnell 1986).
Rights:
Date Uploaded:
December 5, 2019

Using these materials

Access:
The archives are open to the public and anyone is welcome to visit and view the collections.
Collection restrictions:
Access to this collection is unrestricted unless otherwide denoted.
Collection terms of access:
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Access options

Ask an Archivist

Ask a question or schedule an individualized meeting to discuss archival materials and potential research needs.

Schedule a Visit

Archival materials can be viewed in-person in our reading room. We recommend making an appointment to ensure materials are available when you arrive.