D-3208-1 1
8
MACROECONOMIC EFFECTS OF THE ENERGY TRANSITION: 8
A Dynamic Policy Analysis
John P. Sterman
Systen Tynanics Group
Alfred P. Sloan School of Management
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
‘The United States is currently undergoing a transition from
noarenewable energy sources to “unconventional” energy sources, Since
‘O73 there kas been growing awareness that the transition away from
nor:
ewable fuels ill take longer and be more difficult than
anticipeted. As oil imports grew, so did concem over the economic
reperctissions of the energy transition.
4 comon view among energy analysts in industry, academia,
ard governnent is that the transition from depletable oil and gas to
crecnventional energy sources will be accomplished when the price of
conver.
onal energy exceeds the cost of producing the unconventional
scurces. On this view, since unconventional sources such as shale
il, ceal synthetics, nuclear power, and solar energy are either not
depleteble or draw on very large resource bases, the real costs of
ogies should remain fairly constant while depletion of
conventional oil and gas will soon-drive their marginal costs above
those.of the synfuels. Investment in unconventional energy will then
ylant investzent in conventional energy, placing a cap or backstop
on exergy prices.
The bistory of the unconventional sources, however, shows
that far fron remaining constant, the real costs of these tethnologies
rising, often faster than the price of the OPEC oil they are
intended to replace!
D-3298-1 2
‘This paper explores the following questions:
1. What are the economic consequences of escalations in unconventional
energy costs in terns of
= economic growth
~ inflation
- real energy prices
= energy production, consumption, and imports
2. ‘To what extent are escalations internally generated by interactions
between the energy sector and the rest of the econony?
A large model of the national econoay and its coupling with the
energy sector ie the vehicle for thé analysis. Growing out of the Naticnal
Model project at the NIT System Dynamics Group, the model provides a fully
dynamic, behavioral theory of energy-econony interactions. The model
consists of four production sectors (consumer goods, capital plant and
equipment, conventional [depletable] energy, and unconventional -energy),
and household, financial, government, and OPEC sectors. The model
endogenously generates the major energy and economic aggregates including
GNP, consumption, investment, real and nominal wages ard prices, the rate
of inflation, interest rates, and energy production, consumption, imports,
and prices. The model also incorporates realistic representations cf
various policy initiatives such as price controls, tax credits, end
subsidies for energy production.
Simulation results (see figures) show that depletion end the
traneition to unconventional energy can cause a significant intermediate
‘term reduction in economic activity, employment, and the standard of
living. One of the major causes of the large impacts is a large overshoot
of real energy prices above the long run equilibrium value. The overshoot
is primarily caused by escalation in the price of unconventional energy,
causing continued dependence on nonrenewable conventional fuets and
delaying the transition.
‘The escelation in unconventional energy prices is caused by
several factors:
conventicnel energy is very energy intensive. As depletion raises
ional energy, production costs for unconventional rise
ventional depends on energy, creating a positive
gher prices, escalation, continued reliance on and
Gepletion of eenventional osurces, and higher prices. The positive
feeitact lecp is reinforeed by other indirect effects: unonvetnional energy
is intensive; as energy prices rise, capital prices rise and boost
un sl costs further; capital production depends on capital, adding
2
2. ‘neenverticnal energy hes long lead times, leading to shortages of
ital and the use of lator fat sharply diminishing returns) to help meet
denerd.
The unconventional industry faces rapid growth in demand as
oral energy prices rise. To attract workers fast enough, wages in
ticnel industry are bid up above the nation%l average, further
sts. “aterials tottlenecks would also raise costs.
‘ong lead tines, cepitel intensive production, and rapid demand growth
lead to chronic cash flow rroblens, higher than normal bankruptcies, and
rrisz. Elgh risk reduces the external financing available to
sconventione! industries and raises the cost of capital, further boosting
acete.
These forces reinforce each other and lead to escalations in
excess of 2074, even when the potential for substituting other inputs for
energy is high.
Tests of the model explore the sensitivity of the escalation and
c effects to the potential for substituting labor and capital for
che potential for retrofits to the energy requirements of existing
eezitsl. the cost of unconventional energy, and the energy and capital
tensity of unconventional energy. i
etrofite, shorter lead time unconventional energy facilities, and
reductions in the enerey and capitel intensity of unconventional enerey
sppear to be high leverage points for reducing the escalation and 89
ating the macroeconomic effects of ‘the energy transition.
ae)
E
Rene GNP bition 2d /y
UNEMPLOYMENT (FRACTION).
ENEREY PRODUCTION (gua /YEAR)
REAL ENERGY PRICES (i110 $/B8L EQ.)
AmpoRTS.
—
et
+ ENERGY
{ CONSUMPTION
UNCONVENTIONAL: